High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21246/2015dismissed

Gurdeep Singh Dhaliwal v. Union Of India & ORS

2015-11-02Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik3 pages

!"!#$

%&'()!#*+ ,!- , . /&"%" #!# #'!

+&" ."(#'# &"# $ 0&01) ** &2)#!&'3

2-!

+ 0& 3&3&2'3

2 !#&

+ ( !#& + " !#34' + -&!

5%&!"'!

!# +!" %& ,,#*!#*

!#'

(%6,!"+'%#'&) !#7

!# ,!*+- 8" 29 :

&"+& ;

+ <= ,,-'68#

!#'

> !""%'%#'&) !#7 +"

!' + ( !#& !" ?"+ && + @ # + "+ & #' "%&!#* 9B # ,C0 &, #'!#(""""!# "% +, #'"!

/!,, * **42 +"!, 2 !"

+ , #' + ( !#& !" "!

'5!#!#* ? 4+ # '2-+! +!"(

!# ,!*+- 8C2 6*!##!#* &A,- & #'*"%(

#4 2-+! +!" ## !#* ? #'+ & + ""& !# !#&!"

!#%#'&) !#7

+ - " !""%' D%!& , #' & 6%!,'!#*2 -!'#!#*2 %&?, #!#*2 # # 2A # *A# #'(&

!# ,!*+- 8C!# +"

+ , #' &AB0

: #'+ &E ) !#=+"

#' !#&!"

-+#+ A #'!

#'-# +, #'# > 2+

%#'

# B0+ "6#!,,* ,,8 #'%#, - %,,8%(&

+&!*!# ,("!

!#+@

""& !# !#&& '" "%#'&$

FC +

!#&-# +, #'# > +( # ! '

# B0+ '6#!,,* ,,8 #'%#, - %,,8 %(& +&!*!# ,("!

!#+ 0!,) #

B0+ 6# "+!

' -!

+ "!#!"

& '"!*# #' A

!' A !3

# !&, #'&D%!&' +-!'#!#*(%&("" +& '!" D%!&'

+&%*+ +, #' !#&+( !#&6&%*+ +!"

! &"(#'# E,, &2 #'&"(#'# C E ) 0 2 -+ !" A( # % +&!

8 3!' -&!

# A(, '

'C > + A(, "-&'%,8& !3'!#

! &"(#'# + (% 8 AA!""!#& ? %A? A( # % +&!

8 %#'& + 2 #' +

! &"(#'# CE) 0 +(+ *& (+" , &,8"

6,!"+ 68#' #8"+ '- '%6 +%(& !#* B00!,) # -!

+ A

!' A !3 "

+ # !& #' 6

D%!&'( """ +&%*+ +, #' !#&+ (8 A(, '

' C > !" ##@' " ##@%& ? + (+ *& (+" &

+' "##@%&?

:,,8=G +*&!3 # !#&!"

+0!,) # B0+ "6# %(& ' -!

+ A

!' A !3 "

+ # !& 6 D%!&' ( """

+&%*+ +, #' !#&+%"2 D%!&!#* +# !&, #' &-!'#!#*

+ '!" # &6!

#'3!,

!3 & ! , +#"

% !#+ !#&+

+' +(+ *& (+"##@%&?

:,,8=-!

+ +-&!

( !# !# "%((& ""& !#

0!, ) # B0 + " 6# %(& ' + ," &,!" %(# "!

(, # ##@%& ?C (&( &' 68 %&!#'& )!#*+2

"A #20 ,&4 + 3+ &', &#' %#",

,#* + #' !#'# A&!

!# +(&"# ( !#+( !#&+ ",3,' ,,*

!#" A !'!# &"( %(& !#* +0!,) #26% #(&"#2-++ "%(& +0!, ) # !# A !' A ##&2 + " 6# !A(, '' ( 8 ) !,, +&2 (+ *& (+"##@%&?

:,,8='# "+- #8%(& !#* #'&?!#"

!# +0!,) # B0)% +(+ *& (+""+- +*& ""*&-# &%#' +0!, ) # #' +&'"# "A 6 #8

!3!

8 #8%(& !#*&&?!#"

!# +0!,) #-+&!

@!"

"'"# "+- " #8 &"+!#"

!#+

!#&+ "#

+' #8(+ *& (+&& +(, &A-+& 0!,) #+ "6# ,,*',8%(& "-,,!

+& !#&#&+!" ?

"+ &&"+ 3 !,' #865 !#"

!#(%6,!"+'%#'&) !#7

+ +",&,!

#+ "6#%(& !"# +"!

(, #:##@%&?C=(&( &'68 (&!3

"A ##"% +"!

(, #2 +'!"

# 6 -# -(!# "!"

!#* (!# # E0* +(!# #H &!'4 E '!"C 0 &+ &*%A# !"

'!"

# "6 -# -"%6?0!,) #""+%,'6

A &" '# !#' #8A&!

!# +"

!' &*%A# +0!,) #" & '!# +"

!*+ ,!# #'# !# +1?"+ (2 "*!3#68 !#&!# "!

(, #:##@%&?C=!#(!# "

"#0* E '2-+& "!

#'"

H &!'4 E '2-+#6 +& '" & + # !#%!#*& '"( "" &"

!# ) !,, +&2 D%!"!

!# , #'!"# 6 "'%(# +0!,) #" +6%#'

&!"26% D%!"!

!# , #'!" +"( !

! 4+ "& #%A6&" (&

!#"(%6,!"+'+& &2

+0!,) #+ "6# %(& #' &!#"

,,' !" # A ' % #& !" A

, '

&A!# #'2 -+! + &A"(

!#"%#'&) !#"7 #'7 + #"D%# ,82-'# !#' #8A&!

!# +(&"# -&!

( !# +"

A!" &'!#*,8'!"A!""' ! "

! #$%&' "