← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22208/2014dismissed

Kamlesh Rani v. State Of Punjab And Others

2017-08-10Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan7 pages

       

 

       

 

       

 

       

 

 

  

  

  

  



 

 

!  "# 

 

 

!  "# 

 

 

!  "# 

 

 

!  "# $%&'()*%+, -. */,,/%%'

(0,0,.+(/ (/)1) 0%0(.2 1+3%4%+5.0*(/)   

()6.+5(+0)   !7

     

   

  !7

     

   

  !7

     

   

  !7

     

   

/()(+0!

/()(+0!

/()(+0!

/()(+0!

/ %/,+5(/ *%/&%" 59.:%0(2./0*(6(0,0,.+(/ /

9,+,0 9%)0*," )),)0%+0 59.:%0((+(/%'" 1+3%4 ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;<  

   

"  

   

"  

   

"  

   

" *%''(+=(,+0*(,+)0%+06(0,0,.+,)0.0*(./5(/5%0(5  ++(>1/( "6%))(54?0*( ,)0/,:0 51:%0,.+ 22,:(/  (:.+5%/?  51:%0,.+"  %/,5@.0  %+5  ,+  0(/&)  .2  A*,:*  0*( 6(0,0,.+(/*%)4((+/(9(/0(52/.&0*(6.)0.2%,'./,+=,)0/())0. 0*%0.2./@)*.6 

/,(22%:0)"0*%0%/(+.0,+5,)610("&%?4(+.0,:(5 (0,0,.+(/  6.))())()  0*(  C1%',2,:%0,.+  .2  9.:%0,.+%' :.1/)(,+0*(0/%5(.2100,+="%,'./,+=" &4/.,5(/?%+5 ((5'( A./@2/.&0*( (6%/0&(+0.2(:*+,:%' 51:%0,.+%+5+51)0/,%'

/%,+,+="  1+3%4   (0,0,.+(/  A%)  %66.,+0(5  %)  ./@)*.6

00(+5%+01+5(/0*( 51:%0,.+ (6%/0&(+0" 0%0(.2 1+3%49,5( ./5(/5%0(5B  DDB  ,5(&(&.5%0(5  D"6(0,0,.+(/ A%)  6/.9,),.+%''?  6/.&.0(5  %)  %,'./,+=  ,)0/())  1+5(/

 .:%0,.+%' :*(&( +D  B"0*(6(0,0,.+(/A%))(/9(5% )*.A  :%1)(  +.0,:(  :.+0(&6'%0,+=  *(/  /(9(/),.+  2/.&  0*( 6/.&.0,.+%'6.)0.2%,'./,+=,)0/())0.0*(6.)0.2./@)*.6

00(+5%+0.+0*(=/.1+50*%01+5(/0*( 0%010./?1'()=.9(/+,+= )(/9,:("0*(/(,)+.6/.9,),.+2./&%@,+=%66.,+0&(+00.0*(6.)0 .2%,'./,+=,)0/())4?A%?.26/.&.0,.+ (6'?5%0(5  B A%)  )14&,00(5  4?  0*(  6(0,0,.+(/  0.  0*(  )*.A  :%1)(  +.0,:( .A(9(/"9,5(,&61=+(5./5(/5%0(5 ++(>1/( "

6(0,0,.+(/)0%+5)/(9(/0(52/.&0*(6.)0.2%,'./,+=,)0/())0. 0*(6.)0.2./@)*.6 0,)%=%,+)0)1:*4/,(22%:01%'

4%:@5/.60*%00*(,+)0%+0A/,06(0,0,.+*%)4((+2,'(5 (%/+(5  :.1+)('  %66(%/,+=  2./  0*(  6(0,0,.+(/  *%) )14&,00(50*%00*(6/.&.0,.+.20*(6(0,0,.+(/,+0*(?(%/D0. 0*(6.)0.2%,'./,+=,)0/())1+5(/.:%0,.+%' :*(&(A%),+ :.+2./&,0? A,0*0*(,+)0/1:0,.+),))1(54?0*( 0%0(.2 1+3%4 5%0(5 B DDE %+5  D  0,)%/=1(5 0*%0(9(+,2+.

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

,)0/())  %+5"  %)  )1:*"  0*(  %5&,+,)0/%0,9(  ,+)0/1:0,.+)  5%0(5 B DDE%+5 D*%54((+,))1(5A,0*0*(.43(:0,9(.2 2,'',+=16%'%:1+% ,+0*(1'()  0,)9(*(&(+0'?%/=1(50*%0 1+5(/)1:*:,/:1&)0%+:()"0*(6/.&.0,.+.20*(6(0,0,.+(/0.0*( 6.)0.2%,'./,+=,)0/())9,5(./5(/5%0(5  DA%)'(=%''?

9%',5 (%/+(5:.1+)('21/0*(/)14&,0)0*%00*(,&61=+(5./5(/ .2  /(9(/),.+  *%)  4((+ 6%))(5  .+  0*(  )0/(+=0* .2 '(00(/  5%0(5  ++(>1/( ",))1(54?0*( (6%/0&(+0.2(+(/%'

5&,+,)0/%0,.+.+,0./,+=(''" 0%0(.2 1+3%4%+5A*(/(4?% 5(:,),.+A%)0%@(+0*%0%'',+)0/1:0,.+)-:,/:1'%/),))1(5"A*,:*%/( :.+0/%/?0.0*( 0%010./?1'()")*.1'5+.04(,&6'(&(+0(5  0 *%)4((+)14&,00(5 0*%00*('(00(/5%0(5  *%)4((+ ,))1(50.A%/5):.&6',%+:(.20*(./5(/)6%))(54?0*,).1/0,+ ,9,'/,0 (0,0,.+ .

#.2  %+%@*%+5  9   0%0(.2  %+%@*%+5  9   0%0(.2  %+%@*%+5  9   0%0(.2  %+%@*%+5  9   0%0(.2 1+3%4 1+3%4 1+3%4 1+3%4%+5.0*(/) %+5.0*(/) %+5.0*(/) %+5.0*(/)  /(:,)(%/=1&(+0/%,)(5,)0*%0'(00(/5%0(5    :%++.0  *%9(  /(0/.)6(:0,9(  .6(/%0,.+  %+5"  %)  )1:*" A.1'5+.0:.9(/6/.&.0,.+)0*%0%'/(%5?)0..5(22(:0(56/,./0. 0*(5%0(.2,))1%+:(.2)1:*'(00(/

9(+%6'(%%)/(=%/5)5,):/,&,+%0,.+*%)4((+/%,)(5 4?%59(/0,+=0.&(&.5%0(5  D" ++(>1/( "%+5,0,) )14&,00(50*%0%+1&4(/.2.0*(/(&6'.?(()A*.*%5%').4((+ 6/.&.0(5  2/.&  0*(  6.)0  .2  ./@)*.6  00(+5%+0  0.  (A,+= (%:*(/), ( ,&'%%+,"1=%'$,)*./(" *,+5(/ %'$%1/"/&,'%

(9,%+5 %/4*% ,+=*"%/()0,''*.'5,+=0*(6/.&.0,.+%'6.)0%+5 *%9(+.04((+/(9(/0(5%+5,0,).+'?0*(6(0,0,.+(/A*.*%)4((+ ),+='(5  .10  %+5  /(9(/0(5  0.  0*(  6.)0  .2  ./@)*.6 

:0,.+,))0%0(50.4(%/4,0/%/?%+59,.'%0,9(.2 /0,:'()%+5E

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

00(+5%+0)  %/(  )0,''  :.+0,+1,+=  .+  0*(  6/.&.0,.+%'  6.)0)"  %+ %55,0,.+%'  %22,5%9,0  5%0(5  B F  .2  0*(  ,)0/,:0  51:%0,.+

22,:(/ (:.+5%/? 51:%0,.+"%/,5@.0*%)4((+2,'(5%+5,0*%) 4((+  :'%/,2,(5  0*%0  (>:(60  2./  $%+0%  (9,"  +.+(  .2  0*(  .0*(/ +%&(5.22,:,%')%):,0(54?0*(6(0,0,.+(/A(/(6/.&.0(50.0*( 6.)0  .2  (A,+=  (%:*(/)   &0 $%+0%  (9,"  A*.  *%5  4((+ 6/.&.0(5%0 ,)0/,:0(9('2/.&0*(6.)0.2./@)*.6 00(+5%+00.

0*%0.2 (A,+=(%:*(/"*%)%'/(%5?/(0,/(52/.&)(/9,:(A ( B E (%/+(5:.1+)('2./0*(6%/0,()*%9(4((+*(%/5%0 '(+=0*  *(  :.+5,0,.+)  .2  )(/9,:(  =.9(/+,+=  0*(  6.)0  .2 %,'./,+=,)0/())%/(=.9(/+(54?0*( 1+3%4 0%0( 51:%0,.+ '%)) :*..'%5/( (/9,:(1'()"D#*(/(,+%20(/0.4( /(2(//(50.%)8D#1'()8 1'(F=.9(/+)%66.,+0&(+00.%+?

6.)0  ,+  0*( )(/9,:(  %+5  )0,61'%0()  0*%0  +.  6(/).+  )*%''  4( %66.,+0(5  1+'())  *(  6.))())()  +(:())%/?  C1%',2,:%0,.+)  %+5

(>6(/,(+:(%)'%,55.A+,+ 66(+5,>8 8%00%:*(50.0*(1'() *(/('(9%+0(>0/%:0.2 66(+5,>8 8=.9(/+,+=%66.,+0&(+00.

0*(6.)0.2%,'./,+=,)0/()),)/(76/.51:(5*(/(1+5(/! (/7 ,%'

.

(),=+%0,.+  .2 6.)0) ,+,&1& H1%',2,:%0,.+) %+50(%:*,+=(>6(/,(+:( (0*.5 .2 (:/1,0&(+0

,/(:0 %66.,+7 0&(+0 /.&.0,.+    >>>>  >>>> >>>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> %,'./,+= ,)0/()) %0/,:./,55'(./%00%+ ./  15*,&%+,  A,0*  0*/(( ?(%/)  0(%:*(/)  /%,+,+=

,6'.&% 2/.& 0*( +51)0/,()  (6%/0&(+0  .2 +51)0/,%'/%,+,+=  

66(+5,>8 80.1'(F.20*(D#1'()'(%9()+.

&%++(/.25.1400*%00*(6.)0.2%,'./,+=,)0/()),)0.4(2,''(5 16  G  4?  A%?  .2 5,/(:0 %66.,+0&(+0  + .0*(/ A./5)" 0*( &(0*.5.2/(:/1,0&(+04?A%?.26/.&.0,.+0.2,''160*(6.)0.2 %,'./,+=,)0/()):%++.04(/()./0(50.

*(%/=1&(+0/%,)(54?'(%/+(5:.1+)('/(6/()(+0,+= 0*(6(0,0,.+(/0*%0,20*( 0%010./?1'()5.+.06/.9,5(%+%9(+1( .26/.&.0,.+2/.&0*(6.)0.2./@)*.6 00(+5%+00.%,'./,+= ,)0/())",0A%).6(+2./0*( 0%0(.9(/+&(+00.6/.9,5()1:* 6/.9,),.+4?A%?.2,))1%+:(.2(>(:10,9(,+)0/1:0,.+)",)A*.''? &,)7:.+:(,9(5  *(.+84'( 16/(&(.1/0,+  %+0%& *%/&% 9 %+0%& *%/&% 9 %+0%& *%/&% 9 %+0%& *%/&% 9 0%0(.2%3%)0*%+%+5.0*(/)"DE#  0%0(.2%3%)0*%+%+5.0*(/)"DE#  0%0(.2%3%)0*%+%+5.0*(/)"DE#  0%0(.2%3%)0*%+%+5.0*(/)"DE#  DE DE DE DE *%5*('50*%00,''

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

+)5%0(5 DDF%+5B DDE%+5.+0*(4%),).2 A*,:*"0*(6/.9,),.+%'6/.&.0,.+.20*(6(0,0,.+(/0.0*(6.)0.

%,'./,+=,)0/())*%54((+5,/(:0(59,5(./5(/5%0(5 D"

:%++.0:.&(0.0*(%,5.20*(6(0,0,.+(/ *()(,+)0/1:0,.+)A(/( ,+:.+),)0(+0%+5:.+0/%/?0.0*(D#1'()%+5).1=*00.&%@(% 6/.9,),.+2./6/.&.0,.+2/.&%&.+=)0./@)*.6 00(+5%+0)%) .66.)(50.0*(1'(6.),0,.+6/.9,5,+=5,/(:0%66.,+0&(+00.4( 0*(.+'?&(0*.5.2/(:/1,0&(+00.0*(6.)0.2%,'./,+=,)0/())  +0*(',=*0.20*(2%:01%'6.),0,.+21/+,)*(5.+4(*%'2 .20*( 0%0("(9(+0*(6'(%.25,):/,&,+%0,.+/%,)(5.+4(*%'2.2 0*(6(0,0,.+(/:%++.0)1)0%,+ 10.20*(:,0(5.22,:,%')A*.A(/( %''(=(50.*%9(4((+6/.&.0(50.0*(6.)0.2%,'./,+=,)0/())" 0%0(*%):.+:(5(5.+'?%)/(=%/5).+( &0 $%+0% (9,%+5A*.

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

   

  

   

  

   

  

   



 "#

 "#

 "#

 "#      

 

 

 

   

.0(!

.0(!

.0(!

.0(!

*(0*(/)6(%@,+=-/(%).+(5!

()- .

*(0*(/(6./0%4'(!

()- .