High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15458/2024disposed of

Union Of India And ORS v. No 10466216 M Ex Hav Randhir Singh And ANR

2024-12-12Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Ms. Justice Kirti Singh12 pages

" !"#$#% #&'& (") ****

# + " ""#,%""- ( #%#(" # (" # ./+/./.0 12 -03% # # " &# 4 5 #& 55 %," "5&#4( +(" #(

# &,##&&,

$%&'$($%)*+,'-.

. " && "+/.(#6##&1 3 7# 4.8/8+9:;# ,# 5"# (4"<5 0+/++99:#( +.## 08. #(=#&(

<5 "#(%" -&& (5 5' ++/8+99:# 5"# 0//8./+: "5(

<5% " ,# ( (( (4 " # /01

! 2

! 45001 !2

! 50001 6 37,+(078#,9:,;0&8< 37,+(078= #

# &4(,"5",## >?/@(&( "& "#4

"# &#

4&#<5 0 " # &5&#4(" +,## 7 5# #

75 " 7 5# ""( (" &# ! 5#&6# "#(# ,###& " +

,#((& #& ("&&#'44< # +A/../+9 "#(% " # ,# 5"#&&

(" 5 &&#'%,"< # .:+.././ "# 75 "5&#4(" # & &

< % +(& ::/(./..%

("&# 4 5 #&55 %," "5# #5"#&& "#(# 75 "# % 5#4 #&&, < # ./+/./.0 "#<#("#

2#5 "#(

!" "

!&'

(

) * +

, - .

/'0&& 1

- &&/

'" 4

5 A &

< (4"#(# ## "1#3% "&# 4 5 #&55 %" -( #"#(& "# #"#,

("' -78+8-%8;,7&>0;,'+& ; 6(5 4#B#((5<# 7 5# ",% #(&##5( 4 ,"" " (#&&4(# #<-C-<#44 (" (5 &% " && "#4% #"#& # %" 54 & %##44 ("54 ##

(5# &"4%#""#44# 5 %" #%"&4"5 5# & "5 #& 5# & 54#

# &4&#<5%"#5= %(4%"5& (""7

4 " D &2'%5#&

" " &<# ## #" ( " # < 5 # 2#5

"#( &6- (

7 8

# $9

: &" ;

, < - 6'&=

- %:#3 >$ # $-

?3 !0 3 /#$@ # $A

#3 6$ # $

?3 /#$@ #$

?/#$@ # $

C D

?/#$@E # $

C D

, :

=F C #C < $ && G =;

8 F < = '6

? 5<# 13("# <2#5 5&% " " & 5&#%"#,"# # & 54#& #44 ("54 ## (5# &"4%# ,"5" " 2 ( ./ @ <% "% " " # 5" # &

44 = <#& (4"4% " = # " (( # & : "&%"# 4( # &# 44 ("54 ## (5# &"4%," 54#&

,"# # &#=#4(./@4% 4#<& = # 5&## (4 " ! 5#& 6# % #" 5# & 5 "#"# ## # & # &

4&#<5 "# 5&## 54 7 ";

,< - 6'&=

- %:#3 >$ 9 "4%" ""#4#

<-C-<" "5#&# 4#&"#&"(#44 ("

(5# &"455 %5#&&,"#"# ("

54 && %"5 " 54 ,"# #!<%" """#&#(" 4% "# ," # # "% " 55 =&% " " # "# ( #13 (# #%#" 4 #=&(" <5 # # 44 ( " (5 # &"4 4#<&%"(< " ,4=# ( 1#3<-C-<"55 % "4&%# 5#%"# 4#- 5"# %"%"5&#4#

54& 5< # &!<%#&&"(#5 # 554#5 # # " ( <5 " 55 %# 5&&5E %"( 5&# ,"""

(# #<-C-<"55 %#=&=# ( 4&# <5 # ) " #4 #

# &4&#<5 +/ 6"##4#%" 54#&("#(" 5&13"#"5# #&( # &" 55 % & #3"4(#55#5("55 4&# <5%4 54 5 "! 5#& 6# <-#-< " ," # # ,"5"

",<% 5455& "4 ( 54&

3 (" # "(% 4# #& =& 5455& "! 5#&6# % # (4 ( 4&# <5

# &4&#<5%#""#4 5 #& # ++ "%("4 5#&"& "#" #5&

"#< 5 4 5#&2#4#("55

4# %"" 54 & <5%"%" #4,&& 4 "#<# <5%" #1#3%"! 5#&6# = #"#( 55& +. !<%#& 5&# #%"#4# # ("! 5#&6# (&&," &&# ,'"#-

("F ! 5#&1!&#3%.//.GF &4 #&5&F +0 "(%"# , 4 ,""4( "# <5&%,""#"4(&4(" "4%"#(#&4#4 5#&2#4#

4# <-#-<""#&"%"# 5#45 4 # "4 # ) ,"" 4 5#4 # "#"# #,## 4## !<% #&= 4 %(4"(#5#"# %,""" #5##&2-"(" #%# )" "(%"%""&&4(" #B &#5% <-#-< " #5< "4 ( 4&#<5%," %"'4#55& "#"( " # #",##=&(" <5"4 # #5",## & 5#4#

4&#<5 +8 #

%#&= #" (4" 5 %,"""! 5#&6# % #&&5 4#B#

#& 5<#5 #&5"5B%#5&#&## " # <(" #%" "4&4( #(4 5#& 5"=% " <& " &5B 5"# 5 55% ,"(4%#"" # 5#45 !<%("#

4&4(#& &#&%" 4# 5455& =# "(%" ="#&4#B

&#5%#",#5 #& , (

4&#<5 # & 54

(4#5(4&#<5'#&%("#4&

5"=#"# (#&4#B &#5%" " ! 5#&6# 55 %&# #55&%"#"##"

4#5 5(# #% "# 4# # " "&4(#&"#4%#<# (5 &#&" =#5< 5)"(%

"5( (4&#<5% ,& ##&& &# #,&&55& "! 5#&6# %"##5<

5#4 5 (4 # ((5< 5##& 5 55 ," ",& #&( # & +A

,<%,"# #<%"'=

2#5 "5("%# 5#45 " &#4 5#& # 2#5 "#( # & <5

<5 '5 ,"<5

# ! # - &(#< # 5

#" 6" ,"# 5 !#5&# 4#

5 # 1+3 #5 ## &# 4&# <5 ' ' '," 4 #I

(5 H +8

#5"# ( &# 4&#

<5 !

H #5## &# 4&# <5 +; # ("5 <#&"##"4(" #&4#B &#5#" 5#44# 4 ("5&1#3 5&# " D &2'5# & #

$% "! 5#& 6# %"#4 #,"5"",<% ( " % 54& "4% 4#B&4# ( % " 5&## ( &#, 7

4 1#3 "# " "#4"#"5 ("# # ,##=&( (<5%= (#<# & , <-#-<" " " "# 4 # & "&# < 5 "# 4

5#4 5# " ,<% " # 5# < 5 #

5 5"# <-#-<" %#"(5 & "# 4% ##&&#& 5##

#&"! 5#&6# % # &(" #<( #" % " " 4&4 ( " # ( &5B 5"#

5 5##& 55 5"=13% ," 4# 5#4 #<& "#" (" #"#4&%

5#45 (4#5 #& 5(#4&"!<% " ,##&= # "4 5#&%"#

" # (#,&&(4 ##",##5 #& # # 5#4"#

5#4# &4&# <5 +?

,<%## (1#3% 5&"#"#

5 # (4 # # "#< 5 "21#3 # &%5< 5 "41#3"# & "%" %" '5# <, "# "("4 5#&

# %#2#5 1#3'5&%" 5 55# # "#&&(4 #% " "

(" #5# # #=&(#5 #& 5 (#4&"'#&%= 5&# #(4 (4&#<5#

%= 5&#

# & 54

(4&#<5

" +: !<% " " # " "# " # 55 ,"&<5 5#4(4 " (5& #"##5##% 5"24# #" &<# &#%,"5"4#B" (" ## #5##% #("=&"##5"%D

# (4 " ( 4&# <5 5#4 #

("4&#<55=5%" &#5B("# 24# #" &#% 5#" '55& %"#<(" ("# # " "55 ##5##%" %"#

# 5&# 54 #

# & (4&#<5 +9 "%54("7

4 " 2'%5#& #&

' ()B *+, !"- ,"%# 5&##4# " 2%"#" (( ((%#""# 54 ,

"55 &#&#&" # (# & "

5#4 < " ( " B =# " # (( 4# "(#< ./

< ", 5 " 5&## ( &#, 4# < 51#34#B"# 5&## #2&#(&#, 4%" %"2&#(&#,4%#4# < 5 1#3#&4#B"" 5( (<-#-<"

(5 & 55 % % % #& & " 55 %"##4B" # (" ,4# 4# " %# "#%"(&&54&4%#& " % 5<(" #%(#%( &## &#5" .+ "(% " # ( " ( ( " # ((%4("< 51#3 " #& 55 %#& (((4#&& #&# = "& 0-$( +.8+,7&>0;,'+& .. #(4#"%"'( 4", # ," <## <%"#4 4

.0 "4 %## "&# #& 55 %4## # #((4 .8 (#& ,"#&& #&5#13%(# 5

5" 1 !#"4# >8&>8+;:8$)0-*?+8$;,-8.

8;?, >8&>8++8:,+&$@(8 8;?,