High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/555/2007dismissed

M/S Haryana Minerals v. Susheela Devi And ORS.

2019-08-27Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

! "#$% &"

''"" ( & )&*"+* ,' -

&.&"// 0"$+ *''""

)'( 1$+ '%

( "* $+ '%2

455*6"& ) * 44+"- & "!! "/ *''"0* 4 455*6"& ) * #1 0* ) * 4 4+"

- & "!2 !"/*''"

7*&/*$*''" 6/''6*"* '6&5&/ &*"! "0! 6"1 * *&/' ! *"/ & 7* $*''" ""0"!! "/*''""!2 !"/*''"

!!!

" # 8 "!$* *

+ "

' "&/ ,1%0 - ' )/** 6 9' 6 / / %, 1: //,0 ;

11 ' *6 *9'*6&;*9'0 6/ + 6! ' % 1 - .* + ! * /"/1 '!/!** ' <&* '/ + &"1 "0';0**9' *9& 6&+""/8&"0//0 ,0 ** 9'*+/ / %, 2 0' 1/ 1,0 ;0"6/ + */"/ 1 6! + + = '%>; &""!6**9' 0 +"+*""$ &"0**9'%, & & "; * ,1 %0 & 1&"'" / +& 9& 0***&&16*';- ')/**"& 9& *1*' )1)&*" + = 00 ,1 %0 *

> 6 &/*"1'& ) 22* (*" /* '1- .*= / 0 + ?55& 41'!#,0 =& 9'%, 0"" + = + $

! "#$% &"$ 7*"% &"$ * / *$) )/*$ (- @* $ A& / & 1'! 9' 6 / / %, 2 0*&/+/' &" $"1/1' *&, ""/0* &** *&6* - ')/**""' "1'/ * + ! '$ "1/ 1' * & , $$ "/0* &9& & 6!*1 * 8**"1'0 " /* 6!

4"17 6&"$,0 %*"1'0 /+* ' ,'% *'&'' "' 0 16**'5*0 1"6*" '% $***""/*16"!* '$"&*"16 /*1""//** '0 6 19 ' **. '" & * /"/ +/ 9' 6 / / %, 2 **0 / '0 +/*9' + !"!

B %=& 1'!$*.&''"* '% 0 *"/+"+ +/"* '% *&*6! +/*9' */"/ 1 5*0 1&616*" ' %>$**"*""/*"&*"16 /* "1'/*&*'"6!*10 16" * * * 0* * 9' 6 / / %, 2 ***.'"& */"/ +/9'%, 6! '% 5*0 1&616*" ' %B$**".+ ""/"691 / ***"*9'6 / / %, 2 )*) )/*7*. *!

" ,

+6""%2

*/+ *'* 9'0""""* !&1*'& * *1 *0"0*! *9' ,'%*0 1"6!*1* * '%B0 / 0 9'6 / / %, 2 * * '& * * 1 1 '%B*& 1'"!0*"" ! 1" +*"*16& '%B"* &"* **"*6+9' '%>$ 0*/ 1'" 1"*' '% / /* 0 *'*+*"*+& '

""* <&&1 1 '%B "" * ' ' ! 1" * "1 ' 5* '"*0 1 ' % 6* * "1 '$ * ' "1 + * * * + /+ * '+"1' 5&1 0 1 7*' 0 <&'' &"+ * / /&1$*"1'0 ""06!

*7 6&"+0 - )1)&*"$0** " 47 4 %B 0 0 1' ,$$ ' - ')/*$0**" 474 %2 0 0 1' , $ "/ 0* * 2C' &1 1*"/*' "" " "D '!6" 6! ' %> B 9"! + ""!

! "#$ % &"// +*'' **4& 6!"/*' ''" % * ''" 0 /+ * ' '%2*+'' * &/*&" 5*+* " &" *' 6// * &/** # &" *''""**

2 9'6 / / %, 2 *6"6!*''"" ) )/* '% +6""

""* !&10 *+ ' *9'*1*1"$* $*

$*''""* 0**9'$* $&" 6 6& 0* ! "6"! '! 1'; * + '%' % 2*0 1*1* $* $*7 6&"0 /"!*"*''"""6"'! 1' /''""$*!$0 * *0 '*9'<&*1 06/0'6! '% 7* 6/ + 6!" &" * ' /+/ &"*&/**&6116! " &" *' //* &/** $5* &* &61 '& 0 6*" " &" * ''"" +!

1 +6 9# 7 6&"*""0*&*69 6 &""! '/+0*"/"0""&"'$&"1"!/ ! * 7*7 6&"' %>*0 / *1!-FB* 1 )/*$,/ 4" .

! "# ' %B*"1'6 / 0 *+*"*+/ / %, 2 $*6 +** 0+

*"*0*6++*"*+ 6 * 1&6<&+ '%>$ '+"! * "+ $1/* 6!$* '%B

"#&6 / 0 *+*" * "+ 7* 7 6&" * * '" . 6! '%' % 2*0 1$*&/*1/ ***'& **+*" 1 '%B&6& *11 /* '%B**+ <&'' +*"*01*** & * " * +*" ' %> 7* 7 6&" * 6 +* '%B&6 / 0 * 9' '%>0&"'* $*0! 6**10 "6"'!1','% 0 6"+"6"!'!1'+0*/ & &% **0 '%>$0** &*<&6! +/9'%, 2 * /"/1 G+* 0$*'E4&

0*""/0* "6"!0 "1'*6 +*0* / 0 '& ' +*" 6& & 6 " / /&* !0 $*0&"6"+ "6"!*' '"& "!/' +*+11 6"& !*"1 1'&/*66& 0*""0/ "&+ $0** / 0* / /&* ! !

$ "+ ' % > * 9&/1 6/ ' &&

# !

" $ !

% "&

" !

( "

" '

' )

* "

+ #

+ +

' #

" '

& "

# $

" "

(

# '!

" $ - "

- " . )" ' / 0 "

)

( 0 !

- "

4" "

# !

" '

" " 5!""/"! 1!*0 '6! *7 6&",* *10"" $6&'' ' '' "'' + ' "0 7* ""/"! 1!*

7* 1 *''"*11 /"!

"# 8 9 $%&'%&((&)*+,&-.*/&)01,2 &*.+ $%&'%&((&/+(')34& &*.+