High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18073/2022dismissed

Jatinder Kumar Through Lrs Swapnil v. Haryana Urban Development Authority And Others

2023-05-24Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj12 pages

"#$%&%

)* ) *

+*( , )% (#- *( % )+ )%

% ....

+ )%

/ %0 *1 ! "#$%%$%% &'

( )

((! * & + (,- ./ %$%" !0 ./#1 %$%" "%$#%$$2 &' . ( )

( .0 ) * & +. (,- 3 ' 4 5 6 7 0 8 9 5 %:$%"22% .12 %#&0 .%"/ %2 .%/2; 1$$1"22% ! #2%2:< %"$#$$;$87 1##87

< /"$$$87 ' !0 ' 0 0! 1#', %#= 0 !/#=0&0$2 !0 0& ! 0 > ? & @ &' & ' < ! A & < %# .%"/

%2 7 0

."%% !"$$$< %2 .%"/ %2B).;1 $#$""221 ! > & "2$C"22$ !%$$$< %#8%2& 0 0 0& &! %:$%"22% %# & >0 ! ."%% %20 0 !& 0 .%"/& !! 0 &'

& ) ( ) A * & +) A ,- ! C$;87 < !

1##87 < 0 & > 0 '

%# ' & 1##87 < ! & < ' '0 & &' 7 B)*0B -0 & 0 ? ! !& ( ( & ! ) A > 0

0 < & /#= 0 $2 & ' <@ 8 ! !0

00 0B0 0 ! 0 < & /#= .#%/$ ":$;"22C ! $2D$1 %$ '@

! 00 ! "$$""22# ! 0 .":%"7%%"$$%"22#> ! <0&&' ! %# %2?!@ !& $""""22# ! 0 %#! ! ' < 0 0 & >0 &

' 0 ! %2 "2$C"22$0 %28%#3 00 ."%% %20 0@ !$#$""221 0 .%"/ %2 < 4 0 > 0

0 & &! @

' & @ ' $2D$1 0 ! ' !

& &! ! ! & &

0 &' ) A "#$#%$$" @ & 7 1##87 < 7B) !' 8 * -

7B) 0 ' E "%= 4 A $2 0 !

& ' !@0 0

!! 7B) .%22#7%$$"*B F-8 38""1C8%$$;& ( (! 7B)*0B - 0 0&' (0&

& &'( B $:$#"22C %#= 0 1#' & /#=0 $2B0 & ."%% %2 G

0 &' ( @ ! * @(7"C-0 "$$%"22#! C$;87 < 1##87 < 0 >0 <%#= &01#' & /#=0$2 0& C%%#;;$870&' "1$1"22# %#= ! 0 &'

$;$C"22#* @(7";- 0 ' 0 & ! H0! "$$""22# ! C$;87 < < & .0! & '0 ! ! & /#= 0 > 0 0 ' B 0 < 00 ! "$$%"22# !

0 ! ' !

G ) A 0

! ' & (0 ! &' ."#;: %$$2& . ( ) ( .0 ) "%$#%$$2 &' 0 !B 0 ! ! 0?! ! 0 < & 0 & & .0! &' . ( ) ( .2/# %$"2 "2""%$"2 !

"$I ' &' . ( .0 ) ( (! "#" (( ?! "1$"%$$2 .%22#7%$$"*B F-8 38""1C8%$$; & ! 0 0 ! 7B ' ' 0 ( ) ( "1$"%$$2 & ) A & & 0 &' B 0 ' & !

! ! &' & & 0 &' ( (! >0& 8! & '00&'( ?! 0 & !@ 0 ' & . ( .0 ) 0 !0 ! ' < >0 <& %$' ! ! "$I ' "%$#%$$2 &' .

(0 ' ' 0 & 00 0 $/$2%$%" 0 .2/# %$"2 0 ./#1 %$%" ?! (! . ! ?! & $/$2%$%" ./#1 %$%" 0 && & ' $/$2%$%".

0 .$/ %$%"0&' "#$%%$%% ( ! 0 & "#$%%$%% .$/ %$%"0 ./#1 %$%" !0 "%$#%$$2&'. (.0)

J ' ! <

0 ! %#8%2 %2

& & ! &"2$C"22$ %28%# & 0 ! %$$$ < ' & 0 0 &< 0 &%:$%"22%0 0 !"$$$ < ' %# & &! &

%2 ! "2$C"22$ 0 ( 8A 8( 0 &! 0&< !& 0& ((! 0 . ( .0 ) & ! !0 0& ! "%$#%$$2&'. (.0 ) ! 0 ! B,& (

#$ %

($' & ! &# )** # +%' %, ' '-0 B,& ( ' ( ) ( & 0 & 0 B!( B 0 ' & !! ' ' ! J* J

- ' & B,& ( '' B!( > ! ! & 0 & &!0 0&' B,& ( B0 0 & @0 & ! '> ' '& &0 @ ' "$I ' &' ( 0 . ( > 0 &

&' 7B ' "222 .2/# %$"2 0 ' %$ ' ! 0 ' 0 0 ' & ( & . (.0) ) '!& ! ! & . ( .0 ) ! ' ! & > & 0 & ? &' & 0 0 0 ' & ' & 0 '

?%#=

! %2 & 3' & ' & 0 B0 !0 ! ' & ) A ' &' 0 0 0 0 0

1##87 < %2 C/$87 < %# '

'0 %20 '!! !& C$;87 < %2 ! 0 ' @ 0 0 &< ' J (

' @ ' "$I' ! .2/# %$"2 ?! &' ( ! '!&0 &' ( $/$2%$%"0 0 .$/ %$%"0 0 $/$2%$%" .2/# %$"2 & ! !

0 .$/ %$%"./#1 %$%"0 0 ?!

((! .2/# %$"2 ?! !

! ' "$I' ' &!?0 ' &!

'& 0 A ! & 0 0 &

! @ ' !( ! '& > ! 0 ' 0 &' 7 ' ! "2$C"22$ 00 0 &' 0 ! &' <0 0 & & !!< "2$C"22$ &' < > ! 0 &' ( & %2$C%$$2 7 ' & &

< ' 0 '&' ' !

< & 0 "22#

7 >0 &

!0 & >0! '&

7' ' 0 & 0 !!

0 0 &

< ! < ' ?! @ '&&'B! ( &' 7B & ' 0 &! ! & 4

0' ' &

! & @ ' ! 0 ! ! ! ? &'0' ! '0 0 G ' & 0 ' ( 0 ' & ! 0! ( &' ! 7 0 0

! (< ' ! !! *+ )%

1 $2(3/ .