← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/183/2009allowed

Managing Director, Prtc Patiala v. Jagjit Singh And ANR.

2017-04-26Mr. Justice Surya Kant,Mr. Justice Sudip Ahluwalia5 pages



     



 !"# $%&&'( )*   $+,, - ,%./%&0

2

3

  !!!!!!

42  15,6,

!!!!!



 % 



 !%& $%&&'( )*

2

3

  

!!!!!!

 42  6, !!!!!



# 



 !"9 $%&&'( )*

2

3

  !!!!!!

42  +7

36,

3 7 !!!!!



 9 



 !#0' $%&&'( )*

2

3

  

!!!!!!

 42 62:7;,8 2 !!!!!



< 



 !#< $%&&'( )*

2

3

   !!!!!!

 42

6, !!!!!



. 



 !"< $%&&'( )*

2

3

   !!!!!!

42 62:734

=

3 7 !!!!!



 0 



 !". $%&&'( )*

2

3

  !!!!!!

42 677

7 !!!!!



 " 



 !"0 $%&&'( )*

2

3

   !!!!!!

42 2

=6,

7 !!!!!





' 



 !%"& $%&&'( )*

2

3

  

!!!!!!

 42



!!!!!



 & 



 !%"% $%&&'( )*

2

3

   !!!!!!

 42 ,

7

!!!!!



 



 !%'# $%&&'( )*

2

3

  !!!!!!

42 ) 7, 36,

7 !!!!!



 % 



 !9' $%&&'( )*

2

3

  !!!!!!

42

17;,6,

!!!!!



 # ,4,>, ,,  !%9%' $%&9( )*  ,;7

!!!!!!

,,  42



3

  !!!!!





   

    

 -)! 711 ?

/34 + /$ 7

 )!@,:

7  7/34 + /$ 7 ,, , > !

)! :,11 ?

/34 + /$  )!

=6, /34 + /$ 7

,  !%&A&'!

)!@,:

 7/6 , 34 + ?,7 )!

8 2/34 + 

)!@,:

6, 17/34 + /$ 7

(*!

B!B 



  !(  * 7, 37 3,  $  !%&/#</"#/"9/"</ "./"0/%"&/%"%/%'#/#0'/9' $%&&'

3>  !%9%' $%&9 + == C2, ?7,+7$ $ + ,3 , 7+ ,?777

,4 B

  ?7  ,3  $ =  7  4,+  $  7 

B

  /     ,3      $   D ,  6+7=D  ,

+  $ D ,;2 E  4,3  36+7=DF %  36, 12317

?37,C2, , $ 4 2 $ 7=  E ,= ,E 7;

, $ ,4,,  +75231=  $7,  2, !"##

$%

& '( )**+,-./)/

7 5231=  $  36, 1231,  && '(!"##"0#1 

#01  101 &1

2 

1("  ;,3  7  6, 1   +7 5231= $3 ;E7 36, 1231?7,2 7 3, 17+ ,= $

! #  ?4/  =2+7  ?

  7   $ ?

$  7  3+,,  $  7 36, 1231 7C2, - $ D , 6+7=D,

+ $D ,;2 E  4,3  36+7=D/?,7$ + 7 12

3 2+,  $7

B  /7 ; G E1 , ;E7 D;62 = 2, (,*"0#1 2

#01101 &1

!"##

'

$& '(

21("# )*--,--.+*) ,&&. "0#1 

#01101 &1 !"##3

2""0& '(

21("# )*-+ ,.4)- =

3 6,

3 7D+ (2 */7,4,,  +7 5231=  $7, 2,  ?

6, 17D+ (2 *7 ; 43!



=D5231=  $7, 2,32

;E7

?

 $ + 22 73;E7 G 2 6 +,  4 ,, , ,?

3,=,3! 9

 =  7   3, 1  $  7  3+,,   , )

  6, 17D

=

3 6,

3 7D+ (2 */?  ,$,37  1 

3,+, +

;,23  ++  5+7+ ,= $ ,4 B

!

 +7+ 7  ;G =, 3 7;

, $,  ?

$ +    3=, /  (,*  ?77  7  =  E  7 3  G+,3   $   ,

6+7=?,7, 7, 3 , 3

3,$ /(,,*?772+7=  E 3  + = ,3  ?,7  7   2 E  + 3,,   + , 3  ,  7

12 A 2+, !  62$$,+    ;4  7     7  + 3,, + , 3, 7 12 A 2+, 7 4; 73 ;=

 E,

2

37

B  ? 7=  E  ;,1 3  + = E?,72+7+ 3,, !, E, + ?77+ 3,,  + = ,3?,77 7=  E, ,3 ?,+7 4 7 ,

6+7=! < 6, +4,3 32 3

/ 36, 12317 G =, 37, 3,4,32 + ,= =,/?  ?7

,

H B ,37 3 $ 36, 1231

3=,7+  7 3 6, 1231$ 3=,

 $, 3,4,32 + ,= $ +7

B =  E 7;

, $$ + $ +7+ !6, +7=   , 

,

E  6+7=/  ?  C2  7   3  6, 1  231    = : 

4 2 3+,37+ ?,7, , 3 $$ 2= 7!6, +?7 4

1 ,  =, $7,4 +  ,3 ;7 $ $7

,/ ,;E,1

3 7=  ,7, ;$ 7 36, 1 231!

, 3,+3 

;$ 7 36, 1231

<!&<!%&0!

  5 6    7  ,%./%&0 5 6   7 

        

) !<0. $%&&',

  !"# $%&&'

BBB

42 15,6,

BBBB

 -)! 711 ?

/34 + /$ 7

 )!@,:

 7/6 , 34 + ?,7 )!

8 2/34 + 

)!@,:

6, 17/34 + /$ 7

(*!

III

  7     = 3  ,  7 

,+ /  7   =  ,

 ?32;5+  52G+

3<#3 ED3 E, $,, 17

,+ 3! )

33, 3 $!   , .

   7 0&$)8 )*-+ , .

      7