High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2032/2016dismissed

Malwa Engineering Works Th Its Sole Prop v. Union Of India Th Its Secretary And ORS

2016-09-19Mr. Justice Darshan Singh,Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal4 pages

"#$ %$&'(')* ++

* ,- .. - ,- . .. /$($)#* /0'1/"2"3'4%5&"#$ /#6$7$#'#')$/ /(6'(6"8"34%5&"#$ //$(7)%$)#( ")%9 /":$)%$/;(6'4%5&"#$ //$(7)%$)#< ":$(6')%"3 6$7$#'#')$/6"("77/"&6$%#6'(&=/#'27=>)')>#6$/%$/ %"#$% <47"(($%?@#6$22'((')$/4 =)'&'7"3/7/"#')4 6")%'>"/64 86$/$?@ #6$ /$7/$($)#"#') '3$% ?@ #6$ 7$#'#')$/ ($$1')> 7"@2$)# A4AA4 BC48"(/$:$&#$% )#6$&"($')6")%4#6$7$#'#')$/8"("8"/%$%"&)#/"&# / 3'

#')> %/@ 3$"5$(B6/#'&=3#=/$ 8"(#$B (3'% 8"(#$ /2 .$&#/ 4 6")%'>"/6')/$(7)($#C#$)%$/')>)#'&$6$#$)%$/8"( 3"#$%)

< ")%#6$8/18"("33##$%##6$7$#'#')$/)

< (7$/ #6$&)%'#')')#6$&)#/"&#4#6$"2=)##?$

$/$%8"(#')&3=%$"33 #"D$(")%3$5'$((($/5'&$#"D8"(3$5'"?3$=)%$/#6$7/5'(')( #6$ ')")&$&#4 ++94"("2$)%$%=7#%"#$4"##6$#'2$ "&&$7#")&$

#$)%$/4#6$&27)$)#8"(')&3=%$%')#6$"2=)#

$/$%?@#6$7$#'#')$/ )#63@')(#"32$)#(8$/$?$')>7"'% ##6$7$#'#')$/">"')(##6$?'33( /"'($% =7# 5$2?$/4 6$ ($/5'&$ #"D &27)$)# =($% # ?$ %$7('#$%?@#6$7$#'#')$/8'#6#6$%$7"/#2$)#) "&#4#6$($/5'&$#"D) #6$1')% ($/5'&$7/5'%$%?@#6$7$#'#')$/8"($D$27#$%?@5$/)2$)# )%'"4 ')'(#/@ ')")&$4 5'%$ )#'

'&"#') %"#$% 8$

A 8$5$/4#6'()#'

'&"#')%'%)#&2$##6$)#'&$ #6$ =)'&'7"3 /7/"#')4 6$)&$4 #6$ "2=)# ($/5'&$ #"D4 86'&6 8"( ')&3=%$%')#6$"2=)#

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

$/$%(6=3%')&3=%$"33#"D$(")%3$5'$(")%)#6$%"#$86$)#6$ #$)%$/8"( 3"#$%")%"&&$7#$%4($/5'&$#"D8"(3$5'"?3$")%#6$("2$8"( ')&3=%$%')#6$"2=)#

$/$%?@#6$7$#'#')$/((=?($E=$)#3@4#6$ ($/5'&$6"(?$$)$D$27#$% /2#"D4#6$7$#'#')$/&"))#?$7"'%#6"# "2=)#"(#6$("2$8"(?$')>7"'% / =/#6$/%$7('#8'#6#6$($/5'&$#"D %$7"/#2$)#6$7$#'#')$/&"))#?$7$/2'##$%#?$=):=(#3@$)/'&6$%"##6$

&(# #6$.#"#$5$) /#6$7$/'% /2=3@4 #'335$2?$/4 4 #6$"2=)#8"(7"'%?@2'(#"1$"(#6$)#'

'&"#')>/")#')>$D$27#')%'% )#&2$##6$)#'&$ #6$ =)'&'7"3/7/"#')6$"&#')(6"33?$ #"1$) //$&5$/@ #6"#"2=)# /2#6$7$#'#')$/ $"/%3$"/)$%&=)($3 /#6$7"/#'$(")%7$/=($%#6$7"7$/ ?1 6$ "&##6"#($/5'&$#"D8"(3$5'"?3$"##6$#'2$86$)#6$ #$)%$/8"( 3"#$%")%"&&$7#$%)#6$1')% ($/5'&$#?$7/5'%$%?@#6$ 7$#'#')$/'()#')%'(7=#$#'( =/#6$/)#')%'(7=#$#6"##6$"2=)##?$

$/$%?@#6$7$#'#')$/8"(#')&3=%$"33#"D$(")%3$5'$(#8"(" #$/ =)%$/(#")%')>#6$#$/2(")%&"3&=3"#')>#6$"2=)# #"D7"@"?3$4#6$ 7$#'#')$/6"%

$/$%#6$"2=)#0'%$)#'

'&"#')%"#$% 4#6$ 3$5@ ($/5'&$#"D)#6$1')% ($/5'&$7/5'%$%?@#6$7$#'#')$/8"( $D$27#$% /27"@2$)# #"D8$ A 6$)#'

'&"#')6"5')>)# &2$##6$)#'&$ #6$ =)'&'7"3/7/"#')4#6$?'33(/"'($%?@#6$ 7$#'#')$/8$/$&3$"/$%=7#5$2?$/4 486'&6')&3=%$%#6$"2=)#

($/5'&$#"D"(8$33468$5$/4 /2 $&$2?$/4 )8"/%(4#6$"2=)#

($/5'&$#"D8"(/$%=&$%6$>/'$5")&$ #6$7$#'#')$/'(#6"#6$'($)#'#3$% #?$7"'%#6"#"2=)#"(8$338$5$/48$%)# ')%")@2$/'#')#6$ &3"'22"%$)&$#6$"2=)#

$/$%?@#6$7$#'#')$/')&3=%$%"33#"D$( ")%3$5'$(")%(=?($E=$)#3@4#6$3$5@ ($/5'&$#"D8"(8'#6%/"8)?@#6$ 5$/)2$)#4#6"#"2=)#?$')>)$ #6$&27)$)#')#6$7/'&$

$/$% ?@ #6$ 7$#'#')$/4 6$ '( )# $)#'#3$% # &3"'2 #6"# /2 #6$ =)'&'7"3 /7/"#')4"(#6"#"2=)#8"(#?$/$&$'5$%")%7"'%##6$%$7"/#2$)# &)&$/)$%)&"($4#6$"2=)#)"&&=)# #"D'(%'/$&#$%#?$7"'%##6$ 7$#'#')$/46$'()#/$E='/$%#%$7('##6$("2$8'#6#6$%$7"/#2$)#")%

9 8'33?$=):=(#3@$)/'&6$% /#6$/$"()(2$)#')$%"?5$48$%)# ')%")@2$/'#') #6$7/$($)#7$#'#')6$("2$'(4"&&/%')>3@4%'(2'(($%

":$(6')%"3!

=%>$

"/(6").')>6!

=%>$

6$#6$/(7$"1')>B/$"()$%*

$(B 6$#6$//$7/#"?3$*

$(B