← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16926/2017dismissed

Inder Raj Bhatia v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2026-04-01Mr. Justice Namit Kumar10 pages



     

 !"#$%$ &'((  



    

  )'  *+) ( ,)- )

  

   



     !

"

  # $   %%%% )- ) .(/ +0 &    

  '(





'  ))*+)),   

  "

        '

! 

''- !'

.       

           

  

         



                !

"#$ !%   

&  

   



  

 #

    '      (  )         





   



  



     

  

#

       

  

  ) *  + 

    

 

   

,

!"#$-#$ %

(  

          



!  "#$,%  



     

   

 *  + *  +      ./*   



   

         0

,"#$ %

&          



  )  )  

      1#2   



 &      

       

  

   

          

 (  . 

       

 3

    

   



    #

    '    (        -

         



!  "#$,%   

      1

 #  2  "1#2%    

        

     

,

!"#$-#$

%&          



  )  )   

       1#2   



 &    

      

               

 

 

    



  



   

     4 5#6 (      7 ) /  '   

  

  

 



-  (  (    )012&3,4  ( 



'' #

5' 6

' - 

78)) 1,1*)114-!

! 



 

413"

&09 :9:-



&09):

  

"



&322  '



 !

'  /

 -  



  ;

(

' '"

/



  )01<)1&49 =.&:>





- '

!

'

 

 

  ( ? 

 



'

 &&1&)11*9 =.):

  ''

@=

? +A '  





 (        

( 8<4& *)1   

 !  ))    ( ?  

 



    '( -  (    

  

- !'

 1&10)11* 

'

  &&1<)11* 

@=

? +A '  



1  (     

(8<4& *)1 

 !  ))    ( ?  

!

   '' 

   (       

  @=

  ? +A '  

       

       

    (    

  ( ? )&12)11* =.0:

  !

 





 



!

!

0114)11* -       

-  

  1)&1)11*9 =.4:>

 



 -''('

!

'

-'!

  !



 

 

  ( ?  - 

  



 



 



 - - 

#  ' 

"



 



- 

 

 

 

  ''

 !  #



 

"     

     

  0 / '

-

' ! 

    

-

  



 

 ''

 ( 

+A ' - 





( - - !'

 1&10)11* 

'

  &&1<)11*  !



 (      !

'  

>-  

 !



 

0114)11*

 '     4   ''





  < >B' " 

  !    ),&&)1)4   !"#!$%&!' (

)  !

!  &  !    *+*,  -.  +/   ' 

 

'( 



 





 

'  

  (

      

   

     

     '( # ' 

 '

!

' 

 

 "

  

?   



 



  '

  

  "     

  

!     )3&))1&*   

        

  >- 

   





 ' ' 

141&)1&, (

      '(       01&))1&*  >  

 

 

  '

! 

 

'



 

 

- ! (

 

'? !

' '



 '

 ' 

'

 

 !  

'( 



    

  $     '( -  

   '

C-'!

 8& '(   





 -

-'('(  '   

  ( 

   '

  -

'   '

 

-   -  -

'!  

'  '



 

' -0&&))1&*   (

  -

 

'   '- ''!

"'

> !

" 

 -



- ( !-

2  '   !  

> !

" - ''!

>B' " 

 - 

- ' .

 8/    

   

         

 

   



    

 9  2   :     

                 

      

 /  

     

  2      $!! 0!!1$&&2!

(&(*+*,   2     /3            ;

< =/      

       

 

   

   (       

 +    

  

       (              

               

    /       

     

)415 

) &6*+** *

   



   (!7 "!-%! !!&

 !5 8!1 **

)4!%

!! "4 *+ $> ?

  ;

,   @  2    

                      

       A*  > (!7"!

-%!    !&

  !  5 8!1 

, 



  ; B,CC@    



     

  

    

    

  

  .



 

              D 2     

 

     

    $   

          6   ,

6   ! 2  

  $  



 (       ( B ,  6  2   ?

   )4!  % 

!!"4     6 

,

6   !"

% 2   /   

    

   

          

  

     

      ) B      > 

  *   >

&       

  6

  2> &    # 

&  A &

  >>      



; B6   ,

!"

%;   

     6   , 

  6   !"

% 

   

   @           

 6 

,   

       BF       



         

    B   !"

%   

;

B          

      :

  

         

     

    F  B /         

      2    "

%6   !

  6   ,

  & 

 6   ,@   



  

 6 

, 

         

  <      

 <  

    

  

   F  @  <   <         &  



                      !  "

% 

              

           :         

 < <

G 

  

    < <

/

 

     

:

           

   

     < <  

     



 <# <       

  

    

  

            6 

!"

%   /             

    )  5   ! 9) 5  !

!!"





     *+ 

     

:%&9:%&

!!"

;1

/<3

        

         < <  

    

     

 

"         %         

   

   

  

   9  

    

           

     

             < <

  

     

      !"

%

 



 

     ) 5  !9) 5  !

!!"

 =   B < / !!"$

)  &.!



  <<,          

    

  

           



   

                @         

5 &:

 "-&*

 * *     

   

                  &     

 



   

3

 



   

         @    

     !!  >!

6%?) (!6!

!!"

 *++/ + <,/    ; 9 

         

   

  

        

     

   

            

        

        

            2   

5

&:

"

-&       

               

&       

     

 

    @ 

 

  

           

     

          

          



          /     (  

    

    (       

C

=  @  2             

  

 

  

        

    

 

   

  





  

              

  



  

 < "  

 %   /     

                

+     

 

         2  F ' * 0,"

%"

% 9 ?

 F  * 

    

     

     



   

       

     

 

      9     :    + B        

    6   ,

!"

% 2  /    

   

 @   

        

           

 

 

    

   

       2   + 

   

            

           

      2  F '      

 6      (   

. 

 

  D2 2 

 (   !> 

8

  @ 



 

      



 

   7 * 8-  !C 

 

 



;



 (    ' !





 -!

 

@=

? +A '   



' !  ))     ( ? 

'

 &&1&)11*>-   

   

 

     '( - (    

 - !'

 1&10)11*''-(

'

  &&1<)11*-  

@=

? +A '   -

 '  (     

( 8<4& *)1>-  

 !





 



!

!

0114)11*

  

  

 

 (

      )&12)11*        

  

    



7

 









(    

-   !



  



''-  

 

    ' !

 , 

-

 .   

' ' '-

   

 (   (( 9)- ) :

 (   

C !+  D+8

 '  D+8