High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/82/2009allowed

Cit, Karnal v. Karnal Coop. Sugar Mills. Ltd.

2015-08-25Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary12 pages

!"#$# % && !

& ()*'!+ ,,-- ++! % *'!+- '.

/01'2++ 3&

)2 ''0 )*'!+ ,

! 2" 432 /* 2 23 432 / 2

56*0&'2+) $ " #$% & ! "' ()$( * + ,- .% / #%%0' .1& !"'"1 23* +"1,-&"

(0$$424#%%# !()))5#%%%!

16 5

- 7 ! &""

8 ! . 1 !())95)/())/5 )$())$5): 1

!! 1 1 !

1 !()))5 #%%%;

-7 ! &"" !

(%%/%%%451

1 1 '

1 .:*(- & "

()$(;

-7 ! &""

/%%%%%45 ! 1 '1 < = 1

< 81 !> >&" 3 !12 > ! ?! !

1@ ! ! 1 ' < 81 !> ! 1 1 ;

-7 ! &""

1 /:#0//945

1' .) 0%

1 1 !;,

!1 " ! # < >

2 !

A !

! !()))5#%%% ! !1!

" 1 > !! & !"'*-B>&"*-C

# #%%# ' #

:/%%%45

' ##/%%%45 D1 "1

!())95)/ .

' ! (%%/%%%45

E ! !

1 ' 1 .: !

D1 >&"*-

D1 "1

' >

*#%%:-#00&"( 1"1 ! .: " D

! #/%%%%45 1

! 1 ! !1 ">&"*- @ ! ! !

/ #/%%%%45

! ""1

$ #%%$

1 ' /

< = >

/ = ! /:#0//945 1 !!1

! ! !()).5)9 ! ! ! !1>&"*- ">&"*-

# #%%#' #1 !

1 1

' 1 ! .)0%90#45!1

1 1

/:#0//945 !

" 1 "1 F .% / #%%0' ."1 ! /:#0//945 <1

"78 :

" 1

! ! ' ! 1 !())95)/ ())/5)$())$5): !1! ()))5#%%% & 1 !1 &" /(/ #%%0 *

" (:

(# #%(% 6 *-

"78

7 6

*- !

(%%/%%%45 11

11' .:

*(- ? 1 D1>&"*- G!

#)..9 :

())0 1< =

?! !

! ! & ! 1 /H

())$5): 1 E

! ! !

)

D "1 "1

' 1 !!'!1 .:*(-

! 1 .% / #%%0' .!

(%%/%%%451

1 1

! "!!

1 &! !

6 /H

1' ' 1 !1 .: & 5 +(/ 3

. >

?!!

(%%/%%%45 <

1 E ! " = 1

! ! &

!1 !

! & !1 " 1 1 ! & E "' 1 1 !

($ "

! .:1 !

1 1 1 ' ' 1

">&"*-! & A

*-?! >&"0$&"$./*-I ?! >&"2$0&":)*2 -I>1 2?! >&"#/&"(%#*3 !-I>&"

> !?!(/%&".#%* -I A!

>&".#&"(.0* -I>&"

>AJ>

.0&"$%(* >-I32 ?! >&"90&"(/.*> - !1 ! 1 1 ! 1 1 1 8!

(%%/%%%45

1' >&"*-

!1 D

(: 3 1! ! 1 ' 1

E 1< = >

?! >

! ! & 1 E ! " = E

1 E

6K/H

(0"!

(%%/%%%45 1

1 1 ! ! E 1

1 , ? !

"1 1

> 6

"78 (( 6

*-! ! 1 &"

(%9 #%%:#

" (:

(# #%(%

1 5 +) 1 1 !! 1 '

" 1 1 ! ! < 81

!> "1

1 "1

# 1 , ="1 1 5 +#9 3

' 1

/E !1

1 !!1 6 !E 1 ' 1 @

< = >

@ ! ! ! !E

1 1 ! ! 1 !

!E '1 1 1

1 !

#/ 3

4 1>

?! L>&"

1&""238=8&"

90.%424#%%# #.L#%%$* 1 1

E () #(-1! ! 1 "1 "1 '

1 '1 1 0 5

(*- 1 "!

1 D ' 1 1

1 !())$5):

& 1 '!1 !! 1 ! 1

.: " ! 1 !

1 ! >&" 3 !12

?!#()&"/#( & !

! 1 1!

! !

1 ' & !

1 1 ' 1 < = >

?! !

1 '

#$ "2 1 1 1! ! 1!

*- 1"1 1 < !

3 ! "

*- "1 ! ' /E1

< = >

?!>

1 ' ' 1

9 8

, 6

"7.8 (# > 6

*- 1! 1 !

/:#0//945 ! !()))5 #%%%1 1 '1 D 1>&"*- & "1 !

D ! < >

*())0-##)&"

#0/1! ! ' !

! !

11! " /:#0//945! !

=! .)0%99#45 '1& ! !

! ! 7!

1E !11E !

! ! !( ())0 .( .

())) ! ()))5#%%%!

/:#0//945 '1

!()))5#%%% ""1 D >&"*- "1 < >

$*-

!1 > D !

1E 1

" @!

D1 ! !

& 1

1 "6 ! 1

756*0&'2+8 0 010 #)$# 7 & !

'!8 91 9 0