High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/34237/2020allowed

Joginder Kaur And ORS v. Shalini And ANR

2021-04-07Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill12 pages

"%&'&#() * *

#+&(,"- . /- #!0"-'

1*"!&!&#("-'

2"-'/'

30 4&(& (#!0"-

1**"'5#(,"(!'

-"'"(!)

-* -6&(, 4 67 ,6#% !"7 5"!&!&#("-'*

-* **3*3 (,0/7 ,6#% !"7 *

'""8 9/ '0&(+ -&:&( 4

#:54 &(!

!&!4", 30 4&(& 2'* 3/80;&(,"- 3&(+0

#!0"-'7 -#!"%!&#( <#:"( #:"'!&%

2&#4"(%"

'0#-!

>!0"

%!?

'/::#(&(+

#-,"- , !",

* * %#('"9/"(!& 4 5-#%"",&(+'

-&'&(+ !0"-"$-#:*

5"- $ %!'

% '"7 3/80;&(,"-

3&(+0-"'5#(,"(!

#*7 '#(

@-#!0"- 5"!&!&#("- #*7 : --&", 30 4&(&-"'5#(,"(!

* * =* -#:

' &, ;",4#%87 #("

: 4"

%0&4, @#-(

* * A* $!"- : --& +"7 30 4&(& '! B", 0 (,&+ -0

0/'@ (,7 ;0# ;#-8&(+ /(C @ (+&(""-&(+ #44"+"7

0 (,&+ -07 #/'"

#*A 7 3"%!#- 7 0 (,&+ -07

(# &(!"-$"-"(%"

(/%4" - $ :&4B

$$ &-'

-"'5#(,"(!'

* "!&!&#("- #*'&'!"-

;#-8&(+

#6"-(:"(!

" %0"-

'&(%"

-"'&,&(+ 0#:"

&'!-&%!

4 (,0 - '&(%"

D &*"* $!"- : --& +"*

E" -(", '/@:&!'

* A7 5 -"(!'

#!0"- $ :&4B :":@"-'

;"(!

0 (,&+ -0 @-#/+0!

@ %8

:-&!' -7 4#(+ :&(#- %0&4, 6 4/ @4"

-!&%4"'*

"+ -,&(+ &(%&,"(!7

, !", *

* +&6"(

#4&%"7 0 (,&+ -07

%#/(!"-@4 '!

' :"7

%-&:&( 4

(#!0"- #("

3"%!&#('

A7 DF *

554&% !&#( ,&':&'' 4

@"$#-"

+&'!- !"7 &(!"- 4& 7 54" ,&(+

, /+0!"- &(4 ;

("6"- -"'&,", 2&44 +"

/CC $ -5/-7 4 (,0 - (#- ,&,

'0"

(B ,#:"'!&% -"4 !&#('0&5 !0":

(,G#- '0"

'0 -", (B 0#/'"0#4, 5"!&!&#("-'7 @/!

' &, 554&% !&#(

,&':&''", * * F7 ;&!0#/!

! 8&(+ &(!# %#('&,"- !&#(

' &, $ %!/ 4 5#'&!&#(*

'/@:&!!",

"&!0"-

-": &(", 0 (,&+ -0 #- :-&!' -7 ;0&%0

$ %!

%4" -4B -"$4"%!", '"4$,"%4 - !&#( $#-:

!&:"

55#&(!:"(!

!" %0"- 6#,B 2&, 4 B 7

-&,8#!

(("H/-"

5"(,&(+ 4 '!

B" -'

"H%"5!

#("

#$$&%& 4

;&!("''7 (# "6&,"(%"

,,/%", %#:54 &( (!

,&'5/!"7 &$ (B7 @"!;""(

;&$"* '/@:&!!",

7 A=

B" -'

-"'5"%!&6"4B7 ,- ++", &(!#

4&!&+ !&#( #(4B

6&";

0 - ''&(+ !0":

%#(! &(", +"("- 4 #:(&@/'

( !/-"*

@#6"

5"!&!&#("- & 4B'&'

!0-&%"

;""8 $ - 5"!&!&#("- #* %#(%"-(",7 '0"

: --&",

'&'!"-&(4 ;

@"&(+

#6"-(:"(!

" %0"-7 '0"

!;# :&(#- %0&4,-"(7

4&6&(+ 0#:"

'&(%"

D 4 (,0 -7 ;0&%0

$ - ; B 54 %"

5 -"(!'

&*"* 5"!&!&#("-

5"!&!&#("- #**

!0"- '"-6&%"

-"%#-,7

+&6"( ,,-"''

0 (,&+ -07 ;0"-"

#*7 -"'&,"'*

E" -(", '/@:&!'

(# '5"%&$&% 44"+ !&#( 0#;

-"4 !&6"'

&*"* % /'", %!'

,#:"'!&% 6&#4"(%"

0"(%"7 5-#%"",&(+'

&(&!& !",

'/'! &( @4"

"B"'

4 ;*

-"4&"'

C/,+:"(!

#(?@4"

5"H 30B :4 4 "6, !0"-'

-&: 4 7

E" -(", 4'# -"4&"'

C/,+:"(!

#(?@4"

3/5-":"

""!

"0-#!-

(#!0"- 6'

3! !"

** (#!0"-7

;0"-"&( 0"4,

$ %!

@#-("

#/!

"H5"-&"(%"7 % ((#!

#6"-4##8",

!"(,"(%B &(6#46"

"(!&-"

$ :&4B :":@"-'

,#:"'!&% 9/ --"4 ! 8&(+ 54 %"

,&'5/!"'*

C/,+:"(!

(##5 !0"-'

2 (& 30-""7 =

-&:&( 4 DFD7 -"4&",

%#(!"(, 4 ;

,#:"'!&% 6&#4"(%"

@"&(+ :&'/'", '#

!"--#-&I"

0/'@ (,7 !0"&- $ :&4&"'

,&'! (!

-"4 !&6"'

!0/'

50"(#:"(#( (#;

%9/&-", ( :"

JE"+ 4

"--#-&':?*

3!&44 $/-!0"-7 -"4&"'

C/,+:"(!

(,0- - ,"'0 &+0 .

3-&(&6 '

# !0"-'

3! !"

**7

-&:&( 4 A7 %#(!"(, : ,"

#:(&@/'

6 +/"

( !/-"

,# ,&'%4#'"

"6"(

5-&: $ %&"

% '"

%!*

"- %#(!- 7 ;&$"

'/@:&!'

0#/'"

C#&(!

$ :&4B 0#/'"

;0&%0 ,#"'

%" '"

"H&'!

:"-"4B @"% /'"

#*7

0/'@ (,7 ;#-8&(+ 0 (,&+ -0* :#6",

554&% !&#( @"$#-"

+&'!- !"

,&':&'' 4

;0&%0 ,&':&''",

' &, #-,"- 0 6&(+ %0 44"(+", "&!0"- ; B 55" 4

#- -"6&'&#(7 !! &(", $&( 4&!B*

"(%"7 5"!&!&#(

: &(! &( @4"*

-+/",

!0#/+0

'! B", 0 (,&+ -07 B"!

'0#-!

&(!"-6 4'

,/-&(+

5"-&#, 5-"+( (%B %0"%8/57

;"(!

7 0 (,&+ -07 "("- 4 #'5&! 47 3"%!#- A7 0 (,&+ -0*

>+#,0 @0 - B&?

%"-":#(B 5"-$#-:", 4 (,0 -*

&6&(+ 0 (,&+ -0 ,,-"''

'"-6&%"

-"%#-,

@"% /'"

$ %!

'"-6&%"

-"%#-,

0/'@ (,7

,,-"''

0 (,&+ -07 +&6"( !0/'7 ,#"'

:" (

("6"- -"'&,",

0#:"

4 (,0 -*

E" -(",

'/@:&!'

$ - 5"!&!&#("- #* %#(%"-(",7 @"&(+ -" 4 '&'!"-

#*7 '0"

-"+/4 - 6&'&!#-

0#:"

5"!&!&#("- #* 4'#

-"'&,", 4 (,0 -* 0"-"

'5"%&$&% + &('!

0"-*

0"-"

#!0"- @-#!0"- '&'!"-'

0/'@ (,7

@/!

!0"B -- &+(", %%/'",G-"'5#(,"(!'

@"% /'"

!0"B ("6"- !-" !",

%-/"4!B* !0"-

,"4 B", !-& 4 :#6&(+ 554&% !&#( ,&':&'' 4

!0"( 5-"$"--&(+ 5"!&!&#(7 9/ '0&(+

%!*

'/@:&!!", : &(!"( (%"

+- (!",

!-& 4 5 &,

!0/'7

0&'

,"$"(%"

4& @4"

'!-/%8 #$$* #-"#6"-7 +-#/(,'

&44 0" 4!0 #4, +"

;"-"

! 8"( /5 5"!&!&#("-

#/-!7 ;0"( 554&% !&#( !- ('$"-

:-&!' - 4 (,0 -7 @/!

' :"

-"C"%!", * *

(("H/-"

* 0/'7 (#

+-#/(, 9/ '0

;&$"

C/'!

5-#H&"'

#**

'!&44 '/@:&!!",

&*"*

0 @&!

$-/'!- !&(+ -&+0!'

5"!&!&#( 3"%!&#( &(,/ --& +"

D==

0 (,&+ -0* /!7 ;0"(

554&% !&#(

!- ('$"- ' &, 5"!&!&#( :-&!' - 0 (,&+ -07

: ,"

'! !":"(!

,&, ; (!

5/-'/"

5"!&!&#(* E !"-

,&6#-%"

5"!&!&#( &'!-&%!

#/-!'7 0 (,&+ -07 C/'!

0 - ''

6&,"

#-,"- , !",

=* * D7

##-,&( !"

"(%0 #/-!7 !- ('$"--", ,&6#-%"

5"!&!&#(

0 (,&+ -0 :-&!' -* #-"#6"-7 5-#%"",&(+'

9/ '& %&6&4 ( !/-"

-"9/&-", !!"(, " %0 "6"-B , !"

0" -&(+* &'7

!0/'7 54" ,", (# % '"

: ,"

#/!

9/ '0 %-&:&( 4

5-#%"",&(+'

-&'&(+ !0"-"$-#:*

E" -(",

-"4&",

C/,+:"(!

#(?@4"

3/5-":"

&- 4 -'#-

!0"-'

./'/:

-#!! :, '

-'#- #!0"-'7

A=7 %#(!"(,

;&$"

% ( $&4"

+ &('!

0/'@ (,?'

-"4 !&6"'7 &(%4/,&(+ :#!0"- &(4 ;

'&'!"-&(4 ;7 "(!&!4", :#("! -B -"4&"$

+ &('!

0&'

$": 4"

-"4 !&6"'7 ;0&%0 &(%4/,"

:#!0"-&(4 ;

;"44*

E" -(",

4'# -"4&"'

C/,+:"(!

% '"

"C 3&(+0 0 8/-

(#!0"- 6'

('0/4 3/50& 7

-&:&( 4 7

'/@:&!

%%/'",G-"'5#(,"(!'

%#:54 &(!7 !0"&-

"(," 6#/- $#-"+# !0"&- 55" - (%"

@"$#-"

+&'!- !"

$ %&4&! !"

%#/('"44&(+ #55#-!/(&!B @"&(+

0" -,7 % ((#!

55-# %0 &+0 &(6#8&(+

5-#6&'&#('

3"%!&#( F -*** '/%0 5-#6&'&#('

/'", '5 -&(+4B

!## :""!

"(,'

C/'!&%"* 3!&44

$/-!0"-7 '/@:&!!", 3"%!&#( D %!

5-#6&,"'

$#-/:

55" 47 ;0&%0 -"'#-!",

0"(%"7 5"!&!&#( 4& @4"

,&':&''",*

E" -(",

-"4&"'

C/,+:"(!

"40& &+0 3:!* B "6&

3! !"

"40&7

-4* A=D7 %#(!"(,

;0"-"

'5"%&$&% -":",B #5"( 5 -!B

&+0 ;&44 &(!"-$"-"

3"%!&#( F -***7

4!"-( !&6"

-":",B* "

4'# 54 %"'

-"4& (%"

3&(+4"

"(%0 C/,+:"(!

C&(,"- 3&(+0 6'

3! !"

-B ( 7 =

-4* 7 ;0"-"&( 0"4,

;0"-"

%0 -+"'

;"-"

$- :", B" -'

+#7 5-#'"%/!&#(

4" ,&(+ "6&,"(%"7 9/ '0&(+ 5"!&!&#( % ((#!

@"4 !", '! +"*

0" -,

!0"&- @4"

''&'! (%"7 4'# +#("

!0-#/+0 ,#%/:"(!'

$&4"*

@"$#-"

:#!0"-&(4 ;7

$ !0"-&(4 ;

: --&", '&'!"-&(4 ;

: --& +"

#*7

'#4":(&I", * * = :-&!' -

: 4"

%0&4,/-'&- !7

@#-( * * A* "'5#(,"(!

#*7 0/'@ (,7 5#'!",

''&'! (!

-#$"''#- /(C @ (+&(""-&(+ #44"+"7

;0"-" '

;&$"7 %#:54"!", 0**

0B'&%'

/-/ ( 8 "6 (&6"-'&!B*

( % '"7 '! (,

'0"

'! B",

/(C @ (+&(""-&(+ #44"+"7 0 (,&+ -0 :5/'

%%#::#, !&#( '0#-!

&(!"-6 4'

,/-&(+ 5"-&#,

5-"+( (%B '0"

+#!

0"-'"4$ %0"%8",/5

"("- 4 #'5&! 47 3"%!#- A7 0 (,&+ -0 -"'&,",

4 (,0 - 0#:"

'! (,

5"!&!&#("- #*7

;0# : --&", '&'!"-&(4 ;

-"+/4 -4B 6&'&!&(+ 0#:"

# :B :&(,7 5"!&!&#( ,"'"-6"'

44#;",*

"'5#(,"(!

;#-8&(+ " %0"- ; C -

#6#, B 2&, B 4 B @"&(+ 0, 0B'&%'* 3"%!&#(

'!&5/4 !"'

5-#!"%!&#( #-,"- $ 6#/-

;#: (*

3"%!&#( %!

," 4'

:#("! -B -"4&"$

++-&"6", 5 -!B ' :"

% ( @"

+- (!",

@"$#-"

&''/&(+ (#!&%"7 +&'!- !"

5-&:

$ %&"

' !&'$&", &('! (%"'

,#:"'!&%

6&#4"(%"*

6"( 6 -&#/'

%-&:&( 4

#$$"(%"'* #:"'!&% 6&#4"(%"

@ '", ,#:"'!&% -"4 !&#('0&5

'0 -", 0#/'"0#4,*

554B&(+ &(+-",&"(!'

,#:"'!&% 6&#4"(%"

% '"7

C#&(",

/(C @ (+&(""-&(+ #44"+"7 :5/'

%%#::#, !&#(

0 (,&+ -0* ,:&!!", % '"

,/-&(+ 5-"+( (%B7 '0"

!##8 !-" !:"(!

"("- 4 #'5&! 47 3"%!#- A7 0 (,&+ -0* #-"#6"-7

'"-6&%"

-"%#-,7 ,,-"''

/(C @ "(+&(""-&(+ #44"+"7

0 (,&+ -0 +&6"(*

,"(&",

'0"

55#&(!", " %0"- ; C - #6#,B 2&, B 4 B

&'!-&%!

-&,8#!

5"-'#( 4 ,"%4 - !&#( !"(,"-",

!&:"

C#&(&(+7

'! !", '0"

-"'&,",

0 (,&+ -0

* * =

* D* :-&!' - &*"* 5 -"(! 4 0#:"*

&:5#-! (!

(#!"

, !"

: --& +"

5 -!&"'

* * =

'#( @#-( * * A*

/-!0"-7

+ &('!

0 (,&+ -0 #4&%"

* 44"+&(+

4#(+

5 -"(! 4 $ :&4B :":@"-'

$#-%&@4B !##8 @ @B 6 4/ @4"

-!&%4"'

/(C @ (+&(""-&(+ #44"+"

:5/'

-"'&,"(%"

;&!0#/!

&($#-:&(+ #*7 0/'@ (,* 35"%&$&% ,&'%4#'", + &('!

: !!"- -&'"'

#/!

@&%8"-&(+* ;#/4,7 !0/'7 @"

%4" - 5-#%"",&(+'

9/ 5"!&!&#("-'7 ;0# :"%0 (&% 44B '#/+0!

5-#'"%/!", 5-#6&'&#('

(#!0&(+

@/!

@/'"

4"+ 4 C/,&%& 4 5-#%"''* '

(#!&%", @#6"7

$!"- 4" 6&(+ 0/'@ (,?'

%#:5 (B7

'! -!", 4&6&(+ 5 -"(! 4 0#:"*

C/,+:"(!'

30B :4 4

"6, ?'K

""!

"0-#!- ?'K (##5?'

*.* 3-&(&6 '

#?'

% '"'

'/5- 7

$#%/'

$ %!'

'0#/4, @"

'5"%&$&%

,#:"'!&% 6&#4"(%"

!"(,"(%B &(6#46"

"H!"(,",

:":@"-'7 ;0# ; B (/%4" - $ :&4B7 +&6"(

!"-:

E"+ 4 "--#-&':*

( #!0"- 0 (,7 C/,+:"(!'

&- 4

-'#- ?'K "C 3&(+0 0 8/-?'K 3:!* B "6&?'

C&(,"-?'

% '"'

'/5- 7 -"4&",

$#%/'

$ %!'

,#:"'!&%

6&#4"(%"

% '"'7

;&$"

"6"-B -&+0!

$&4"

+ &('!

0/'@ (,?'

-"4 !&6"'7 &(%4/,&(+ :#!0"-&(4 ;

'&'!"-&(4 ;7 ;0# 55-# %0 &+0 /-!

;&!0#/!

$ %&4&! !&(+

%#/('"44&(+ $#-"+# !0"&- 55" - (%"

@"$#-"

+&'!- !"*

0"4, !0"-"&( &$

'5"%&$&% -":",B7

#5"( 5 -!B 6 &4 '/%0 -":",B &(6#8"

5-#6&'&#('

3"%!&#( F -***

0/'7 C/,+:"(!'

%&!",

554&% @4"

$ %!'

% '"*

#(?@4"

3/5-":"

"5'& ##,'

E!,* (,

(#!0"- 2'* 35"%& 4 /,&%& 4 +&'!- !"

#!0"-'7

DDF= 3

D7 ;0&4"

-"4B&(+ &!'

5-"6&#/'

,"%&'&#('7 &(%4/,&(+ #("

,"4&6"-", 3! !"

-B ( 2'* 0* 0 C ( E 47

F7 ;0&4"

'"!!&(+ '&,"

#-,"- 5 ''", &+0 0"4,

&$ (# '/@'! (%"

%#:54 &(!7

!0"( &+0 ;#/4, @"

;"44 ;&!0&( &!'

-&+0!

9/ '0

5-#%"",&(+'*

#@'"-6 !&#('

: ,"

&+0

'! +"

! 8&(+ %#+(&I (%"

+&'!- !"7 % ((#!

' &, '# @'/-,

&(0"-"(!4B &:5-#@ @4"

@ '&'

;0&%0 (# 5-/,"(!

: (

% ( "6"- -" %0

C/'!

%#(%4/'&#( "H&'!'

(# '/$$&%&"(!

+-#/(, 5-#%"",&(+'

+ &('!

%%/'",7 ;"-"

'"!

'&,"*

(#!&%", @#6"7 !- ('$"- 5"!&!&#(

5"!&!&#("-

@ '&'

4"+ 4 -&+0!7 ,&':&''",

##-,&( !"

"(%0 * * D* #;"6"-7

,/-&(+ 4 '!

$#/- B" -'7 "H%"5!

#("

#$$&%& 4 ;&!("''7 (#

#!0"- ;&!("''

"H :&(", !0/'7

@"&(+ (# 0" ,; B !-& 47 ' :"

'!&44 '! (,'

&(&!& 4 '! +"*

"!&!&#("-

:#!0"-&(4 ;

+", A= B" -'

,&' @4", "B"'7 '/$$"-&(+ #4, +"

&4:"(!'

;0"-" '

5"!&!&#("-

$ !0"-&(4 ;7 +", B" -'7

%0-#(&% 8&,("B 5 !&"(!

,& 4B'&'

!0-&%"

;""8*

"!&!&#("- #*

: --&", '&'!"-&(4 ;

#6"-(:"(!

" %0"-

'&(%"

: --& +"

D7 '0"

-"'&,&(+

0#:"

4##8&(+ $!"- !;# :&(#- %0&4,-"(*

# #!0"- 4"+ 4 5#&(!

;#-!0 %#('&,"- !&#( "&!0"-

/-+", #- 5-"''", 5 -!&"'*

0/'7 ;0&4"

'/::&(+ &!7 0"4,

5/-"

,&'5/!"

@"!;""( ;&$"7 +&6"(

%#4#/- 5-#%"",&(+'

'# -#5"

0 54"''

5 -"(!'&(4 ;

: --&", '&'!"-&(4 ;*

0"B

-#5", #@4&9/"

:#!&6"

0 - ''

:"(! 44B

!#-!/-"

!0":*

#-"#6"-7 4"6"4",

6 +/"7 +"("- 4 #:(&@/'

( !/-"

5"-

C/,+:"(!'

#(?@4"

5"H #/-!7 -"4&",

-"$"--", @#6"7

5-#%"",&(+'

9/ 5"!&!&#("-'7 (#!0&(+7 @/!

%4" - @/'"

5-#%"''

4 ;*

( 6&";

@#6"7 5"!&!&#( 44#;",*

&:5/+(",

%#:54 &(!K

'/::#(&(+

#-,"-

, !",

* * %#('"9/"(!& 4 5-#%"",&(+'

-&'&(+ !0"-"$-#:7

9/ '0",7 9/ 5"!&!&#("-'*

* *

! "!

<0"!0"- -" '#(",G'5" 8&(+M

"'G#

<0"!0"- -"5#-! @4"M

"'G#