High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19794/2016dismissed

Kanchan Bala v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2017-08-22Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

"#$$%&'&()

+"(%,"("-"

$#&#&($/ 0$/'1'

2#"#$ 1(3"4"(5#,$/'

$'6(5$(#'

/$'$(#).

/ + "##758%"#$/#,$6$#&#&($/

$#&#&($/,"'&(8:$5#,$$;#/"/5&("/<=/&#31/&'5&%#&(#,&' 1/# '$$:&(> #,$ &''1"(%$ " /&# "(5"?1' / 5&/$%#&(> #,$ /$'6(5$(#.51%"#&($6"/#?$(#"'"-'#,$6/$?&$//$%/1&#?$(#">$(%< #,$2#"#$&$#,$ 1(3"4 14-&%2$/8&%$??&''&(7 "#&"-",$/$&("#$/# 4$/$$//$5"'#,$??&''&(!#"66&(#,$/(#,$6'#@$%#1/$/&( ??$/%$">"&('##,$2%"#$>/< '6$/6-$"5&(>'(/$%/576$#&#&($/6"''$5?&(#,$<$"/ *"(5#,$/$"#$/61/'1$5 ?"(5'1%%$''1--<%?6-$#$5#,$'"?$&( #,$ <$"/

,$/$"#$/7 #,$ 6$#&#&($/ ,"' "-' A1"-&&$5 #,$ %(51%#$54<#,$ 58$/#&'$?$(# ( 5"#$5 *

="' &''1$5 4< #,$ ??&''&(&(8&#&(>"66-&%"#&('//$%/1&#?$(# 6'#'@$%#1/$/'

--$>$ "5/$! &(%-15&(> 6'#' / @$%#1/$/' &( #,$ '#/$"? ??$/%$ 6'#'=$/$/$'$/8$5/#,$2%"#$>/<

$#&#&($/4$-(>'##,$2%"#$>/<"(5,"5"66-&$5/#,$ 6'# @$%#1/$/7 ??$/%$ &( /$'6('$ # #,$ "58$/#&'$?$(# 5"#$5 *

'6$/6$#&#&($/7',$="'#,$'-$%"(5&5"#$/$%??$(5$5/ "66&(#?$(###,$6'#@$%#1/$/7??$/%$">"&('##,$2%"#$>/< #'#/"('6&/$'#,"##,$#,$(,"&/?"(#,$??&''&( /

"8&2&5,1="'"//$'#$54<#,$0&>&-"(%$1/$"1(#,$"--$>"#&(' #":&(>4/&4$"(5%??&##&(>8"/&1'&--$>"-&#&$'"(5&//$>1-"/&#&$'=,&-$ ?":&(> 5&$/$(# '$-$%#&(' "(5 "-- #,$ "66&(#?$(#' ?"5$ 1(5$/ ,&' ,"&/?"(',&6 %"?$ 1(5$/ #,$ '%"(($/ 8$( #,$ /$%/1&#?$(# 6/%$'' &(&#&"#$5&(#,$-&>,##,$"58$/#&'$?$(#5"#$5*

/#,$6'# @$%#1/$/'--$>$"5/$!="''%/"66$5 214'$A1$(#-<&(6&(##&?$&(#,$<$"/

*"/$%/1&#?$(# 6/%$''="'">"&(&(&#&"#$5/&--&(>16#,$6'#'@$%#1/$/'--$>$ "5/$!&(5&$/$(#'#/$"?'"(5&(=,&%,#,$6$#&#&($/"66-&$5"(5'143$%#$5 ,$/'$-#"6/%$'''$-$%#&(,$6-$"5$5%"'$#,$6$#&#&($/,$/'$- &'#,"#',$="'(#'1%%$''1-&('1%,/$%/1&#?$(#6/%$'' ,$&('#"(#6$#&#&(,"'4$$(&-$5(#,$'#/$(>#,315>$?$(# 5"#$5

B76"''$54<#,$/5&("#$$(%,&(

"# (($;1/$ . 1('$- '14?&#'#,"##,$6$#&#&($/#,$/$&(("?$-<21(&#""-'4$-(>$5##,$2 %"#$>/<"(5,"56"/#&%&6"#$5&(#,$6/%$'''$-$%#&(&(&#&"#$58&5$ "58$/#&'$?$(# 5"#$5 *

/ #,$ 6'# @$%#1/$/7 1'&% ('#/1?$(#'! # &' '14?&##$5 #,"# #,$ =/&# 6$#&#&( ="' "--=$5 "(5 5&/$%#&('=$/$&''1$5##,$??&''&(#/$.%(51%##,$&(#$/8&$= #,'$%"(5&5"#$'=,,"5"66-&$5&(/$'6('$##,$"58$/#&'$?$(#5"#$5 *

/#,$6'#@$%#1/$/&( 1'&%('#/1?$(#'!1(5$/#,$2 %"#$>/<"(5#,$/$"#$/6/%$$51/#,$/&("%%/5"(%$=&#,-"=1('$- =1-5"/>1$#,"##,$=/&#6$#&#&(="'"--=$54<(#&%&(>#,"#"2

.B.

%"(5&5"#$,"54$$('$-$%#$5"'6$/%"#$>/<"(5="'%-"&?&(>"66&(#?$(# (#,$4"'&''$-$%#&((?$/&#"(5&(#,$"4'$(%$"(<?"#$/&"-( /$%/5#'1>>$'##,"##,$'$-$%#&(#,$6$#&#&($/#,$/$&(("?$-<21(&#"# 4$(#"&//#"&(#$57#,$/$=1-54$(>/1(5#5$(<#,$/,$/8$'#$5 /&>,#"66&(#?$(# 1('$-%-"&?'#,"#6/$'$(#6$#&#&($/&'&5$(#&%"--<'&#1"#$5"' #,$/$&'(#"&(#&('"/"',$/'$-$%#&(##,$6'#@$%#1/$/--$>$ "5/$!&(#,$'#/$"???$/%$&'%(%$/($5"(5"''1%,7',$&'$(#&#-$5 # 6"/&#<#/$"#?$(#(#,$#1%,'#($/#&%-$'"(5 #,$ ('#&#1#&((5&" "8&(>,$"/5%1('$-/#,$6$#&#&($/"#-$(>#,7#,&'1/#&' #,$%('&5$/$58&$=#,"##,$&('#"(#6$#&#&(&'=,--<?&'%(%$&8$5 #&'#,$6-$"5$5%"'$#,$6$#&#&($/,$/'$-#,"#',$,"5 6"/#&%&6"#$5&("'$-$%#&(6/%$''//$%/1&#?$(###,$6'#@$%#1/$/ --$>$ "5/$! &( #,$ '#/$"? ??$/%$ &( 61/'1"(%$ # #,$ "58$/#&'$?$(#5"#$5*

21%,'$-$%#&(6/%$''="''%/"66$5 '14'$A1$(#/$%/1&#?$(#6/%$''="'&(&#&"#$5&(#,$<$"/

*&(=,&%,#,$ 6$#&#&($/6"/#&%&6"#$5"(5="'(#'$-$%#$5(%$5$5-<7=,&-$6"/#&%&6"#&(> &(#,$'$-$%#&(6/%$''&(&#&"#$5&(#,$<$"/

*76$#&#&($/%,'$(## ">&#"#$,$//&>,#'$$:&(>"66&(#?$(#&(61/'1"(%$##,$&(&#&"-/$%/1&#?$(# 6/%$''/$-"#&(>##,$"58$/#&'$?$(#5"#$5*

#&'(=&(#,$<$"/

#,"##,$6$#&#&($/,"'=:$(16(/?5$$6'-1?4$/"'&''#":&(>,$/ %-"&?&(/$-"#&(#"'$-$%#&(6/%$''&(&#&"#$5&(#,$<$"/

,$315>$?$(#&(21(&#"C'%"'$'16/"!%"((#$(1/$##,$ 4$($&##,$6$#&#&($/ $#&#&($/%"((#%-"&?#4$&5$(#&%"--<'&#1"#$5&(

"--/$'6$%#',$%"(5&5"#$"/$.(#&%$5("?$-<21(&#"="'8&>&-"(#"41# ,$//&>,#'"(5%,'$#"66/"%,#,$=/&#%1/#&(#,$<$"/

*&#'$-=,$( #,$'$%(5/$%/1&#?$(#6/%$''8&5$"58$/#&'$?$(#&''1$5&(#,$<$"/

* ,"54$$(&(&#&"#$5 $#&#&($/%"((#4$6$/?&##$5#>"&("(<&?6$#1'/? #,$315>$?$(#/$(5$/$5&(#,$%"'$"%"(5&5"#$=,,"5"66/"%,$5#,&' 1/#=$--&(#&?$7$8$(#,1>,7#,$/$-&$'1>,#/"(5>/"(#$5?"<4$&( '&?&-"/#$/?'/$$/$(%$&(#,&'/$>"/5?"<4$?"5$##,$5$%&'&(#,$ (C4-$216/$?$1/#&( !"# $% & '( ' ) ,&>,-<4$-"#$5%-"&?&''1>,##4$'$#16&(#,$&('#"(# 6$#&#&( %"'$/&(#$/$/$(%$&'?"5$1#

$#&#&(&'5&'?&''$5

-1%:< ,$#,$/'6$":&(>D/$"'($5) $'D ,$#,$/ $6/#"4-$) $'D