High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/8954/2021disposed of

Sandeep Kumar @ Sandeep Chugh v. State Of Haryana And Others

2021-11-16Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu40 pages

!" #$ %&

# $ %

% !"&

$ !"

'()& !" *+, -

" ..,/..0 1 &"+2.

" 3405 "& 6" " *.758" 9 * 6 3: 6 & "

*+, *+ & *; *+*, 6 1

*+<=#

& >.433.:3:

8 9 6

*+ " ! &<' - & *+ & - !="6

.:33 *+) ".:3. -& " * & 6 1' .:34 *+)"

!6"#1- ?& &"" - & !6

11' .:34 !6"#1

6&5::+::#& 11!

*+ " # ""

" 30 * ! ' * 8 9 & 1@ 1 " " 30 *- " ! & *&&" - *+&

& " & 6 *+ "" " ! & &6 *+ 1"6 .:34 6 1 6" 6! *+& " & & ' .:.: 1

".:.: & " *+

' *&" ! *+# & "

)& "& *+

A1*:,,0.;:4.:.: "5.5 52: 54. +42< 1 " - 1"6 .:.:! *+&!&# 6"#' ..3:.:.: "6 6

*+ "6 *+ " " - &

533:.:.: " / &

! 6& *+*+ & & " - A1 & "" 6 " .233.:.:&! *+" " <A1- 66 " B - &

!! " #!& " "4

":5:..:.3' - *+,# " #&"-

& 6 & #& "" 6 $ B *+, & "& 6 " &

1" "

" 6" -"" 30:;.:.3&" " & *+ 7 ;

3+3:.:.3 -

"*330;.:.3 # < !.3:4.:.3& .3;.:.3 &" *+" " & ? &! *+ " ?- " " ' * *+ # " ?& " & &" "#& ! # &! "#"- " &" = # ?

" 1 !" "! "35:0.:.3 ' " A $! = ) "

" * 6 354.:33 6 3;..:34

" 1 "

6 .,:0.:.3 ' " A $! = *+ # " !6 &

8 9 6 & ! / " !

CA 32::% - &!" "8D "9&

&"&# &! &! # ,:: ( 83:5: 1 9 6"# !"&& " - " & E !" " - #& E" " 3,:4.:.3 "" 66 )! ! "

*;7,6 ;:: C & " ;, & < & &! &"&6 <

& "& &

! - & 6 -""

! " ; , 6 - > & 3,4.:.3 32:4.:.3 &

" 6

6 "6 & -6!"" .+:4.:.3 & &

(

!""#!$

& $ ' !(

( *+

)

, "

(

- ! . /

0 1 % (

!( %

234 5 ( 5 2 (5 4

% (

( 6 +' )( 1 7 8% 0 1 7 8% 9 :

%( !

!( !(( %7

8; % ( . % ; < / % ) = ( %

$ "

!+22% ' 1 > ?( 715.*+28

(

( % ; 3 ?

! ! $/!)@1 !

4 % 1

(

32 % ) (; A0 *)

% $1 > ' :) !B @

1 0 1 ; < !

(

% 5 % 1 B C1 )

< ( ; ( % ; ( (%

; ) % , ) ( % C4D!$1 > ' :) ! B ;

) % ( %(

) ,

) !. '*# ! ( )

8 ( $()!

(

. ) ; ( % ; ( ( -

/ 4+! ! % 1 !

5 0 1 ) 234 % 2

% % (% !(

% (

( ; 0 1 ( (

( $()!

( (

( ! 234)

( % (

@ (

-$ !0 1

) 2 4% " " ? E

( % ?$/!)@ 1 ! % )

)

@ ! '<5( " ! B 1

% 9

234 5

A0 ) % %)

% % @ 1 < )( ! ! = /

)

234F2!)@1 ! ! (%

2 4

0 1 %;

(

% 1 C1

2 4 B *+% ( )*+!

( !5 2 4 ),;(0 1 % % : " %

) 234 " %) ! B

(

G *.< " & B ""! " *;7,F.; !) " & 6 & " *;,- & "6# " *.1& "6 " 6 E

" " *; , *;,& " !/#& < "6 6 $ " - " .2:4.:.3& & &

) 4 0 1 ( ( 2 4

5 2 4 ) ( 0 1 1 )

! ""#$

$ 5@!:(( ) 2 4

= %

0 1 5 2 4)

!") %

( !( % ): ( =

0 1

2 4!

% )

$ ; %

2 4( ),;( 0 1 % % : "@ % ( G +, # & ! #&< "66 $ "

" 333:.:.3 & &6

! ; %

( )< )

! 4 ; %

4 0 1 (

%; @

; (

)

%- $1

,#) A0 0 1 ) A0 -

; ! (

) < 0 1 (

%; @

1 4 (

% % ; %; ?H G - "&# 3+3:.:.36 "" *, 6 *+,1 6 6

6"" " & !

"&" < 1

* + & > .433.:3:

& & #

" ' .:33

? ' .:33 $ * & 6 :5:4.:33 *+&*&?

".:3.- 6( .:3,(

>$" 6 .:30 *+* 1=! 81=9?*! 6 .:30 89&6 3;:..:34( ">66 3839 1( * " 3423&"

= %% I 78" % A 0

J'! = !K

6 % 78 - 6 I 7%8

A 0 J' KG ( ":4:0.:.3

' " A $! ? "

*+" !

' ) "@C " & > !"

-" .,:0.:.3 - 6

.5:0.:.3 &1 -

.+:4.:.38 0"6

.:.39&"

< $L$<#$1/A5/'>A<1L '"

<BM :<C<</ << # " $L 5/M"B 1/A5/'>A<1L $L1$<B:5L "1+*+ $LL </51/A5"1+* 1 H

1$A#$7" !% ?+8 "

:0 1$A#$7"%!% 2+8 -L'/5L 5:"C<:B/10N1<< #""

:LAM$<#$1/A5>A:#L""5L /L $L"5< #!< 5<C"L/ LL -L5 "$L5/M"B1/A5/'>A<1L!5"

B/ :/ .1"BB "

:LL 0A "5 1$A#$( B"<0"1$A#$( I 1

! L $ ( I %

% (

1 !

< ! 1 7% ?% 8! ! 0 1 7% 2'% +8! % D %( I -'144+> 7

%' 1<"8

' :) !'

% 2 ( % ?> ( > >A:: ( %

)

( 6 ( )( 2> 4 " ( 4> % > "5-A$ /( (78)

(

E D ) ) ; L . 78

) ( )),

) *H# 7 8 -

( D (

% )

%) % (

( L . * ( ! ) !0 ( ) ( L % ) ( < % 0

) !) ( % % ) 0 ) L % %- 16 % )A0

< 'E 0

< <

+ / 4% %

) E < ;; 0 % ; E % () %

%( (

E 0 )(

( ( A0"

( 0

! 0 ; (

0 ( %

; ( )( E

! %

)

;

; 0 ( E !% 0 E % %% ) ( 1"'1")% (

) % 0 E

(

% % % (; 0 ( ? ) * +/ %( (

(! %

< ! ; ,-.// !

% 1 ' % ) * +/ % 2

! % 1"'1"! % 0 ) L . % 1 ( % = $:

) 0 ) L . .

012),3444! 5!"

4 ( !) ! 1/C<:+ !) E'"

% %1 1 B""E 1) ' L $ %;!4!

( H( = ) E

( %

)

< 1 /

% %) 0,014+.4,3., .

0 ,406.101) ,0+ 2),344"

D % )0 %%

A 0 7( A0< 8! %

E % % * < 0 E % )( L * +/ % + < 0 E % %% () L . ) ( 1"'1" (;

;(

) (

( %

L .

) = % ( = %) 0 $78!9$:-1 : 1 #438*.2.11

1 % ( D ) ( )% ;

) 0 E

L (!

) %

< )

)

0 ! ; % 0 )(

% ? = 0 (

( ,-!!-$!9 8-#59 $ ;9-5< *

9 95--!/!!$-9 -* 9 $

9<9 !

!"#

$%!& !"

'()*+,-.-)/0+-'1230(+041)( $1 > ' :) G 1 & ) " " ? > 6 " " 66 ? !! 1 & 6 6 6 " " " " " &

" -" "&

*;7, "

*+& 6 *+

*& ! ?""

& ? 1= .:1

"351

8=! @ 9 .::: *+* ""

!? C & ? "6

*+ *!6> ? " " "

*+" " 6"#1# & 1 *+ "

!?1 1" *+&" " !"1.4,.:34& "# 3::4.:34 &"" *+& " 6"# ? - *& ?-

! 6 1 &6 ( - *+& 6 "1 ? * " *- &?..:0.:34" 6"#&# 6 .:34353:.:34 &6"#?A &? "&# *! 6 .:34 A1 C! ?..:0.:34 #&"

(" *+" E& 6 *+ " 6 & "

6 &"" A1*:,,0 .;:4.:.: "5.5 52: 54. +42< 1 6 -

" 6 !5:3:.:.: & ! "

*+ " & # *+ " " 34:;.:.3!

"*;53+:20/.:.3= :0:,.:.3 < "" A &" "6 *+ ! "3+:2.:.3?&" 6 !&" 1 & 3::4.:.31" 30:4.:.3 3,:4.:.3 &6 "6 " < ! "6 *;,6 ! 6 "

< & ! "A1 *5+:.+4.:.3 "5.5 ++0 5+1 6

- A1*554.+4.:.3 "5.5 5.; 5+ ;:,1 != 1 " 6 " - ! ?

1 6 & "" 6 & &" & !

6 # & !) ? 1 * ! E 6 6 "B ? 6 "!= !!"

= 6* 66! 6 ?"B ( >6 "B ( >1 1"> &) " E " ) " & " #!&6 "- 6 "6" 6 6" " 6!" " " *+< ?! 6" < - # "" " 1& & " " 1& 6G6 1& & ")!" <

6 & *+ 16& "-& 6 " "!

" *+" " 6-!66

% = *+,

6 - 6 "" " 6 " ?

" 1 6 " "66" *;, *+& 1# ?6 66" ( & 6 6 6>1 " "

" 6 6"

*+< ( ">66 - 6 & 1

& "*+" "

"6"B " ) " - " B @ "- !$"

6 66 !? "G GGA # "G

6 . 2 6 6 &

* ! &! " " 1.4:,.:346 1 6 & *+ " " !"!"6" & "6 "

! *!E 6 6 " ? 356'4)(7+'35 89'

" - & ) " 6 " " " "& 166G6 & " H ) " # " &

) " 58 -=# 1=#=&

%1 ( &6 !

> %

)

' % L) ! ) $1 %; =

((

= !( 1 ( @ "$1 ! ! ); @ ) !

( @

(1 )( )

! !

(, ) % ) % I (

% 1 5)1 "(

( .

( @ $ 1 =

( O @ ;

(

@ G 8 9" ;,1!& 6) " 89 6 " 16 " !6" " &6 " - B & " ( 38 !39!!'(75 6276:7("8"!;!!

- !6 !

> -**-! -/!$8-$! - ! 9 5 - -9 - /8 !9 4 L (@

( %

(

% (

) < 35-?!

- " % "

. 9 " (.+'9 (( % ) %

!@ % 1

= % (

! ! (! )

@ = < ( % )

% ((!%

!% % ( ! @

( % (

! % =

) ) (

! (

( <(

( %

I %

(

! ( (

((

< @8#

*/?!

189- */"

# $ E% 1 % )

35-?!

- " % "

9 " (.+'9( <

( %) D . )=

( % ' 1 ,# >

# . "

!*+!

$ # "

!+24 % $1 1 % !

(( % ) (

7 4A$- !-5 ?! .#9

!-5!

( 1 1:91899 ?!

8<-!"

8 $! !95 -9 * (

% % ( E(

E %; ( (

% (

(

% 7 B !B> @-&

' -

'8.

(

! % =

) %

) = $()!( ) % ! )

! (

)

E ( ! 7

% $- !> <?!

<3!

5B9 +5 ( + < @8# */ ?!

189- */ "

# $ E% 1 % ) H P1 ;

% !

)

) ( !

@ ( (

% )

# E 7 8!1 ( E

! ! !

) ) % % ) %) !

) )

% = ?(E(

E ? "

( (

((1 (

(

% )

( ) % ;

! ( ( 1 @

G $ E% 1 C898 ?!

.$-=C898H

' #'% )

( H > /! *#* 8!9: -9 24< @ ! (

(

! ( ; )

( -

% % ) < % = % )( " ( (

% % %

) % <

(

( < !

! % !) ( E

! ! ! !

)

) %

- ) %) !

) % =

! ( ! ) !

% <

@ !

(

! (

( )(

G < +-1<-8?!

1$-C9"

( 1 '

$ E% 1 % )

H ?

Q% Q(

( ; %

( ) )!! (

( Q%

Q ) 7+8 > ) > 713 8"

!2! Q% ; !

% !

! (

% !

) Q + ( )%; %1 (

E % ! !

78 @ I 78

% I7?8% )

I78 I728% ) ) ) I 748

) ) ( !

) G < # .// '

9 !

19C!*?!

:C!*9 99

$ E% 1 % ) H >?

! 1 ( ; ) !

I I(

% % ;

I ) )

) % ( )

( (

% ) ! ) I G 89

!1 " 6#"

! " 6 " " 6# " 1 " 6

! ! " & " 1'+2-75754 7127<75<+7+) 39),2'#

!"&#; = G6 " B

> <

( %

! 1 ) 5 ; !

(

( (

% % )

. !

%% (

< L 6%!

% %

( ( % ) (

@ !

( @ 1 J # )7 1 : 8

% $1 ( (

( %

! ) !

;

%)/ !

( ! !

% % (

(

' ! ( % % ) % ( @ ) @ < %% !

( ;

% (

% %

% (% < 1

! )

' !

;

(

)% % ;;;

;;;

% . : ( > ( % = ( ) %> - 1 C5) 1 78.))(; : (

> ! ! ?? 1 ) ! (

( )(

= % (

%; @ % ( % ) ) )

(! %! )

; ! )

( %

) % %@

(

% " @ % (

% ) ) = ;

) % (

G - !&& 727(' 7:27>0('<3.275 347,' !"?#&8""

+ ( )%; % (

O % ! !

78 @ I78 % I 7?8 % )

I 78

I728% ) ) ) I748

% ) ) (

)

2. ( !

> 6 0 6 >( 3

O % )H ( (!% ) % ;

! % (

(( () %R ; (

G 1 % % %

(

; % ) ( ) ; ( % ; (

2 ! !

% ) @

6 ! ! ) % (

! ! !

; !

(

! ) @ )

! 6 ! ! %)

% ( ) 7% 0 8 % ; %$1

@ "

?4 1 < G 2)>7+)('7,97*+6'5+2)/()6)5+*76) -

& *+& >.433.:3:

& & #

" ' .:33 ?' .:33 $ *&6 :5:4.:33 *+ &*&? ".:3. - 6 ( .:3, ( > $" 6 .:30 *+*1=! 81=9 ?*! 6 .:3089&6 3;..:34- *+&" " 1 .4,.:34-" &)" 1& *+" " !"!"6" 6# "# 3::4.:34 61&"& !6& !"1 *& "*

# *&

*+& 6

'- &?..0.:34 " 6"#&# 6 .:34353:.:34 &6"#?A &? "&#

'' *! 6 .:341 ".:.: & & " *+ & " *&" ! *+ A1*:,,0 .;:4.:.: "5.5 52: 54.+42< 1

" - 1"6 .:.:! *+&!&# 6"#' ..3:.:.:

"6 6 *+ "6 *+ ""- &

533:.:.: " / &

!6& *+ *+ & &"- A1&"" 6".233.:.:*+ 1

""" 6"""

?& * *+"" 34;.:.3= 0,.:.3 < "" A *+! " 3+2.:.3?&" 6 !&" 350.:.3 " ' " A $! = ) " " *

" 1 " 6 ! "

*+& 6> " & B !" @ C .,0.:.38 ! ,"6 .:.39 ' " A $! = *+ # " !6 & 8 96&! / "! CA 32::

% -

" 6 ' "A $! = ! 6" 6 6 & *;,- & 6 & & 6 "#"6& *;

,- ) >

A1 ! 6 6 6

"*+E ? " *G " 6# " 6 "

6 # 6 *+ " 1#?6 6 ?"

' > " - *+& " *! ? -" 1 .4:,.:34&6

@E" 6 6 <"6

.:34 " ..:0.:34 "6 .:.:*+&" ! & &6 - ""&" " "6 .:.:E" & * + & &

..3:.:.: - ! .,0.:.3 ' " A $! = " *+ #*!6 &

6&!/ "! C A 32::% - -

" " *+6& " * ?:2:;.:.3 &*!" " *& ? 6 ! "

!6> && 66 " *+! " ?- "( @ "- !$"

6 !

'% ? - 6

*+ "" " )+)(>'57+'35 "( 6 6 6!& " " " & -

? 1 " !& !"

!66>6" " ? & *+ 1 &" 6 #? &

-# " " "

" !&

'#& 6 6

! 6& ?1? *+& !"

* &" 6" !& " 11 <

")" !" 6 6

- 6 ?61

'( ".4:,.:348&! &6 & 6 6 3;:..:349I

''#

" 6& *+ " 6 & 6 ! " ! G 8 9 & & 6!6" *+, "! , $" 6 .:.3 *;, & # ' " ,$" 6 .:.33:::

& &

& 6 & 6 ! " '

*;, & " " 6 "

!"& "" ! & #!6 & *+8 96&!/ ""!

6!& *;, ! & *+

" 8*9 & " / ! "" 6&

"&#

& # &" & " " #

" 6 & !6 E " ! !

6! 1"6 & 6 ! +- 1<-8# 1$-C9&

(1'

- (

!(( ;% ) =

% % = (

( % %( )

O !

((

% !%

. %

% !

) '

O %

%( ) (

) ( ;

) O

' %

(

%( % O )

) " O ( %%

% % % )

< ! )

% ) ! ;

(

% ( % ( (

! ( )

! (

@ ) (

) ! (

)

; !% ) O ! ! )

(

% (;

) ( @ . (

)

@ ) ( % ) %

)

G ! " $

3<)>.)("@!"

# C #/ J C 6 J/*