High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/33537/2020allowed

Shiv Kumar Alias Shivam Garg v. State Of Punjab And Another

2021-05-27Mr. Justice B.S. Walia7 pages

CRM-M No.33537 of 2020 Date of decision

!" !# $ %&&'(%! & &%')

(* + (, ('&%! $ %-.'(,%(&- '! / '(0+1%2! -&3%4 1

!%-%(&/ 2! 5,%%.(#6, '3 &%)'!&%.%&&'(%! 2! 5+%%!(#66

(* + 2!

15& (6, '3 &%)'!!%-.'(,%(&' 777

! :%!(&%.%&&'( (,%!%3&'(;<! -)'!= -(# ') '<, &%,>6!%#-&%!%, (,%!%3&'(-?< (,; & '13% & &'( &:@6 (#!

!6 -&!3& (#!

! (, 11 3'(-%= %(& 1 .!'3%%,(#- % ( &(# &%!%)!' '( &% + -- ') 3'.!'-%6 ((%A @?6, &%, 89 B% !(%, 3'

(-%1 3'(&%(,- & & &% )'!%%(&'(%, C - !%#-&%!%,'(&%+ --')-& &%%(&')!%-.'(,%(&'6& &&%.%&&'(%! C1% C'!5(# ( - 3%-& -'. , !(# &% .%!', > &' D>6-&'1%3 - (,C'1%- 1%+11-)!'&%3 -@+'A')&%-'.+ & , %&'(&%!

%(&'('))!%(,-6%1,%!- (,!%-.%3& +1%%+%!-')-'3%&:6&% &&%! , +%%( 3 +1: -%&&1%, (, 3'.!'-% ((%A E? , &%, !%3'!,%, -.%!C3!%-.'(,%(&',,('&C-&'.!'-%3 &% &%.%&&'(%!(&% )'!%%(&'(%, 3 -% ('!% , (: '+*%3&'(6 )&% )'!%%(&'(%, C -= -%,

CRM-M No.33537 of 2020 [2] 8?9 &.

!- (&&'-- (3%')'&3%')'&'('(D6 1% !(%,& &%'

(-%1'( ,% -& &%%(&& &%,,('&C- &' )1% !%.1: ( %C ') 3 +1% -%&&1%%(& ') &% ,-.

&% '(#-& &% . !&%- ,% 3'.!'-%6 ((%A E? , &%, B5%C-%6 2!

15& (6 1% !(%, 3'

(-%1 ..% !(# '( +% 1) ') !%-.'(,%(& ' -& &%, & & % , (' '+*%3&'( ) &% )'!%%(&'(%, (, 11 3'(-%= %(& 1.!'3%%,(#-% ( &(#&%!%)!'C%!%= -%,( %C')&% 3'.!'-%6((%A E?, &%,33'!,(#1:6(&%1#&') )'!%%(&'(%,-& &%%(&-6. !&%-C%!%,!%3&%,&'. &( ..% ! (3%+%)'!% &%1% !(%,11 = 2 #-&! &%E &:2 #-&! &%3'(3%!(%,'(?)'! !%3'!,(#')&%!-& &%%(&-(&%!-')3'.!'-%6((%A E?, &%, 8;9

!- (&&%!%&'6-& &%%(&-')&%. !&%-%&%.%&&'(%! - C%11 - 3'.1 ( (&E!%-.'(,%(& ' C%!% !%3'!,%, &' &% %))%3& & & &% &&%! ,+%%( '1 (& !1:3'.!'-%,C&&%.%&&'(%!

!" &!'

#-) &%! 5%-

!C&'

& (:.!%-- !%63'%!3'('!

(, % ()1 %(3% (, '

& ') &% )!%% C11 ') &% 3'.1 ( (& E !%-.'(,%(&' 89 B5%C-%6 % , '(-& +1% !1 1 (#6 ( %-&# &(# ))3%! ')&%3 -% ,% -& &%%(&& &&%.%&&'(%!C -&%-'1% 33 -%,6& &% ,(%&%!+%%(,%31 !%, .!'31 %,'))%(,%!('!C%!% (:.!'3%%,(#- .%(,(# # (-& ('! C - &%!% 3!'--@3 -% ( &% &&%!

!- (& &%!%&'6 !%.'!& C - - +&&%, +: &% 1% !(%, %) ,3 1 2 #-&! &%6 (#!

! & & 3'.!'-% +%&C%%( &% . !&%- C - '1 (& !:6 C&'

& (: .!%-- !%6 3'%!3'( '! (, % ()1 %(3% %&36 & & 3 11 ( , ('& +%%( .!%-%(&%,6('! , (:3!'--@3 -%+%%(!%#-&%!%,(&% &&%!

CRM-M No.33537 of 2020 [3] 8D9 B% !(%, & &% '

(-%1 - C%11 - 1% !(%, 3'

(-%1 )'! &% 3'.1 ( (&E!%-.'(,%(& ' 1-' - ..'!& &% .! :%! )'! = -(# ') &% )'!%%(&'(%, (, 113'(-%= %(& 1.!'3%%,(#-% ( &(#&%!%)!' (, -& &% & & &%: % (' '+*%3&'( ) &% )'!%%(&'(%, (, 11 3'(-%= %(& 1.!'3%%,(#-% ( &(#&%!%)!' !%= -%,'(&%+ --') 3'.!'-%6 ((%A E? , &%, ( %C ') &% 3'.1%&% -%&&1%%(&')&%,-.

&%+%&C%%(&%. !&%- 3 +1:C&&%(&%! %(&'( ')!%-.%3& +1%.%!-'(-%&3 B% !(%, '

(-%1 % !%)%!!%, &' &% ,%3-'( ') '(0+1% &% .!%% '

!& (

-C%11 -'(0+1%

11%(3')&-'

!&(! "

# #

% %1% (& %A&! 3& ') &% )'!%%(&'(%, ,%3-'(0- - !%.!', 3%, - (,%!/@ &'

( (# )#(# #* +$

!"# $

&' () ()

% $

$ $

CRM-M No.33537 of 2020 [4]

$ * *

% $

% + *

* %* $

% ,

+ % '

$ /

* *

% %* $

% %

% *

CRM-M No.33537 of 2020 [5] %

()

$, &'

( (# ! " )# (# #* 1!2$ * %*

% $

34" $-$$

* *

* % 5 5$ 6

% % %

CRM-M No.33537 of 2020 [6] 34" $-$$ * % $

* %

% $ 3#$ % %

$-$$

34"$ *

!"# $-$$*

$7 < %% !,1% !(%,3'

(-%1)'!&%. !&%- (,#'(%&!'

# &%!%3'!, ,&&%,1:(&%% %(& 1&:')3'.!'-%') ,-.

&%6+'& -,%--& (,&'# ( -&%3'.!'-%('&'(1:+!(#-.% 3% (, !'(: +%&C%%(&%. !&%-6+ & 1-'!%-&'!%-&! (= 1&:(-'3%&: 33'!,(#1:6(

%C')&%3'.!'-%6((%A E?, &%,6-& &%%(&-')&% . !&%-+%)'!%&%1% !(%,%) ,3 12 #-&! &%6 (#!

!6+%-,%-6!%.'!& - +&&%,+:&%1% !(%, ,3 1 ))3%!6&%.'--+1&:')3'( 3&'(')&% .%&&'(%!(&%3 -%-!%'&% (,+1% 563'(-%= %(&1:63'(&( &'(')&% 3!( 1 3 -% # (-& &% 33 -%, E .%&&'(%! ,%-.&% ) 11 (, 3'.1%&% -%&&1%%(&+%&C%%(&%. !&%-C'

1,-%!

%('.

!.'-%63'(-%= %(& 11:6( '!,%!&'-%3 !%&%%(,-')* -&3%6&C'

1,+% ..!'.! &%&'.

&&%3!( 1

CRM-M No.33537 of 2020 [7] 3 -% &' ( %(, In the light of the position noted above, ') &% 3'(-,%!%, %C & & &%!% - (' .%,%(& ( &% C : ') &- ' !& ( %A%!3-(#&-(%!%(&.'C%!- (,%!%3&'(;<! &'= -&% (, 113'(-%= %(& 1.!'3%%,(#-% ( &(#&%!%)!' -(' -%) 1.

!.'-% C'

1,+%-%!

%,+:.%!&&(#&%3!( 13 -%&'3'(&( % > 33'!,(#1:6 ( &% 1#& ') .'-&'( ('&%, +' %6 &% (-& (& .%&&'(- 11'C%, '<, &%,>6!%#-&%!%, (,%!%3&'(- ?< (,; & '13%& &'(&:@6 (#!

!6-&!3& (#!

! (, 11 3'(-%= %(& 1 .!'3%%,(#- % ( &(# &%!%)!'6 !% = -%, = &% .%&&'(%!

%&&'( 11'C%,(&% )'!%%(&'(%,&%!-

, 9 + : ;:< 9

;:<