High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20528/2016allowed

Dr. B.L.Kapur Memorial Hospital Th D.S. Bhasin v. Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal Ludhiana And ANR

2019-10-14Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

[1]

!"#"$% & ' ()* +,(-.("

/#+"

0 "$( 1(#,# (#" "$2

"!(3$ ,# ("

/("4,$ /3), 5"

$ 5( 0#+$ $ (% $64/-(,# "!7 /"

(#$ % -(77, $3 8!

( -(-71"(93 8!

"$( -#75 "//"- :

$3 8!

( -(75 (;

$752 /3 8!

((#+$ $ <<< 7)3=( />

( ?("$ 5;("

+ "$"# 5"##, $! ;("

( "( (" (@, #5"$2$$A,(B

3(:!

"$2

"$ "/ 4? 5 + "$( ,$ ( 7!

"$ CC=>=4> $ ,# ("

/ "#+, # !

'&D =5("$

( ( (( # E 5 !

6>3 #9"$2 ++(8 5 "#."## / (#+$ $ B;(9.

$ ) ($ !,$#/ 5 + "$( 4? (/?"$2 ,+$ !"#"$ $64/ 57,+(.,( "$-B#5

($(9#8# 5 2,45 " /,45 "

$ 5(# 'D = > 7

3 !$

$ "$ "$24"$2 (("8

5$ ,# ("

/("4,$ /F!,.F) 4,( ,( 3 ), 5"

=5("$

( ( (( # E 5 ("4,$ /6>

.# "!$@,"(?;

#"$8"/

"$ 5+("$!"+/# $

/:,# "!3

#(@,"( 2"8 $++( 5.+/?(

[2] +( ,! 8" $!3 "

$?3 /# 5 ;(9.

$ (4, 8" $! "

5 # !5# $ $ # " A(!"# 4"$2 !

((" , ("4,$ /;

(("8

#;$!$!/,#"$$.("

#$ 58" $! +( ,! 4 ("

5(2 ( 5+( ."#!$ ,!

5;5"!5

5 ;(9.

$ ;

# !5 (2 ) ($ !,$#/ !$ $ #

#+"

+( ?( 5 8"$2 4$ .

"$ 5 ;("

$ #

"$ 8$ , /"

? 5 .# "!$@,"(?4"$2 ,$ 48"

$ $? 2(,$ 3 .

2.$ 4 +(."

5 !

# $ .("

#3 $ ++( ?;5

#8(;

#2( /) ($ !,$#/ !$

5!"(!,.#

$!# 5".+,2$ ( ("#/"

4/ 4 # #" $ .

( (.

5 / ($ ("4,$ +(!

5( "$ 5 .

( "$ 5 /"25 5 !"#"$ $64/ 7,+(.,( "$-B#5

($(9#6#!

#=#,+( > 2"8 $ ++( 5 .+/?( +( ,! 8" $! /# ;(9.

$ (4, 5# ."

5#!5## 5(

( (("8

!"#"$ ;"

5 (2 ( ."#!$ ,!

//2 "$# 5 ;(9.

$ /8 A !

-B# 5

($ (9#6# !

# =#,+( > "# (+( ,! #,$ (%F G5$ $

"$ ,$ ( 7!

"$ CC ;5 5(

++(8 / ( ( +(."##"$ "# .

("4,$ / "

5 "$"

//? /"."

:,("# "!

"$$/? #;5 5( +(".

!" !

# "# .

, "$ (#+!

5 ."#!$ ,!

!5 (2 5"# "#3 5;8(3 5 +#"

"$ $/? ;5$ .# "!$@,"(?+(! "$2 5( ( "#."## /"# (

$? !

"# # ?3 ( 5 8"! 8"/

"$ 5 +("$!"+/# $

/ :,# "! $

[3] 5(5 $ 3 5("#8"/

"$ 5+("$!"+/# $

:,# "!3 ("4,$ / ;"// 5$ 2"8 ++( .+/?( +( ,! 8" $!3 "

$?3 /# ;(9.

$ (4, "

5#!5##$ 5/

(8$

("4,$ /;"//4$ / (("8

#;$!$!/,#"$ $.("

#$ 58" $!+( ,! 4 ("

5(2 (

5+( 5."#!$ ,!

!5 (2 3 ("4,$ /3

5$3;"//$ 4!$ "$ .(/? !$#" (;5 5( +(".

!" !

# "# #

4/"#5 "$# 5 .+/? $ 5(;( #3"$#,!5 $8$ 5.+/?(6# "$ "$2"$

5 .# "! $@,"(? ;"// / +# 5# ;"// 4 #,4# , 5"$ +$ $ !$!/,#"$# ("4,$ $.("

#H C ) ($ !,$#/ 5 (#+$ $ F;(9.

$ # $ "#+, 5 +#"

"$ # $ "! 48 $ #

#5 5 # $ 4:!

"$ 5+( ?( / ($ !,$#/ "$(#,4:!

5 !$ "

"(!

"$# 4 "##, 5 / ($ ("4,$ !$!/, 5+(! "$2#

(/"# $ "$ $?!

#;"

5"$ +(" ,(.$ 5#

"#+, ++ $!4 ( ("4,$ / & $8"; 5+#"

"$ #$ 483".+,2$ ( ( $$A,(B

3"## #" #"#(.

("4,$ !$ ,!

+(! "$2#"$ 5/"25 5 !"#"$ $64/

5 7,+(. ,( "$ -B# 5

($ (9#6# !

# =#,+( > "$

!!( $!;"

5/ ; 5#

2 5/ "$2 5"$@,"(? 4$

[4]

"( $ +(+( 5(

(

9 !"#"$$

"$B# CC=>=4> 5!

(+(8" "$2

"8++( "#

/ 8" $!3 ;"

5"$ +(" ,( .$ 5#

+ "#+,

"$2"$ ++ $!4 ( / "# ( "(!

+, ++ $!4 ( 5/ ($ ("4,$ /$

"$#

$ # "#+# 48 (.# =7)>

& ' :#5995,(

5 5(#+ 9"$2B( #$ %

#B 5 5((+(

4/ %