High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/224/2014disposed of

Iqbal Singh v. Industrial Tribunal Patiala & ORS

2023-09-02Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger10 pages

!"# $% &#'()($* ++ ,-!. /(*01 ++++++ #"("($*#2 3#2)4) *&4)"2(!. 2(-4*!.5 !"(!.! "12$401 (") 2#)(&(*0 %%('#2 !*& $"1#2) ++++++ #)6$*&#*")

2#)#*"

2+ +/+ !**45 &7$'!"# %$2

2+ 3(8!) /(*015 &7$'!"# %$2 "1# 6#"("($*#2+ $*# %$2 2#)6$*&#*" $+ +

2+ 24* 46"!5 &7$'!"# %$2 2#)6$*&#*" $+ + + + + #"("($*#2 ,-!. /(*01 1!) %(.#& "1# (*)"!*" (7(. 2(" #"("($* 4*&#2 2"('.#) 9 $% "1# $*)"("4"($* $% *&(!5 )##8(*0 :2(" (* "1# *!"42# $% '#2"($2!2( %$2 ,4!)1(*0 "1# (;640*#& :!2& &!"#& ++

**#<42# 5 6!))#& -= "1# *&4)"2(!. 2(-4*!.5 !"(!.! 1#2#(*!%"#2 2#%#22#& "$ !) >"1# 2(-4*!. -#.$:> "$ "1# #<"#*"5 :1#2#-= 2#.(#% $% 2#(*)"!"#;#*" :("1 !.. '$*)#,4#*"(!. -#*#%(") 1!) -##* &#'.(*#& "$ "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* !*& $*.= '$;6#*)!"($* 1!) -##* !:!2&#&+

2(#%.=5 "1# 6#"("($*#2$28;!* 2!()#& !* (*&4)"2(!. &()64"# -= )#27(*0 ! &#;!*& *$"('# &!"#& +9+ !*& $* %!(.42# $% '$*'(.(!"($* 62$'##&(*0)5 "1# &()64"# :!) 2#%#22#& %$2 !&?4&('!"($* "$ "1# 2(-4*!. -#.$:+ * "1# '.!(; 6#"("($*5 "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* 6.#!&#& "1!" 1# ?$(*#& 2#)6$*&#*" $+ $7(*0 $42#)) @(;("#& 1#2#(*!%"#2 2#%#22#& "$ !) >2#)6$*&#*" !*!0#;#*"> $* ++A+ # :!) :$28(*0 :("1 2#)6$*&#*" !*!0#;#*" !) ! /"$2# 4*)1( !"

1;#&0!21 !*& :!) &2!:(*0 )+ 5 6#2 ;$*"1+ " :!) 6.#!&#& "1!" "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* 1!& :$28#& %$2 ;$2# "1!* &!=) (* "1# .!)" '!.#*&!2 =#!2+ 1# 6#"("($*#2 :$28;!* '.!(;#& "1!" 1# '$*"(*4$4).= :$28#& :("1 2#)6$*&#*" !*!0#;#*"

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

$* "1# 6.#! "1!" "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* :!) #*0!0#& %$2 ! %(<#& 6#2($& (* ! 6!2"('4.!2 62$?#'" "$ -# '$;6.#"#& !) 6#2 &(2#'"($*) 0(7#* -= 4*?!- $7#2*;#*" !" "1# "(;# $% 1!*&(*0 $7#2 $% "1# 62$?#'" '!..#& >1# (*( =&#.

2$?#'"> !"

1;#&0!21 $%%('#+ " :!) )"!"#& "1!" '(7(. 62$?#'" :!) #*"24)"#& "$ 2#)6$*&#*" !*!0#;#*" -= "1# 4*?!- $7#2*;#*" !*& 6#"("($*#2:$28;!*

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

* "1# -!)() $% "1# 6.#!&(*0) $% "1# 6!2"(#)5 "1# ())4#) :#2# %2!;#& !*& 6!2"(#) .#& "1#(2 2#)6#'"(7# #7(&#*'#+ A+ * $2&#2 "$ 62$7# (") '!)#5 "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* #<!;(*#& $*#

7"!2 /(*01 !) !*& 1# 1(;)#.% )"#66#& (* "1# :("*#)) -$< !) + #)6$*&#*" !*!0#;#*" #<!;(*#& $*# :("*#)) + /4*&!2#):!2!*5 1(#%

4)(*#)) #7#.$6;#*"+ 9+

%"#2 '$*)(&#2(*0 "1# '!)# $% "1# 2#)6#'"(7# 6!2"(#) !) :#.. !) #7(&#*'# ;!"#2(!. 6.!'#& $* 2#'$2&5 "1# 2(-4*!. -#.$: !*):#2#& "1# 2#%#2#*'#5 7(&# !:!2& &!"#& ++

**#<42# 5 :1#2#-= (" :!) 1#.& "1!" "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* 1!& '$;6.#"#& &!=) $% '$*"(*4$4) )#27('# (* "1# .!)" '!.#*&!2 =#!2 !*& "1# "#2;(*!"($* $% )#27('#) $% "1#

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

%"#2 !204(*0 %$2 )$;# "(;#5 .#!2*#& '$4*)#. %$2 "1# 6#"("($*#2 :$28;!* '$*%(*#) 1() 62!=#2 $*.= :("1 2#0!2& "$ #*1!*'#;#*" $% '$;6#*)!"($* !) !:!2&#& -= "1# 2(-4*!. -#.$:5 -= )4-;(""(*0 "1!" "1# '$;6#*)!"($* !:!2&#& -= "1# *&4)"2(!. 2(-4*!. () "$$ ;#!02#+ +

* "1# $"1#2 1!*&5 .#!2*#& '$4*)#. %$2 2#)6$*&#*" !*!0#;#*"

1!) $66$)#& "1# 62!=#2 $% "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* $* "1# 02$4*& "1!" "1# !662$62(!"# 2#.(#% 1!) !.2#!&= -##* 02!*"#& "$ "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* !) "1# 2#.(#% $% 2#(*)"!"#;#*" :("1 %4.. -!'8 :!0#) !*& '$*"(*4("= $% )#27('# () *$" !4"$;!"('+ " () )4-;(""#& "1!" "1# (;640*#& !:!2& () ?4)"(%(#& !*& &$#) *$" '!.. %$2 !*= (*"#2%#2#*'#+ ''$2&(*0.=5 62!=#2 %$2 &();())!. $% "1# (*)"!*" :2(" 6#"("($* 1!) -##* ;!&#+

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

5 "1#

6#< $42" 1#.& "1!" :1#* "1# "#2;(*!"($* () )#" !)(&# -#'!4)# $% 7($.!"($* $% /#'"($* A $% '"5 (" () *$" *#'#))!2= "1!" "1# 2#.(#% $% 2#(*)"!"#;#*" -# 0(7#* !) ! ;!""#2 $% 2(01"+ *

!"5 (" :!) (*"#2 !.(! 1#.& "1!" (* "1$)# '!)#) :1#2# "1# :$28;!* 1!& :$28#& $* &!(.= :!0# -!)() !*& :$28#& ;#2#.= %$2 ! 6#2($& $% &!=) $2 =#!2) !*& :1#2# "1# "#2;(*!"($* 1!& "!8#* 6.!'# ;!*= =#!2) !0$5 "1# 2#'#*" "2#*& :!) "$ 02!*" '$;6#*)!"($* (* .(#4 $% 2#(*)"!"#;#*"+ *

#$ '!)# )462!5 "1# $*>-.# 6#< $42"

2#("#2!"#& "1# "2#*& -= 2#%#22(*0 "$ "1# 7!2($4) ?4&0;#*") !*& (*"#2 !.(! 1#.& !) 4*&#2 % &'() &) &

(( &((&+

$ +

& ) (+ $, ,&'

& )

- &(

& &

& .&

)'$ ( / $0'

$1 2!34 &$ & %

/1 567

9 &'$& ) $ & $&

$&'

$, '

&*&

,&-8'$

& 9

$& :

1 '( '

& )2)( -

<') *

$&' 2& & '$=&) 2:

)$&*&

) $ & $&

$&'

> *(2?@

$$+ &0&

& ) - ?)

@ )2 ?

( .&$

/-(&0*

&0&

& -$:&$

@ - (

A'* * 2 @ 1)* - 7 , ', 2

= *-&

( ( '. *$ 7

0'/-(&0*

- = * $

2 B/1 - 1$ & A'* ) ,&&,/0 - @

2B < '(

) $ &((&+$ :

$2 0099 )990 $4 )3 C4 $ '

( - +&

$ &'

'( )

) $ & $ ( )

( (0&$

& & *0(& + $ &'

) &, (( (2

( &

'(( , + $ +&'()&)

( &((&+;&+-2

0 $ 2

$, $

( (0&$

& )

(

$$2

$ &' $ & $ $

(

- +

( ,+ &

, + $ $ &

) * , + &((

00&0

- $

& &

*0(& $

& &

0$ ,)0&)'&*0 $

$ )&

$, ()

)$& <'$

DDDD DDDDD DDDDD 3 +&'(),2

'$2$

, & ) $ & $

$ &' $( (( ))&+

&) & *

0 $$)

- &(

& &

& >. (

* , $ $ ) ,'

+ ) &

$ &'() & 2 &+-2 '

((0 $$)7 + )&

'((, + $

$ +

+& * $ &*0( )3) $& +&

) & *

& 0

'( (2 ) (>+ $ $ &

, &'

) &,0&0,

$&'

)

$ )&*0 $

& $,

+ ))

$ &'

$ ) $

$ ), + ) (+ + & )&$ & &() 0&$ ) 0*

*0(&C 3 :

$ , 00( ) -

(

7( 0 /0 *

&$ A'* ( +

$ &' $

) 044420 C - +&

&$ )( ( 0&$

& )

+& * +

) $ ) ( + $ ,&'

$, )

+& ) )( &&9 $2(

), + $ &

& ,$ ) &,<'$

)

$ ) *& &*0 $

+&'()$',$-

)$& <'$

C + " () :$2"1:1(.# "$ 2#%#2 "$ "1# &#'()($* $% "1# $*>-.# 6#< $42" (* $'$ ''* (2 / D :1#2#(*5 "1# 6#< $42"

1!) '.#!2.= 1#.& "1!" :1#* "1#2# () 7($.!"($* $% /#'"($* A $% '"5 "1# 2#(*)"!"#;#*" :("1 %4.. -!'8 :!0#) () *$" !4"$;!"('5 "1# :$28;!* )1$4.& -# 0(7#* ;$*#"!2= '$;6#*)!"($* :1('1 :(.. ;##" "1# #*&) $% ?4)"('#+ 1# $*>-.# /462#;# $42" $-)#27#& !) 4*&#2 %9 $( &*

)

&$ ) <') *

0(&

'(( , + $2 +

& $ &'

) &, (( ( $ & 00( ) *

((

(( $$E

(

* , 0&$

& + $- $ & '( F0*

+& * *

) (( (( )F&* (

)

)F& , + & -

& 2 '

( ,&' 0

;&+-2+

&*$ &

& & ) (+ +& )+

& $ &'

) (( (, '$& 0&)' ( ) 2 *(

- &(

& &

& .&

)'$ (/ $0'

$1 2

$&' $& $ $

- +

$' $$

, + $ $ & '

)

$ )

+& * $ &'(),

- *& &*0 $

+ ((*

)$& <'$

& ( & $

& $&,- &'$ 3= $& $ &)

( &

$' $$ &,- &'$ $

( +

& $ &'

) &, (( (, '$&

& >0 *

& *

&*0 $

& )

0 $ * ) & ( 8'

) '

)

& .&

)'$ (/ $0'

$1 2-

$ (+ $ &0 &

& *

$- $ &

*0(& , 0

&*0 $

$' +& * + $+&

& ) (+ , $ $ )-

$ &

&$ '( $

-?* /- 2"327 '$ +

& ( * '( $

& ) $ &

'- $ ) (+ +& 2 & '$ '(0'0&$ $ &

&,$-)

$' +& * ) ,

- *&

&*0 $

& ,

$*' $

$ *

)

2 +&'() -*& &*0 $

& & (

&*&

&*0 $

& ) &

0 $' $

& 2

( &

02 +&'() & $-

0'0&$5 A+ 1# $*>-.# 6#< $42" (* ! 6.#"1$2! $% '!)#) 1!) &(2#'"#& '$;6#*)!"($* (* .(#4 $% 2#(*)"!"#;#*"+ #%#2#*'# '!* -# ;!&# "$ ,&&, /0 - @

2B < '( 42

= *- &

( ( '. *$7

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

''$2&(*0.=5 (* ;= '$*)(&#2#& 7(#:5 "1# (*"#2#)" $% ?4)"('# :$4.& -# ;#" (% "1# '$;6#*)!"($* !:!2&#& "$ "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* -= "1# 2(-4*!. -#.$: () #*1!*'#& "$ )+ 55 + #)6$*&#*" !*!0#;#*" () &(2#'"#& "$ 6!= "1# #*1!*'#& !;$4*" "$ "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* !%"#2 !&?4)"(*0 '$;6#*)!"($*5 (% !*= 6!(& :("1(* ! 6#2($& $% "12## ;$*"1) %2$;

"1# &!"# $% 2#'#(6"

62#)#*"!"($* $% '#2"(%(#& '$6= $% "1() $2&#2+ * '!)# $% *$*6!=;#*" $% !;$4*" "$ "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* :("1(* "1# )"(64.!"#& 6#2($&5 "1# 6#"("($*#2:$28;!* )1!.. -# #*"(".#& "$ '.!(; )(;6.# (*"#2#)" !" "1# 2!"# $% 9E 6#2 !**4; "(.. )4'1 "(;# 6!=;#*" () *$" ;!&#+ + 1# (*)"!*" :2(" 6#"("($* () &()6$)#& $% (* "1# !%$2#)"!"#& "#2;)+ +

.. 6#*&(*0 !66.('!"($* )5 (% !*=5 )1!.. )"!*& '.$)#&+ ++ )?8) 1#"1#2 )6#!8(*0 2#!)$*#& #) $ 1#"1#2 2#6$2"!-.# #) $