High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/77/2006dismissed

Bhura Singh v. Balbir Singh

2026-05-08Ms. Justice Ramesh Kumari11 pages

RSA No. 77 of 2006 1

!! "#$$%& '( )*

+$, $- #$#%

+$. $- #$#%

CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE RAMESH KUMARI

!"# ! !" # $$$$

& ' ! () %* *((+ ,# -. , # , /# # # 0 # 1" / ## # # 0 ##" # ,#!# * # %*2 !#!*+ (+ *((% #' ! , (% (3 *((+ # ! #! # # 4 # ! ! ' ! , #. . - "

RSA No. 77 of 2006 2 * & # #! 5 # # / ! # * #! ## *+ (+ *((% #6 76 % 76 *",# ## ## ! ,! ! #*2! &# , , ## ## &# # ! , ! # ! ,' ## / # # # # ! & # 6 ! !

#!# (8 (% *((9/ %" :# !# * (( (((;/#! ## *+ (+ *((% 6 ## ## <= *" ># % ## , ! # <= 8" : ## %( (((;/ #! # <= 9" :# ## !<= +" : # # # <=-

RSA No. 77 of 2006 3 )" : # ## ! #!<=- ?" # + - # ## 6! :% @ !:*# ## !# 6 :8 ## 76 :8;

= # 6! !' -:%6! !# -:* )

# ! , ! ' ! (% (3 *((+ ## A

" B ?

#! ' ! (% (3 *((+ , ###C , # ! ! ' ! () %* *((+ > # # , ! !/" # # # " E , C !!, # 5 # ! # * #! ##

RSA No. 77 of 2006 4 *+ (+ *((% 6 76 % 76 * ,

! 5 ,# #! ## & ## ##! , # & ##!, ! , # # & ## #/6! !#6 # 6;#, F # # # #6! # ## # , # # , ! > # 76 % 76 * # ! :*@ ! !! # ## :% # !; > #

# , ## %( / ! ! # # ## "! ! , #:% #!, ,,! #:*@ ! :8 ## !# ! 6 # %%D # G > ! %DD%,! # 6 # , ># , ! # # & # # ! ! # #!

RSA No. 77 of 2006 5 # # %% H # , , C # ! ! # # #! / #$ %

! & ! ! ' (& ! ) %* & # 5 # ! -:* 6 , ## ## H ,! #! ##! = # ! , # # ! % 76 * ## ! %8 & ##!# 6:8 ## 76 :8;

& # ! ## # ! # * I *2 ! # #!, 6 , ! ! H # ! # # , ! # # H ! , , ! # :% :* @ ! # %9 H 6! :% :* @ ! ## #6 # 76 % 76 * , , # :%

RSA No. 77 of 2006 6 ! , #, *+ (+ *((%# 5 !# *

# *2 ! # ! #! ## & 76 % J76 * # # ## ! ! !

-# 76 % J 76 * # ! H , !

H #, ! , ## # #:*@ ! %+ :*@ ! , # 76 % 76 *#,! # ## ## ## # # ! ! 6 # ## !# *#! ## %) - # ! !/ # # ,# ##,!# * # H ## 6!

#,# ! ! ,D%(,# 6 # > , ##" # ! ! ! , & ###, * # ! # # ## ! ## :* @ ! , !! # ## 6! !

RSA No. 77 of 2006 7 #!! 5 !# 5 ! , # # ! ! , :%# !; -# !! # !! ,#:*@ !# ##! ! # *!

&# ## ## ,! , ! , # %?

F ! ## ## ! , # , ! # # &# # , ! 6 ## , ! , # & ## E ! , # # , %D F !## !# 6 # # # :* @ ! :% !

# 6 # :* 6! #,:% ! # H !

RSA No. 77 of 2006 8 #,

, ## K , # # :% 5 !

!! , # :* @ ! :% #, J76 % 76 * #, ! # 6 #! # ! ! & # , , ## , :* @ ! :% :* @ !#, ! # * # :8 ##!# , # ! # %((;/ *( & ## !, # # # # # 76 % 76 * :8 ##

' 6!

# , # ! # 76!

6! # ## ! ,# ## # , !, &# !,5 76 %J76 *# # # # , !!, ## %3 = ## # 6 # 76 % 76 * , %%D # G > ! %DD% ,! #6 # ! %%D # G > ! %DD% # /

RSA No. 77 of 2006 9

"# *( > ## !! ## # 76 % 76 * # # # ! , ! ,## ## ! > # ,! , 6! ,6 , J 76 % J 76 * #

RSA No. 77 of 2006 10 # ! ! # # ! #H 1 6

"#""$%

/ $%%%%""

& ''( )* +

& ''(

" *

#%%%"" " *% > &' 6 # # # -:%6! ,!

6 # # ! # *

# *2 ! , ! > ! , # , ## C ##! ! ' ! , ** & # ##, , C 6 # % 76 *,# ## ## # # , H 1 6 #() A

* !+& , - &.&/ *8 > ## # ## 6 # 76 %J76 *, , # #

RSA No. 77 of 2006 11 ! &#!#! , ## ## *9 & ! ' ! ,

, !# #! ,# ' ! # E # , # (RAMESH KUMARI) JUDGE 08.05.2026 ravinder Whether speaking/reasoned √Yes/No Whether reportable √Yes/No