Shamsher Singh And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ORS



 
      
  



!"#"

$%  & & '

()*#) + ("$,) $ $

) + &&&

"

"

$ +-#.

/ +#0# ( 

+1$ $

) +# &&& #2 $ $ #
3% 45 3(& (
  

 



 


 

  ! "

### "

)+"6 & -+7.& $ %&    

'() % (  !&(


     

  

*+, ,- .,//0
1+ / '&& &'% 2    .'(3& % '  (

2 &  ( &

' (&%'

    '45678 

 $   '0      (,/ ,9 .,/"&' // ,- .,/"0
1- $."

,- .,/:& :

''0 

 0
1//    ;

 .+ /, .,/:

0
1/.'  8&)   '&( 

'&9- &&&

$( (+/ ,< .,/:/ /, .,/: '1(   (7 8& $&

+'+, ,= .,/=0
1/+%( 

'&

&'% (1 (   >

$&&'   '%&) %     

  $ (8&

 ) %&(
& ?(1  "   ) % 0
1/" 8&)  

+, ,9 .,/=0
1/:&

"  % '  '%  '% % '%

.9 /.

.,/=  ,"

/, .,/=0
1/=    (  &&  (@ .,/= (

    $  ( ,= /.

.,/=0
1/9   & 7 8&)  &&&) %2 (9-  

7  &

''%

8  :=   & '''%&.,//

@            

       

 /.'(   

+ % ) %&1(1
& ?( & 
(

)  %&1(1
&    ?(       .,,+    &    '    A    72A   (&   &&)(( A(' (&&'%   '  3     '  (         :    =    (  ! % 

'( 4 444 /. )    3   $  4 4      '    

 

(      (    &  

( &       (             )1

!& &           ((          (    ) ((.,,=&(  .:B 4 4(  (  ((     A    7    4 4        (( 

 .-'1


 

   



 

  

      !"

 

9        

# 

"  $  

      # 

     

     $  

    #

    #

"

      "      #





$

 # 

# %  & !"

 

     '   ## "    

 

   

             

       

#    #    

& "  #$   (     )



#  *

  + 

&   

*

+ 

& 

  

 

  

# 

    #     !"

   "

     

"        )



# *

+ 

& 

*

+ 

    

 

   # &     &  ## "        

  

, ##  "   

   - "

  

"

%   

#  

     !"

  ##   .



 "   

    

       

# 





  ##    #           #    /

 +

  

   

#      1 #    2,

3 

+

   2)   +    2 4   0

 & 5,*64    

"    ,-67     





       /&     8         

 +

9:

4   & #   



"  ,##    

 :

4    

%  8 

 

  

  



; 
     ;

"   

 , # +

 )

;

 C &0
1/"(

                   &    % (&& (&  (8 /: A72A(' (% (&   $ '&(

     8 =,,,21    (    (    (&  0&   &    2'(&'%( (   >    (' E /.)3!&(  


    !

   

@,"

,< .,/9)

'&1 D,

 

 #   

& #   

< ##    .

 

 

   



 +# %   

   %   ===&   " 

     

#  , 8 ==;

,"

,< .,/9  ,< /, .,/9           
 %       )1(1
&  %&   ?  

  3     

' (1 (1) %      1%      

8&)  /< /, .,/"081 "2/ (1(1) %( * ( 8!  % 1% () ''%&&  

 $          %&    '   (&  (  !  ;(  '       

(    (( '

 

(   $ / (,+ /, .,,9+/ ,< .,/:      .       (,/ ,9 .,/,+/ ,< .,/:

$A7  ."

,- .,/:0
1//&& ) %( 1.,/:   '&.+ /, .,/:0
1.

 ;

    '  &&    

 '&    9-     '

 

,- // .,/:    ,:

,.

.,/=  &  &  &  (

 2

&  &  (  ''(A

 &    +/ ,+ .,/=  0  81"2.    $    7

8&  )           ,- /.

.,/=  &&& (1(1) %9-  ) 8081"2"  & ! ('   $''

:='&&('&

(!&( ()


  

    

&&&'' (           
 %    (  

  

(&

' "1  '& ( $A 1?'

  )1 %&)(
&

?   &&)(('(%( 1
>1.. / 

&

&    #  8 



#

  3 



 



%          3 

;

>? )  ## 

  0

 +





 #   

         

   #    

 #  ## 

     %   

 ##

%

 #

     "

#  3 

;

$8&)      & &( (  ) %& ' '

 $  ( 4 4 /.) 3

& (.,,<.8 F:.9"

# $%&'

 (

 ) *+

!,-   
.   ' 7A'&'  ( ' $'F ) )A%?(

'4 4   '        '&

 (    $  7  A ('   &1
)  

   :

% 

< 

   

"  

  @

@ 

  

         , #     

: +

    )

    )     

  



#  



    

  "



"#"



 #    , 

 

   4 3 

    # &     / 0/ ! 0 '

    & A/==1B +1    /

      %      :

  0

    C

  +

# +

":

%D  , 

# 





  

   # # 

#  # 

:

%E  

 #   #"##



 &  "    

  / # F

#        

 #  

  

 

  "   

,

 





  

   

     +

"  :

%

  /  #     :

4    

   #  ,

 / # F

#  

  #  

  5 +

 5   #  -

        F         

 

 #  ##

  )  #  

 +

    

"  



   #

  "    5   # -

+

"   , .  "



#   /

      

    ;

? !&( 1 ,     2     /  ,.  30     
.   .,,9/

) $ <:=45, 6 6  8  '/ '

.!  / %  /*   .,,:/

) $ "/''

  78)   ) & 

?

''%&   (      /

' +'( !&(4 

() 


     

   (  

7(

 & & '   -   .

";1$#)"

 )

) + #2 <"$,=+ # $

%  #=

)

) + + + >7

%

 #=