← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2021/2016disposed of

Rajiv Johar v. Union Of India & ANR.

2016-03-02Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain3 pages

    

 

!"# $#%&'&()*

  









   ) +,--, .#'#(") ./!(!('!01$2%!"# ."3#4#"&"&(#. .-5$3&.!.1$2%!"# ."3#.#'4($#("'  !6#'3&($!0 3#4#"&"&(#.3!'!44.!%3#$"3&'%5."&/457(&(7"3#.$#. $!"#$ 8

14!''#$9:.#'4($#("12&$#;3&%33&'!440&%!"&( .!%"&%#!'"!.:;!'.#6#%"#$("3#7.5($"3!" "3#!440&%!"&(;!'(" &0#$ '&</("3'9# .#"3##<4&.: 4#.&$

2!0&$&": ,#!.(#$%5('#0 ."3#4#"&"&(#.'59/&""#$"3!"($59"1!' 4#.  "3#  50#  =    "3#  "!.&#'  50#'1  >?

.  '3."1  +"3#  50#'+ 1 !440&%!"&( ..#(#;!03!'"9# &0#$'&</("3'9# .#"3#$!"# #<4&.:

 4#.&$ 2!0&$&":13;#2#.1"3#!44.4.&!"#72#.(/#("3!'9##(7&2#( 4;#.  "  .#0!<  "3#  %($&"&(  %('&$#.&(7  "3#  .#!'('  '"!"#$  &(  "3# !440&%!"&(("3#%!'#&(3!($1"3##."& .!%"&%# "3#4#"&"&(#.

;!'"#<4&.#(=

?# &0#$"3#!440&%!"&((@> ?3#$#0!:

%%5..#$(!%%5(" "3#.#!'("3!" !"3#. "3#4#"&"&(#.;!'(";#00 !($ 3##<4&.#$ ( *

3#!

.#'!&$ .#!'(' ;#.#/#("&(#$ &( .#'4('#""3#("&%#&''5#$""3#4#"&"&(#.('544." 3&'40#!"3!"

 $#0!:&( &0&(7"3#!440&%!"&(&'(" !"!01.#0&!(%#;!'40!%#$54("3# 65$7/#("' #03&&735."&(  =? * ?A##0!/ -3!./!2(&( ($&!1$#%&$#$(

> ?!($B#.!0!&735."&(   * >@8 ? C DD!(6&"3B5/!.2(&( ($&!

!($!("3#.1$#%&$#$( @

? (  "3#  "3#.  3!($1  0#!.(#$  %5('#0  .  "3#  .#'4($#("'

'59/&""#$"3!""3#!440&%!"&(3!2&(7("9##( &0#$;&"3&( "3#4#.&$ 4.#'%.&9#$5($#."3#50#'!($"3#.#!'(!''&7(#$9:"3#4#"&"&(#.;!'("

5($"9#"#(!90#1"3#!440&%!"&( ..#(#;!0 &0#$9:"3#4#"&"&(#.;!'

.&73"0:$&'/&''#$ #!.$0#!.(#$%5('#0 ."3#4!."&#'!($4#.5'#$"3#4!4#.

9E 50#= "3#50#'4.2&$#'"3!"!440&%!"&( ..#(#;!0

#."& .!%"&%#!'"!.:&'"9#'59/&""#$'&</("3'9# .#"3# $!"# #<4&.: "3#4#.&$ 2!0&$&":13;#2#.14.2&'""3#50# 4.2&$#'"3!""3#!44.4.&!"#2#.(/#("/!:1%('&$#.&(7"3#.#!'(' '"!"#$&("3#!440&%!"&(1.#0!<"3#%($&"&( '59/&''&( !440&%!"&( .!%"&%#50#= "3#50#'&'#<".!%"#$9#0;) F=#(#;!0 .!%"&%#DD3##."&

.!%"&%#&''5#$5($#.'59D.50# 8  .50#=/!:9#.#(#;#$ ! 5."3#.4#.&$ &2#:#!.'(4!:/#(" 4.#'%.&9#$ ##( !440&%!"&(  .  .#(#;!0    #."& &%!"#    .!%"&%#  '3!00  9# '59/&""#$""3#!44.4.&!"#2#.(/#("9# .#'&</("3'

./"3#$!"# #<4&.: &"'4#.&$ 2!0&$&": .2&$#$  "3!"  "3#  !44.4.&!"#  2#.(/#("  /!:1  ! "#.

%('&$#.&(7"3#.#!'(''"!"#$&("3#!440&%!"&(1.#0!< "3#%($&"&( '59/&''&( !440&%!"&( ..#(#;!0

%#."& 4.!%"&%#9# .#"3#!92#'4#%& &%4#.&$G (%#"3#4.2&'""3#50#&"'#0 4.2&$#'"3!""3#.#&'4;#.

".#0!<1/#!(&(7"3#.#9:"3#4#.&$4.#'%.&9#$"3#.#&(&'("/!($!".:( "3#%!'#&(3!($1"3##."& .!%"&%# "3#4#"&"&(#.;!'"#<4&.#( =

?#!440&#$ ..#(#;!0"3#.# (@> ?1(;3&%3%#."!&( H5#.&#';#.#.!&'#$2&$#0#""#.$!"#$? ?1;3&%3;#.#.#'4($#$"9:

* "3#4#"&"&(#.2&$#0#""#.$!"#$* ?3&0#'4#%& :&(7"3#.#!'( $#0!:#$ &0&(7 "3#!440&%!"&(1"3#4#"&"&(#.'59/&""#$!'5($#.) F#!'(' .$#0!:&(!440:&(7 ..#(#;!0)D 3!"/:.#(#;!0 %#."& 4.!%"&%#5($#."3#"!.:%"

>?&'="32#/9#.1 ?!($3!2#!440&#$ ..#(#;!0( @"3-#4"#/9#.1 ?1;3#.#!'3!2#"!440:'&</("3'9# .# "3#.#(#;!0$!"#!'4#.(#;!/#($/#("&("3#.50#=D 3# "!.&#'50#'1 >?

3!""3#.#&'$#0!: !95""3.##/("3'

$5#" !/&0:3#!0"34.90#/'3!"/: !"3#..#/!&('2#.:

'&%E!($3#&'9#$.&$$#( ./0!'"#&73"/("3'13#&'!95"=?

:#!.'0$ #<D'#.2&%#/!(!($!(!$2%!"# /.#2#./:;& #&'

'5

#.&(7 ./'0&4D$&'%4.90#/!/"3#(0:4#.'("0E !

"#."3#/1"3#.# .#%50$("!440: ..#(#;!0&("&/#$5# "/#("!0'".#''';#!.(!"3"3!""3#.#'3!00("$#0!:&(

5"5.#&(!(:.#'4#%"G 4#.5'!0 "3#!

.#'!&$.#!'('3;'"3!""3#!440&%!"&( %50$("9# &0#$9#%!5'# &00(#'' !"3#. "3#4#"&"&(#.1;3;!'=?

:#!.' !7#!($#<D'#.2&%#/!(3#4#"&"&(#.!0'%0!&/#$"3!"3&';& # ;!'!0''5

#.&(7 ./'0&4D$&'%&"35"%('&$#.&(7"3#.#!'(''"!"#$&( "3#!440&%!"&(1"3#%/4#"#("!5"3.&":.#6#%"#$"3#!440&%!"&(/#.#0: '"!"&(7"3!""3#!440&%!"&(;!'(" &0#$'&</("3'4.&.""3#$!"#

#<4&.: .!%"&%#3#.#!'(!''&7(#$&'(""#(!90# (2&#; /:!

.#'!&$$&'%5''&(1"3#;.&"4#"&"&(&'!00;#$ 3#&/457(#$%//5(&%!"&(.#6#%"&(7"3#!440&%!"&( "3#4#"&"&(#. .!%"&%#!'"!.:&''#"!'&$#3#/!""#.&' .#/&""#$9!%E""3#%/4#"#("!5"3.&":"9#$#%&$#$! .#'33#4#"&"&(#.

'3!009#!"0&9#.":"'5440#/#(""3#.#!'( .((D &0&(7 "3#!440&%!"&( ;&"3&("3#4#.&$4.#'%.&9#$

!6#'3&($!0 5$7# *

/E

# #."#4."#.