Brij Mohan Syal v. The Punjab State Power Corporation Limited And ORS
!
"#$# %&'((' )#*+ , %-.
/ 000((
# # % ) 1$( , 2%* 3-
4 ) )5 )
# %6#7#
!%! )$( 000(( $5 %!
% $
+& 86 +( - 1 -(
1 -(9( !
" # $
!% &'
(&!% )
!* !!
(&!%
+" # , -# )
(.
&'
(&!/ + 01# #2 " #
(
$ ##3 # ## ) // 4(& 56 7# 88 59
) # (* &'
(&!. : *!8 4(& 56 7# **& 59 " ## " " "
"# -# < '&'44 0 = 2 ) " &* &4 (&!. ) !'& 56
" # #" (' 56 ) "
: 7#
# !4 &4 (&!.
) ) # , ''*&&&> ) ) " (* !( (&!.
: # ) ) !( &* (&!'
*
# ##
< (%>(&!. (8 &'
(&!.
# )
> " # ) ) ? @ 0?@2 " ) &!
&!
(&!.
"
# , 8/(%!.> ) &% &'
(&!' " , %&'4&'> " , (%%!!'>
.
# ) " #
, -# A) !* !!
(&!% # )
"" )
+ 1# # ) ) # 1# # (.
&'
(&!/ # # A
'
" # , -# )
+ 1# # " ) #
"
# (* &'
(&!. ) < (%>(&!. ) # ) "
(8 &'
(&!.
" # # ) # #" < (%>(&!. # " ## "
"
? " : ) 0#
2 " # ) # " ) ?@ ) # "3" ?
@
, < ! . ) ) ) # B 7# !/& 59 ) "" *!8 4(& 56 ) 7# !'& 59 = (8 &* (&!4 7# ) 1 < '.>!*8!& (& &.
(&!4 (% &'
(&!4
)"
# ) = # 2 1 0!2 < A"
C !'& 56 2 1 0!2 < ;#" - C (' 56 %
" # #"
?@ " < (%>(&!.
"
# ?
: &* &4 (&!. ) !%' 56 ?@
) # ) )"
" " ?@ " ) )"
+: +" 0 ## 2 ) " < (%>(&!.
(8 &'
(&!.
7# !/& 59 ) " "" *!8 4(& 56 )
!'& 59 7# = # (8 &* (&!4 ) # ) # ## < (%>(&!.
" " ? $
A> A"
) ) ? @ " (/ !& (&!* ## ## ) #
#"
/
+ "
) # (.
&* (&!8 ) ) "
?
" " "
#
!&
) #" # # 2 ;
: *!8 4(& 56 7# **& 59
" ## " " " + "
# (* &'
(&!. ) &* &4 (&!. ) ) # # :
2 ;
"# # ) # " "
0#
2
2 ;
#
" # )
#"
2 ;
##
)
)
"
# >
) ) ? @ 0?@2 ##
) ) &!
&!
(&!.
2 ;
" ##
"
2 ;
"
7# ) "
) ) "
B A " # )
#"
B " # ) ? @
2 ;
" ) )"
# " # "
!!
# , -# )
+ 1# # ) " " " + 1# # :
!
"
#
$%
& '
( )
'* +
+
, -. '
/ # '
0'
11 " 23
' *
!!245
6 ( )
11 " 23 !
" 23
'*!!245 245
/ # ) # '
70 5
5 89 ""
"
6+
: !
;< 5'* $ 5=5 8
23< $
7
/
23
8
( )
'* !
#+ '* 245 2450 )
5=58
!
"
0
"
: 5
5
+ 0 0
& '
$% '
( )
'* 5
0
-//'.
5'*
!
" /9 6"
0 '' 9 ; 6
!
' '' 9 ; 60 !
60 (
6 0
+
> + 0 +
0 0 + :
+
' ' -''. 9 ; 6 0 0 !
6 + 5=58
#-5'*.
"
60 :
+
+ +
>7
'' 9 ; 6 0 + 0
6$% 0
60
#')
$ +
7 ?+#@:':' 9 ;
!
0 +#')
, A$
0 7 + #@:'
+ 0:
0
;
+
++ :
+
'
$$
9 ; 0 A $
#')+ '' ; 6
!
6
, A$ 0 7 ?+ #@:'
1
)# 0$
> 7 ;# 7
/ +
$% 0
'' 1;
"
!
A :
(
> 7 )
0
'' ; 6
!
6 ++
(
0
+
' (
:
+9 0 +
2 0
&
+
''9 ; 6 !
6 "
0 9
0 0
> 0
!
" 23 -0
+
+
. //' $% 0 +
>7
# '
' -#''. $
#')
(
1
7 ?+ #@:' 0 #') +
:
;< #')
!
"
6
# 6 @5<
$
0' :
2
'' ; 6
!
6
+
+ : 5 /
+ +
5 $
0 :
) #
#
)
!
" 23
' *
245
+ 2 0
;
+
+#') ''9 ; 6
!
6
0+#')
7 ?+#@:'B
1
9 + )
7
5
+ >;$
7
+#')0 <
0+#@:'
$ 0
) 0 (
#')
( + + +;
+
-.' +
+
+
$ ! @ # $ /
, A%
# "-.5
+ + 0
0 + + 0 +
#')
+ 0
0 +
A $+ + '
+ 0 '' 9 ; + #')
7 ?+ +
7
7 ' )59 "
! !
!
-.'
( )
'*
6
'' 9
; 6
!
6 :
0
+
$ + ( )
'*
6 -0 '' 9 ; 6
!
6
+ . 5=58
"
6
5'* '
(
''9 ; 6
+ $ +
5
5 -5=5. 8
( )
;' *
2 + +
+
+ +
5
'
5 +
5'* ( )
;' *
& $
0$ % -$%. + 0
-
( )
;' *
.
0 + + ''9 ; 6
!
# :
0
+ +
; +
5
:
;
(;
0
; !(
? #
,- )
+ 1# # < # "
) + 1# # # # > ) ? + 1# # ##
)
# #
"
" ## "" :# # ##
!*
? "
0#
2 " ?@ "# D
? ) ) # (&!. ##
## )
" " ##
!.
" # D
+ ," ## "
" )
" ) D
+ ) # ## D " # (% &'
(&!. D # :
# # # # " )"
!'
-"
#
" # # #
,- 1# # ? # ) D # D
!4
"
# ,- )
+ 1# # " # #
'((' :1 -(; ? "> E
E><