Roshan Lal v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
"
#
"
"
$ "%% & '' '
'
()
! "
'
*( #
'
+
$ %
&
,'
,
*'
)+(* '(%
('
, ) *%
+'
++ %
)'
+ %
'
+ + #
'
*, (
'
( +
!
),
'
,
'
,(
,'
( '!
*'
*,+ (
('
*( %
+'
*(*
)'
( *+
*%
'
),, )
'
'
-, *%
, '
, ! *%
'
, ( *%
,'
* #!
*'
*,) (!
*%
('
*(* ' ,
+'
*(( ), %
* )'
+ ., %
'
,(++ # +
'
,))*
'
*
- / ! "/
,
'
' / ! "
( '
** % '
,'
+*, ' ,
*'
+ * %
('
+ (
+'
+(+ ) ,
)'
)()
+
'
)( * *%
'
)(+ (
'
)+* - *%
'
** * *%
! '
"
-! % ,
",
'
(, %
) ,'
,( ) *%
*'
)
('
*( % *
+'
+*
)'
,)( + *%
,'
,(+ '
*%
,'
,),, -./0 0"
,'
)++( ) , *%"
, '
( -./0 ) , 1' 2 *%"
*%
,'
) % '
" ! "
*%"
,,'
+()) (
,*'
), ) ,
,('
+() )%"
,+'
(+) + *%
,)'
+)) ,
*'
,)) % *%
*'
,,() * *%
*'
,,) 3% ,
* '
,,)) )
*'
)* -./0
*,'
++ +) *
**'
)) '
(
*('
( *) -./0 ) , 1' 2 *%"
*+'
) *
*)'
*),( -!
('
) .
('
( -!
('
())+
'
! " 12
( '
((( #
('
(() -! *%
(,'
(+ , *%
(*'
+,) )% (
(('
+ )(( -./0 +
, (+'
))) *
()'
),) #+
+'
) () %
+'
) ( 0
'
10 3
+'
*, *%
+ '
+( '%
* +'
) ** 0%
+,'
,
+*'
*+ -./0 )!
+('
* , -
++'
**,, % -
+)'
(,
( ! "
)'
(, -./0 )!
)'
(,+ -./0
! "/
)'
((* * .% -!
) '
+
*%
)'
+ 0!
+ ),'
+*) 4 *%
)*'
+)( +
)('
,)
! "
)+'
(,)( -./0 ) , *%" -"
! "/
))'
( *%
' *)
) ' +(* -./0 *
/ ! "/
' *()
' ),, %
' )*))* % *%
$ %
! &
,' (*( !
*' ( ),
! "
(' )(( *, % '
" %
! "
+' (* *%
/& 1!2 / '
3 " /"2 5 ) * / '!"
12 & 667 78/ & 6876 7/
& 699 7/ & 6986 7/
& 6989 7/ & 687: 7/ & 68 7
& 68; 7/
& 688; 7/ & 68:9 78/ & 68:; 78/ & 68:;: 78/
& 68;87 78/ & 6866 7/ & 6 78
& 6 78/ & 6 78/ & 6:6 78/ & 6:< 78/ & 6:;: 78/ & 6:;; 78/ & 6968 7/ & 6<7;< 78/
& 6<6; 78/ & 6<6;9 78 & 6<69: 78/ & 669;< 76</ & 66<8 76</ & 669; 76</ & 6;9 76<
& 69< 76</ & 66< 76</ & 9989 76</ & 867<7 76</ & ;;;7 7/ & ;;<8 7/ & ;97 7/ & 967 76</ & << 76</ & < 76</ & <86; 76</ & 986 76 ) * ) ,/ '!" +
) *, / '!"
& 8787 76 ) '
0 / '!"
) .,
/ '!"
& <: 6<<:
) * ) ,/ '!"
& 69;9 78 ) *,/ '!" & <8: 76
) (!
0/ '!"
) 0!
/ '!"
) #
) ,/ '
'0
) ( 0/ '
'0
) ) / '
'0/
)
/ '!" 12
& 667 78/ & 6876 7/ & 699 7/ & 6986 7/
& 6989 7/ & 687: 7/ & 68 7/ & 68; 7/ & 688; 7/ & 68:9 78/ & 68:; 78/
& 68:;: 78/ & 68;87 78/ & 6866 7/ & 6 78 & 6 78/ & 6 78/ & 6:6 78/ & 6:< 78/ & 6:;: 78
& 6:;; 78/
& 6968 7/ & 6<7;< 78/ & 6<6; 78/
& 6<6;9 78 & 6<69: 78/ & 669;< 76</
& 66<8 76</ & 669; 76<
& 6;9 76<
& 69< 76</ & 66< 76</ & 9989 76</
& 867<7 76</ & ;;;7 7/ & ;;<8 7/ & ;97 7/ & 967 76</ & << 76</ & < 76</ & <86; 76</ & 986 76 ) ,!
/ '!"
) ,% / '!"
& ;7 7
& < 77 ) *!
/ '!"
) .% / '!"
& 698: 77 )
+ / '!"
& 87< 78 ) ) )% +/
'!" & ;9 77 ) , . / '!"
& 8<8: 76:
) ', -% / '!"
& 6987 76;
) " 0/ '!"
& < 77 ) ) *% 0 / '!"
) */ ) 0
'
+ / '!" & . ::/ :8/ :96 76
& 7:<7 76
) ' , 0/ '!"
) % 0/ '!"
12 & 68< 78 & 6<<: 7 ) ) ,/ '!"
& 6:87 76 ) %
%/ '!"
& 67;<6 76 ) ."
) " / '!"
& ;7<< 769 ) ) ,/ '!"
& 6::7 76 ) ! ) ,/ '!"
& ;6 78
) '(/ '!" +
) * ! '(/ '!"
& <;; 7
& ;: 76;
) . / '!"
& ;: 76;
) * / '!"
.8 & ;7<< 769/ & 6766 76<
. :
& 6<99 76;/ & 8;8: 76< ) #
) ,/ '!"
. & 69;9 78 ) '! '/ '!"
. & 6<<: 7 ) .,
%/ '!"
) (! / '!"
. & ;7 7 ) - / '!" +
) / '!"
. & ;6 78 ) '% #+ / '!"
. & <: 6<<:
) '% *,/ '!"
. & . 9<;/ 67:;
7
) ! * / '!"
. & 697: 78
) #
*/ '!"
& 6<<: 7 )
*%/ '!"
) % / '!"
. & 6::7 76 ) / '!"
. & 6986 7
. 3 6;6 76 ) )/ '!"
. & 6:87 76
. & 878 76 ) / '!" . ) '
+ / '!"
. 6/ & 688 76;
) '% #+ / '!"
. & <: 6<<:
) ( / '!"
) / '!" .3 = :
& 698: 77 ) !, / '!"
. & 69;9 7
) 0 / '!"
& 66<9; 76:
" /"24
" + "%% >
+ > % + + % '
" ! " %
+ ("
(" >
/
+ % '
" ! " ?@ ? @ + %
'"
6
A
" % "
" " ! +
!
% "
",/ %
, % & . 667 78
! / +" +
"
""%
+
" "
"
+ "
>
7 6 769 1' B 6;2
/ ! "/ + " (" " +
B
+
" % "
" +" + B
. ! "
%/ / !
%/ -" '% 1 ? . 8 "@ 2
' "" C " 7 6 779/ 77</ :
7 767/ 7;
767/ 766 6:
768 1' B ;
"! 2 + !% + !" +
%
!" / % "
+ "! " "
% "
! !" D% % '
" ! "/ 76 1 ?!" / 76@ 2
" + / "%% + " 7;
76 1' B 92
/ ! "/
, . B% % % !" / 76
> % % '
" ! "C% ! !" " 1 ?' @ 2
+ ! % D% E
' !
7:
7;
76 1' B <2/ +!/ % %/
" + + ! 76 1' B 672 + % +
& . 7<;
76
+
%5
!
!!"
!#
! $
"
! %&'(
"
!%&'( $ !( "
)
"
!
*
+ ! !!
!
* ,
-
!
!
./%&'# "
)
!
* !
"
!%&'(+
!
!
*
!
!
!
!
!
!
0
"
!%&'(
!!
-
!
"
"
!%&'(
!
!
!
!
"
!%&'( +!!
!!
!
!1 :
"
" + + + " "%% "
. 7;
76
"!
B" +
% + ;
A ! + " " + "%%/ ' / ! "/ '% " DB"! 3"/ '%
! ,
%/ '% B % !" / 76/ +" ! "
%
" + % & . 8<
( 76 ?
/ +" + +
+
5 + !
! !%%2,%%/
3 &''&%&'# * $4 " $
5! *
"
! #
! $
"
!%&'( " 6 7
!!"#$% % &
&.&8%&'# * $2
$
!
!! "
! #
! $
"
!%&'( $ ! ( " $
)
"
!
*
9!
9 :
%%&4/
%&'( &.&8%&'#6 7
!
! $
!
"
!%&'( )
+
!!
!!
!
! !! 3
&''&%&'# * $4 " $
5!
*
, !
"
!#
! $
"
!%&'( !!
&.&8%&'# 6 7
!! 0
&''&%&'# * $4
&.&8%&'#)
" $
!
&''&%&'# * $4 1
! 7 76:
+
" " " (" + 76 1' B <2
%% " "%%
!
!+ "
"%% !
B%
"!
% % ' C
% % !" / 76 +
)
+
!
? '45
+
.% " +
"
% ' C + " 5 3'
'
5 %$%
%
$ 363 3%7 85%9 . .% " 0 ) %% , 3 77 777 77 77F7 0G;:77 % C
, "% 3 " + " ' 77 777 77F6977 0G;777 C +,
+ " ' 7 ;7 7F6877 0G;7 , 3 77 777 77 77F7 0G;:77 % C
, "% 3 " + " ' 77 777 77F6977 0G;777 %
+ " ' 7 ;7 7F6877 0G;7 < . " " % % ! 7 76;
1' B 62 !" / 76 , + ?
% '
" ! "/ !"C% ! !" " 1 '% % 2 / 76;
1 ?!" / 76;@ 2/ %,
% %
+5
?
+
% " +
"
% ' C + " 5 3'
'
5 %$%
%
$ 363 3%7 85%9 '
.% " -'
6I 76 :
) % % "
76:
%
-'
6I , 3 ;:77 177F 772 <77 6;677
, "% "
+ " ' ;777 177F6 9;7 6;7 %
+ " ' ;777 177F6 9;7 6;7 C +,
+ " ' ;7 17F6 ;6; 6<6 , 3 ;:77 177F 772 <77 6;677
, "% "
+ " ' ;777 177F6 9;7 6;7 %
+ " ' ;777 177F6 9;7 6;7 C +,
+ " ' ;7 17F6 ;6; 6<6 . % , 3 ;:77 177F 772 <77 6;677
G 1$2
, "% "
+ " ' ;777 177F6 9;7 6;7 %
+ " ' ;777 177F6 9;7 6;7 C +,
+ " ' ;7 17F6 ;6; 6<6
' / ! " !
8 7:
76;
1' B 62 , , " 76;
+ "
% + +" + "
+
" + + ! !" / 76 + % +
"%% 769 1' B 6:2 & . 66;
76;
+ " . +
+ " " " % " " / / % % %
" % + % % !" " +"
" + % % " 769 A + %
+ %
,
B"
" "
+ % %
' / ! " + % + " "
(
/ % / /
"!
% %
A "% " / . 7 6 769 +" (" %
+
A +
+ "
" + / % " +
+ " ? % %/ "!
" % B @ 6 A
", > "/
" "%
"
% "/ % ("
. ' + %
"
' " ' ! " ! " '"/ 6<9
% "
%
+ ("
!% " ' ?@ ? @ "/ + % '"
6 A
' ( "/ +
" % ("
" %
" + 6 ) * /
"
! +
' +
'" "
! "
, % ! "% % "! "
" '" 6<9 / / % + '"
6 A +" + % ' %
+ ("
6 ) * ) ,/ '!" + " !"
!
" %
' !
% ?
% '
" ! " 1' 2C% ! !" " 1 2/ 76@
! " / 0! % ! +,
' C !
!! "
6:
+ !% " 76 > 76;
"
% !
B ! " '
' ("
! "
% / / " " "
%
% "
' C "
+ % '"
6 A " + %
6;
"/ '!"
! % %
) ) ,/
'!"
" B% > % / ) * / ) #
/ ) - / ) ) '% #+
+
) !, / '!" %
' C
!
+ "
, % ! "%
+"
!
+
+ !
! "/ " <1'2 '" 6<9 6< A %
! " "% ! + %
"%% ' C
"
'" 6<9/
0! % "
" " % " + 0! % " + " " +
% ! % (" +" " ' C !
'" 6<9
7 ) /
'!"
% ' C
"
" % 0! % "
"
% + " ' C
% +
+ % ! !"
+ C !" ' C 6 ) #
) ,/ '!" ' %
!" / 76
! " " "
%
+
' C
!
% %
)
%% " ' C
%
, A " "
%
/ %
" + !
' C %
+ % '"
6 A
8 ! " % %
"
! " J " " > %
" + ' C " +" !
"
"
" ' C " '" 6<9
!
+
+ " ' C +
+ !
! "/
:
' C "! " ! " 91'2 +"
+ C " % %% +
" ! "
%
+ "
% 0! % "
' C "
+
% %
"%% + %+
%% %! " %%
/ " " "
0! % + , / ! "/
*
;
K
'B ! ! ("
"% " '( K " 12 - K " 12 "
" % + " " "
% " 0! % ! - K " 12 5
!
;
;
" !
!
!
2 !'4(8! <
!! !
!
!
!;
!!
<
! 3 !
! !
;
!
! =!
!
;
!!
!
!
+
!
;
!
! 0 ! !
! !;
!
!
! !! ;
0
! ! ! !
!!
;
!
(
! 3 !! 0 ! < **** ** ** ** <
!
!
'4#2
" '82&9 !!
!! ;
!
!
!
! !
!
!
;
7 !
!
0 !
!!
;
! > !
!
9
!
;
? !
!
;
!
!
* ;
!
!?
!
!
!?:
! !
! ;
! !
!
;
7 3
!
+ !
! !
;
! ;
!!
!
!
9
!
!
!
;
!
! !
*
!3 ! 3 +
$
!
!
!
;
< +
!@ * ! !
;
*
! !
!
;
! !
!
*
!
!
7
!
!
!
!
! ! $ A # '& ( )* + , ,)- !
) *
!
! ! !
0
!
+ !!
!
! ! !
> < <+!
! !B
!
!
$A C!!@<+ !-
<'&
-"2%&22( < < <
!! !
!
!
!
! !
! ! !
! ! !
!
;
+ !
CD 7 !D <
!
!
!
< +
! !@
!
!
! ! !
! !
! ! ;
!
!
;
! !
$ ! ! > $ ! !
!
!
!E
) >
!
! +
!
!CD 7
2#% 7 !
! < ;
<
!
!
;
!!
;
!
< 9 '
" K
% '( K " 12/ "
B " "
! ("
"% "
A
' 'K " 12/ +" 5 12 A "
0! % / +
+ + "
% " 0! % 12 & "
" %" % %
B " / + % "
% + 0! %
""
12 A %
! " +
( % +" " " 1!2 DB " ?- !! % "
'
" % 1!2 A "
"
% " "
0! %
" / +
! " "
% " 0! % 1!2 ""
/ -% 0! %
/ +
" ! "
% " 0! % < A ! "/ + + ' C % " 0! % "
% ?@
+ %
B '"
6 .+ "%
%
" > % / " ' C "! " " '" 6<9/
% % ! ! ! " 9'/ +" 5 8 &% .% .%
/0 9
3
!
! !
! !
3 !! " !!
!1 A + "
" 1 2 '% 3 4
% % %. '% &
5
( * 6
, (* /
()* " ! # 'B / ;
( % > + !
B A
' ' " 12 ! " '( 12 %
+ " "
% "
! % "% + %
B KK '"
6
" " ?C 5:F"+1'44%'
+'&& @'44'(
#/81 +/ "
%% % " / "% " "
. D
+
%
"! + +
! %
"
! %
"
+ " J
"
+ %
! % "/ " >% '"
6
8 $/ " + % " " ?7 1 7%
3 7 1 7%
8%.9 :.%%
5
( * 6 -+ (* /
( * , / + % "% + + %
'"
6 +
" "
"
0! % / %
-" % %!
" 0! %
"
% "
"
"
0! %
$% " !/ +
"
% +"
" / % / + " " ! "% / "!
+ " "
! % + !
,
! " !/ + !
" "% !
"
% "C / " %
!+ %
"
'"
6 " B/ + ' C + !
( % / + 0! % E 7I ' C +" " + " !
+ ! %( +
"
+ 3 "/ + 0! % E A +
" %
7I ' C +" +
' C
/ ! ,
% !/ 0! % +
7I
/
+
' C A
%
0! % ! ! "
' C A +
% B ' C %"
% /
/ % "/
"
8 " %
> > % +
% '
"
! " 1' 2 % ! !" " 1 2/ +
%! " " ! + ! A !
% "
&
" " "! %!% " (" +
+ " +" "
+ 12
"! %!% A ""
"
"/
,
"! A % ! ! ! A " '""
%/ % %
"! " "! " ) "! "/ "
/ " "
"
"
12
+ "
" ! %!% A +
6<7
! % "!
!
$"
." " ) & " ! " % * 0 " * ,
"%
" ! ' A +
%
12 A / 0! % !
+ E )
% 0! % A "% B " # 76
% ! % !/
" %+,
"! %!% "
% K " +
, " :
# 76
+ ! % L, %LK 1
" 2 " % / ("! % +
,
) '
"
% +,
" !
! / +,
% " KD
K " !
! % ) ! 1) 2
% +
"
$ " ) .% % +
76 E
% + " + ("!5 12
! L, %L 1 " 2
% " MKD
NK " !
! % ) ! 1) 2
1"2 ! % !/
" %+,
"! %!% "
12
"! %!% "
!
) B ! " " + %
" " ! " ("
! " / "
" % "
!
+ " +
! %
* K )
.
! / L + % %
! %
1!2
%
? ! " '" 16<62@ !
%+,
'" "
* +, "!
" / /
! "
%,
"%% %
/ (/ " / / % ,/
! %
% /777 "!
6<<7 ) ' + / "! " !
%,
!
A " 6<97/ % "
! " " B
%% !
%,
" "
/ % /
/ % % +" % % + %!
+ " " + "
,K "!
%
,
"
"! A !
" / ! " '"/
"
("! "
" "!
/ "/
" !
"
" "! ! " / !
B"
! "
0 17792 "
+
LA
" !/ %% "
"! + % / % " !
& " $ " " ! !
+ " "
%%
" ! " "
%% /
%
! !
! % LOP
1!2
0 "
"!
( %" " " " " ""
+" + " " " "
" "% " J + + " + % % %+ B % 5 '"/ )% 0 K B % K "! " "
A ("! + " ! "
! " %% % " + "
+ $%5
$% "! % % "
'" %
!
K " "
! 5 % '"/ 0 ( ! " A J
," A
B" B / ", /
B" "
! "
" % " '
"
" " " / /
/ + "
"!
" " "
! 1!2 ! )!% ' A " )B D" %5
' "/ " " %"
! %
% %B " % "
" %
"/ ! ! "
+ ! + ! J
"
"
+
"
! " $45 ' "/ "!
"%
$! 4 1$42 #+
. " "!
-%""/ +
" " .
" !5 6<9/ .
-! % "
1.- 2 "%%
" "!
! ),
"
0! % A " .
" ! 77 D
% . - 5 .
! -! % 1. - 2/ " / + .
! -! % '"/ 6<: 1!2 $% ! " "! A
+ %!% % " !
""
"! " 5 '
" '
"5 .
! -! % 1. - 2/ .
'
"
! ),
$ A 1.'$D-2/ A $% $ !
% 1A$$ 32/ ')E
!
-! %
1 3-D ,
"5 (
) ! 1) 2 ,/
) ! , + ! , "
! ! "
"
"!% !
"
"
" !
" , "
"!% %"" "
+, "
J /
, "!/ +
J "
"
M "
" /
+
! % N 8 .+ "%
", "
" " + / % "
' C +
+
"5 12
' C % ! "! " !
! "/ 6<9
" 12 A +
+ " ! ' C +
+ +"
! "
+,
+
!
%
! " 12
)
%% ' C
!
B" % ("
+ 1!2
)
%%
% 1!2
C+ % ' C
! ' C +" % +
, ' C " "! " 1!2
"
,
"
' C + " " / / % "
B +" +
" % %
B 1!2 % " ' C
' C 1!2
,
" , !
1B2
' C ( %
" ""
" 8< '" 6<9/ +" 5 .% + 01% .%% $ $ % .1
$
!!
!
! !
!!
!!
1B2
A "
,
" !
+ . / 8/ 87/ 8/ 7/ / / ;
6 ' C +"
" +5 ! 8$;.%@$+ 0
!! ! !
!
,
! ! !
! G 0
!!
!!
@$ +
!
!
H !
!
!E
! !
!
!
! !
! H
6!
! !
! !
H +
! !
+
!
! !3
+
!
+
! ! !! +
!
+
!
0+
;
! !
! !
! !* +
!+ > > !
$
!7
! 7 ;
!
+ !
!! !
!
!$ !
, B !! ! !
!
!!
!!
0 :
@ $
! !
!
! ! ;!C
+ < 7% &/ !!
!!
! + 9
7 $ -
!!
!!
;!7 @$ '
+ !
C
H % +
> ! ! $
$*
!
"
H .
+ "
H ( +
H # +
!
H +
!
!
!
! / +
!
!
!
+ 7 $-*! +
7 $ - +! C & %@ + C
!!
!!
@$ '
!
$ $ ! !!
!$ ! !!
+
,
*
!! ! % C*
;
$! ! !
H .
"
) GF6H ( =!
!
+ C
!!
!!
*
;!
+ C
!!
!!
!@$ '
+
$!
>5>
! $ !
! H % +
* "
!H .
+
,
H ( + C !!!
$"
!H # + !
! " *
!
! + ! !
!
7
) GF6
* "
,
"
/ + !
!E
!
+
0
,
! !
! ! H + !
"
!
! H '& +
! ''
+
,!!
'% + ! '.
+ "
!
"
!
" '( + !
'# + !
"!, *7
'2 + *
!
'/ ;!! @
! '8 C 7 $- *!!
H '4 !
!
C
!! 7 $- 4$
)
'48(
*
!)
C
!! !
!! !
!
"
!7 $-
0
,, ! +
C
!! !! !!
! !!
C
" ) 7 &@ +C!! C
+ C !!
! 1 1B2 '
% " +
'" 6<9 +
! " 12/ +" ! % " % "! "/ (" +" % "%% %% + %% " B"
! ! $% ! "
"
!
' C % % " +" ! %% ! B"
! +" " % % "
% "
8:
'
"
"!
! '" 6<9
+
+ ' C
! % ' C ! J !
"
0! % + ? !! " @ % % + "
" / +" "
%""
" %% + % + !
/ "/ "
?@ ? @
8;
! " / % !
" "
AQ A + '"
8 RA +" ! "
,* ! "
" ! % / %""
%% " / %% " %"
" % " / +" 5 !+=4 4 .1% .01% .%%$ 0
-!
!
! $
$
!
!
$
! $
1 '
! > % + ' C "
+
+
K
% " 0 )> / A/ !
! " " 5 12
"
0! % B + % B )
%" % " "
"/ % 7I 12
!! "
0! % "
"
" %
12
/ %
%
"
"
" +
1!2
"
0! %
,( 8< ' % !/ % " +" "
' C ! " %
"
+ % + "
% "
) ! ! +,
"
"
"
7 "/ +
%
""
/
%
6 +!/ % "
! + ! % !
!
+ ' C / !"
!
!" " % +"
, " !
" % "" " +
+
'""
/ +
% + " 8 '
%"
" / /
-3 " /"20 ''
"
: 9, I,:
9 ! I,: