Jasbir Singh Alias Jasvir Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals) And Others
!
" ! #$%$&
!%'( &(+#,#)$
------
5(/,6,
88(%3, 6$9%.
)'2(/, ------
(,8)$&($',
: ;
0 0
/(,($'
/- 02(//< =- 0#$13%
&4)+%'( 8('#'#)$(/-
/- %4$(('
0#$12 0($#)/ ! 6$9%.-
/-
%9(,2 2%'(9% &4)+%'(
- - 0
;
2#, %883#+%'#)$ 0(+'#)$ 83%+#$1 /(+)/& /(83< .(2%3* >%< %**#&%4#'-
/(%,)$, 7($'#)$(& %883#+%'#)$ ,%7( %33)>(& /(83< >%< %**#&%4#'
'%?($ /(+)/& ,6.9(+'
%33 96,'
(@+(8'#)$,- 883#+%'#)$ %++)/&#$13< &#,8),(& )*-
02)/'
/(83< >%< %**#&%4#'
,- =)7%3 #''%3 .(2%3* /(,8)$&($', A )6/'
')&%< '%?($ /(+)/& ,6.9(+'
%33 96,'
(@+(8'#)$,-
/'#+3(, )$,'#'6'#)$ $&#% #$'(/ %3#% ,((?#$1 $%'6/( +(/'#)/%/#
88(%3, 6$9%.
,2)/'
:
)77#,,#)$(/:
%3%$&2%/ !#4#,#)$
%3%$&2%/
,2)/'
:!#4#,#)$%3 )77#,,#)$(/:-
/#(*3< &(7#,( 02/#
)1#$&(/ 0#$12 8/(4#)6,
(2,#3 8/)+((&#$1, >(/( #$#'#%'(& *#33#$1 4%+%$+<-
86/,6%$+( 8/)+3%7%'#)$ 7%&( *#33#$1 4%+%$+< 8(/,)$,
#$+36&#$1 06+2% %883#(& ,%7(-
*'(/ +3%#7, +%$&#&%'(, %#.
(2,#3&%/ $%7( )$( +%$&#&%'(, $%7(3< 02#$1%/% &#/(+'(& %88(%/ .(*)/( (2,#3&%/ >2(/( *)6/ +%$&#&%'(, $%7(3< 02#$1%/% 0#$12 %/.2%9%$ 0#$12
8('#'#)$(/
%88(%/(& /(7%#$#$1 '2/(( &#& %88(%/ /(,63'
>2#+2 '2(< >(/( 8/)+((&(& (@8%/'(-
2( (2,#3&%/ $%7( 02#$1%/% &#/(+'(& %88(%/ .(*)/( 06.
%1#,'/%'( >2(/( %/.2%9%$ >#'2&/(> 2#, +%$&#&%'6/( *%4)6/ 0)2%$ ;%3 >#'2&/(> 2#, +%$&#&%'6/( *%4)6/ 02#$1%/% 0#$12-
2( 06.
%1#,'/%'( %*'(/ +3%#7 +%$&#&%'(, $%7(
'2(/(%*'(/ ,($'
A
7%''(/ )33(+')/-
>%< '2/(( +%$&#&%'(, $%7(3<
02#$1%/%
8('#'#)$(/ /(7%#$(& */%<-
A- ;(%/$(& %*'(/ /(3%'#4( 7(/#',&(7(/#', +%$&#&%'(, *)6$&
7),'
,6#'%.3( ,6+2 2#7
(#$1 %11/#(4(&
%88(%3
.(*)/( >2#+2 +%7( %33)>(&
A 7%''(/ /(7%$&(& +)$,#&(/ ;%7.%/&%/# #/C%86/- A-A
((3#$1 &#,,%'#,*#(& )77#,,#)$(/:,
8/(*(//(& %88(%3
.(*)/(
>2#+2 +%7( &#,7#,,(&
-
%*)/(7($'#)$(& +#/+67,'%$+(, /(3#(* , $)'#+(& %.)4(-
- ;(%/$(& +)6$,(3 ,6.7#', /(4($6( %6'2)/#'#(, .(3)> (//(& 3%> *%+', 8%,,#$1 )/&(/, >#'2)6'
%88/(+#%'#$1 ,(''3(& 3%> 7%''(/ ;%7.%/&%/ +2)#+( 3#12'3< #$'(/*(/(& 6$3(,, '2(/( 8%'($'
#33(1%3#'< 8(/4(/,#'<-
*6/'2(/ ,6.7#''(& %88(33%'( %6'2)/#'< #33(1%33< %/.#'/%/#3< &#/(+'(&
>#'2)6'
7(/#', +%$&#&%'(,- +)$'($&(& .(#$1 7)/( (&6+%'(& <)6$1(/ %1( (@,(/4#+(7%$ .(3)$1#$1 0+2(&63(& %,'( +)776$#'<
&(,(/4(,
0-
+)$'($&(& /(4($6( %6'2)/#'#(, >/)$13< %/.#'/%/#3< /(%,)$(&
)33(+')/- ,6.7#''(& &%'( 8%,,#$1 +/#7#$%3 +%,( 8($&#$1 >2(/(#$ 2( +)$4#+'(&
96&1(7($'
-
)**($+(, 86$#,2%.3( 0(+'#)$, A A A -
#'2 ,6.7#,,#)$, 8/%<(/ .(($ 7%&( )/&(/,
/(4($6( %6'2)/#'#(, .(3)>-
- (/ +)$'/% +)6$,(3 %88(%/#$1
)88),(& ,6.7#,,#)$, 7%&( .(2%3* ,6.7#''#$1 )/&(/,
/(%,)$(& 96,'#*#(& >2#+2 &) +%33 #$'(/*(/($+( )6/'-
,6.7#''(& #1$)/(& 2(/(&#'%/< +3%#7 .(#$1 ,)$ 8/(4#)6, ;%7.%/&%/- ++)/&#$13< 8/%<(/ .(($ 7%&( &#,7#,,%3 8('#'#)$-
- 2(%/& +)6$,(3 /(,8(+'#4( 8%/'#(, 8(/6,(& 8%8(/.))?
'2(#/ %.3( %,,#,'%$+(-
B- (/( #'
>)63& %88),#'( ,'%'( /(3%'#4( 7(/#',
$)'#+(& #', >2#+2
%/'#+63%/,
(,8)$&($'
1(
&6+%'#)$%3 D6%3#*#+%'#)$ - - 8%,, '2
%,'
8/)*#3( @,(/4#+(7%$ @,(/4#+(7%$
(+)77($&(& 0! B-
8(/6,%3 %.)4( (@'/%+'
*#$&#$1, /('6/$(& >)63& 7%$#*(,'
(&1( )4(/ 2( <)6$1(/ %1( 7)/( (&6+%'(& '2%$
#4#3 )$:.3( 068/(7( )6/'
2(3& /(1%/& 0'%'( 6$9%. %1( /(3(4%$'
*%+')/-
B- , /(1%/&, 2(/(&#'%/< +3%#7 83(%&(& ,%7( .(($ 2(3& 63'/% 4#/(, )$,'#'6'#)$ !#4#,#)$ ($+2 )6/'
!"#$ $-
B-A 7< +)$,#&(/(& 4#(> 7)/( ,6#'%.3(
2( /#12'3<
B- +%,(
%
& '
(%% )**! +,
#4#3 AE #'
2(3& !#4#,#)$ ($+2 )6/'
+2)#+( +%$$)'
3#12'3< %,#&( (4($ #* '>) 4#(>, 8),,#.3( 6$3(,, '2(/( 8%'($'
#33(1%3#'< 8(/4(/,#'< '2(/(#$- (,'%.3#,2(& 7%#$ %6'2)/#'< ;%7.%/&%/- >2)
%88/(+#%'(, %$'(+(&($', %33 */%< .6'
8(/,)$%33< #$'(/%+', '2(7-
- 4#(> %.)4( &#,+6,,#)$ %7 +)$,#&(/(& 4#(>
(//(& 3%> *%+', )33(+')/:,
(,63'%$'3< %33)>(&
%88)#$'#$1 (2,#3 7%#$'%#$(&-
- ($&#$1 %883#+%'#)$
, #* %$< ,2%33 ,'%$& +3),(&-
0
!
,9?, 2('2(/ ,8(%?#$1/(%,)$(&
"(,
) 2('2(/ /(8)/'%.3( "(,
)