Vinod Kumar Sharma v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!
"# !$%&%"'(
)%'"* +,- .
/0 .-
*!$! &!*
0.",10 23&
! % %"'!.
)!.&,& / !
"# ,'4 5 '* " 0!.& !&6"'*!' & 7( 32 7 / / 7
/
/
/ 7
/
/ 2
!
# " $% &' (&&' ! # ) * + %, &- &$ (&&$
.
!
/ ) * 0
!
%- &' (&%$
# "!
)
"
%( &' (&%1 3 4%(5 &- &$ (&&$
(6 &- (&&7
3 #
)
! 4 ! # !
.
8 # #
" $% &7 %,7-
! " 9 %& %% %,76
:
! ! )
. &% &- %,77
) . ! .# .
; $& &1 %,'1 < ! 4 " = .
&- &' %,,1 :
! = .
!
) . &- &' %,,7 :
! = .
$& %& (&&& ! 0 : 2;5 :
! ) * + %, &- &$ (&&$ -&, -%, -(& -67 -6'-7% %(&4>
0 %$ 2%5 25 25 %$ 2(5 0
%,'' ! "
> ( ) *
" ! ! ! !
!
"
) * ! &- &$ (&&$
&7 &1 (&&$ !
* - 2(5 2>5
* ! !
&- &$ (&&$
!
= (&&$
(6 &- (&&7 !
!
(6 &- (&&7 3 4$5
"
" ?
#
! 0 : 2;5 " $% &' (&&'
" ! "
) * + %, &- &$ (&&$ # ! ! ?
#
%- &' (&%$ 0
!
) * + %, &- &$ (&&$ / " !
) * ! "
"
"
" " ! ! ! .# .
0 ; ! #
) * + %, &- &$ (&&$
*
! ! !
!
" ! ! ! :
@ ! #
) * + %, &- &$ (&&$
! / "
" 0
!
%- &' (&%$
! / ! # ) * + %, &- &$ (&&$
!
" *
+ / ! ! /
" /
/
A
# ! ! / ) * + %, &- &$ (&&$ ! #
@
"
" *
!
" &( &, (&%- &1 %% (&%$ (& &% (&%-
# /
) * + %, &- &$ (&&$
! %( &' (&%1 ! ! 3 #
# #
&- &$ (&&$
(6 &- (&&7
! %( &' (&%1
" #
# "
?
#
! !
) * + %, &- &$ (&&$
" *
" # " 3 #
#
" 4 # ! /
#
#
#
! &% &% (&&6 ! * 4
4 B
!
"
#$
#% $ &'( ) *
" +,+", +,
!
" +,(
)
- (*
." %% ) "
! / "
'
)
" - "
""
" (
( (
0 ( 1
" ( .(
( -
"
"
"
%
0
#
2 (- "
( (
+,( ) .
$ - ) 3 4-
5 ( )
- 6
$ 7
3 "( " (
3"
"
- ) 34-
#
$
(( "(
#
$
%
%(
(
7% - ) 34-
8$8
%& 8$$# $ %
%
-
8&
(*- !
-"
/ & (
%
-"
-
! 4-
-
8$8
%&& 8 #
(
(9
- "
( $
&#$
:%
(
(( "( $
$ (
$
8& - (("
(" "
6
78
&7)8 $ $ 7
" ( 7) * 2 (
- "
-
(# 8& "
(
8&- ) " * (*
- (
+;, 28 % $ 3 "
(
" <&
9 (
-
3"
<& " ( " ( " "
(
" !'
3 =
!3> !8! ?*
"
7
%
8
-"
(
( (
(
; @
*
(
-
(" (
(-
<& +, 7
%8& ( ( ( 4)
- ) " * (*
- (
+;,) 3
$
& 7 $
% +,) -
( (
.
-
(
%
(("
= * (
(
(-
"
6 "
2(("
= (
+,%##
8&6 &"&
4 (
- (."" 4
) 3 -
)A&8%7 8 7& #8)A878 8%
%#$7 7
2(("
= (
- '
7
7 +,2
(B - A " (7$$7# 8&
- ) " * (*
-
(
+;, (("
$
: # 7
2(("
= (
-
% #C +!
!
!
3 #
!
"
# #
" " :
"
" %( &' (&%1 3 4%(5 3 #
"
#
# ! ! "
) * #
@
"
"
C
# #
@
" %( &' (&%1 3 4%(5 * 7 $ 2>5
*
*
4
#
< *
# 4 +,5 4-
-
& (
"
&
"
D
"("
+,
"
4-
(
(
&
(
" E +,
+, "
$
$ &.
4-
(
"
"
"
" "
(
(
(
(
(
"
(
" -
3 " 3
" (
"
+ ,5
"
& (
3(
4-
3 "
- ( &
+%, (
"
" -
< ) -
" (
(
"
4-
"
4-
; (
-
D
(
"
(
"(
" 4-
(
( "
" +
,("
"
+ , " (
&
+ ,
(
(
+7, "
(
&
+, + , 4-
3 "
- (&
+%, + , " +
,(
"
"
-
"
(
- "
4-
( 0
(
"
( " " "
"( "
+#,5
-D
( (
"
"
"
&
+, (
" "
(
"
4-
-
(
" "
(
"
&
+,
D
""
- (&
+ , &
+7, " +$, " (
&
+7,
(
"
"("
"
(
"(
< ) - ( 4-
"
(
" -
- ( D
4-
F
( "
-
" (
( (F +, 9
- 9"
(
"
( 4-
E +,
- ( D 9"
((- " (
4-
+%, (
"
&
+,&
+ , &
+7,
3 "
"
""
"
+ ,
-&
+ ,
&
+7,
"
"
$C
* ! !
! ! #
#
!
! # "
# " # "
!
# ! ! #
) * "
! 3 0
!
%- &' (&%$
* 7 $4> # #
A *
#
# !
"
+ !
" *
"
!
3 #
# "
# !
" "
#
< %( &' (&%1 3 4%(5
#
# * 7 $ 2>5
! 3 0
!
" !
" "
# %( &' (&%1 3 4%(5
!
!
%- %6 0 !
"
D # !
/
! " #
*
8C 0
!"
# $ 4 G 6" (A0
0
"
E -
(
-
( " "
0 (
( " "
(
- - " ) "&
0 )
" - - ("&
0
" " 6"
.
" "
(
((
(
((
"
-
(
3 ( *
6
"
() "
2
-46 +
%,!**
$
6 ) "
*
"
;
*
" ( "(" " 6"
.
9
"
( (
-"
6 ("
;
*
*
(3"
( "
"
(
( (
-"
6
"
(
"&
0 *
- .
"
( * ( !
D ; !" +
,
D (
-"
(
- " " ; -
(
D
"
- (
(( -
" "" " "
*
" D
( -
((-
(
-"
( "
-
( 5
( -
"
- 3
("(
" 5 -
" " ( 6"
. " -
"&
0 .
3 )D
"
"
- -
" * 0
"
( (
-"
-"
( .
(
& ( ".
3 )D
&
-
" 0
( - .
3 )D
"" ; -
"C < 0
%!&'(
) *+,- . *#( " " 4 B )
(
-
((
" 3(
" ( "
(
D
( *
( $
(
+.
9
)& , -
"
( "
*
(
"("
-
-
((
(
!"" -
"
"
2
- (
-
D
+.
9
)& , -- "" (" ( 3 "
! "
> ('-
0
( "" (
" -
5 *
(
-
(
&"
( - 3 " A
"
-
!"
"
64) ;
+.
9
)& ,C ) 0
%!/('' !,) , * 0 12 3 "0+,- "# 4 G A9(" (
"
(
= D( D .D> =
" B * -(
"
( ""
"
D (
" "
- - (.
"
#( * ( "
((" "
0
" "=
-
+= D( ,"
"
- " " !
0
" -
( ((
2 "
! "&
(
D 9
(
"-
-"
(
( "
D
"" ( " " (
"
(@
"@ .
"
#( * ( C < 0
(/ & !
+,- . *# $ 4 G(
"
(
-
( "
"
( "
-
"
((
"
(
"
"
"
(("
- - " "
! "
"
; ) "
! !
4-
D " D
- 1
"
0
D - "
( 1 " " (
((
(
"
7 H"D
((" -
((
-
D > D ! (; A-
(
- (.
"
( * (
"
" (" " *
-
(
""
"
( 0
-- (.
"
( * ( (
" " "
((
"
& " ;
"
C
)
!
"
!
# #
# " .
!
%- %6 0
9
8C 0 !
0
<
#
" *
"
# " "
# !
#
<
"
# # ?
* " #
# " !
" +
"
# "
" #
)
> 0
3! !,)
,
3"
!*
3 $ /#
* 3 " #
# " !
# " "
0 < "
"
4 - (
( ( 3 " 9
"(
(
- " -
) 3*-
-"
("
(
: " "
+, %( 3 6 ! @" +
, ! 4-
"" (" (
!
H
(
" "
+, "
4-
(
-
"(
0 !
" "
+-,
-
"-
( 4-
(
(
3 6 ! @" +
,
"
" ( (
-
"
"
"
"
" ( (
( (
(3 "
(
"
( ! "
"
%+,
- ( (
- " "
( "
"-
( "
( (" - -
(
!
* I
4" 0"
4 +,-
#56 7'856
"
<& J# ("
"
-
" J
J.
"
.( * (
< J!
)
*
)*,"
* 9&&
- (
- ( J 2 "
"
0 ( 3 " -.
"
- (
( " " .
"
. ( * (
(
D (
-
- "
-
( - " " " "
$
"- "
- " "
(
"
J J ( (
.
"
.2 ("" " " - (
(
" - (
. "
- (
" "
- (
-
;
"
-
-
((
J -
( "
-
" ( !
(
!
*
-
3 ; 3 ! @"
-
- D 4 ! @ " +
,
3
" '!4 @" +
, 6 ! @" +
,
; ! "
"
; -
"
-
3"
C 0
!
#
@
!
;
# (&&'
/ "
#
! "
" A " #
! ! !
" *
" )
> " #
" ! "
8 ! /
" (&%$ !
" # ! &' &% (&%6 %$ %& (&%1
#
@
" ! / 0
!
%- &' (&%$
" # ! !
+ (&%1 =# (&%6
#
# /
" (&%$
!
)
> 0
"9 !,)#''56 7(/
#
#
<
"
4 B! "
4-
"
(
( )
" !
(
(
.
(" " " "
( ""
9"
( (
"
.
* =) @" +
,( !
" (
( "
(
(( (
("
"
"
(
(
(
C *
" )
> 0 !
! #
!
" #
!
) * + %, &- &$ (&&$ ! %- &' (&&$ ! /
< !
" ! #
"
! 3
) 0 > 0
4 " - . *"
#56 7/ ! # !
#
<
"
"
4 B 3
( (
("
@
( ( (
" (
" " "
" ( + ( (
, " " "
- (
( ! " "
"( ! C <
"
!
,F &% %% (&%$ ! " #
!
@
! #
0/
#
" *
"
! #
< !
!
<
"
! "
"
"
@
#
9
"
#
"
# !
/ 7
/
/
: "G H
: H