Chandigarh Administration Thru Home Secy, Ctu And ORS. v. Kamal Prashad And ORS.


 

       


   

 

     

   



  

          !    

  


 



   "#$%#$&%#$'()*$+$,%-#.(/)0$&$1.&%$)2,%#$)2*$-%3 $-



 

 "  !"!



  

!  !!

 

  

 "!

 

  

!

#$4#5&*$5*52,-%&$-1.,)$,%.

2-%#5%#$1&.)(4$)65/-$ #.(-$&$,%&$4$21%-%.-#.7%#5%#$75-&$-2)2,*5% 8$4%.&9


#5,)2*5&#6&.+1&2/:;; %. (*(-%; 5,) 4/52+$) #.(-$&$,% 5//.75,4$  7#2/$  #$  75-  54%(5//<  &$-2)2,*  5%   89  $4%.&  


#5,)2*5&#



(&2,*%#$4.(&-$.6$,=(2&<2%45+$%./2*#%%#5% 89 $4%.&
 #5,)2*5&#75-5//.%%$)%.65%#$&.6&$-1.,)$,%. 7#.755 .>$&,+$,%-$&>5,%7#$&$5-&$-1.,)$,%. 4#.-$%.1&.)(4$65?$ #.(-$&$,%&$4$21%5-%#&.(*##$75-&$-2)2,*5% 8$4%.&9


#5,)2*5&#.7,$)0<.,$ 5+5&5, 2,)2,*-7$&$&$4.&)$)5*52,-%#2+ 2,%#$$,=(2&<5,)5-5&$-(/%.67#24##$75-)2-+2--$)6&.+-$&>24$



$-1.,)$,%.

4#5//$,*$)#2-)2-+2--5/ %%#$2,%$&>$,%2.,.6%#$ .(&% #$75-&$2,-%5%$)2,-$&>24$ @$&42-2,*%#$.1%2.,6.&6&$-#)$15&%+$,%5/ $,=(2&<%#$$15&%+$,%5*52,1&.4$$)$)5*52,-%#2+   $-1.,)$,%.

75-5*52,6.(,)*(2/%<5,)75-1(,2-#$)72%#-%.115*$.6%7.2,4&$+$,%- 72%#4(+(/5%2>$$66$4%%&$5%2,*%#$2,%$&>$,2,*1$&2.)6&.+%#$)5%$.6 )2-+2--5/%.%#$)5%$.6'.2,2,*5-/$5>$72%#.(%15<

$-1.,)$,%.

4#5//$,*$)%#$.(%4.+$.6%#$-$4.,)&.(,) .6  $,=(2&<  1&.4$$)2,*-  0$6.&$  %#$  &20(,5/  7#.  #5>2,*  6.(,)  %#5% &$-1.,)$,%.

75-$,%2%/$)%.4/52+.(-$ $,%//.75,4$7#$,#$7554%(5//<&$-2)2,*72%##2-65%#$&5-1$&%#$ (/$-2*,.&$)%#$650&245%$) &$4$21%-1&.)(4$)0<&$-1.,)$,%.

6.&4/52+2,*.(-$ $,%//.75,4$ 5,)  -$%  5-2)$  %#$  $,=(2&< 1&.4$$)2,*-  7#24#  4(/+2,5%$)  2,  %#$  50.>$ 1$,5/%<

!$5&,$)4.(,-$/511$5&2,*6.&%#$7&2%1$%2%2.,$&-(0+2%%$)%#5% %#$ &20(,5/  652/$)  %.  ,.%24$  %#5%  &$-1.,)$,%  .   1&.)(4$)  65?$  5,) 650&245%$)&$,%5/&$4$21%-5-%#.(*##$75-&$-2)2,*5% 8-2%(5%$)2, $4%.&  9
  #5,)2*5&#  .7,$)  0<  .,$  5+  5&5,  %  2-  #2-  6(&%#$& -(0+2--2.,%#5%$>$,262%2-4.,-%&($)%#5%#$75-$,%2%/$)%..(-$ $,% //.75,4$5-#$75-&$-2)2,*72%##2-65%#$&2,%#$#.(-$7#24#755//.%%$)%.#2-65%#$&1&.)(4%2.,.6650&245%$)).4(+$,%75-,.%$@1$4%$) 6&.+5 .>$&,+$,%-$&>5,%



   /$5&,$) 4.(,-$/ 511$5&2,* 6.& &$-1.,)$,% . >$#$+$,%/<-(0+2%%$)%#5%5-1$&%#$ (/$%#$7&2%1$%2%2.,$&75-$,%2%/$)%.

&$-2)$72%##2-65%#$&2,%#$#.(-$5//.%%$)%.#2+.&75-.7,$)0<#2+

A
,5-+(4#5-#$75-$,%2%/$)%.4/52+.(-$ $,%//.75,4$%#$5//$*$) 1&.)(4%2.,.6-(4#54$&%26245%$15/$-2,%.2,-2*,26245,4$ $5/-.-(0+2%%$) %#5%&$-1.,)$,%.

,$>$&1&.)(4$)-(4#565?$4$&%26245%$,.&#5)#$ -(66$&$)5,<-(11/$+$,%5&<-%5%$+$,%)(&2,*%#$4.(&-$.6-$4.,)&.(,).6 $,=(2&<5)+2%%2,*1&.)(4%2.,.6-(4#65?$&$,%5/&$4$21%-



#$*&5>5+$,.6%#$4#5&*$/$>$//$)5*52,-%&$-1.,)$,%. 75-%#5%#$#5>2,*1&.)(4$)65?$5,)650&245%$)&$,%5/&$4$21%6&.+51$&-., 7#.75-,.%%#$.7,$&.6%#$#.(-$+2-/$)5,)4#$5%$)%#$$15&%+$,% 7#24#54%7.(/)5+.(,%%.(,0$4.+2,*.651(0/24-$&>5,%  #$/.-- .445-2.,$)%.%#$ .>$&,+$,%.,544.(,%.61&.)(4%2.,.6-(4#54$&%26245%$ 2--$4.,)5&<  #$=($-%2.,2-7#$%#$&&$-1.,)$,%.

75-#.,$-%2, 4/52+2,*.(-$ $,%//.75,4$0<1&.)(42,*&$,%5/&$4$21%6&.+5*$,(2,$ -.(&4$ $&<(,6.&%(,5%$/<&$-1.,)$,%.

)$,2$-,.%.,/<%#$1&.)(4%2., .6  -(4#  5  65?$  &$,%5/  &$4$21%  6.&+  5  -1(&2.(-  -.(&4$  0(%  5/-.  %#$ -(11/$+$,%5&<-%5%$+$,%-(66$&$)0<#2+5)+2%%2,*%#$1&.)(4%2.,.6-(4# 4$&%26245%$)(&2,*%#$4.(&-$.6$,=(2&< #$.&2*2,5/&$4.&)-1&.)(4$)0< %#$7&2%1$%2%2.,$&$-%50/2-#$-%#5%&$-1.,)$,%. #5-1&.)(4$)565?$5,) 650&245%$)&$,%5/&$4$21%6&.+.,$ 5+5&5,7#.75-,.%%#$.7,$&.6  8$4%.&9
 #5,)2*5&#  $-1.,)$,%.

#5-45%$*.&245//< 5)+2%%$)  2,  #2-  -(11/$+$,%5&< -%5%$+$,%  -(66$&$)  )(&2,*  %#$ 4.(&-$ .6 -$4.,)&.(,).6$,=(2&<%#5%#$)2)1&.)(4$-(4#5&$,%5/&$4$21%5%%#$%2+$ 7#$,#$.&2*2,5//<4/52+$)#.(-$&$,%5//.75,4$6&.+%#$7&2%1$%2%2.,$&

(4#  5  &$,%5/  &$4$21%  +52,%52,$)  )(&2,*  %#$  &$*(/5&  4.(&-$  .6  .662425/ %&5,-54%2.,5,)%#$-(11/$+$,%5&<-%5%$+$,%-(66$&$)0<&$-1.,)$,%.

9
)(&2,*%#$4.(&-$.6$,=(2&<45,,.%5%5//0$)$,2$)0<&$-1.,)$,%.

#$7&2%1$%2%2.,$&#5-4.,>2,4$)%#$ .(&%%#5%%#.(*#5-1$&

(/$&$-1.,)$,%.

75-$,%2%/$)%.4/52+.(-$ $,%//.75,4$5-#$ 5//$*$)/<&$-2)$)72%##2-65%#$&#$#5)1&.)(4$)65?$&$,%5/&$4$21%6&.+5 1$&-.,7#.75-,.%%#$.7,$&.6%#$#.(-$5,)%#$&$0<#$+2-/$)5,) 4#$5%$)%#$$15&%+$,%

;

%2-57$//-$%%/$)1&.1.-2%2.,.6/57%#5%%#$ .(&%-#5//,.% 2,%$&6$&$72%#%#$62,)2,*-.6$,=(2&<5,)%#$1(,2-#+$,%575&)$)%#$&$2, (,/$--%#$)($1&.4$)(&$-5,)%#$1&2,421/$-.6,5%(&5/'(-%24$7$&$,.% 5)#$&$)  %.  0<  %#$  $15&%+$,%  )(&2,*  %#$  4.(&-$  .6  $,=(2&<  5,)  %#$ 1(,2-#+$,%75-)2-1&.1.&%2.,5%$-.+(4#-.2%-#.4?$)%#$4.,-42$,4$.6 %#$ .(&% ,.(&4.,-2)$&$)>2$7%#$&20(,5/#5-(,,$4$--5&2/<2,%$&6$&$) 72%#%#$7$//4.,-2)$&$)62,)2,*5,)%#$1&.1.&%2.,5%$1(,2-#+$,%575&)$) %.&$-1.,)$,%.

:

, >2$7  .6 %#$  50.>$ 7#2/$ (1-$%%2,* %#$ 2+1(*,$) .&)$& 15--$)0<%#$&20(,5/%#$7&2%1$%2%2.,-%5,)-5//.7$)

   "#  $    $0&(5&<  "

 # (/5%2 $