Makhan Singh v. The Financial Commissioner (Appeals), Punjab Chandigarh And Others



   




  !




   

"#$ '$()*)%+

, , 

"-."+ /)+0.

,,,,,, $#)#)%+$1 2$1*3*

66$"4*7 3+8"9 %#.$1* ,,,,,, $*6%+'$+#*
   :; ,

/
  /  1$*$+# 1, /31)+'$1 /."15"7

'<%("#$

6$#)#)%+$1, 1, "<+$$# /)+0.7 /$+)%1

 3+8"9,

, ,  / 7

,

, $#)#)%+$1

"-."+ )+*#"+# ()<)4 =1)# 6$#)#)%+

1#)(4$* >
%+*#)#3#)%+ +')"7 *$$-)+0 =1)# +"#31$

($1#)%1"1) *$##)+0 "*)'$ , , 

7 $63#@
%55)**)%+$1(35
%44$(#%17 36+"0"1

*.%1# :
%44$(#%1:7 "66%)+#)+0

<)44"0$ A%#9"4"7 $.*)4 )*#1)(# 36+"0"1,

,

&31#.$1 61"@$1 *$##)+0 "*)'$ ,, 

7

66$"4*7 3+8"9

*.%1# :

%55)**)%+$1:7

36+"0"1 )<)*)%+7 36+"0"1

*.%1# : )<)*)%+"4



%55)**)%+$1: *$# "*)'$ '$()*)%+,

, 1)$&4@7 %+ '$5)*$ /.1) A."8"+ /)+0.7 61$<)%3* <)44"0$ A%#9"4"7 $.*)4 36+"0"17 )*#1)(# 36+"0"17 61%($$')+0* )+)#)"#$'

&)44)+0 <"("+(@,

631*3"+($ 61%(4"5"#)%+ <)44"0$ &)44)+0 <"("+(@ ;"59"1'"17  6$1*%+* "664)$'

"&%1$*")'

6%*#,

")9 $.*)4'"17 36+"0"17 1$(%55$+'$'

+"5$ 61$*$+#

"-."+ "66%)+#5$+# "&%1$*")'

<"("+(@7 .%=$<$17 /39 "0)*#1"#$7 36+"0"17 1$(%55$+'$'

+"5$

"66%)+#5$+# *")'

<"("+(@ &)4$ *$+#
%44$(#%1,

,
%44$(#%17 , , 

7 "&#$1 (%+*)'$1)+0 5$1)#* ("+')'"#$*7 "66%)+#$'

<)44"0$ A%#9"4",

, # #1"+*6)1$* "&%1$*")'

%44$(#%1:* , , 

 (."44$+0$'

61$*$+# &)4)+0 "+ "66$"4



  

/)5)4"14@7 %#.$1 ("+')'"#$*7 +"5$4@7 "19."8"+ /)+0.

A34=)+'$1 /)+0.

#.$)1 1$*6$(#)<$ "66$"4*

"&%1$*")'

"66$"4* ("5$ '$()'$'

=)#.

')1$(#)%+ 1$.$"1 "44 6"1#)$* '$()'$ "&1$*., ,

$$4)+0 "001)$<$'

"0")+*# "&%1$*")'



.$1$)+ *$6"1"#$ "66$"4*



 7 

   

 

=.)(.

("5$ '$()'$'7 ,, 

7 '$()*)%+,

,

"&%1$5$+#)%+$'

()1(35*#"+($*7 )+*#"+# ()<)4 =1)# 6$#)#)%+ #.)*
%31#7 1$4)$& *7 +%#)($'

"9%<$,

, ;$"1+$'

(%3+*$4 *395)#*

$11$'

4"= &"(#* 1$5"+')+0 '$()*)%+,

# )* *395)##$'

)* 5%1$ 5$1)#%1)%3* #."+

.)* +"5$ 1$(%55$+'$'

")9 $.*)4'"17 36+"0"1,

# )* &31#.$1 *395)##$'

%=+* 5%1$ 4"+'

<)44"0$ (4$"+ "+#$($'$+#*, # )* +$?# *395)##$'

)* "+ %4'

6$1*%+ "1%3+'

> @$"1* "0$ 9$)+0 @%3+0$1 "0$ #."+

*.%34'

"66%)+#$'

<)44"0$ A%#9"4",

)#.

"&%1$5$+#)%+$'

*395)**)%+*7 61"@$1 *$##)+0 "*)'$

,, 

 1$*#%1)+0

,  ."<$ .$"1'

(%3+*$4 ."<$ 6$13*$'

6"6$19%%- =)#.

.)* "94$ "**)*#"+($,

>, 61$*$+# ("*$7 ."'

"66%)+#$'

<)44"0$ A%#9"4"

%9*$1<)+0

 



       

      

      



                            



                      

 

      !

        "

   "

     #      $ %  

        

&    '"



  



&    # &       (  

    "

     # &       )

  

  

      #   &       * 

 

    





  #   * 



                 #   $       '

 + ,#-

  

 " 

      

      '

     

* 



      

  

  ,  

        ,   ) .



     "

 /

)  #$#0#, #  

 '

 + ,#3

  

     #4 >, "&%1$*")'

(."44$+0$'

"-."+ =$44 #=% %#.$1 ("+')'"#$*7 +"5$4@7 "19."8"+ /)+0.

A34=)+'$1 /)+0.7 "44 "66$"4* '$()'$'7

%9*$1<)+0
5# - "    

        # -   6-+ 



        













 

 



 "  



"

     &

 

 



    #   -  

       

      

               &

 #$  -   '

 &

 

   

  

      #



  



             



#4 >, "&%1$*")'

%55)**)%+$1:*

 &31#.$1 (."44$+0$'

="@ "66$"4*7 =.)(.

'$()'$'

,, 

7

'$()*)%+ %9*$1<)+0
5# - " 

  

    "               #     &  



+  '

+   

     '

 &

  +   



  

  

  

"

 

  6-+ #7289212 8:;< -!&     

#   0      

             



    6-+    

  

 &  (-&    

 "

 :1#25#921<                 

 #- "

 

 &  

       

   = 

"



         

 

#$                         &  

 + , +    

#4 >,

6$13*"4

=%34'

*.%=

>

."'

("*$* '$()*)%+ %+4@ %+ (%+#$+#)%+* 1")*$'

"66$44"+#* .)5

."<)+0 (1)5)+"4 ("*$* 1$0)*#$1$'

"0")+*# .)5 #.$1$ "+ "44$0"#)%+ 1$0"1'* .)* 4%= B3"4)&)("#)%+,

>,

66"1$+#4@7

=.)4$ 1$5"+')+0 ("*$ %9*$1<$'

&"1 "44$0"#)%+ (1)5)+"4 ("*$* "0")+*#

"1$ (%+($1+$'7 ("+($44"#)%+ 1$6%1# ."'

*395)##$'

#.$1$)+7 =.)(.

'34@ "(($6#$'

(%+($1+$'

(%31# %+ , , 7 "((%1')+04@7 &"(#* 1$B3)1$'

1$$<"43"#$'

1$(%+*)'$1$'

,
%+*)'$1)+0 "&%1$5$+#)%+$'

&"(#* ()1(35*#"+($*7  "5 (%+*)'$1$'

<)$= 1$<$+3$ "3#.%1)#)$* 9$4%= "66%)+#5$+# "1$ 1$B3)1$'

"664@ #.$)1 83')()"4 5)+'

"##$+')+0 &"(#* ()1(35*#"+($* =$44 1$4$<"+# 5$1)#* '$5$1)#* ("+')'"#$* #.$1$"&#$17 (.%%*$ 5%*# *3)#"94$ ("+')'"#$ "66%)+#5$+# 6%*# ;"59"1'"1,

C,

((%1')+04@7 '$()*)%+ %+4@ 4%%- )+#% "44$0"#)%+ (1)5)+"4 ("*$ 9$)+0 6$+')+0 "0")+*# (.%*$+ ("+')'"#$ ),$,

/)+0., ("*$7 "+@ ("+')'"#$ ."'

"44$0$'

"+@ (1)5)+"4 ("*$ )* 6$+')+0 "0")+*# "+%#.$1 ("+')'"#$7 #.$+ *.%34'

."<$ ("44$'

36%+ *3(.

("+')'"#$* *39*#"+#)"#$ #.$)1 1$*6$(#)<$ (4")5* "+'%1 ("44$'

1$6%1# 1$0"1'



&1%5 (%+($1+$'

B3"1#$1*7 .%=$<$17 )# "66$"1* +% *3(.

$?$1()*$ ("11)$'

%3#,

, $ )# 5"@7

%+4@ 1$(%+*)'$1)+0 &"(#* ("*$ =$44 5$1)#* ("+')'"#$* 61%6$1 5"++$17 "66$"4*7 *$6"1"#$ ("+')'"#$*7 )+(43')+0 .$1$)+,

631*3"+($

=%34'

=$44 =)#.)+ )#* 1)0.# 64$"'

*39*#"+#)"#$ .)* (4")5*

 , "##$+')+0 ()1(35*#"+($*7 *)+($ %+4@ 1$5)##$'

'$()*)%+7 +% )+#$1&$1$+($ )* 1$B3)1$'

#.)*
%31# $?$1()*$ )#* =1)# 831)*')(#)%+7 1$*34#"+#4@7 )+*#"+# ()<)4 =1)# 6$#)#)%+ &")4* *"5$ )* "((%1')+04@ ')*5)**$',

, $+')+0 "664)("#)%+

*7 )& "+@7 *."44 *#"+'

(4%*$',

 / 

 

, , 

*8-* .$#.$1 *6$"-)+01$"*%+$'

!$*



% .$#.$1 1$6%1#"94$ !$* 

%