High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4218/2012allowed

Ajmer Singh v. P.R.T.C. And ORS.

2016-11-21Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan9 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

+,#-.&(/0 #"&"&(#-' 1#-'2'

.!$-!('3-"-3-!"&(4!50!!$4!"&!6!4!($"0#-' #'3($#("' ) 7 8 .98. -#'#(") -1&:!'0!"-!"04 $;%!"#4 -"0#3#"&"&(#- - ('02623"!4 ''&'"!(" 2(+!5

0#"0#-"0##3-"#-' 6%!6(#<'3!3#-,!=5#!66<#$"'##"0# +2$/,#("> 5#-# #--#$""0##3-"#--(" ? 0#"0#-"0#+2$/,#("'026$5#-#3-"#$&("0#$&/#'"> 98.4 0#3#"&"&(#-4<0-#"&-#$!'!(('3#%"- -,"0#

&%#

#(#-!6!(!/#-4.!$-!('3-"-3-!"&(40!($&/!-040!' &(;:#$"0#<-&"+2-&'$&%"&( "0&'2-"2($#- -"&%6#' * @ ('"&"2"&( ($&! -&''2!(%# !<-&"&("0#(!"2-# %#-"&-!-& - A2!'0&(/"0#&,32/(#$-$#-$!"#$

((#C2-#*4<0#-#5= "0#-#!'(' -$#%6&(&(/ "0# 3#('&(!-= 5#(# &"' 0!' 5##( %(;#=#$4 %6!&,&(/"0!""0#!%"&( "0#-#'3($#("'&'%("-!-=""0#.!$ -!('3-"-3-!"&(,36=##'#('&(-!"2&"=!($#(#-!6-;&$#(" 2($#/26!"&('4 BB 4!($"0!""0#3#"&"&(#-0!'5##($#3-&;#$ 0&'

3#('&(!-=5#(# &"'&('3&"# "0# !%""0!"0#0!$3"#$ -"0#'!,#!($

&66#$ "0# %($&"&(' "0#-# 0# 3#"&"&(#- !6' '##:' ! <-&"

,!($!,2'$&-#%"&(/"0#-#'3($#("'"-#6#!'#3#('&(!($/-!("0&,!66"0# 3#('&(!-=5#(# &"'&("#-,' "0#.!$-!('3-"-3-!"&( ,36=##' #('&(-!"2&"= !($ #(#-!6 -;&$#(" 2($ #/26!"&('4

BB 4 -!,#$5=-#'3($#("-3-!"&(!6(/<&"0

D&("#-#'"3#-!((2, ("0#$#6!=#$3!=,#(" "0#'!,#"&' 2-"0#-'"!"#$"0!"(%#"0# 3#"&"&(#-&'-#&('"!"#$&('#-;&%#40#%!(("5#$#(&#$"0#5#(# ''2-#$ !-##--/-#''&(.%0#,#&('0-"7 .%0#,#7 0#3#"&"&(#-<!'!33&("#$!'!($2%"-&(.!$ -!('3-"-3-!"&(&('0-"7.7( E B*B#<!'3-,"#$ !'!.25('3#%"-(

?!($"0#(3-,"#$!'!(('3#%"-( ?

@#-#"&-#$ -,'#-;&%#(?

(!""!&(&(/"0#!/#

'23#-!((2!"&( 2-&(/0&''#-;&%#4"0#3#"&"&(#-<!''2'3#($#$ '#-;&%#(E BB!($26"&,!"#6=!

"#-06$&(/"0#&(A2&-=4"0#3#"&"&(#- <!' $&',&''#$ -, '#-;&%# ( * BB* 0# 3#"&"&(#- -!&'#$ !( &($2'"-&!6$&'32"#0#8!52-2-"4!"&!6!4;&$#!<!-$$!"#$ E@

-#&('"!"#$"0#3#"&"&(#-&('#-;&%#<&"0%("&(2&"= '#-;&%#!($ 2665!%:

<!/#' /!&('""0#'!&$!<!-$4"0#-#'3($#("',;#$"0&'2-"!($ &6#$

4"&"6#$!'1#-'2'-#'&$&(/

&%#-48!52- 2-"!($!("0#-4<0&%0&''"&663#($&(/5# -#"0&'2-"4&(<0&%0"0# 3#-!"&( "0#!<!-$<!'("'"!=#$!($"0#5!%:<!/#'<#-#-$#-#$" 5#3!&$"&''"!"#$"0!""0#3#"&"&(#-0!$3"#$ -3#('&(!-=5#(# &"'

2($#- -#/26!"&(' %!66#$ 7"0# . !$ -!('3-" -3-!"&( ,36=##'#('&(-!"2&"=!($#(#-!6-;&$#("2($#/26!"&('4 BB &( '0-" 7"0# #/26!"&(' BB 7 0#( 0# <!' 3-,"#$ !' .25 ('3#%"-!($('3#%"-(

?!($?

@-#'3#%"&;#6=4"0#

? 3#"&"&(#-<!'#("&"6#$"/#"!$$&"&(!6&(%-#,#("2($#-26# 2(+!5&;&6.#-;&%#'26#'4162,# 4!-" <#;#-4"0#'!,#<!'("

/-!("#$ " 0&, #<!' !6' #("&"6#$ " (# !$$&"&(!6 &(%-#,#(" ( %,36#"&( * ? =#!-' '#-;&%# 2($#- "0# ''2-#$ !-##- -/-#''&(.%0#,#4 BB 4!336&%!56#<&"0#

#%" -, BB*4'&(%#0# %,36#"#$ * ? =#!-' '#-;&%# !' ! ($2%"- ( E E4 E BB?!($ E

!-6&#-4"0#3#"&"&(#-0!$ &6#$

4 <0&%0 <!' $#%&$#$ 5="0&' 2-" ( @

4&( <0&%0 "0# -#'3($#("'<#-#$&-#%"#$"$#%&$#"0#6#/!6("&%#<&"0&(!3#-&$ "0-## ,("0' -,"0#$!"# -#%#&3" %#-"& &#$%3= "0#-$#-<4"0# 6#/!6("&%#0!'5##($#%&$#$4;&$#-$#-$!"#$

((#C2-#*4 &(<0&%0"0#3#('&(!-=5#(# &"'0!;#5##($#(&#$("0#/-2($"0!""0# 3#"&"&(#- 0!$ (" 3"#$ - "0# 3#('&( '%0#,# <0#( "0# '!,# <!' &("-$2%#$&("0#-#'3($#("-3-!"&(<&"0#

#%" -, E* BB 0# %6!&, -5#(# '%0#,#0!'!6'5##($#%6&(#$ 0#3#"&"&(#- %6!&,'"0!"0#0!$,;#$!(!336&%!"&(2($#-"0#&/0""( -,!"&(

%"4

E5# -#"0#82$0&!(!#3" -#'3($#("$#3!-",#("4<0&%0"6$ 0&,"0!""0#&( -,!"&(<&665#!;!&6!56#!"0!($&/!-0#3"(6=!($ "0!""0#0!($&/!-0#3" -#'3($#("$#3!-",#("4;&$#6#""#- * *4 $!"#$ @@

4'"!"#$"0!""0#&( -,!"&(%26$5#'2336&#$5=82$0&!(!

#3"0#-# -#4((# "0#$#3"'2336&#$"0#$%2,#(";&$#<0&%0&" %26$5#'25'"!("&!"#$"0!""0#3#"&"&(#-0!'(" &66#$"0#3"&( ("0#-#36=4"0#-#'3($#("'0!;#"!:#("0#36#!"0!""0# . !$ -!('3-" -3-!"&( ,36=##' #('&( -!"2&"= !($ #(#-!6-;&$#("2($#/26!"&('4 BB 4$("!336=""0##,36=##'4 <03" -"0#'!&$-#/26!"&('452" !&6#$"-# 2($"0#!,2(" !$;!(%#

"!:#(2" "0##,36=#-7''0!-# %("-&52"&("!6(/<&"0&("#-#'"

"0#-#(4!''"&326!"#$&(6!2'#? "0#'!&$#/26!"&(' BB ($#- 6!2'# "0#'!&$#/26!"&(' BB 4"0#3"&(<!'"5##C#-%&'#$ <&"0&( ! 3#-&$ '&C ,("0' -, "0# $!"# &''2!(%# "0# '!&$ -#/26!"&('!($(%#"0#3"&(&'#C#-%&'#$4"0#%(%#-(#$#,36=##'0!66 $#3'&" "0##,36=#-7' '0!-# %("-&52"&( "<!-$'4-#%#&;#$ 5= 0&,"!:#(&(!$;!(%#4& !(=4<&"0&(!3#-&$ '&C,("0' -,"0#$!"#

&''2!(%# "0##/26!"&(' BB !($"0!"&(%!'#4"0#3"&(&'("

#C#-%&'#$<&"0&("0#'3#%& &#$3#-&$4"0##,36=##'0!665#$##,#$"5# %("&(2&(/&("0##C&'"&(/%("-&52"-=3-;&$#(" 2($5#(# &""&''"!"#$ "0!"'&(%#"0#3#"&"&(#-$&$("'25,&"!(=3"&(2($#-#/26!"&('

BB !($"0!"0#!6' !&6#$"$#3'&""0#!$;!(%# ' ?4

"!:#(5= 0&,2" #,36=#-'0!-#<&"0&(!'"&326!"#$3#-&$4"0#-# -#40#&'("

#("&"6#$"5#(# #/26!"&(' BB 0#'2'3#('&( "0#3#"&"&(#- !($0&'"#-,&(!"&( -,'#-;&%#!($'25'#A2#("6=-#&('"!"#,#("&('#-;&%# <!'!$,&""#$4'"!"&(/"0!"!/!&('""0#!<!-$ "0#8!52-2-"4!"&!6!4

4 &6#$5=-#'3($#("'&'3#($&(/5# -#"0&'2-"

- &(!6!$+2$&%!"&(0#3#"&"&(#-<!'!66<#$"+&($2"=<&"0#

#%"

-, @*

4'25+#%"""0# &(!62"%,# "0#'!&$<-&"3#"&"&("<!'

'"!"#$"0!""0#3#"&"&(#-<!'/-!("#$ =#!-'&(%-#,#("<&"0#

#%"

@ B(%,36#"&( =#!-' '#-;&%#2($#-"0# .%0#,## <!'3-,"#$!'!.25('3#%"-(

?!($!'!(('3#%"-( ?

@ '0#$&$("%,36#"# =#!-' '#-;&%#((#3'"!

"#-0&'

-#&('"!"#,#("&('#-;&%#<&"0#

#%" -, @*

4 "0#-# -#40#&'("

#("&"6#$"!(=5#(# .%0#,# 0!;#0#!-$"0#6#!-(#$%2('#6' -"0#3!-"&#'!($0!;#!6'

E %!-# 266=/(#"0-2/0"0# &6# 0#-#!-#"<3!-"' "0#%6!&, "0#3#"&"&(#-F &-'"&' - /-!(" 3#('&(!($"0#'#%($&' -/-!(" 5#(# .%0#,#( %,36#"&( * ? =#!-' '#-;&%#

$,&""#$6=4"0#3#"&"&(#-<!'/-!("#$ =#!-'&(%-#,#("<&"0 #

#%" -, @ B2($#-"0# .%0#,#42($#-<0&%0"0# <!'" 5#/-!("#$(%,36#"&( * ? =#!-' '#-;&%#0# .%0#,# <!'&,36#,#("#$("0#-#%,,#($!"&(' "0#"0!=,,&''&(4;&$# ;#-(,#("("& &%!"&($!"#$ EB BB <&"0#

#%" -, BB*42($#- <0&%0& !(#,36=##&'("3-,"#$""0#(#C"0&/0#-6#;#6(!%%2("

((!;!&6!5&6&"= !;!%!(%=!"'2%00&/0#-6#;#6-((#C&'"#(%# !

3-,"&(!66#;#640#'0!665#/-!("#$"0#3!='%!6#'&("0#(#C"0&/0#- 0&#-!-%0=(%,36#"&( =#!-' '#-;&%#&(!3'"("0!"%!'#40&'3!= &'"5# &C#$!""0#(#C"0&/0#-'"!/#&("0#,!'"#-'%!6#!($0#<&665# !66<#$(#C"&(%-#,#("<&"0#

#%" -,"0#$!"#0#<26$0!;##!-(#$"0# (#C"&(%-#,#("0#-#!

"#-4(%,36#"&( * =#!-' '#-;&%#40#<!'

"5#/-!("#$3- &%&#(%='"#323& 0#'"&66%("&(2#'("0#'!,#3'"( "0&'%!'#4"0#3#"&"&(#-!$,&""#$6=+&(#$'#-;&%#( E B*B0# .%0#,#<!'&("-$2%#$<&"0#

#%" -, BB* '3#-"0#'"!($ -#'3($#("'4"0#3#"&"&(#-<!'/-!("#$ =#!-'&(%-#,#("<&"0#

#%"

@ B ("0#3-#'#("%!'#4"0#3#"&"&(#-<!''2'3#($#$(E BB !($0&''#-;&%#'<#-#"#-,&(!"#$( * BB*(!%%2(" !<!-$ 8!52-2-"4!"&!6!4"0#3#"&"&(#-<!'!66<#$"+&("0#$2"=<&"0#

#%"

-, @*

0#-# -#4 0&' #("&-# '#-;&%# $2-&(/ "0# 3#-&$ 0# -#,!&(#$2($#-"#-,&(!"&(4&'"5#%2("#$!'A2!6& =&(/'#-;&%# -"0#

* 32-3'# /-!(" 0#3#"&"&(#-<!'3-,"#$!'!.25('3#%"- (

?!($"0#-#!

"#-!'!(('3#%"-(?

@ <#;#-4 5# -#"0!"40#<!'#("&"6#$" !'0#%("&(2#$("0#'!,#3'"

($2%"-"&'!33!-#(""0!""0#5#(# .%0#,#<&"0#

#%"

BB*<!'("/-!("#$"0&,4 -<0&%00#&'#("&"6#$!

"#-%('&$#-&(/ 0&'#("&-#'#-;&%#&(%62$&(/"0#3#-&$0#-#,!&(#$2($#-'2'3#('&(!($ "#-,&(!"&( <4 %,&(/ " "0# A2#'"&( -#/!-$&(/ /-!(" 3"&(4 &"

%,#'2""0!""0##/26!"&(' BB <#-#3-,26/!"#$&("0#=#!- BB 0#3#"&"&(#-<!'/;#-(#$5="0'#-#/26!"&('&("0#=#!- BB 0# 3#"&"&(#-%6!&,'"0!"0#0!$/&;#(3"&(2($#-6!2'# "0#'!&$ #/26!"&(' BB <#;#-4"0#-#'3($#("'$#(&#$"0#'!,#0#=0!;# !6'-#6&#$23(6!2'#? "0#'!&$#/26!"&(' BB 42($#-<0&%0 !(#,36=##<00!'"!:#(!$;!(%#2" "0##,36=#-7''0!-# %("-&52"-=3-;&$#(" 2($&'-#A2&-#$"-# 2($"0#'!,#!($(&"'

!&62-#4 0# &' (" #("&"6#$ " "0# '!&$ 5#(# &"' 6!2'# ? "0# '!&$ #/26!"&(' BB &'-#3-$2%#$!'2($#-) G6!2'#?

336&%!"&() 0#'#-#/26!"&(''0!66!336=""0# #,36=##' "0#..!$-!('3-"-3-!"&(<0) & <#-#!-#!33&("#$(-!

"#-"0# $!"# &''2# #/26!"&('(<06# "&,#!($-#/26!-5!'&'F!($ && <#-# <-:&(/ &,,#$&!"#6= 5# -# "0#$!"# &''2# #/26!"&('!($3"

-"0#'#-#/26!"&(' 0#'#-#/26!"&(''0!66("!336=""0##,36=##4 <0) CCCCC CCCCC CCCCC

@ 0 3" - "0# ,36=##'

#('&(-!"2&"= !($ #(#-!6 -;&$#(" 2($ #/26!"&(' BB 452" !&6#$"-# 2($"0#!,2("

!$;!(%#"!:#(2" "0#,36=#-7''0!-#

"0# ("-&52"-= -;&$#(" 2($ !6(/<&"0 &("#-#'""0#-#(<&"0&("0#'"&326!"#$3#-&$H 0#3#"&"&(#-$#'("%6!&,"0!"0#0!$$#3'&"#$"0#'!&$ !$;!(%# 0#-# -#4 6!2'#? "0# '!&$ #/26!"&(' BB &'

!""-!%"#$!($0#&'("#("&"6#$"5#(# '!&$#/26!"&(' BB 4'!'

"%6!&,"0#3#('&( 0#6#!-(#$%2('#6 -"0#3#"&"&(#-0!'!-/2#$ "0!""0# 3"&( -,&'<&"0"0#-#'3($#("'!($"0#=0!;#("3-$2%#$"0#'!,# $#'3&"#"0#&( -,!"&('2/0"2($#-"0# %" %%-$&(/"0&,4"0# 3"&(<!'/&;#(<&"0&('"&326!"#$"&,#&("0#=#!- BB <#;#-4"0# &( -,!"&(2($#-"0# %"<!''2/0"&("0#=#!-

0#("0# 3#"&"&(#-%6!&,'"0!"0#0!$/&;#("0#3"&(""0#-#'3($#("'4&"<!' - "0#3#"&"&(#-"3-;#"0!""0#3"&(<!'/&;#(""0#-#'3($#("'<&"0&( '"&326!"#$"&,#

"#-"0#6!3'# B=#!-'40#%!(("'!="0!"'&(%#"0#%3= "0#3"&(&'("'2336&#$"0&,2($#-"0#! "#- B=#!-'4"0#-# -#4 &"'026$5#3-#'2,#$"0!"0#0!$/&;#(3"&(2($#-"0##/26!"&('

BB 0#6#!-(#$%2('#6 -"0#3#"&"&(#-0!'!6'-#6&#$23("0#-$#- $!"#$ @

E ((#C2-# E4;&$#<0&%0"0#0!$!$3"#$"0# 2(+!5&;&6.#-;&%#' 26#'42(+!5 ;#-(,#(" ,36=##'($2%" 26#'4 B**<&"0-#"-'3#%"&;##

#%"!'<#66!'3-'3#%"&;#6=<#;#-4"0# 3#('&(-26#'0!;#("5##(!$3"#$5="0#0#-# -#4"0#3#('&( %!'# "0#3#"&"&(#-&'$##,#$"5#%('&$#-#$2($#-#/26!"&(' BB .&(%#"0#3#"&"&(#-0!' !&6#$"3-;#"0!"0#0!$#C#-%&'#$"0#3"&( 2($#-"0##/26!"&(' BB !($"0!"0#0!'!6' !&6#$"-# 2($"0#

#,36=#-7''0!-# %("-&52"&("4"0#-# -#40#&'("#("&"6#$""0# 5#(# 3#('&(2($#-"0##/26!"&(' BB "&'"5# 2-"0#-("&%#$ "0!" -,"0#=#!- BB (<!-$'"&66"0#-#"&-#,#(" "0#3#"&"&(#-&("0# =#!-

40&''0!-# %("-&52"&("<!-$'&'5#&(/$#$2%"#$452"&( "0#'# *=#!-'40#(#;#--!&'#$!(=5+#%"&("0!"0&'%("-&52"&(&' '"&665#&(/<-(/6=$#$2%"#$!"2-!66=4"0#'"!"#,#("'<#-#5#&(/'#(" "0&,#<!''6##3&(/;#-"0#,!""#- - @=#!-'!($<:#23(6= !

"#-0&'-#"&-#,#(""%6!&,"0!"0#0!$/&;#("0#3"&( -'0& "&(/ "3#('&( 0# 6#!-(#$ %2('#6 - "0# 3#"&"&(#- 0!' -#6&#$ 23( "0# !2"0-&"= "0# 3#C2-"&( !(/!6-#2- 6258"$1#-'2'#/&(!6 &-#%"-4,36=##'."!"#('2-!(%#-3-!"&(4 E . !($ "0#!2"0-&"&#' "0&'2-"&(&$!-.&(/01#-'2'0#-#'&$&(/

&%#-4 8!52-2-"4 !"0&($!4

??.??!($0!-!(!''1#-'2'2(+!5 ."!"#6#%"-&%&"= !-$4!"&!6!4!($!("0#-

E .8@?!($&"0!'

5##(!-/2#$"0!"&(%!'# '%&!6<#6 !-#6#/&'6!"&(4"0#5#(# &"0!'"5# /-!("#$5=/&;&(/6&5#-!6&("#-3-#"!"&( !, "0# ;&#< "0!" "0#-# &' ( A2#'"&( 6&5#-!6 &("#-3-#"!"&(("0#3-#'#("%!'#4"0#3#"&"&(#-<!'"3-;#"0!"0#0!$ /&;#("0#3"&( -'0& "&(/ -,"3#('&(!($0#0!$-# 2($#$"0# !$;!(%#"!:#( -,"0##,36=#-7''0!-# %("-&52"&("<!-$' "

('"!/#4"0#3#"&"&(#--# 2($#$"0#'!&$!$;!(%#"!:#( -,"0##,36=#-7'

'0!-# %("-&52"&("<!-$'0#-# -#40#&'("#("&"6#$""0# 5#(# #/26!"&(' BB (;&#< "0# -#/&(/$&'%2''&(4"0#3-#'#("<-&"3#"&"&(&' 3!-"6=!66<#$0#3#"&"&(4' !-!'A2!'0&(/ -$#-$!"#$

B ((#C2-#*$#%6&(&(/"0#/-!(" 3#('&(!-=5#(# &"'""0#3#"&"&(#-4 &'$&',&''#$. !-!'"0#/-!(" &'%(%#-(#$4"0#<-&" ,!($!,2'

&'&''2#$4$&-#%"&(/"0#-#'3($#("'"%,32"#"0##("&-#'#-;&%# 3#"&"&(#-&(%62$&(/"0#3#-&$$2-&(/<0&%00#-#,!&(#$2($#-"#-,&(!"&( !($"0#-#!

"#-/-!(""0#5#(# .%0#,#$!"#$ EB BB ((#C2-# 4 #

#%"&;# -, BB* &( "#-,' "0# '!&$ &('"-2%"&(' "0# ;#-(,#("!($3!''(#%#''!-=-$#-'<&"0&("0-##,("0' -,"0#$!"#

-#%#&3" %#-"& &#$%3= "0&'-$#-0#!--#!-'4& !(=4'0!665#3!&$!"

"0#-!"# BD3#-!((2,4'"!-"&(/ -,"0#$!"#&"5#%!,#$2# 0#3-#'#("<-&"3#"&"&(&'3!-"6=!66<#$ 98.

* '+:' 0#"0#-'3#!:&(/-#!'(#$ ) #' 0#"0#-#3-"!56# )