Mangal Singh v. Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal Amritsar & ORS
! "# $%&%'
! "# $%&%'
! "# $%&%'
! "# $%&%' (
(
(
(
)"*+, "*-
.
%!&!
% "*
%"
%!
)# )# )# )# 01),, , 01),, , 01),, , 01),, , % # % # % # % # )%,-%2( 3
% 44444 44444 44444 44444 , ( , ( , ( , (
%-!
- !/
" -++ "* "*
/% 5%
6 6(5- $'(!2
! + 2
$'- 25 " *%"
% 23
" //+ " &"
% ,
7789 % + !/&
! :;<80 0 %!-% 9 -
%( "$%
(5! - - 5%=
-
>)"* %2 $%&%'
&/ 6 , ! /
% 5 ++ *++'
%2 "
5 '5' ! //+ "( ++5 "*%% %!?
!/%
2/&*"
%
6 65
+ 2
#> % &+%! ! &"/ !+%'?5* ! %2
6 %
@A6?>/ 2"
@(76; "&! % '
% ::
( ::: "
& 6 %
B/ %""&2&?!
'2 "&! ( 6 % "
-+
2"
-! %
@A6?> / % 2"
- !
2"* !
!""
7-3
$
%" "*-&* /%
! &% "* $3 !
'
%!"
-3
"/' "*$"&! %
B/ %'
% ++ ! 2/+'
!?5%=2 &% "*
$3 !
'
%! @ A(6<?>
%"
3 -5* ! '
%! ::A> :::
&/ 6 %
6 '!/ '
%C7 '!5* ! %
@:; </ !
/ '&"
% ! :;< @7(;: ?> !&++ 3 -5* ! ::A> :::"
&/ 6 %
< '! A '!
%&"D$1 3 * ! %
@:; < / !
@ ( :6?>
A '!! =+ 3 -5* ! '
% ::A>::
%
@:; </! @ ( :6?> 3 9
" -2 2/ "! "
"&&!
%2 $
6 2% -"
A '
%! &"
% !
" 6> % + !/&
! :;< %
@(A6?>/ %2"
!+%'"
+'%
@:6?> @7:(: ?> 3 9 -%
2"
-! !+%' " + & "
-%
2"
-!&"
% !
" 6> % + !/&
:;< %
@A6?>/ %2"
- @A;<6?> # @<
3 9 2/&"
"
%
6B/ %""&2
% @< ( > 6 /! ! !
$3 %2
::A ++
+ "* /% //+ A : @;( ( ?> "
" 2/&"
"
!
$3
!2 %
;B/ %""&2$' - !&% ++
+ ! " /'2 ++
!?2&"
%2
! E9 2* 2/ "! " % &! "* 2 +
% "
*"'( -%!!2 ( -&2 + "(
2 "? %!
+'
"* - + -
!
E/+ "
$3 ! "
::A ++
+ "*
/% //+ ""
!!
$3 F @"
1 / %'
% ::A :!'
%! @ ( ( ?> "
!!
!!
"0$+ &%
%
@ 3 -&!"
! +' ++ "+/'2
+# @
<
&"!
+
%-!!&$2
% $&"+- -
%5!
&"/ 5* ! %2 6 (
3 5* !"
!&++ 3 5* !($& 5!"
%
$"&!( ! = + 3 5*
" -2 2/ "! " 1
&"!
+-! !&$2
/
% 5! + $+ $ /
2&"
"G& "+"*5 - 2/&"
"
%
;B(5- !( % $&"+- "+'*%"
"
% %
:B/ %""&2
/% (%
!5 /%
E /%
! ""
- // %
" % $ -+
!/
%- - 2!
// %
!!>$E ! -
- !
3 ! "*% + "
"
E/%
%( +
% $&"+ - /
% 5!
&"/
5* ! %2 6 2&"
"* @(76; 6/ !(
3 5* !2&"
"* @7(;: ?> !&++ 3 5* !2&"
"* @ ( :6?> , %!
"&! ! "
%"
% $&"+% *- +'
!
&+ " $ *%"
/
% ! "
" - ! % *% 5! +
$'
/
%
% - "+' E2 "
- 2!
! !!"
- "
"' &2 %'
- 5!
$ / $"&! 3"
/ % , %!
" -2 2/ "! 2* ! + 2
%&"
%,
"6
;
! "
%"
( !2 -! $
" % *- +'
!++5
% $&"+
!!
/% /!
+5 /%
"*!&"
%,
"7789 %
" " " /%
"*! - +
% $&"+ " 2/&
%2! 2"
'G&"
E !
"* % *- " + & ! $ "* /% 3 &!+' *
% %5 !
&+'/%3
%
-! $
" - $' ,&/% &% " %+ %+ %+ %+
"+"
% %"!/% %/% " 1
3 %!&! -
"+"
% %"!/% %/% " 1
3 %!&! -
"+"
% %"!/% %/% " 1
3 %!&! -
"+"
% %"!/% %/% " 1
3 %!&! -
%=2 ""
" %=2 ""
" %=2 ""
" %=2 ""
" %( :<;8;9, (!&"
%#>
! "5 5 ++>!
/%
"*
%!
"778989 !/%
"*(* %++'( " " "/%
"*5-
1$&%&% + &+
! 2&"
2"
'
5%=2" %2- ! 2/+'
%(%
5%=2" !
"' $
5- - !
/$+ "* 2/&
%2! 2"
'(
1$&%&% /%
! 2/&
"
%2! 2"
' - ! + &+ " % 2/& ++5!&/"" E !
"*% *-
2"
'%$
( "3 5 !$ "*/% 3 &!+'
*
( %( %5 !
( &+' /%3
% -
) " "*"* "
%(!
+1
3 -
) " "*"* "
%(!
+1
3 -
) " "*"* "
%(!
+1
3 -
) " "*"* "
%(!
+1
3 2 !-5% 2 !-5% 2 !-5% 2 !-5%(8 A98 9, ; 5!%
%
/%
"*! &"
% !
" 778989 %
"+*&! " /%
"*! "
1$&%&% ++
&/" 2/&
%2!
2"
'
+ 2
$'5%=2 " ! "!& - !
! " !
" " "* &%
5!
+!%
%
% *-
5- -
! !&*- $ 2/&
2&!
" E !
"* !'(+% '
&/"% /%3
%"
2&!
% !
&%!
" % + " + "!- / $
" "
% +5%=2""
- ! 2/+'
%
" !& ( + 2 % %
2
$'
/+ "
* "!
"3+3 "3 *
%2 " " 8 9
/+ "
0!% *- %
I8 9 %% "* + $ + '
( " +& "*(5-
!( ++( + $+ % " I "
8 9
0! + $ + '( "' -
5%= "*& !& -+ $ + '5 -3 5 * 3
!* %++'% *%
! "%"
" /%
"*
%2 " " 8 9
%%
$3 ! !'(
0!+ $ + '2'!2
!$
3
%2 " " " "/%
"*!&
!" -
%2 " "!&"
!8 9"
8 9- '% "%2++'% *%
!
"! !& "
" " /%
"*, "
/%
"*&"
%!
"77 8989 ! " " " "/%
"*
!-&+ ++5 " "3 * " "
%2 " "!8 9"
8 9$3 !("%2++'( &
!! /
! %& "/%
"*
% !
" 778989( ! " " /%
"*( 2'$ "
!!%'
%2 "
' %!"$'5-2%* "!
5-2
+ 2 !2
! -++ "* "
! % & ! 2 +' 0
+0 ++
%2 " "! 8 9 "
8 9 0
+0 "
" /%
"* 5&+ $ / %! "( $ &!
" /%
"*! " 5- -
+ $ + ' ! 5%=
& % D&!
"!
G& +&/"
%2 " "!8 9"
8 9 /% +!
!
* "/% !!+ "*
"+%
-
% (5- " + 2 !2
$
% 1$&%&% &"
%!
"778989
&% 2&!
+ %+'&"
%!
+ 2 "!
%5- - ! "
"" %%*
"!' " % +% $&"+5- - +"
!
2= "! "
"
%2 " "!8 9"
8 9%
%%
$3 ( % /%
2/&
$
$'
&$$ "* %2 % ! 0
+0 ! 2 "
$&! "
!! 2/& " " !& - !
%2 " "!8 9"
8 9% " 0
+0
2/& " - 2/& " !
"!
G& + &/"
!&$!
%'
%2 " "!8 9"
8 9! +!
!
*
/% !!5- - 22
-%
% +% $&"+
5!(
% (- ",
,
,
,
"= ="
%"
/&% 3 1 J-"
+5+ "= ="
%"
/&% 3 1 J-"
+5+ "= ="
%"
/&% 3 1 J-"
+5+ "= ="
%"
/&% 3 1 J-"
+5+ A91$16A:8,9( 5%=2" ""
/& %5% + 2 " " //+ " &"
"778989 "% !/
2
%5- - !
" $!
"" E !
"*% *- 5- - "$
//%/%
+' !&$D
>2
% " "
% +
!/&
5- -% G& % !%
&"
%!
K !/
3
% "
- !
""
E&% > !
+!% !
% + !/&
$'!
%3 "*
2"
"
&% "* &%!
%*&2 !(+
&"!
+ %
%5!&"$+
++! 5-
< 2
//%/%
3 %"2 % "
!/&
% !
%-
%" , % !
+ 2
$' /
= "* 2/&"
"
! "
%"
!2 5!+! % *- +'" *%"
% $&"+ -
% $&"+- *%"
"
%
:B/ %""&2 2&"
- %
"
++5
% $&"+ !% !"$+ ++! %" "
( " % &2!
!
/% ("*%&"
% "
- !&% 5- +
% ! "*D&% !
"&"
%% "!
( !2
& !2 !!
8, 9 8, 9 8, 9 8, 9 $%&%' (
$%&%' (
$%&%' (
$%&%' (
2-3 %