← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21081/2015dismissed

Ashok Sharma Nabhewala v. Punjab And Haryana High Court Th. Its Registrar And ORS.

2025-08-05Justice (To Be Nominated),Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari10 pages

 -1-





 

 

 





   





%&'

() *'+,-,(. ""

    8      

      84 ( 

 !  "

#  #

 !  "

#   # 

  # 





    (  2 

2   2 3 3 !

2 4 3 !

  (   2 2 !

2 4! 2 !

  (  "# 5555 !



    

 $ "&/ 0  6  ( 

    (   !        

  !

     *

   "#$%"$ # & '  7%0  

(    !  

((     !

7 2



            

 2  9 : 

! 7  2

   (

 

 

   

  ( 

(  "

   

 (    "")*"

""+  ,    

 (        



 4  )       

      - . 

 &

  /

( 0 0

 -2-

4 ;< << &    ?4 ;<< <.0 !

  =

  , " 6     (

   

     

'(  

  

   

  ,  -

<;   (  "    ( 

    

7  2 9:

 " 2 1! 

 % 2  9 = 2  !

@( # 2 A  9

 ) 21

9   + 2 ! :   %  >   

   2  !   :  

   2

!

 

     <$%"$=   :   

       6

(  %   2

>  ! ((   $+"$= >        

  

      



.

 2

(





>    

    :   

        

    (

 

 ( (6   

  = 6  (    ((  

  (      

   /(   

     

 ;<<  '  >  (( 

    2

    ( ( ! (    

 -3-

  ( 





) ) !

      ( 

  (( !

         2

       = 

, # 6  '

!

  (  

'

  (

  

( 

  

  !

  

       2

 

>( 

 >  6    (



   '



*(     

     2

       4  )    (

 

  ( 

 '

   ( 

 

 



   2

 ,  4 >     

      (       (  

    

 (( ! ;

   !

     )      

  (  "

    ( 

!  ((  

 



   (  "      

 ( ,    

 2

  

       

      2

 

  > 



  



;<<   

 

  !   

   (

 



    (



B 



         (

   4     

 

   (

 

 -4-  + -          ( 7  

((  

         ;<<  

   

        ///             

  

 &

"#$;"$$$0



  

 

A

(

 

'

!

  

  !

  

   ( 

 6

 

   (   

 !

     ( 

               



  (  

  : 



    

    4     ;<<   

  

 >     <  !

      ( 

         

(    (  

  ; :

   ( 

 

 

            

(         ! 

( ! ;<<  !

  

  !

>  

4  $ 6  

  ( (  

    

4  ;<<   



  

      6

   4  % ( !   

 - .



  





A 

4 =(



  ! ((

  

  - 

 4  # (

    

 

  &0

 (   

 

    

A

 

( (( 

 

 -5-

&0  



  7  

 (     

A



!

(  ((      !  

  '



A



 

6 ( !  4

(   

A

 (( ( 

 '   

 

!    

 )   

   



  

 

  !

    ( '

 !  

3,&1 &1'

45'0,(6- %445(0 0%2 () &1'

1,') 6-&,+' B  ( !     4  ) (   

  

 



  

 

 





  

A



( !

 45')'5'.&,%2 5,81& () &1'

'

%--(+,%&'

*0(+%&'- () &1'

%22(&&''"

 

( ! 



A

  '

( 

 ( !    

      

( 

!   (



  ;  

    

 

   

             7 







 !  



 7%5'

6-'54 (

  

 "  



   

  

  '  4 % % # ) ;  

  



           

 



 -6-

 



 !         

    "   ""      " 

! #   $ 

$       !   

         %&     "      ""    & $     '   

   $    

!    $  %&        )

 $) $             $    

&! *      $  %&     "  "    %& 

          +   &      

    """    '      $ %&  ,

 !           %& 

      "

"  '

&%&      "&  ""&  

  "  "     &     - &  &      "                 

       

 

."

$ & "

 $  %&     &      

 '   " " $ $"&  $    $      "                 /

 

"

   " !

" 

  !       "  #

  

!    & "     0   $              $     "    &                    "   $       



 -7-     "    $      $    

 



!         (   "

" &

!      "

"           2  "   " "    "$  "     "     $   "     &  " 3 3 '"      " $ &     & $      

         $

!        .                 $  

   

&!     $   "    "."         &!    $ $" 

"    $    &  "&                 4 & ! #          5 %  ) 7    &   

   $ $    &

!          "          $           

 $   "    &

!       

 )8 $  $   "  $  )  "       )     $

'!             

            + $   $ $  '!     

"       

&  $8 $   '    8 $  $ "    

 -8-  "     $ &             &   $    $  "."            $  '     '

!                ""    " "   $  

    &   

    $   "                "" 

                    '

!        &       "     .    & 

 "'

   "  $  

  '

!     %&             

          &    $    "  "       

         

 .

$  $      &    %      

!

'   4   

'( 

  

   

A

    

   (( !    2

     !

( ! 4 )( 







!  



*













 

A

  

(   !

   (

     

! ,   



 

!

     (          (  (( ! 

A



 -9-

= 6   

      4  )        !



   (

( (       

 

. 



   ,    

    (        

  

   

    (

 

4 +   '   !

6     

 4     ;<<  !



       6 

A

.

(   



7

 

 !    (

 #          !

 (     

  '

' 

 

   ;<< 6   

   (

    

  4

   



(

   

  ( 

 !

  !   

 (   ((  !  

A

   

 (B 

  

  

 

 A

    ( !   !

  

 ,   

   (



2

 



     

 ( !

    4

  

    

   (

    

 !      

 ( !    

( 

    



    (  > 

 ) 6   (

    

 

2

 >      

 -10-

      (

 

    

 ,!



 !

           

 !



  

 

 (     ( 

      = =  ,    

 + , 

    

!

     

(    *

   

 ;<<



> 

6  (  ! 

  

      <   ((    (  

# ""  # 

  # 

 









C (  *  C (  *