← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21651/2015disposed of

M.K.Saxena v. Sarva Hy.Gramin Bank & ANR.

2019-06-27Mr. Justice Arun Monga15 pages

   !"# $"%&'&(&#)&&&

&( !&#

 (*+,  - ./0 ** 12 /34!5*'6& #7 8*  -

 /95: ** 12 /34!5*'6& #7 #&+;'9 #%"/

 &#"!& 

 

 !" # "

 $ 

 %## "

$ $    &&& &#"!&<%  $'     (( )))   

()  *  +(

 !"  # ",()  (

)  # - ./ 

01          )    ))     "#2# "  ./ 

#1  

      3)       (   )       4  5   3(  $+ . $+ 1



6

7  + )+  ) $+($ ((  %%  8(' ( 84) ,) ('  $$ ' 

   .*)1#!# )# 6 - ,  '   +(' '  ( 9    (   :; ' + <)8 $+,  ; :   =(

 )( )    )    

      )    :        (    -####:

(    '    '  '    (  ):

)  

) 0#')6%. 133($+.8 > ?()  1  4 )   # #  '  

        #%#%# 6./

-1))' '( (  



 



       

                

  

 !" #$"%  &'

  



   

           

 

 

 !" $ " (&) * # 



   

           

 

 

 !" +# ,, -   -)*

=

%  

 

  &              

,   ,

  

,, ,.

" 9))) 



( ' ' ,; 8 ' ); ; )))    ); ' ' ' 8' ( )   '  (

(    )  

); =($ 

    )   )     /

(

(+,'  )   *); '  )+ 

' ' ))  '' ))   ) ! 9 ));  )

))      

'      $+  (  '    =())  ' ) #%#%# 6./

-1 2 @+'    4 @( ' '+   .*)1' 

 ( )) 

    #%#%# 6  ./ 

61  9  )    '   )'

   



       

                

  

 !" #$"%  &'



>

   



       

                

  

 !" $ " (& #  



       

                

  

 !" +# ,, -   - %  

   &              

  ,        ,

       

,, ,.

0 9  ;        4@(      #%#!# -./

"1'  (

 ( (% # -./

21 ) ('  (

 ))  "#2# "./

%1' ( 

 %## " %  )



4 =4/

   4  4@(  )      '  )))  (       ); ( )  () # 9    =(   )) +(   + +(  9  =(' ) ()  + $ 

 5' )  ) '

 $+ +7A''      =( 

  $+'   +7A)  ))  $+ 

  9 ) ' =( +7A   ) 



  ));  '  '  9 5$ ;)  ( 9'      (  )) 5/ ))  $+,  (   

'5'   

() ()     9))  (   +  =(/  '   $ 

 ')   (

( 9  *,' )   =(  

 )(()  (( (  )) 6 9 )  

  )+7 ' (5) )) )     (    (+  (

      )    (  ' ' 

'  ( - ,) $+       ) ()  =('  () $+5 

'$+'  $ 

 (  '  ((( " ,  $ 

  7

'    ( ' ()B   8  

)     =(' 

)((

 $+, (        ))      +  (           );+()  +7A8

    

' ) 

(   )(()  +7A' ' (7 (C')')( '  D ' ((  )((

  !    ' '

$+5'   (' '))' ''+$+ '    

#%#%# 6) ) 

  '  )     $          '))      ()/)   ; ))) (5  ) ' (  ( (( (  ();  2 (   )         )   ,  ))          (    

  0  ) )   

7   

(  ( 33($+.8 >?()  4) . ) 1( 

,

( 8' ( +         )  (   ,              ( 

 3)   ( ))   )'   % 9    )(  7            ( 5' ( )'(( )  -#%# "./

-1,

    ))   (  3) ( #   '      )   )        ))     ( ((  ) )    ))           @   )              

) (46#)) $+ %2"9   ') (+ ) :) '   9 ( ) ) )  ( )  9      ./ 

-1  '   

)) )) 8 '+33($+  ' 'E $    #6# !./ !1'  (   )   (

    '        )  

?

    4 ;) '   ) 4@ 5F)4(, ')' (

 ##%# !./  !: 10 # !./ !:1 )   -#%# "  (7))/  ) ,       (' )'   ')))  )  /   6 8)( ) ) ) 

 )     ' ' 

             (  '    (       (   (      ))          ) ) )   / 0  12'34 5 6-7++)* 

"$$48 79 1:7; 3- <7 ++#)%*  

 !! $       )   )      )  (+

(

 )  (   )   ,'  +;  (  -

 

 '   ' () $+9 +          )  '  ))'     )   '   " 5               )

-

  ))  

' 

 ) ( )  (+  (

 ( ) ) 

7 );  ( )' (

7 + ' (+  (

 )   (9     )      )        /       7(  ) ) )  ! 8(  (   ) ) )  $ 

  =( ( 

'+')+)   )

'$+  (( )    

' ()          G  )         <) 8G)  ();  )  

 )) $ 

 )   (  .  -####:

1  )      )      9   ' +')) 



' ' ))   $ 

  9;   ()) )+ )) )  2 9  (

 ) )  ) ( )  );  ( )   ) ,(('  ?; 8

)' /)'

C &       &  

  &   

  )89=>* ,,  &

 ,        ,  

?

7 

 

  

@@>A-7;:-

 

     -

      - , 18  4 ;

&7      



 18  4 ,

  

7, ,  '&  

   ,   7 'B,       

         B    

       ><       , , 

              

    

,   &     B  

   & 

 < ,    

 

     ,    '    

  &   , 

    4 , 

 &

     '  

"  & ,  <     6 ,  ,

     ,   '?

    &   

& 

       7            ,

  '.

0 9    (      ?;  8    ( ))   ( (  ())')/

C1  &            &7   

, 7     7     

& &      

&   ,   ,      9C  5, 7   ,      

                & 

   

'    ,  <      ,      4)?*?

7

   '              B 7      

 

  7 

,

  ,     7 '

 & <,     &;

 <  , 

,,       1 

& C   7 ,< & 1& 

,   C   ,         

     

           

   ,   'B  ,

<D  &   (    ,

 ,   < 6        <                      

   7       '  

        

    &  

 < , & 'C    BC  ,  ;&    

   7 1   

&       4-  B7  '        &     ,

  <   <    <;   

  

 7 ,

  

  

  ,  

     ,  '   <    <       <  '   

     &     



      7    '  B   <    .

%       )     (  ))  ) ) ) )   4)=(3  +7A8

  ')'( ( '   ( )   (  

'   =(, )  =() )  

 )' *,:

 ()  6#

) ) $+  + (' (   )' )(    )    +)'(+ ( ' ( 6  *))   )=(3

+7A () (  

'   =(5 ) (  ) + ' F)(  ,('  )  (9  ) () 

' ') 

)  =(?

)) '



     =(      ))       

'  '   +')+) :  6   $+F )   =(  ()   (  7 (  '   

=

(+    $+F      =(,((+ ((  ( 66 E (

)(     (   7 (  '/ 9 $+  ( )  ( (

)    ())

  )    )           '    (7   (     (

)  (      +   () ()  )  )

)) () ()  )   )?()    ; ( (

()               () (  '      (  (

):()( )( ) H,>8 < 44+  3 >##0."14@ 2#' ) 

C#1

&     7&

 ,    7 

    7 ;

D , 

     ; 

     

    &

        1

  7    ;

D , 

    ;  (&5/47,  15+++  !$E     %8 

&  

 <  &

 , &    7 ,  ,    ,

                       C   :

/  



 &7

 ,  ,  

>

&

& 7 &

& 

  .

6-      )  4 ) ' (;$+)  )'

@

 >F

,/       

 ,7'   ,  

 

    ,  7        

     < 

 

 7  

       ,                  





7     ,   7  >

      



)*

  )*    ,,    , 

& G )*   ,

 H )&* 

& 

 

 

 



    7   ,  ,

  

  <      H )&* 

      ,   ,  B   



&   

 )* &    , &      )&*       )*     >   )*   #+7

       ,  , ,             ,  ,  



  B,   

, 

   &   , ,     ,  )* 

    ,  )*

,    

)&*  &  

 &              C      ,

H )&*     C       ,

. 6" =') 60  

  ) ;); )) 

( (  (/ )) 

')'(()  ) (9 ))) ) ;)  ( ))) '  '   ( 6! $   (  &#"!& %"(!

,  - I:

( 

 +:  A :  

)

A :