High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16283/2017allowed

Rajesh Goyal And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-08-08Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath6 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!)#&*+!,!'-"*#.& #"%"%'#.& /& *#"!"# !.+!'!!'-"*#.& #&0'-#'"& 1( 1( 1( 1(2 31 441 2 31 441 2 31 441 2 31 441 .#&#'"( 1.)!+ !%'5-6$!"#5 ."*#0#"%"%'#.& 1.!7.!8*1*7'"!5 5!.+!'! 441 5 441 5 441 5 441 5 *# 0#"%"%'#.& *!6# $*!,,#'9#- "*# .-#. "*# ,,#$".5 %&!.-!"#- :!'- "*#;;%&&%'#.5%&!.-!"#- 8+ <*%$* "*#+ *!6# 8##' -%.#$"#- " 0!+ ! &7; :5=5>=? "<!.-& "*# -# %$%#'"&"!;0-7"+!'- =?"<!.-&.#9%&".!"%'$*!.9#& '8.%# 5"*#0#"%"%'#.&*!-07.$*!&#-@!'!, ;!.,! ,!'- &%"7!"#-%'#<1-#,<'A"#'&%'5%&!.6%-#/!&%@! : -!"#-

.!&!,#$'&%-#.!"%' 5 5=?!

"#.!

%A%'9&"!;0-7"+ 5:>5 =?*#0#"%"%'#.&.#$#%6#-!'"%$#%&&7#-7'-#.7,#=BC !.+!'!"!;0B.#6#'"%' '-#./!,7!"%' '&".7;#'"&C7,#&5> . &*." E"*# 7,#&2F 8#$!7&# "*# 78 #9%&".!.5 %&!. 6%-# *%& 1#; ?-!"#- :;!-#!.# #.#'$#""*#,,#$".5'"*#8!&%& !' !7-%" 8)#$"%'5 .#9!.-%'9 -# %$%#'$+ &"!;0 -7"+ " "*# "7'#

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

: "%",#- !& IJ%,# %'9* IJ%,# %'9* IJ%,# %'9* IJ%,# %'9* /& ;;%&&%'#.5 %&!. %6' %&!. !'- "*#.& ;;%&&%'#.5 %&!. %6' %&!. !'- "*#.& ;;%&&%'#.5 %&!. %6' %&!. !'- "*#.& ;;%&&%'#.5 %&!. %6' %&!. !'- "*#.&K -#$%-#-' ' "*# "*#. *!'-5 ,#!.'#- $7'&#, . "*# .#&0'-#'"& *!& &78;%""#-"*!""*#0#"%"%'#.&*!-<.'9,+!

%A#-"*#&"!;0-7"+5$!,$7,!"#- H >? 0#. &G +!.-5 <*#.#!& "*# $,,#$". .!"# 0.#6!%,%'9 %' "*# !.#! <*#.#,!'-*!&8##'&,-<!& ?0#.&G+!.-"%&!,&&78;%""#-"*!" "*#.# %& ' #... $;;%""#- 8+ "*# .#&0'-#'"& !& "*# .# #.#'$# 7'-#. #$"%':B "*#$"$!'8#;!-#<%"*%'"*.##+#!.& .;"*#-!"# .#9%&".!"%' "*#&!,#-##- *!6# *#!.- ,#!.'#- $7'&#, . "*# 0!."%#& !'- 0#.7&#- "*# .#$.-<%"*"*#%.!8,#!&&%&"!'$# '.-#."!00.#$%!"#"*#%..#&0#$"%6#!.97;#'"&5%"<7,-8# .#,#6!'"";#'"%'#$"%': "*#$"5<*%$*.#!-!&7'-#.(

I:'&".7;#'"&7'-#.6!,7#-*<"8# -#!," <%"* BC "*# #9%&"#.%'9

%$#. !00%'"#-7'-#."*##9%&".!"%'$"5> 5 <*%,# .#9%&"#.%'9 %'&".7;#'" ".!'& #..%'9 !'+ 0.0#."+ *!& .#!&' " 8#,%#6# "*!""*# 6!,7# 0.0#."+ . "*# $'&%-#.!"%'5 !& "*#$!&#;!+8#5*!&'"8##'".7,+&#" ."* %' "*# %'&".7;#'"5 *# ;!+5 !

"#. .#9%&"#.%'9 &7$*%'&".7;#'"5.# #."*#&!;#",,#$".

. -#"#.;%'!"%' "*# 6!,7# . $'&%-#.!"%'5!&"*#$!&#;!+8#L"*#0.0#. -7"+0!+!8,#"*#.#' C'.#$#%0" .# #.#'$#7'-#.&78&#$"%' BC5 "*# ,,#$". &*!,,5 !

"#. 9%6%'9 "*# 0!."%#& ! .#!&'!8,# 00."7'%"+ 8#%'9 *#!.- !'- !

"#. *,-%'9 !' #'G7%.+ %' &7$* ;!''#.!&;!+8#0.#&$.%8#-8+.7,#&;!-# 7'-#. "*%& $"5 -#"#.;%'# "*# 6!,7# . $'&%-#.!"%'!'-"*#-7"+!&!

.#&!%-!'- "*#-# %$%#'"!;7'" -7"+5% !'+5&*!,,8# 0!+!8,#8+"*#0#.&',%!8,#"0!+"*#-7"+ C *# ,,#$". ;!+ &7 ;"75 . '?.#$#%0" .# #.#'$# .; "*# '&0#$". #'#.!, #9%&".!"%'."*##9%&".!. ! -%&".%$"%'<*&#)7.%&-%$"%'"*#0.0#."+. !'+ 0."%' "*#.# <*%$* %& "*# &78)#$" ;!""#. "*#%'&".7;#'"%&&%"7!"#5!00%'"#- 7'-#. "*# #9%&".!"%' $"5 > 5 &*!,,5 <%"*%' "*.## +#!.& .; "*# -!"# .#9%&".!"%' !'+ %'&".7;#'"5 '" !,.#!-+ .# #..#-"*%;7'-#.&78&#$"%'B,C5$!,, . !'-#A!;%'#"*#%'&".7;#'" ."*#07.0&# &!"%& +%'9*%;&#, !&""*#$..#$"'#&&

: %"& 6!,7# . $'&%-#.!"%'5 !& "*# $!&# ;!+ 8#5!'-"*#-7"+0!+!8,#"*#.#'!'-% !

"#. &7$*#A!;%'!"%'5*#*!&.#!&'&"8#,%#6# "*!""*#6!,7#.'&%-#.!"%'*!&'"8##' ".7,+ &#" ."* %' "*# %'&".7;#'"5 *# ;!+ -#"#.;%'#"*#6!,7#.$'&%-#.!"%'!'-"*# -7"+ !& !

.#&!%- %' !$$.-!'$# <%"* "*# 0.$#-7.#0.6%-#- .%'&78&#$"%' CL!'-"*#-# %$%#'"!;7'" -7"+5% !'+5 &*!,,8#0!+!8,#8+"*#0#.&',%!8,#"0!+ "*#-7"+( .6%-#- "*!" "*# ,,#$". &*!,,5 <%"*%' ! 0#.%- "< +#!.& .; "*# -!"# "*# $;;#'$#;#'" "*# '-%!' "!;0 B!.+!'! ;#'-;#'"C $"5 > 5 !,& 8# $;0#"#'" " !$" !& !

.#&!%- %' .#&0#$" "*# %'&".7;#'"& .#9%&"#.#- ' . !

"#. "*#

%.&"-!+ 6#;8#.5> !'-8# .#"*#

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

#$#%0" "*#.#0." "*#!7-%"8+"*#;0".,,#.!'-7-%". #'#.!, '-%! . 8+ !'+ "*#. !7"*.%"+ !7"*.%&#- 8+ "*# "!"# 6#.';#'" . &7 ;"7 ' "*# 0.#&#'" $!&#5 !-;%""#-,+5 %" %& '" !' !$"%'%'%"%!"#-8+"*#,,#$".$7; %&".

%$#.&7;"7.!"*#.%"*!&8##' "!@#' ' "*# .# #.#'$# ;!-# 8+ "*# 78 #9%&".!. 6%-# *%& ;#; > -!"#- =: 5 <* %& '" ! $;0#"#'" !7"*.%"+ 7'-#. #$"%' :B C "*# $" " ;!@# #6#'"*#.# #.#'$#*7&5"*#!$"%'%'%"%!"#- !9!%'&""*#0#"%"%'#.'"*#.# #.#'$#;!-# 8+"*#78#9%&".!.5 %'-%'"#.;& #$"%' :B "*#$"%&0!"#'",+%,,#9!,K

*7&5 %'6%#<"*#.# 5 "*#0.#&#'" 0#"%"%'%& !,,<#- !'-"*# %;079'#-.-#.0!&&#-8+"*#,,#$".5%&!.-!"#- :!'- ;;%&&%'#.5%&!.-!"#- !.#*#.#8+G7!&*#- B B B B441 C 441 C 441 C 441 C

*#"*#.&0#!@%'9?.#!&'#- ( #&? *#"*#.#0."!8,# ( #&?