High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20700/2016dismissed

Mobasi Ram v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli17 pages

!"#"$% & '( #" ) * "$+ ,+#-# .

+/ $ 0+# *#1$ $

+#$ % '+,"2+ )."$304 5!

"$+ '+ $2-+ '"

64 6 5!

$+ 64 +/ 7"

'+.

-+ (0'

34##"#

$+ 6 +/ '+) +,"5233 +7 64 5!

4 '+.0"5 #0 +4 5!

++#1$ $ 8 90

+# " 1+#$! "# ("$3 +!+ 0+-30 5" !$ +$!"$3 #"$! 1+! "$3# +("$3!$ -!

"$5"+ 6-+ : ;;;;

+0 5"$3!0#$$ ## "6 01+!##

0-30!)16 7 /( !25" +

& & ==& $$-$! -$ +.!

0> $ !<-"#"

"$!

4 ?=@4 "$+0 "$52 0 7+"

A-+"# "!

"$ 0"# -+ B

+ !)"$3 "$

"30 "+)1$#

$ + $#1 +$!/"$ 0> $ !<-"#"

"$4 0 ("6"

$ #

6)$ !

&90+"$

++ ++ #C !

&D:7 @4(/ "6"$3 01+#$ "$"$ 0/

B 0+(/!6 ")"$3

"$ 6 $ <- 0"##0 +

66"$3"$ E0 #+ # &@FFGFF 9 &:4 9

:4 F&F 9 ?:4 F&F 9 @:

) #-+"$3 E

) +6 #"

0"$ 0+5$-#

,"66 3

$0 "40#"6 $ "# +"!

-+3 $40 #6 1# "$5"7 .!

"$@9: 0 !

&%(/ 1#"

"56/ !$ $ "$3

0 0 # (-"6 0-# 70"!0"#!$ "$- ("$0"#1####"$ 0!)1$#

!<-"+ 6 $ 7 #$"

0+1 " $+ 1#"

"$ 0 +$!-+

##-!04( 0!$ "$3$!"#1+5" -$ +.!

"$@9: & +#

"# "

01+-# 6 016 "$3#+5 6#

+)$ "$ $ (6$3"$3

0+ 01+#$ "$+7 !<-"+ 5" $ "!

"$#

@ == ? @ == "##- -$ + .!

"$ @

?=@ !

B 667 (/ +

& & ==& -$ + .!

?=@!

4 01-(6"!1-+1#" +- "6"H

"$ 6

++#" $ 64!))+!"

64"$# "$ $ 1$#1 !4+!+

"$ "$ -+3 $ # 1+ 0 16 $ 1+1 + -$ + 0 +/ +( 561)$ - 0+"

4 =

#($!$ $

5+ $ "$ <-# "$4 0-# 7 # (-"6 70+"$ 5$ 0 6!

+"!"

/ !$$!

"$7 #3 "I 70"!0"## "66"$0"#1####"$ $ 0!$ "$-#

(+#" "$3"$ 0# " 0-#$6/ -+ 0+($!$ $

"$#1"

"$ 1+! "$3# 7+ !)16 7 / ( !2"$ 0/ ==&(- $"

0+ 01####"$ $ 5+70"!0

0 0-# 0 6# ($ !$# +-!

4 "#

2$ $+ "# 0 !)1$#

" 0") $

)1 0 6# ($ ) 1+A!

0 !

# "#!+")"$

"$(/!$ $ "$3

0#-++-$ "$36 $ "$+ 6+ / ($ +6 # +) "$4 70+ # "$ 0"# !

# "

0 $"

0+($+6 # $+00 #($!)1$#

#766

0 # +-!

-+ $52"$3 0 1+5"#"$# .!

"$ @ 9: 0 !

&4 "

0 # ($ !$ $

0 63"#6

-+ 0 # $ 0 # "

& 1+5"#"$# (/ 1+5" "$3 )"$3 "!

"$ 70"!0 1+5" # + ) 1#"$34"$!

#4"

0+ 0!$ "$3$!/ #1+5" -$ +.!

"$@ 9: 0 !

& "# #

"# " 70+ # "$ 0"# !

# ( !$ "$3$!"# + -6 "66 $ #

"# " 0-#4 !

#"#) - "##- $! !6

+0"#6 $ #

$ #6 1# & #-11+ 0"# !6 ")4 0 +6"

$! 0 # ($ 16 ! $ A- 3)$ ## (/ 0.-1+)-+ "$!

# 6 #C

!" #! !$

"$ 0#")"6 +#"

$ 70"606 "$3

0 1 /)$ ) "$ #-+/ !

$$ ( 06 ( <-"5 6$ !)1$#

"$ 1 " 6 $ 7$+#F1+#$# "$ +# 4 0 $D(6 !-+ "+!

"$1+! "$3# 0 56 1# 0"6#

"$3-1 1#"

"5!

#0"#0-#7 #$ +6 # +) "$ #1"

"6"$3 0+<-"#"

(A!

"$#40

11+ !0 0"# -+ (/ "6"$3 @G? G 70"!0 7 "#1# 5" + +

? & G7"

0 "+!

"$# #-()"

+1+#$

6# 0+"

"# !" 0 # ) "$

!!+ $!7"

06 7470+

0+1+#$

"$7 ##-()"

70"!0 ) ( +A!

5" 0 ")1-3$ + +

(/ !$ $ "$3

0"#!6 ")0 #($+A!

$ 03+-$

$ "$ <-# "$ "# 16 $$ + +#" $ 0 # ) 7"66

561 16 # @) +6 "$!6- "$3 $ ) +7" + $% % &'

) * +

' G 07+"

"$!

)-1 +0 +"$3( + 0"#-+ $ &

70+(/ 0 $ "! ) "$ 7 # "##- -+"$3

@ 1$ $!/

"$ "$3

0.-1+)-+ "##"H

0!$ +5+#/+-1 #+3 + # 0"$ +1+

"$ .!

"$@9:

&4 00 +"$3"$ 01+#$ )

+7 ++

0 !"#"$ 0$# "$$!0 0.-1+)-+ 70"!0!

)

( !" "$ * +

-. 0 1$-6 ")

1 3+ 10 +) $# "$ $!0 A- 3)$ 6 /"$3 7$ 0 3-" "$3 1+"$!"16# "# +1+ -! 0+"$(67% /0 1

" "

2 2

2 &

2 2

% &

%%22' 3

&' 2

" &"2

2 #- 2 & ! %/(

"& %

& /( /( 4 2 5

! % 2

22'

2 & &*

' 2 &

! 2 4 527

" & %

8 ' 2

&2 % "

2 2 25 2

2 #-

& %

! *

& !

$5 2

#- &22

& 97 2 "

2 5 * 2 7 %

8 '2 22'

! &

:% :

2 2 2 5 2

2 #- ; * &

" 7'

7 2 4 & ' &'

" $% % 2 %

2 2

! .

! & 2

" 2

" &" < 2

2 #-

" &' % 25

= >% &

2 #-

" # 2

" 2 2 &

' 2 2 ' &2

! 2 2 5 %

4 2 &

&' &3

2 2' -

! % 2 5

' 2 2 5

22 2

%% 5

' 2 2

2 2

2 5 (

$ ##$!4 0 $# "$ $!0 0 1I -+ 0 !6 + 0 !6- # -( <- 0 7+ # J1 " K "$ .!

"$ @ 9:4 J 1#"

K!!-++"$3"$ 01+5"# .!

"$@9: $ + 07+ J+K-# "$( 7$ 0( 0!$ "$3$!"# .!

"$@9: !

& # J$+K + # J $ K .")"6 +6/4 0 I1+##"$ J10/#"!

1####"$K!!-++"$3"$ 0) "$#!

"$0 6#($!6 +"

" ) J + 7"$3 1 $!0$ ) KFJ

H$ )!0 K 0 # ($ !+/#

66"H

+#2"$36 1#"$34( 0!$ "$3$!"#7"660 5 (#

"# " + 1+"$!"16# #6 " 7$(/ 0.-1+)-+ +!+/#

66"H -$ +% :

$ 66 0# !

## 70+"$ "$ 1+!## 0 ($ "$"

(- + 0 #$ ($ $$-$! -$ +.!

?=@4$

!))$!)$ !

&" @4 0+"#$6 1# 1+! "$3#

0# )7"66!$ "$-4075+47"

0+" +

!)1$#

"$ 0 ( +)"$ -$ + 0 1+5"#"$#

0 !

& 66 0# !

## 70+"$ + -$ + .!

?=@0 #($ $$-$! 1+"+ !))$!)$ &4 01+5"#"$# & 7-6 0 5 $ ( +"$3 + 116"!

1+! "$3#7"66!$ "$-"$+#1!

0#!

##4 #"

?=@0 #$ ($+1 6 9(:

0 7+ C+D -# "$ ( 7$ ( 0 !$ "$3$!"# .!

"$@9: &"# (+ #/(+ /( 70"!0 ) $#

#2 6 1#"$3 1+! "$3# ( 0 !$ "$3$!"# )-# ( -6 "66 '

$"$3 0+(/4

01####"$0 ($

2$(-

!)1$#

"$ 7 # $ +!"5 4 0+ 7-6 ( $ 6 1# .")"6 +6/4 "

!)1$#

"$ 0 # ($ !!1 (- 1####"$ 0 # $ ($

2$4 0+ 7-6 ( $ 6 1#"$3 2 --!.!

8 " 9!:

#1!

!)1$#

!<-"+ "# !$!+$ 4 0.-1+)-+ #!

3+"!

66/(#+5

0I1+##"$1 " "$ 0) "$1 .!

"$@9: !

& # $ "$!6- 1#"

!)1$#

"$ "$ !-+ 0

"#+<-"+ (1+5 "#

0!)1$#

)-$ 7 $ + 70"!00 #($I16 "$ "$

$ +"$3 )-$ 7-6 )

)-$ "# ) "6 (6 0 6 $ 7$+

7-6 ( "#!0 +3 0(6"3

) 2 /)$ $ "$

5$ #-!0 1+#$ !

$$ ( 1$ 6"#

-6 "$ ) 2"$3 /)$ 0"6+ ++"$3 .!

"$& 9 :4& 9:4 &@ 0 !

?=@ $ !)1 +"$3 0) 7"

0 1 )

1+5"#"$#".!

$ ? &4

0 1I -+ 0 # !6 +"

0 $6/ !$#<-$! $$1 /)$ !)1$#

"$ "# ) 2 0 1 /)$ "$ +# # 1+ .!

"$ &@ 0 !

?=@ 5$ .-1+)-+ -+ 0+!6 +"

$! /)$ !)1$#

"$0 #($

+ F $ + -$ +.!

"$& 9 :4

!<-"+"$3 0+"

$$ (1$ 6"# +$$1 /)$

)-$ #+) "$-$1 " - + -# !!1 (/

$ 7$+ !6 +"

/ "

-+ 0+4 0.-1+) -+

-+ 0+(#+5

6 $ 7$+0 "6 0+ +$!

? 0"30+!)1$#

"$0!

$$ !6 ")

07 #$ "

)-$ 9 :

0"6+ "$3 01+5"# .!

"$@ & ( 1 .!

"$ @ 9: 0 !

&4 0 .-1+) -+ #!6 +"

"$!

#4 0

+1 /)$ #($ ) (- $ 1#"

4 6"

("6"

/ 1 / )-$ 6$3 7"

"$ +# #-(#"# $ "

$ 1#"

+) A+"

/ 06 "$3#

"5/ +#+)+4!)1$#

"$-$ + & (1 " $ 7$+# #$

$ "!

+ 6 "$ -$ + .!

"$ @ 0 !

?=@ 3 + "$3 0 1#"

#($!6 +"

" "$

A- 3)$

0 0"30+ !)1$#

6674 )$/ #0-6 $ 0 5 ($ 1#"

0 > !<-"#"

"$66!

++"$ #-+/+"$ 0-+ 7"

+#1!

) A+"

/ 6 $ 06 "$3#4) $"$3 0+(/"

7 1#"

"$ $/ 0+) #7"

0+#1!

) A+"

/ 06 "$3#4 0 0"30+ !)1$#

"$ 7"66 $ 6674 (- "$ +# -$ + .!

"$ &@ 0 !

?=@ 7-6 ( !$#<-$! 9:

#+3 + # 0)

2"$31####"$4 0.-1+)-+ !6 +"

+ 7"$3 "$<-# +1+ F))+ $ -) 7-6 )

10/#"!

61####"$0 #($

2$06 7 7"

0+3 + 5# "$3 6 $ 0 #$! "$($+"

$! 01####"$0 #($

2$-$ +.!

?=@4 $ 5# #"$ 0.

0+ $$ ( $/ "5# "$3+6 1#"$3

= :

0"6 !)1- "$3 0 3 1 1+" "5 / +# ( 7$

+ $ !))$!)$ 0 !

&4 $/ "$ +")+ +#-(#"# "$3"# (I!6- 70"!0) $#

+I!6- "$3 0"$ +")+ +4 01++<-"#"

3 11+" G/ +#"#$ 0+4 01+5"#"$# .!

"$@9:!

$$ ("$52 93:

0$D(6-+ -+ 0+!6 +"

6 $ 0 +6"+($!0 66$3 "$ 7 -106 4 70"!0 ) $# 0 1+! "$3 # !$!6- 4 -)(+66 1+ "$ .!

"$ @ 9: 0 !

& $$ ("$52 #"

#$ +5"5#

6 ")( ++ !6 ")# 90:

$ 1 && 4 0 $D(6 -+ 0 # ) "

1+5"#"$ .!

"$@9: &"#) ( "$52 (/ 0 ($ "!"

+"# " 6 $ 7$+# 70 7+ +!+ #

") "##- $! $ "!

"$ -$ + .!

"$@ ?=@$/#-(#<-$ 1-+!0 #+4 06 ++ 0+7"#4!

$$ "$52 01+5"#"$# .!

@9: &

+0 5"$33$"$ 0A- 3)$ ## (/ 0$D(6 $# "$$!04 +70# !"#"$40 +"$3"$ 01+#$ !

#7 21 1$ "$34 7 1+! #

6 )

+"I 0 "$#

# $

1+"$!"16#6 " 7$(/ 01I-+ +7 #4"

+<-"+$!## +/)$

"$ 0!

$ 4 07+"

)$ 7 "6 $ (0 66 0 +#1$ $ # 7 / ( !2 $ = G

0+(/+ "$3 66 0!6 ")#1- + 0(/ "$+

"$ -+$4 1+ / + "#)"## 6 0 7+"

1 "$ (/ #1!"

66/ !$ $ "$3

$ "$<-# "$"#5+/)-!0##$ !0"5 1-(6"!1-+1# +70"!0"

7 !<-"+ #)-!0#4"

016

# 766 # + 0 +!+ +5 6#

"$#1"

0 5"$3 +!"5 7+"

)$ 4 "$+0 #!0#$$ "6 $/+16"!

0-#

"$ 07+"

)$ 53$-$+(-

? '+ $2-+ '"

+"$3 0

"!"

6 +#1$ $ # ) #

#16 "$ 07+"

)$ "6 7 /( !2"$

0/ +

+#-

"!"$ )$#

0+<-"+)$ #6 " 7$ "$ $ + 561)$ - 0+"

/ 9#-1+ : $ 7-6 ( #-

"!"$ $3

0!6 ")1- + 0(/ "$+4(#" #00 #1"$ - !$!

6)$

# (/ 0 1 "$+ 0"6 + ++"$3 0 7+"

)$ "6 4 "

0 # ($ +3-

0 1 "$+ 0 # !$!

6 +"-#

0-#40 #$ 11+ !0 0"#!-+ 7"

0!6 $0 $ # # ($ +3-

0 1####"$ 0 6 $ "$ <-# "$ 7

2$ 5" +

+H$ )!0 @G

& & ==&0

+ )$/

0 $ "+ 6 !<-"+ 5" + "$ <-# "$ 7 # #

4 4G 4&

GGF $ - "

4 11+I= L )-$ #

$ # 6+ / "#(-+# 70"!05$"$!6- # 0!)1$#

"$)$/ #+3 + # $ "$<-# "$<- 0!#0 ++ "$+0"6+ ++"$3

16 "$ 0 7+"

$ #

)$ 4 "

0 # ($ +3-

"$ "$4 "$+0 ## -1 !

# 0")0 5"$3 0-#5+ !<-"+ 70+"$ 0 "# +#" "$3 (- 0 # " 0-# 0 # $ ($ +6 # +) "$70+

+"#

- $ "$<-# "$4 70"!0

0+ "$+707 #7$+

") 0!$# +-!

) #-+"$3 E?'70"!0 #+6 # $ "

"#$6/ 05 6 $ 470"!00 #($ !<-"+ 4$ 70"!0 !!-$ "

#6 0 1 "$ "# +<-"+ ( "#)"## 7"

I)16 +/ !# + 0 5"$3 11+ !0 0"# !-+ ( # -1$ )"##

)$ $ )"#+1+#$

"$ 7 -+ 0+ +3-

"$+0 #-30 $0 $!)$ !)1$#

+)"$ (/ "6"$3 +$! 1 "$ -$ + .!

? ?=@ !

<- E0 #+ &@FFGF4 4 70+

0!)1$#

)-$ 7 #$0 $! (-

# #

"$ +16/ $0 $! !)1$#

"$ !-6 $ ( 1 " "$+ " $ 1+5" 0"#( $2 !!-$ $ 0++65 !-)$ # "

0+3 +

$ "$<-# "$"#5+/)-!0##$

!0"5 01-(6"!1-+1# +70"!0"

7 !<-"+ 4"

#($#

#1+ 016 $$"$3) 4"

#1 & )7" #!

+ "5" "$3 + 4 )7" #+5"!+ 4#"

1+") +/#!064 &$# 6 @) +6 !

3+/ $ 16 # ) +6 !

3+/ = / 16 !"$3 +6"

$! $ 0 1+"$!"16 6 " 7$ (/ .-1+)-+ 4'+'"

60 +3-

"$+0 5"$316 7+$3

)1 )"#6 0"#-+ #

2-$ -

3 0 )"$3 "!

"$1+5" -$ +.!

@9: &01 "$+0 # 6"(+

6/) 7+$3 #

$ !<-"+ 400 0-#70"!00 #$ ($ +6 # 470+ 0$ "+!$# +-!

) #-+"$3 2 6?'

+6 "$I"# $!

") "$"

"$ "$1+! "$3#0 ($ +6 # 0 1 "$+ 0 -+ 0+ !$!

"$ 0 6 $ "$ <-# "$40"# !#0 ++ $ 0"# 0+!#0 ++#0 5 6+ / !!1

0!)1$#

"$01 "$+0 6#!$!

-) 0") 5"$3 "6 0+ +$!1 "$#2"$3$0 $!)$ !)1$#

+ 0"# 6 !<-"+ "

# "

) /4 0 1####"$ 0 6 $ "$ <-# "$0 6+ /($

2$(/ + 7"$3

H$ )!0 @G

& & ==& 0 6 $ "$ <-# !<-"+ I!6- "$3 !$# +-!

1+ "$ 2 ?'70"!0"$ +)# $ +561)$ - 0+"

/9#-1+ :"##-

"!"$ !$# +-

010/#"!

61####"$

0 6 $ "$ <-# "$ 0 5 ($

2$ .

0 <-# "$ !)1$#

$ "$<-# (1 " $ 7$+4 .-1+) -+ 0 # !6 +"

I1+##"$ 1 " "$ 0 ) "$ 1 .!

"$@9: &7"66( ) (#

"# " "

!)1$#

)-$ 7 $ + 70"!00 #($I16 "$ )

)-$ "# ) "6 (6 $ 7$+

7-6 ( "#!0 +3 0(6"3

) 2 /)$ 0$ 40 +3-

0+6"

$!16 ! (/ "$+$-$'-$"!"1 6+1+

9#-1+ :"# 6# $061 "$+ 0# " A- 3)$ #($ I1+##6/ 5++-6 "$ & $ + 561)$ - 0+"

/ 9.-1+ :

2"$3"

-+ 0+4'+'"

60 +3-

#"$! 07+ J+K!!-++"$3"$( 0!$ "$3$!"#)$ "$ "$ 0) "$.!

@ 9: 0 !

& 0 # ($ + # J$+F $ K4 ( !$ "$3$!"#!!-++"$37"660 5 ()

+"6/ -6 "66

01++<-"#"

3 11+" G/ +#+)+( 7$

+ $ !)"$3"$

&70"!0) $#

0+"

/ "# +<-"+ )$#

$/ ") 1+"+ 3 1 1+" G / +#4 0 1####"$ 0 # ($

2$ (/ + 7"$3 $!0$ ) +5$ 0!)1$#

"$"# $ + 4"

7"66$3

0!6 ") 0 6 $ 7$+ 6 1#"$3 -F# @ 9: 0 !

& -+ 0+

+3-

0 6 $ "$ <-# "$ "# 5+/ )-!0 ##$ !0"5

& 1-(6"!1-+1##)-!0#5$ 0+ "# 6#

$/+6 #F !6

"$ 6 1#"$37"66 5+#6/

016 $$"$3"$ +)# 6 / - 16 $ +

+ 0 5"$3 (# 7 -+ 0-30

-6 !$#" +

0 +"5 !6 ")# 1- + 0 (/ 0 !)1 "$3 1 "#4 0 5"$3 3$ 0+-30 +#1!

"516 "$3# 0A- 3)$ ## (/ 0$# "$$!0 0.-1+)-+ 47 + 0!$#" + 1"$"$

0"$#

"$ #+5# ( "#)"## +)+ $$+ #$$ 0"$#

#4"

"# 0!

3+"!16 #

$ 0.

01####"$

$ "$<-# "$0 6+ /($

2$7 /( !2"$ 0/ ==&" (/

H$ )!0 @G

& & ==& 0-#4 0 6 $ "$ <-# "$ #

$ # 5# "$ 0 .

66 "$ $ 1-+1## 0"6 "$ +1+ "$3 07+ J10/#"!

61####"$K4 0.-1+)-+ 06

0 +!+ "$3 1 $!0$ ) "# 5 6" )

2"$3 1####"$ I16 "$

$! 01####"$ 6 $ "#

2$4 $ 5# #"$ .

$ "

0 1####"$ "# +

"$ (/ 0 +# 70"6 $ 7$+ + $/ 0+ 1+#$4 "

7"66 ( $6/ "$ 0 !

+#1 ##+ $ "

7"66$ ( "6 (6 $ 7$+ !6 ")

1####"$ 0 #$D ($

2$ +) 0")

0 "# # "66 7$+ "$ 1####"$$ 0"$#

$!!

#4 0-30!$!

6 (/ "$+(- #

(/ 0+#1$ $ #4I!6- "$3 0!$# +-!

1+ "$ E ?' $ 4 0 1####"$ 0 +# F+) "$"$3 6 $ 7

2$ (/

H$ )!0 4 0+ +4 7 0 5 $ 0#"

0 10/#"!

1####"$ 0 6 $ "$ <-# "$ #

$ #

2$ 0-#4 "

"# $

"6 (6 "$+ !$

0"## "66"$1####"$

@ $ "$ <-# !!+ "$36/4 $ 0 !$ "$3$!/ !!-++"$3 "$ .!

"$@9: &3#

0-30 "$ +)# 0 1+"$!"16 6 " 7$ "$ $ + 561)$ - 0+"

/ 9.-1+ :4

+ 0 5"$3 ($ +!+

1####"$ $ "$<-# "$0 #($

2$4 0"#"# 0$ + "$+#

+0"#!6 ") 6 1#"$3("$3#-30 -F#@9: (- # "66 #"$!4 0 1 "$+ 0 # #1!"

66/

2$ 0 16

!)1$#

$ "$<-# "$0 #$"

0+($1 " $+ 1#"

( + 0 +$!-+ 477-6 6"2 # 0"#!$ "$ "$+"$ 06"30 01+"$!"16#6 " 7$"$$ +561)$ - 0+"

/ 9.-1+ : 0 .

"$ "

# 7+"

$ #

)$ 0 # !

3+"!

66/ !$

0 1 "$+ "# 0 !#0 ++ "$ 1"! 6 I "

("$3!6 ") "$ 07+"

"$0-30 "$+0 $ +!"5 0!)1$#

"$(- )"

6/40"# 0+!#0 ++#0 5

6+ / !!1 0"+#0 + !)1$#

"$01 "$+ 0-300

"6 0 + +$! F# .!

? ?=@ !

"# ")1+

0"306"30 0+

0 1I !-+ 70"6 "$ +1+ "$3 0 7+ C1 " D !!-++"$3"$.!

"$@9: 07+ C 1#"

D-# "$1+5"# .!

"$ @ 9: 0 !

& 0 # 5+/ !

3+"!

66/ (#+5 ) $"$3

( 0 (/ 06 "$3

0 7+ C1 " D # $ "$!6- 1#"

$ "$!

#4 )-$ #($ $ + 4 0(6"3

1 /"# -6 "66 0

7-6 !$# +- ) $J $ + )-$ K # ($ I16 "$ "$ & )

)-$ "#F7 # )

"6 (6 0 6 $ 7$+

7-6 ( "#!0 +3 (6"3

) 2 0 1 /)$ $ 0+ 6")( 70"!0

# "$

6 )

+"I 0 1+#$ !

# "#

6 $ 7$+ 70 "6 +$! -F# ? ?=@ !

!6 ")

0 0 # $ ($ 1 "

G !)1$#

"$ 6 +"

/"$3 0"# #1!

4 0 .-1+) -+ "$ @ ) "

70$ 0 6 $ 7$+ # $ !!1 )-$ !)1$#

"$(- #2# + +$! +0"30+!)1$#

"$4 0+!

$( $<-# "$ #-!0"$ "5" - 6#

"$3

07 #$ " )-$

+)"$ (/ 0 66!

$ #"$!4 (#" #

!)1$#

"$7 # -6/ $ + "$+F0"#1+ !##+70+"$ 5$0"# 0+!#0 ++#0 5 !!1 )-$ !)1$#

"$(/

0 1 "$+ "$#

!!1 "$3 0 # ) !0# "6 0 + +$! -$ +#!

? ?=@!

7"66$ (1$ "$+ $7!$

0!)1$#

"$0 #$ ($1 " 0")$5"7

(54 7 0 5 $ 0#"

"$ 0 !

# "$ 0 $ 4 !)1$#

"$7 # -6/ $ + (- "$+!0# $ !!1

0# ) 0-#4 0.

#!6 +6/ "#!0 +3 "

#(6"3

) 2

/)$ 0-#4 0#!$ !$ "$3$!/ +"$3"$.!

"$@9: & 6#3##

0"$#

$!!

#"#!$!+$

& '+$2-+'"

6$ 0# +$3 0

#16 "$ 7+"

)$ #50)$ 6/!$ $

!<-"+ 6

01-(6"!1-+1#1-(6"!1-+1#+- "6"H

"$ 6 ++#" $ 64 !))+!"

64"$# "$ $ 1$#1 !4+!+

"$ "$-+3 $ 1+ 016 $1+1 + -$ + 0 +/ +( $561)$ - 0+"

/ !

4 =

01-(6"!1-+1#"# !0"5 (/ + 7"$3F 11+5"$3 / - 16 $#1+ /- 16 $1+1 + "$"$<-# "$4

$ "$<-# "$"#5+/)-!0##$ !0"5 01-(6"!1-+1#

$ "

016 $$"$3 & )7" #!

+ "5" "$3+ 4 )7" #+5"!+ 4#"

1+") +/#!064 &$#16 @ ) +6 !

3+/ $ 16 # ) +6 !

3+/0 5!$#" + 0"# +3-)$ + "# (/ 0 +#1$ $ $ 7 + "$ !)16

3+)$ 7"

0# ) 0"#"# $")1+

(21 "$)"$ 70"6 6"$3 7"

0 !

# +"#"$3 - "$ 6

!0"5 01-(6"!1-+1# $ "

"# 0.

0+"

/70"#"$ (# 1#"

!" (- - "6"H

"$ 0 6 !<-"+ 4

+ "

5"$3($5# "$.

@ $ 0"$#

#4 +) 1+-# 6 016 "$3#) "$ 5"7 0!

3+"!!

#16 (/ 0.

"#-$ )("3--#6/!6

"$+0 #$ $6/!$!

-) 0!$# +-!

1+ "$0 5"$3($+6 # (/ 0+"

"#(- #1#"

"56/) 7+$3#

0"#(-"6 -10-#0 #$ ($+6 # #)-!0# " $D 5$ "#!6# (- 0"# 0+ ! #0 ++# 0 5"$3 !!1 !)1$#

"$ 9 # 16 "$ 0 7+"

$ #

)$ 70"!0 7$ -$!$ +5+ :4 "

"# !6

0 1 "$+ 0 +" )"#6 0"# !-+ 70"!0+<-"+# (5"7 5+/#+"-#6/7+"

+) /"# <-"

(6 $ 1+#$ "$52"$3 0 7+"

A-+"# "!

"$ "# -$ + -$7+"

$!$ $ $6/#

#(- !)16

#+)

01+-# 6 016 "$3#4"

"#!+/#

6!6

"$+0 #$

11+ !0 0"#-+ 7"

0!6 $0 $ # +-

#7+!$!

0+ 0 )"##

)$ 7 # ) 3"5 ")1+##"$

0 (-"6 -1 0-#!$# +-!

#$ ($+6 # !6 +6/ 1+!

0"#2"$ 1+ "! 0"#

6$ "##-

"!"$ $3

0<-"

(6 +6"

("$3 1+ / + 75+4 (/ +!+ "$3 -+ $3-"#04 7 + "$ -+#65# "$

2"$3 -1 0"# "##- -+ 0+ $ ")1#"

"$ I)16 +/ !# +0 5"$3!$!

6 $ )"##

G # #<-6 (5 "#!-##"$ $ "$ 5"7 6 7 #-)) +"H "$ 1 & & $ + 561)$ - 0+"

/ 9#-1+ :4 #1!"

66/

+0 5"$3+!+

"$ 0!

#"$0 $ 4 010/#"!

1####"$ $ "$<-# "$I!6- "$3 0!$# +-!

1+ "$

2 ?'70"!07 #+6 # 9 0-30!$!

6 (/ "$+:0 5"$3 ($

2$4#

"# /"$3 "#!0 +3"$3 06"

("6"

/ ) 2 /)$ !)1$#

!<-"+ 6#!$#" +"$3

$ "$ <-# "$"#5+/)-!0##$ !0"5 01-(6"!1-+1#470 5$ 0#"

"$ 0"$#

#4 0.

-66/ "#!0 +3 "

(6"3

"$<- ( 0!$ "$3$!"#!!-++"$3"$.!

"$@9: !

& $ "

("$3 #4 0 1+#$ 1 "$ )+"

# "#)"## 0$!4 0"$#

"$"# "#)"##

5"$3 "#)"## 0 ) "$ 7+"

1 "$4 1$ "$3

116"!

"$4 "

$/4 6# ) 0 # )

-# <-4 "

$/4 #

$ #

9,.E: . 9>>: (+- +/ &4 $ A 0 0+#1 2"$3F+ #$

#F 0 0++1+