High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20453/2016dismissed

Chamkaur Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2024-07-30Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger7 pages

"#"$%"& '(

)*)

+,"

&"./#/'(

)*) 0+12+3$ 4/(50 )))))) ",/,/'("$ 6"$#3# 4,+,"

3(7+8 ',0"$#

)))))) "#9'(&"(,# :; )

4 4 $"#"(, $)

#0'2 0+$&<+7=

&%'.+,"

9",/,/'("$) $) /$1+>7/, 4/(50 /<+(+= 4"(/'$

3(7+8)

$) )) 0+$&<+7=

&%'.+,"

) ) 4 =

",/,/'("$

0+12+3$ 4/(50 -/>"&

$,/.>"# * '(#,/,3,/'( (&/+= #""2/(5 #",,/(5 +#/&"

'$&"$ )*)

(("?3$"

= 9+##"& /#,$/., '>>".,'$= 4+(5$3$

= +99'/(,/(5

%,+$ 4/(50

"0#/> 03$/= /#,$/., 4+(5$3$= <0/.0 ("<>@ .$"+,"& 9'#,)

",/,/'("$ -3$,0"$ #""2# #",,/(5 +#/&"

'$&"$ )

)

(("?3$"

= 9+##"& /%/#/'(+> +,/+>+ /%/#/'(= +,/+>+

'$&"$ ) )

(("?3$"

= 9+##"&

3(7+8

= <0"$"8@ +99"+> $"%/#/'(= 9$"-"$$"& +5+/(#,

'>>".,'$:# '$&"$ )*)

(("?3$"

= <"$"

&/#1/##"&= $"#9".,/%">@) ) $/"->@= ("<>@ 9'#,

.$"+,"& "0#/> 03$/= /#,$/., 4+(5$3$= 9$'."## /(/,/+,"& -/>>/(5 9'#,)

93$#3+(."

9$'.>+1+,/'(= <">> +>'(5</,0 -"< ',0"$ .+(&/&+,"# +99>/"& 9'#,)

'>>".,'$= %/&"

/,# '$&"$ )*)

(("?3$"

= -'3(&

%,+$ 4/(50 -/, #3/,+8>"

.+(&/&+,"

("<>@ .$"+,"& 9'#,

+..'$&/(5>@= +99'/(,"&

%,+$ 4/(50 9'#,= %/&"

/,# '$&"$ )*)

(("?3$"

)

( +( +99"+> -/>"& 9",/,/'("$= +-'$"#+/& '>>".,'$:# '$&"$ )*)

(("?3$"

390">& /%/#/'(+> +,/+>+ /%/#/'(= +,/+>+= %/&"

/,# '$&"$ )

)

(("?3$"

-3$,0"$ $"%/#/'( -/>"& +>#'

&/#1/##"&

3(7+8= %/&"

/,# '$&"$ ) )

(("?3$"

,0"$"8@= 390">& '>>".,'$:# '$&"$ )*)

(("?3$"

)

+-'$"1"(,/'("& -/>"& 8"-'$"

'3$,= $">/"- #= (',/."& +8'%")

) ;"+$("& #381/,# <">> +99">>+,"

$"%/#/'(+> +3,0'$/,/"# "$$"& +99'/(,/(5

</,0'3, +99$"./+,/(5 -+., 1'$"

1"$/,'$/'3# ,0+( +>#'

#,''& .'(%/.,"& .+#"

)*)= $"5/#,"$"& 4".,/'(# = =

+, '>/."

4,+,/'( 40"$93$= %/&"

73&51"(,

*) ) = 9+##"&

3&/./+> +5/#,$+,"

#, >+##= 03$/

(("?3$"

)

, /#= ,0"$"-'$"= .'(,"(&"& #/(."

.'(%/.,"&= +..'$&/(5>@= '350, &/#B3+>/-/"& 0'>&/(5 9'#,

+#,")

, -3$,0"$ #381/,,"& 3(+3,0'$/C"& 9'##"##/'( 9+(.0+@+, >+(&= ,0"$"-'$"= -/, .+(&/&+,"

+99'/(,"&

+#,")

..'$&/(5>@= 9$+@"& /1935("& '$&"$# #", +#/&"

+99'/(,"&

"0#/> 03$/= /#,$/., 4+(5$3$) "$ .'(,$+= +99"+$/(5

'99'#"& #381/##/'(# 1+&"

'( 8"0+>- #381/,,"& $/50,>@ +99$"./+,"& 1"$/,# &"1"$/,# .+(&/&+,"# +-,"$ -/(&/(5 -/, #3/,+8>"

.+(&/&+,"= +99'/(,"&

+99'/(,1"(, -3$,0"$ +--/$1"& /%/#/'(+> +,/+>+ /%/#/'(= +,/+>+ <">>

3(7+8)

, #381/,,"& 9"$ <">> #",,>"& >+<= .0'/."

$"#9".,"& #+1"

>/50,>@ /(,"$-"$"& 3(>"## 9+,"(, />>"5+>/,@ '$ 9"$%"$#/,@)

, -3$,0"$ #381/,,"& +>,0'350 .'(%/.,"& 4".,/'(# = =

= 0'<"%"$= #"(,"(."& /19$/#'(1"(, $+,0"$= '$&"$"& $">"+#"& '( 9$'8+,/'( +(&= ,0"$"-'$"= &/#B3+>/-/.+,/'( +99'/(,"&

,"$1#

3(7+8 ;+(& "%"(3"

3>"#)

# $"5+$&# +>>"5+,/'( 3(+3,0'$/C"& 9'##"##/'( 9+(.0+@+, >+(&= #381/,,"& +#2"& 9+@ %+>3"

+$"+ 0/# 9'##"##/'(= <0/.0 1"$">@ 8/#<+# >+(&= %/&"

'$&"$ )) +>$"+&@ #381/,,"& $"B3/$"& 9+@1"(, +>> -+.,# &3>@ .'(#/&"$"& +99">>+,"

$"%/#/'(+> +3,0'$/,/"# 8">'<)

0"$"-'$"= /(-"$"(."

$"B3/$"& 1+&"

/1935("& '$&"$#)

..'$&/(5>@= &/#1/##+> 9$+@"& -'$)

0"+$& 9+$,/"# +>#'

9"$3#"& 9+9"$ 8''2 ,0"/$ +8>"

+##/#,+(.")

*) -/$#, /##3"

<0/.0 <'3>& .+>> &"./#/'( <0",0"$ #3--"$# &/#B3+>/-/.+,/'(= <0/.0 <'3>& 1+2"

>/+8>"

&/#1/##+> 9'#,

$"#3>,+(,>@ 1+2"

/(">/5/8>"

+99'/(,1"(, ;+18+$&+$) .'((".,/'(=

3(7+8 ;+(& "%"(3"

3>"#

#0'$, :; 3>"#: .+( $"-"$$"& ,'= <0/.0 $"+&#

!!!

" #

!!!! !" *)

#38$3>"

; 3>"#= -/%"

.>+3#"# 9$'%/&"&= <0/.0 ./$.31#,+(."# 9$"#.$/8"& <0/.0

0"+&1+( #0+>> &/#1/##"&)

#3.0 .+#"#= #.'9"

&/#.$",/'( 9"$#'( ("."##+$/>@ &/#1/##"&= /- -'3(& .'%"$"& +(@ .>+3#"#)

*) ( ',0"$ 0+(&= #38$3>"

; 3>"#= &/#.$",/'( .'(-"$$"& '( .'(#/&"$ &"#/$+8/>/,@ &/#1/##/(5 9"$#'(= /- #3--"$# +(@ &/#+8/>/,/"# '$ &/#B3+>/-/.+,/'(# 9$"#.$/8"& #"%"( .>+3#"# #38$3>") 0/# #38$3>"

9$'%/&"# 0"+&1+( 1+@ &/#1/##"&= /- +(@ ./$.31#,+(."# 1"(,/'("& .>+3#"# #38$3>"

.'1"

'..3$) ("

.>+3#"# 9$'%/&"# #/,3+,/'( <0"$"

.$/1/(+> 9$'.""&/(5# ,+2"( +5+/(#, 0"+&1+( <0/.0 #0'<# 3(-/, "(,$3#,"& +(@ >'(5"$ &3,/"# 0/# '--/.") '<"%"$= 1+,,"$ >"-, 93$">@ +, &/#.$",/'( &"./&"

./$.31#,+(."# "+.0 .+#"

<0",0"$ &/#1/## '$ ,+2"

#'1"

',0"$ +.,/'( +5+/(#, #3.0 .+#"#) A) 9$"#"(, .+#"= /(%'>%"& .+#"

)*)=

<0"$"/( +>'(5</,0 ',0"$# .'(%/.,"& '--"(."# 4".,/'(# = =

= $"5/#,"$"& +, '>/."

4,+,/'( 40"$93$= 0'<"%"$= $">"+#"& '( 9$'8+,/'() .'(%/.,/'( 9"$,+/(# @"+$ #3.0 .+#"

.+( -+>>

// + ; 3>"#)

) 0"$"-'$"= 1@ .'(#/&"$"& %/"<= +$531"(,# #3--"$# >"5+> &/#B3+>/-/.+,/'( 8'$("

'3, 9$'%/#/'(# $3>"

// + ; 3>"#) +& #3--"$/(5 +(@ &/#B3+>/-/.+,/'( 9$"#.$/8"& #38$3>"

; 3>"#= 0/# +$531"(,# <'3>& B3/,"

%+>/&) 3, .+#"

&/#B3+>/-/.+,/'(# #38$3>"

; 3>"#= 1+,,"$ 8"/(5 93$">@ &/#.$",/'(+$@D '>>".,'$:# .0'/."

.+(&/&+,"= <0'

#3--"$"& +(@ /(-/$1/,/"# #'1"

,/1"

+5'= $"#9".,"&)

) '>>".,'$= '11/##/'("$ <">>

3(7+8= 0">& /(-$/(5"1"(, &/#B3+>/-@/(5 +99'/(,1"(,

+#,")

# $"5+$&# +>>"5+,/'( 3(+3,0'$/C"& 9'##"##/'( 9+(.0+@+, >+(&= '8#"$%"&

3(7+8= +>$"+&@ &"+>, '87".,/'( '8#"$%"& 3(&"$ $%

" "

(

)

) !

& *

) 1@ .'(#/&"$"& %/"<= +,,"(&/(5 -+.,# #.'9"

+(@ /(,"$-"$"(."

-/(&/(5# $",3$("&

3(7+8) '$"'%"$= &/#93,"& 8"-'$"

.'3$, #/(."

&+,"

+99'/(,1"(,

9"$-'$1/(5 0/# &3,/"# ,/>> ('< /)") >+#, +>1'#,

@"+$#)

, <">>"#,+8>/#0"& 9'#/,/'( .0'/."

>/50,>@ /(,"$-"$"& </,0= "%"( /- ,<'

%/"<# +$"

9'##/8>"D 3(>"## +(@ 9+,"(, />>"5+>/,@ '$ 9"$%"$#/,@ ,0"$"/()

$"5+$&= $"-"$"(."

.+( 1+&"

73&51"(, $"(&"$"& /%/#/'( "(.0 '3$, .+#"

/%/> * )

) (&"$ &'

-/(& +(@ 1"$/, #+1"

13#, -+/>) "#3>,+(,>@= &/#1/##"&)

"(&/(5 +99>/.+,/'(

#= /- +(@= #0+>> +>#'

#,+(& .>'#"&)

)*)

#72# 0",0"$ #9"+2/(5$"+#'("&

!"#

0",0"$ $"9'$,+8>"

!"#