High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1676/2019dismissed

Harinder Dhingra v. Narbir Singh

2024-08-28Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu16 pages

! "# $% & ' () *+!+%,& & '

, -. / / /

# # $ .

/ /

% &' " ()*) + , "#- , . # /

""" """

#$!% "

! &

& '

( ! "#"$$ %&''()

01- "2## 3 4 "# 5 - 6"- #6# " ,2 " #" 7

82 9 " : # "#- 7 :

8 - $ *+ *, - . /

1 (

"# # ;)0, ,"# ()0; 7 3,

,8 " <& <0 &<()-#= # >,#7> 3= # 48 ! "

"# ,%.9<<<;< &<() (?

<( &<() 7 /(8 # 32 & ! 3 4& 4#- (&1/ #

()1(7 3

()1(8 (00 ();*'1*&<*'0*'?*0(.

, "#"- &<;,

& @ ## "# (?

<( &<() /(8 ""/

( A (1 <( &<<1 % # " : #

"#-7 3:

48"= - 7-8

& A # &1 <) &<(* % # :

" @ , - ! " 7-8 , ! "-

;

&<<17 3A.

" $ " # # = - # 6# - !"B

-#- - "C"# - B ()?'2

" # # @ - ! " # 6# ! " B

-#- ## B()?0 A D -! ,""" A.

- "B

-#- ## B

* A #/ - A #" "#5# ,"". $ -

# *'*95,.9A9:9 9&<()//..9'<& ;

( &<()5# ,""."

, " + #

(&1/

()1(

A ## # # # " " " -$ ##- ## - A 5# ,"" ##- 5# ,"" ! "

A $ #- ##- # - # # " -2 (&1/

()1( ;(

()1< (00 (); *&< *'0 *'? E *0( . # , (?'< # " 78 5# ,""78 - " "# # "

;

## #"- "# ,F/(2 G" H ,F/&2 # " 5G

(5G

/() #

"# ## #= # " "# &<; ,

, " <& <0 &<()2

/,0

. ,/ , # = # "" " "# ""

(

"""

#- A ## ## A , 6 # " A

" ##- & . # # #56 4 7 ! 0 8&

9 05:;<'6'4<,56

3 *

3 % ! = > > 3

5:;:(64/4?@<,56> %

0 AB%

0 A4& ! %

4 4& 5:;<@6 : 4 C?@, 506 % = ! 7% 4 D 4 0

5:;;?6@4< (,5063A

% ! 4 4

! 7 $

5:;<;6<:4E;',506>

! 4 2

5F%<<@ :;; 6%G2 ,50648 ! 8

5:;< 6( 4C:C

. / '

: #= #

#-" " "#"

""" '

(

" "# ## '(1( -"7 8- -""## - -()??

6 #@

# "# ## &*0( D" - -&<<( ++ " -""## ##

6 #@

# #! " - ""## 7 - 8 ## -" 7 8

6 #@

D"7 -8

6 # @

7 8

" - #$ -- " -- #### .9 "D -"

"# - D!, # # # 2 .9 "D - 6 '

; :#-" ! 2

" # "## '

#" A. #-

+# $"# "G # # ?

@ - G &<;,

/ :;( "" !

# %

# % ) *+*!

(

# " 7-8 "# # 6- &<&,

, ##

" "# -

###- ) # - I# ",

! 4 H &

5<'@:6( 4 C<C # # ;<& %# , 7, ,"# (?)?8 7 &<; ,

,8 0 / ,

) *+-!& .&

! !

' !

/ !

0 !

! !

) *+-! & .&( (< ,

## ##- #= # #" "#

(* (1 (' &( E &? " #/ 12 !

) *+* &.&

$ 3

45161 $ )

)

1788 $ #9% ' :

4 *,21 ;

)

3 *++1 . // $ )

)

! ' #$ %

." 18+*17,+ < = > ) = ?@

& < $ )

)

#. %!

#9%! ' ;

#$ )

' #$ % $ 16

" ! "

$ #9% 1788 ;

3 % ' #$ %! : *5

= $ *++6>*+12 *++7 ) = !

" :*5

! 15

:*5 *++6

A #3 % ?

B$ 9

! $ )

)

! . B $ !

C ;<& $

:*5 *++7 ) = < !

B$ 9

: !

:*5 *+12

B$ 9

B !

$ ! "

$ )

) . ?

:*5

$ )

)

! ?

$ !

1, *+ *1

" ! ) 216 > 2*+ .&

) 25->252 .& ! ")

:*5 >.

*++6! *++7 > *+12

! ** *, *8 ! & & .!17,- !185-

! ! D

EEE9 & & .! 17,-

& / 4 ! ) 258 &.& C

) 1*6 ! 1761 ) 257 &.&

4 !

: 4 *5

*++6!*++7 > *+12

3 0

) -6 -5 !1761 )!

) -6 -5 !1761 !

= &

)! !

A !*+17

16 !1+ >6

*+17!

/ (

# G ##- " - # = # # + #" $ "6+

## "" " "# ((

# - I# " , 4A4& 3 0!

8 %

5:;< 6(4 <:( ## #, ;)0*<( ,

, (* #/ <C !

;

! 3 & /

3 &

/ ) -7, 2+1&.&

;

! !

! / ( (& "#

##- -" 7 8 - ()??

6 # @

## D" 7 - 8 -&<<( 6 #@

(;

" "# " (1 <( &<<1 ## &1 <) &<(* % "#- # - # ##- # "

. 7## " D -8 - D!,2 "$ ##"$ -# #>" &'

""9 # " ## (* 2 ## "# " . 9 - " $ - -

" - # 5

. - D!,9 - . ## - 2## # ## ""-

" # 6 (1 .6 # " ## "# . # " 6#- . - D!, # #2 " # "

## "# .9 - # " - #" 9 " "# # #

(0 A " . " "# 6#- - D!,

"# "

. (?

# ## - # :

6" - # 6# ()

# # "$ " # "- ()?'()?0()??

"## # # " ## , # #9 "# 2 " # " # #- "# 6 &< . - # # #- #

()1(- , "+ &(

# # , # + # " // " ##-" ## / 78 . 4 7 + 5 6 " # "# " >" &' # */ , 5# # I# ", #

# "

J $ - ,

6" "# 78 .

3 *

3 % + 5 6 ## # - "

. # # # % .. # (( , , + # " I#", # "2 6# 78 . > %

0 A %

0 A 4& + 5 6 # 6# "@ " + - $- %

#6# # - " # 6# . # 6# 7 8 . % = + 5 6 - "

6 6# @ 5 . # "2 # 8 .3A

% ! 4 4 + 5 6 6 ()'0 " # 2 # 8 . >

4 + 5 6 #- 6 ## " ,

9## # " "

- #" 6 " - ""# ## . "2 ## 8 .48 +5 6 #

J "" 6

"# " 6 # " "#

"# A 6# # #2

## " "#$

### " "

&& . , - ## #- - " - # = # A " "# # 2 + # G #-

#- 5 " " - - &;

,6#- G " &* %

# 78- ### &?

&<&*

/ /

12 )2 "!3 (4+%56" (!% $, !6 12 )2 " 3")(78 , !6