High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18418/2021dismissed

Ravi Prakash Yadav v. State Of Haryana And Others

2021-11-15Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

! "#$% " & '

() $ * +, -) .

"'",$/'+ 0"

'$ /+

'$ -$'",$/+1+ .1/()

2 $3/'+ 0"

4,-" 1"#/+

* 56 8$"""10"

"$ - "1-)* ""

#$%/" "11,#$ / 4

/" "

0"", 9 $", 6 : +;

" 0$"$$$-1" $""

) + 1# 0"

""*1 "1/0"-)

""1* /11,", $

,"" $" * , 11) ) $ - $"* 9 " 0#," " * + 1#/0$"$" "

" $1

#", ;

" "<

$ $", 1" -

," - $ $ " * + 1# 0$"$ $ * "$-"," $1 ")($

$*)

""1* -" 110 "

0#","$,",$"

" "11, 1 **" " +* $ "/$$-0#",0"

""*1 "1/0"

1-"" $ -$ $ 0 "* + 1#/ $) ! 0 "11 4 1)/ " *", $ " * ,

" " $"

1**" = ""

"11)"

11) *

" $ 0# $ "1 $ ,$ $811) '

0 $ , 1

011

$ "1/ $ * " 0 ,, $ 1

* "<

1**" 0 >811)'

0?;*

* @" $) != $

""*1 "1/0"$* $ 811)'

0* "0 0# $ " $ + 2$= $

0 0 -"* " - $ / 0"" 0"

-"* "-))/9 1) $ 0#," -"," $1" "1 $ * "0# *

"+ 1#"- $ $ " * $ + 1# 0 1)",

6 ",1)/" $ " / $ 1

$"* 0 ", 811) * 1#+", "/ " 0 "* + 1#01)", = " $) A/0$"1 "0""/ $ * "1$" ,,0

1 *1)-) *1", "" , ",$" ;

"8$ / $ * "$ "10"

"" $" ", $

" 1 $*

""*1 "1$ $ "10 ,", #)0

1 **" $ * 0$"$ $ * " 0 0#", ",1) $ 0"

* " 0 "* $ -"

6 8$

/ $ * "1 0 * "< " " $ 0#",0"

)-#+

-1$0", $ "1 $ *"/* " $-,"8$ ?;

" /0"$ ,$

;

" $ * " " 1

!: B (0 "B * "/ "1 "" 9 ;

" "" $

1" 1- #(0 *"1) * / $ /$$ "10"

"" $" #",1",1) $*" 4 ) "11

$ #", " " *1 $ * " -) ) *1) -"(0/" 0"

" 1 $ * " "

0 " "C 0* $A "

)

$ " " ! *" 5B "1-) "8$* ""$11,",

"11,1/ 11"/0$"$"1"-1 - " 8$0"

""-",**-)* 56 ", A ! "0$" "*

811)'

0?;* -" B)

;*")

*"/$" 0;

$B)***1 , -)/0"= $" * :-

- 1*

**1 * * " $ 0 -", *1 -) $

1 *1)/ "$**$ $" -)0)

"1", 56A A= "

0 "* " B : -", * " $ **$ $ * * " $ * 0 ,", $

**" /0$"$0 ""0 "" "

" "=

*", /,, " 0

"0 * 6: B/ $

;

"0, -) $ *

)- $0 "* 811)'

0?;* 0"

""*1 "1/0"

**" 1- " 1)-) $* ,"

"* CC

",1")/0$"$ 1- 1) C $ ,$

", +,)/ " 0) * " " 0#", "11 6 : 0"

$ "

* 5!/0$0* "

""*1 "1/0"

"0$"

$ " 0",* / 1

0 0"

* 5 9 0",

! * /* 5!0* " $"* * * 5011"$"* "= $,,

* "011$01"= " $ ) ",$ #", "D;

" $" $ -$1-) $+*; "

!"#!$ % &' * $

110

1 *1)$",$ $ $"$ 0 " " ! 8$"*"

"$-"

"" 3 , * -) $"(",$

", $ "", "/ $* 56*) " "1 $0"

" C$$1 1 $* "-",",

$ ,$ $C " $" "

" $0"

" " "1 : + "

1)/ "0""

"11)**" B) -" -9 1)$" ;

" " 8$* "$*1" / 0$"$"1 1

A !-)*

) ""/0"

""*1 "1/ 0"/ *) +;

6, ",**1 **" 0811)'

0 ?;* $0#", + 2$

""*1 "1/ 0"**"-* B)/" 0) * ", $9 "+;

"0"

$, " "1 **1, -)0" ?;

"/ /0" ! ;

" *" 811)'

0?;*

$B)+;

! 66 A1 **1-) 0", ",;

" B) 811) * 1# +;

A"" "1**11

!: A;

",*"

811) * 1# B) B! A+;

" A)",**1 0" ;

" *" 811) * 1# B) A A+;

A A" ;

"*"

811) * 1# B) A " * :8$ "0 0#",, 1 -" $ $" *" 0 -", ;

* **1 , -)0" " " B)+", $ * / *1 " $*" ;

"/ "0 1"/0$/ $ "" $ 0#", $* $1"",$" 0 = *"

1#-", /" "$-"*0"

$ (0/#*",""0 $ " $" - )11, " *3 "," )

"- /0"/"

*1 "-1 $1

0 1- "* 1 $"

"1 $0",

$" * , 11* * 1#0 "11 * * "0 ", $* 811) * 1# #*",""0 $- ""1"

" 0"/"

* "0-", " 0 6 :

$0 "* 811) * 1# " *1) 0$ $

"" 0#;"

: )", $, ;

" *1)0#", -" 0$ $ $ *1)$ *)$"1)C $ ""1 "

" $ 0"" ,/ $"

"1) ,"

"0"

$ ""

- *1)9 "/) $0#", "* " $"

"1 *1)$"

1-" "1)-"*0"

$8$* "

) 0#" "11 $3 )", $;

" $" 8$ "1-"1"

) $0#" - $"0*" $ *1) $ *1) B " $ " $* "1 **" $*"$"*1

1-" ? $0"/ " $ " * , / $ "1 $ *"

"11) " " $) 9 " **" ) * 811)

* 1# -"/ $ "0 1-," * 8$",$ " , ;

" "0 $3 , $+*; ( ) )

+ # ,$!- '"

$* 5 ", ,$0#" "1-1/0"

111",)11, " 0"

$, " ,"

) "0"

$" -",) $", $0 0"" *1 $ * "0"

$ $

1 *1)/ " *"-1) "" $0 1 ", 0"+ 1# $" -;

C -*"

","11)**" + 1#$"**" 0

811) * 1# $ ,$ $ ",$ $ - *

+ 2$ 1#

0# " -

"$, $"", "+ 1#? $0"/"

$ *1") ,,",D

", "D ""

(). A !/*) 0$"$$-*1 +;

!/ $ "" 0* C1 *1")

", "D ""

"0$"$ )-

0$9 "* 1) *1 1)-) $* /0$* $ - " $ ""

9 1"

)","

"/ $1"-1

* "11* "

", 1"-"1"

" " -**-)( $* " "" ' " " $" "

0$1

" "

* 1 / $ 8$ ""-" 1)-) C( 0 **" -" -) 0) $1", ) ; " " ""

",**1" " $* # * ",

$* 9 " 1 " " , 1* 8$ * 0$"$$0**" /

- " * "

"*"

" * "11 CC $*1") 1 * -"0$, 1* ;" 8$ - -)-)",9 ""

" $? *1) ?;$,-) " " $50**""

"11) *" ;", ) "11 $, 11 " **" 8$ "1 * $-," $"8$ * " **1"-1 $

" 8$ / " "" $-110 0#

"11, 1" - "**" /- "

$$-,,-) * ",***

"11", $9 " 9 "" CC $*1")/+;

!/$0 1$ 1 $", )-

0$$0**" * 1)

1-" B) ," * /0$"$" " + $ * " 0#",

6: B * 6 : / $* 56$*"

"11) #

00"

$" * 5!/0$0* 0"

""*1 "1/0"*

"0$ $" $"11,1 0 / "0 #," $ " $*

5!0* " $"* * /0$* 5 011"8$* " "",""" $ *"$" )1,1 ) ) ",$ "$" -",110 """C)$$1)- *"1) $*" 6 E 1 $ * " ** $" " $ " 3 , " -",

. */0$""

0--)

$+*; 0$ *1)**" -"-)

110",, 1* ) 1/ $",$ $ *1) , 1"F " "C 0

*1) -" $

)",$ 01

" " 8$;

3 , *" ""/0

% (

*-)"""2$

$" "E+5 " C*5!6/ !!! $3 , /"

$--

" " "

# $

# '

) %

)

* +!

!" # !$

% &'() !* ,!

- * !

! " # (+ ,-,+

-.,/+ + -.- 0 1- 12&-3 ,-,+0(-4 (-1!

& -- 1' ,+ ((,'- 5+ 6 (,- 7 11-8- ( -. , +-1 7& -1- '. -.(- 1.+1-& 1-( - &,-0,1 -.- 0 , 0

,-+1'(,1+1 + ( -0-

+ ( --&,-,-+1' .1 -0-. 0-( &,,'.,1-- 0 &,-+ -'- 0 ,,-+1-' 0(- 1+(-0-& 1-(-,-+1 9,!!-. - +-6 &-. .+ - (-

'--14 (-1!& - 0 * :0( +((1"

)

$) #.

)/ )

# 8$1 "0" $3 , ""*5!/ 0$"$0 $ 110",

% . &

-0 12

12 $

1 2

# ($

$1" *3 , 1 2 ) 3 4 0

1 (

6 *-)"""2$ $" "E+A: " /0$"

" ", $1,1*"

" $ -3 " "1/ $"""2$0$"1

" ", $3 , -) '",12$1"",, 1"F " " "$ - "

110

1 *1)$",$ $$"D$ 0 " " $ -#* " " *0 " ",0"

" - "

";* "1" (C ) ;" $*0 ! 8$" 0"

""" "",1) ! 2"3

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#