← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21114/2015dismissed

J D Sandhu v. Central Administrative Tribunal Chandigarh Bench, Chandigarh Tho' Its Registrar & ORS

2020-02-26Mr Justice Jaswant Singh,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra12 pages

  

       



    !"  

#$%$%&#'

()   *   (  *+

      #),&-#&$)

!. /*

       /*

  **   



  



   



 



** +   !   





" 

 

%

  &'

() +,-  &.





,/0

 "

 +  1!# 2. 3

, "   5&6







 

  2 +  13,2. 0 

   &7 )5 &)() +,-  (&.

   & #$  

1 " 

 

 2    "   /    "  /

8

   )( )'

&)(9 +,-  '.

 /

" :0 , "  (()

/ 0

0

  &'

() +,-  &. /

&

 ; " #

    

/ <  0 

= +< .

(9 )> (6>'

 0   /    0 

= + .

*) (& (6>6 , () )7 (657 ?

= &( )5 (67* 0  (6 )'

(677 (6 )7 (677

" (* )'

(66>  " *( )'

&))'





   () (& (66) =

"

 / )'

)> (679  0   "



// 

!- 0

  &> )* (66(

! ,

>>&

(66(

*( )'

(66( " 0   (( () (666

"   0   * 



            

                             

   

                 

 

  



   

 !

 0

! 

// 

!-

 0

  )5 )9 &))) / 

       

     

    

    "

"

     

 #   $ 

               

      

   





 % &  

 

   

    %       %      

    

  

      "

"

  "           

       



   &

   

 

  

   



        # 

     

      

   

  

             '  

   #

     !

,   

+ 

/    $.

 

&7 )5 &)()

!  

 ,

 &)() /

 /    / )> )6 &)((

! 

 " 



@ &(7&&

&)(& "/  

(( )* 

#$  "

 



@

 

 "  0 

/ ((

+ " .

:"/ :  (6>6  0 

= ? 

A   +3$ A.

  + "  A.

 $ 0" "0   0 %  /

B-/

"   #

/

%    

  





 /

%    

 

  $ /  " 

 /

%    

 ""  C$



/

B-/  0     -/  /  

 ""    $ /

,  0

 

  /

 " " 

/#     "

 0"" %  



 / 



  %   % 

-

 

#

 $ 0 

8 0 /

0  / : 

  

 

 "    #

 $  0   /     0 / "

/ "/  $ "       $  

  / "

0 

- "

"  "

 

  "    

 =      0   

 / /  //#

0 "  "  

" $   " 

0  

3   0 " $ " " " /

  0   0

  /    /# "   =  "  

 =  "

0 

  %    "$

0  / A 0/ 

  # / /  

,

 /

  =



! /  /   /  # 0

*

:    0 " "

"  0  

,

 &)() /

 /    / )> )6 &)((

! 

 " 



@ &(7&&

&)(&  

(( )*  

#$  "



"   ;      "   $ " )5 )9 &)))    



/    $  

&7 )5 &)()

 "  



 "  /

"

 / )'

)> (679



 "

!3 , !

 !

 $

" #  "    /   

=

" "  

0 

   $ -   $ $  "$ 

! ,

/  

/    / /

"$ 

, /

"   "

 

&> $ =

"

 / )'

)> (679

 = -"

"

 0""

!

"/ $ (659 (65' (65> (655 

** $ " "

" 

$ ""

0 

$ (679 = /

#

 ,

&)() / #  "  &(

! ,/0 ," (67'



 $

"

"   

 /

 / + " .

:"/ :  (6>6 + / (67>.  0   0 /

 "   $

 C!

" " " /       $      /  $

 "          /  0  $    0 0""$

 / 0 "

 /   0 " "

 /

$

/

 

 "  "  0 "  

 1

 

/  /    

'

@ 0 

 

 " 

  0 " 

    " 

"

>

    " /    

 

 " 

 

 /" / "

/    / /

"$ 

: "

"  0$  " /

 

%  

/  #0 ,



() )9 = 

  

)'

)> (679

   /  (677 "" "

-    

 #   #

 $   #



0  /

B-/  %    "  " 

 /     /   

"

$ (677 ""/"

" 

    /  



/   &'

$

!  0 

/

/ " //" 

'

> (679 &) &)(& 

"     #  /  /#

/  # 0 "  /

    / #

!

 

   

    

/ 

"

 2

/  %



" "  " /  " "   "   "  

/ 

 /    " 

"   

 $

? ;# /

 "  

    

+&))7.() 

(('    " "

  "  



"   

 "    " - #0 

( 

         )      

      "         

              

 

       #                     

     %  

 

 

      %       

      %   "             



     

        



   

     

  

        ! 8 "   

 

+&)().

& 

'6 ? ;# /

 

" #; " +.

      1 2 12 C "  " " / " " 

C!#

  

" "  "  " 



 "

" 

00 12  / # 

! 

/   $

"   "  " 

"

"  "     " / "

 3

D " 

4

D "  "       -/ /   "  0 " / " " "  

-

/    $

"

,# 0 "  ? ;# /

 "

  

 



 

 



 +(&.



(56

8 /     "$

0



"

"  

    /  0"   0 

 "

" 

"

 ! "!  #

 

 +&))5.



&57 ? ;# /

      

/   0

     ,"

&&>

 

 $      

  # /

"   

   0 $

     =  

 $

" 0

"      ?

  -" " $ " 

8 " #      $% !

+(65'.

( 

('& ? ;# /



     0  

 /    0      "

 

  - /   /  $

"

 

 $  

/ 

 -"     ,"

&&>    " 0 " 

 "    / 

"



/ #      -"

" 

  -"  - $    ,"

&&> "

    " - 



 

     "

 

  / $   /

0

# 0 "  &(

! ,/0 ," (67'   

/  "#

/   "  #0   

 &'

$ = 

 " "

"   #    / #

,$    0   #  



: "

"  0$  /  "$    #0 /       /   

/ 0  /      $

"    ""

  0  /= $

 /   :/  /  / 

"  /   "

 

 0

/    #

   

"$   

!   /

"    

 

" / 

"  /   + " .

:"/ :  (6>6 + / (67>.

  0

 #

 $ /  

 "   $    /   

)'

)> (679

? 0 "  /   0

"  :    /   " 

   0

 :    

"

 / 

()

 /   /

  !3 #  /

8 "   /

  

"   =  " "" " :  /

 

  / #

 $



"    /

"  "   

 



,   $ "  0""   

 

!3  "   $     " "   "   "

  !3

((

, %

# 0

 



,/0 0    &'

() &)(*  / 3, 5&6 

 0   )( )'

&)(9  / :0 , "  (()

3,

5&6



/ 0 "

  

 

 0

/     / 0 # 0 

/ /

   

**   

  

  " /

@ =C  EC4 @  #  EC4