Jatinder Singh Bhangu v. Union Of India And Others
!"# $ %#&#%'#
) )
!"# $ *%( +#
)
$,
#% -, !.
.
!
/#$,$,( #%
0#%& &
,(
(1
,
($.#%&
/#&*(
# $&
2($, - %##
/#$,$,( #%
0#%& &
,(
(1
,
($.#%&
/#&*(
# $&
34 56 3) - -6 7 -
56 3) - 3 -6
!
"
# $ "%#& '( $) *+,-+"./.-
0 $ "%#& '( $) *+,1*"./.- 222
3 -67 ) *
## 3 *+,-+ ./.- 4 *+,1* ./.- "
## 5
" "
3"# $) *+,-+ ./.- .
&
..67..," $ "% "3 "
!"
# $#
%
& & $ !" ' $
( )
%
&
*" +
% (
#
%
&, +
- )( $ !"$
# %
.
)
(
#
- )
, /
& $ !" # $# # ,
8
)
# /
/ 0 1( 2 #
& " "
" 3 "
9 " %# & ' 9 : : "
# 3
:" # ././ ./.*"%#& ' .1 /1 ././ ( #
" ;
" : .< /8 ./.-
*-<"%#& '=">*16*?@"# 8 %# & ' A"" 3 3 # # "# " '
& "" ? # "# " "# $## " %# & '
& 3 " "#31- "# " : "
# .* /6 ./.- "# "" " " 5 # 3 "
# - & .< /8 ./.-
*-< # .* /6 ./.- " # 3 *-- "*16* +
"=@ # .< /8 ./.- *-< "
" .1 /8 ./.. 3 *+*"*16*3 " 5 # ( " &
: $ >9
;
<
',
%
#
0&)
+("# =
11,+#% > 8?
="
: >#<
!
?@ ( " # : $ >
! " # $ % &!? B "
: $ >#' ( )
!*"$
+, -.
!/ *-<"*16* B A""=" >BA?@
" """
# *+* 3 *-- "*16* # 0
$ " #
: $ &
: $ *-< A"" 3 "" ## # ./ /.
./.8 $ "(& '=">$ (&?@ & B A"" # " *1 /* ./.- ( "%#& '= #@ *-< $ : $ >
0121)
$! *3"
$*, .!/ "# " : $ & C =$@ ( ./-*7./.- 9 #"&
: $ "
#$ 3
, )
#" "
3 < & # "# " 3 # BA
*-< & "
"# $## " %# & '
& "
# # 3 #
3 *-- ""
# *--
*+*;
"
" #5 A"" ( " &
: $ 4 5 #1 # (.6! *-< B A"" & ' " # 3 4 ( # '
#
5
& ((
&
( # (
( ' (
/
54 5 #
"
& &
/
# (
( ' (
/ )
6(
.
:
$ 7 ( ) 8
9( % 2 (
2
( ( ( (#
+
/ 0 9( % 2 ) # (
"
) / 8 # 02 /((
) :
)
(
# 0 1( % 2 / :
8
)
"" $. )
/# ) #
(( # ";
& / -
(# - 8 ) ( +
/
/
(
# ";
) +
/ /
%
(#/ (
)
) # 0 1( % 2
(/ $ + ((
/
# ";
( / ( 4
(( (/ )
(# <-
-
/ (( - /
- ( # "
;
= & (( -
(#4 -
- ( (
((# / - ( (( ((# D */ "$ : $ %,$(
'#%&# & >)?
6$ >- *% ? ""## # ./ /.
./.8 $ (& # *-< BA % $ : $ 3 """## # E # # & # *8 /1 ./.8 $ : $ 3 F 4 2 >0 ( )
6# /
((
& (/ $/ %
&
" / ?
( #
?"
# ' (
# (+
2 -
.
" / ?
$ @;/( )
(( 8 #
#
(
)
(#
%
&
' ( ( ( )
+ #/ $ + $=
.$<=< $"4!A # 26;4 ((#
( - > ( )
B C (( + 2 )
' 4
B C + 2
B 4
#
6
8 B C
( %
6
(#
+ 2
( D 4
B C
'
(
((
6
%
/
6
)
&
/ # B C(( '
&
5
)
(
6 / 7!C .
$
(# D **
# # " " ( " # : $ #= %# #+.
(<(!2 6$ )>- *% ?3 # /8 /+ ./.-
*-< " "5 ./.* B A"" % # #
: $ *8 /1 ./.8 $ : $ 3 "" ## # $ (& & ' " # # : $ 3 3 ((
(/
((
> $ 7
= )( ( # B C
%
.
E $ 7
/ /
?@ ) %
( ( (# F 1 ) %
6
%
6
%
&
/
# + C % /
)
(( > %
.
(
(
%
/
%
= ((
%
&
4
/ % # 26;4/
)
%
.
( ( (#
/ /
%
&
/
%
=
( (
%
&
4 % (#( (
%
&
(#/ (# + C
%
&
B C 4 )
# ( ( $
%
)
/
/ %
((# )
%
&
/
- %
&
/
(# ( $ ( ( ( $ ( / (
%
&
/ # 26;4/ % # 26;4/
(
0
!( (# ( ( 4 )
# (#8 ( $
( (#8 % ( $
% ( ( / (# ( $
% 7
( $
% ( # ) %
6
/ %
)
/
/
%
=
4
/ 1
/
% (#
( $ # ( #
%
6
4
/
/ % %
% 4 5 ) %
6
5 %
(# 8 (
(
4
/
8 / )
%
6
( ( (
(# ) % +
/ 5 ) %
6
5 ) 4 % )
%
&
/ (( ((
/
8 #
( # 6
%
&
4
/5 ) %
6
5
( ( (#
4 5 ) %
6
5 ( ) %
6
/ 8
(4 B 2 (2 B
%
6
( ( (# % +
) "
= &
%
6
(( ( ( % $= 7 #
# (/
# - - )( (
8 - - ( '
# #
# )
/ '
((
( ( #
((
#(4
/
4 # 8
((
(/ ( '
4
/ -
) '
)(#
$& 7
C
@ + # $/ C
@ (#
)(
@ AG% 26;4 C
@
( %
?
) #
@
/ )
# C
@ + # $ (#
# )
(( % ?@ HH $? 7
0 1( 2( 02 4 C) !) A %/ 0 1( 2( 02
% ?@ %
4
/ '
(
'
C
%
&
4 0 1( 2( 02
@ + # $ + $=
.$<=< $4!A
( 4
/ (
(
C
@ ' # B C '
%
&
+ 1( 4 ( 02
4 5 #1 #1
0 5 ( )
)
%
.
% ?@
# B C )( (7 (
)
8
*.
& # " " "
: $ #' ( =
@ &$ ' # 3 "#&
# : $ *16* "
# '
# ' % A""
3# ' " # # 3 & 3 " "3
*-, *-< *-< # "
# *-- " " # *+* #" # # "
& "" # 3 "
/* /- ./.* &9 " "
# # "
3 %# & ' ' " & "
9 *+* *-<"
"3 # # 5 " *-< *+*"*16* 3 B* ,.
6
8 /
=/ '
)
& / C
(( )
/(
#
/ - /
(
& / - /#
/
#
( ) #
) # /
(# , )
((/ # /(#
(# -
$?> ! )
(( (
C
(
) # C
)(
#
> ! ) )((( - C
/ )(
#/ (
&
* ( I+
& /
C
( /I #
) #
8 #
( # 6 , # '
) #
)
, #
)
?
?
, ) #
)(( C
$. ,
) #
-
-
4 ( 2 * ( I+
/ /I
$
8
/
# -
$ / #
(/ /
, ) #
$$ / "
/ #
(/ /
, C
/ )(
! (2
2
/ #
#/ (( / '
(( # )(( / J -
$
$
#
#
(/ /
, ) C
/ )(
! (2
2
/ #
8
/ J -
$
$
# #
(/ / / #
/ ( /
/ C
((
)
(
K L
8
/
# -
) #
#/(( /'
(( #
)((
8
J -
#
:
* ( $I+
/
#
#
.
)
+#<#&&
&&#&&"# $
(1
, +("#
#&+ *, !
&&#&&"# $)
4 2 ( M # 8 / #
C
( MJ /
/ "
=
&
-
"
&
.
/
#/
#
(##I
(
" #
#
((#
( ,
(
( (
( , " / / "
# ' 4 2 ( M #/
)
"
/# C
(MJ /
#
)
(( (# (((#
/ #
> ! )
(( $ #
@ /
$ *) # "
"
((/
# / (
0
!( D *8 & $ # ' " 3 "
*+*"*16*"
*-66=G@ .1 /8 ./.. # # " # & #
3 #"%#G # #./..3 3 3
#"
.
" / ?
$
?
/ 2 ( M # 8
(( % / (#>" (
4 % # (( "
* % / ((
( C
(MJ 7
% / (
- / NN 3 O
" / ?
$
?
, 3 ((
O (
((
/ # (
(
(/ ( ( ((
( / ) J
7
/
/ (( )
) (# 6 ( $ +
% /NN /
=
/
&
/ (( ((
/
8 #
( # 6
&
/
/ )
6
8
(
(
D *- & "
## *-< A"" % " ""## # ./ /.
./.8 *1 /* ./.- ( "%#& '= #@ *+ 5# " *+*;
# ""
# "#
"3
*-< 3 *-< $
8=@"" .1 /8 ./.. *+* #3 *-< G3 " 3 # ##"#
"
"3
& 9 " " "
# 3
" "3
*-< B A"" & "" ## # #
% '# '9
&
$ &# " *-- *+* 3 " .1 /8 ./.. ;
& #
" ""## #
% 7 # *6 % 3
" " 3 "
3' # &
: $ & 3
3 *, & B A""
*-< ;
3
3 >-6 ?
>3 -6?
-
)
# 9
)
7 H ) H