High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21749/2014disposed of

Prem Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2018-01-18Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan4 pages

!"# #$%&%'( ) ) !"# #$%&%'( ) ) !"# #$%&%'( ) ) !"# #$%&%'( ) ) *#+,%'-.

*#+,%'-.

#"%"%'#* #"%"%'#* #"%"%'#* #"%"%'#* /#*&0& /#*&0& /#*&0& /#*&0& ,"!"# 0'1!2!'3".#*& ,"!"# 0'1!2!'3".#*& ,"!"# 0'1!2!'3".#*& ,"!"# 0'1!2!'3".#*& #&4'3#'"& #&4'3#'"& #&4'3#'"& #&4'3#'"& ( ( ( ( 5 6 ,

7 5 6 ,

7 5 6 , , 5 6 , , 5 6 , , 5 6 , , *#&#'"( *,,!'3.08 39$!"# *".#4#"%"%'#* * !-+.!',.0+!'8,* 80'1!2 *0*+##",%'-.8 39$!"# **#&4'3#'": ;;;

1!<70+!*%""!=8 *!=

1!<70+!*%""!=8 *!= .#4*!<#*%'".%&4#"%"%' %=#32<>!< 402=%$%'"#*#&"

=%"%-!"%'0'3#* *"%$=#: ".#'&"%"0"%' '3%!8%& *%&&0!'$# !>*%"%'".#'!"0*# +!'3!+0&3%*#$"%'-*#&4'3#'"& !'3?

"@"*#&"*!%'".#9#*=!3%'- *!$"**==#<&8>.%$.!*#2#%'- *0'%'$'"*!9#'"%' 9!*%0&4*9%&%'& ".#"*/#.%$=#& $"!& >#==!&*0=#& *!+#3".#*#0'3#*

%3!9%"3!"#3 ,.,0A.>%'3#*70+!*8 ,8%&"*%$"*!'&4*"

%$#*8&.%!*40*.!&2##' %=#3 '4!*!&?

!'3 8%"%&&"!"#3".!""*!

%$$.#$A%'-%&2#%'-$'30$"#3!"*#-0=!* %'"#*9!=&&!&"$.#$A9!*%0&"*!

%$9%=!"%'&%'$=03%'-".#4=<%'- 9#*=!3#3"*!$"*"*==#<&$!**<%'-&0-!*$!'#!'3".#*4*30$#&" .!& 0*".#*2##'&02+%""#3".!":"*!$"*"*==#<&2#!*%'-#-%&"*!"%' & B)CD :@8 B)D :@8 B

@ 8 B?D :8

D@ ?!'3 B

7D :

@>#*#$.!==!'#3!'3%+40'3#3 *".#

#'$# 9#*=!3%'- >!*#'#&&%&!=&+!3#"".# !*+#*&8>.

40*$.!&#3 &0-!*$!'# *+ *#&4'3#'" :BD&

,04#* 6%+%"#3 !'3.!>!8%&"*%$"&.%!*40*!'3D&'3%!',0$*&#,0-!*6%+%"#38 0A#*%!'%&"*%$"&.%!*40*.#*#=#9!'"4!*!& ".#&"!"0&*#4*"

*#!3&!&0'3#*(B E? .!"!& !*!&".#!'&>#*%'-*#&4'3#'"D3#4'#'"%& $'$#*'#38".#"*!

%$$.#$A%'-%&2#%'-$'30$"#3!"

*#-0=!* %'"#*9!=& " $.#$A 9!*%0& "*!

%$ 9%=!"%'& %'$=03%'- ".# 4=<%'- 9#*=!3#3 "*!$"* "*==#<& $!**<%'-&0-!*$!'#!'3".#*4*30$#&

.!"30*%'-".#$0*&# "*!

%$$.#$A%'-8:*!$"* *==#<&2#!*%'-#-%&"*!"%'& B)CD :@8 )D :@8 B

@ 8 B?D :8

D@ ? !'3 B

7D :

@ >#*# $.!==!'#3 !'3 %+40'3#3 * ".#

#'$# 9#*=!3%'- >.%=# $!**<%'- &0-!*$!'# !'3 ".#* 4*30$#& !'3 $+40'3%'- ## F@ 8DB >!& *#$9#*#3 *+ ".#$'$#*'#3>'#*& *!$"**==#<&.#3#"!%= ".#$.!==!'&8

#'$#&$++%""#3!'3".#!+0'"

%'#*#$9#*#3%&-%9#'2#=>( ,= ,= ,= ,= *!$"**==#< *!$"**==#< *!$"**==#< *!$"**==#< .!==!' .!==!' .!==!' .!==!'

#'$#

+0'"

%'#%'&

! !

! ! "

# $%

# &'(

) # !*

! ! " # &'+

# !! ! !

)# &, &

# !*

! ! "

&# -!

# @ .!" ".# !'!-%'- %*#$"*D!'!-#* D& ,04#* 6%+%"#3 !'3.!>!8 %&"*%$" &.%!*40*8

#&4'3#'" : !'3 D& '3%!' ,0$*&# ,0-!* 6%+%"#38 0A#*%!' %&"*%$" &.%!*40* >#*# !=& *#G0#&"#3 2< ".# !'&>#*%'- *#&4'3#'"D 3#4'#'" 9%3#.%&

%$#=#""#* )D 3!"#3:

"+!A#!==0"#

*"&"$*#!"#!>!*#'#&&!+'- ".# !*+#*& *#-!*3%'- ".# $'&#G0#'$#& 9#*=!3%'-3!'-#*0&4*1#$"%'.#<>#*#!=& %'

*+#3".!"%'$!&#".#<'##3!'<!&&%&"!'$# *+ ".#

%$#"$*#!"#!>!*#'#&&!+'-".# !*+#*&%'

".%&2#.!= 8".#&!+#&.!==2##H"#'3#3"".#+& ".!"".#*3#* ".%&'52=#0*"!*#$+4=%#3>%".

%'=#""#*!'3&4%*%" : .!"%'*#&4'&#"".#!29#$++0'%$!"%' *+ ".#!'&>#*%'-*#&4'3#'"D3#4'#'"8".#*#&%3#'"

,0-!*&6%+%"#39%3#".#%*=#""#*

,6( ( ? 3!"#3 ? %'"%+!"#3 ".!" 30*%'- ".# $!'#$*0&.%'-&#!&'8".#<>#*#*#-0=!*=<*-!'%I%'- !>!*#'#&& 4*-*!++#& >%". ".# .#=4 =$!=

3+%'%&"*!"%'%'".#%*,0-!*%== ".!&!=&2##' %'"%+!"#32<".#+".!"".#<>#*#4*9%3%'-*# =#$"*& %'#!$.!'3#9#*<,0-!*!'#"*==#<"!9%3!'< A%'3 +%&.!44#'%'-.#<.!9#!=&&044=%#3&+# ".#$4%#& ".#4*#&&'#>&>.%$..!3!44#!*#3 %'".#4*#&&%'".%&2#.!= J ? '9%#> ".#!29#8$0'&#= *".#4#"%"%'#*&"!"#&".!"

4#"%"%'+!<2#3%&4&#3 !&&0$.!"".%&&"!-#>%".=%2#*"<"".# 4#"%"%'#*"!44*!$.".%&0*"!-!%'%'$!&#!'<-*%#9!'$#&0*9%9#& 2< 0*'%&.%'- 0==!'33#"!%=4!*"%$0=!*&

.#4#"%"%'%&3%&4&#3 >%".!

*#&!%3=%2#*"< @ >#9#*8".#-*!'" 4#*+%&&%'" %=#".# *#&.4#"%"%'

!&402=%$%'"#*#&"=%"%-!"%'6&.!=='"4*#$=03#".# #'$. *+ "#&"%'-".#$*#3#'"%!=& ".#4#"%"%'#*9%IB!B9%I".#+!%'"!%'!2%=%"< ".# 4#"%"%' !& 6 0'3#* ".# 5!%'"!%'!2%=%"< 02=%$ '"#*#&"

!%'"!%'!2%=%"< 02=%$ '"#*#&"

6%"%-!"%'0=#&8 5 6%"%-!"%'0=#&8 5 6%"%-!"%'0=#&8 5 6%"%-!"%'0=#&8 5 '$!&#8! *#&.>*%"4#"%"%'*#=!"%'-"".# 4*#&#'"$!0&#%& %=#32<".#4#"%"%'#*8".#

%$#&.!=="!-".#*#$*3& ".#4*#&#'">*%"4#"%"%'%#

7 6

!'0!*< )8 )

!'0!*< )8 ) , 6 , 6 , 6 , 6 A!'$.!'

.#".#*&4#!A%'-D*#!&'#3K #&D .#".#**#4*"!2=#K #&D