High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20782/2016dismissed

Gram Panchayat Manesar v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2017-02-27Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan6 pages

#$% &%'()(*+

!+ , -!.. - , -!. .. /%)%*$+ !//0*#(*1.%*(/&2'#$%3($4 !/.0*(5.4#/6#1&2'#$% /$4%7%$($(*%/ !/#/)488#/3#51&2'#$% /$4%'#2%#$/9 /%)7*&%*$: #;%)4 (*&#5 /#6 #*'4#<#$1 !#*%)#/ 4#) (5%& $4% 7/%)%*$ 7%$($(* '4#55%*8(*8$4%/&%/&#$%& =**%>0/%9 ?" !/ /0* #(*1 5%#/*%& )%*(/ '0*)%5 #77%#/(*8 / $4% 7%$($(*%/ )0@6($$%& $4#$ $4% 2%/*6%*$ 2(&% /&%/ &#$%& :

**%>0/%9"7%/6($$%&$4%/#6#*'4#<#$$%>'4#*8% ?#'/%) 5#*& 3($4#/<#*#.$#$%*&0)$/(#5#*&* /#)$/0'$0/% %2%576%*$/7/#$(*

/)4/$1,$4%/7/#$(*,"4%# /%)#(&/&%/3#)'4#55%*8%&134%/%$4% &% (*($%)$#*&$#A%*@<$4%/#6#*'4#<#$3#)$4#$($4#&'*)%*$%& / %>'4#*8%134('43#) /$4%@%*% ($ $4%/%)(&%*$) $4%#/%#2%*$4% )$#*&$#A%*@<$4%/7/#$(*(*$4%/%75<(*$4#$7%$($(*3#)$4#$$4%<4#& '*)%*$%&$$4%%>'4#*8%4%3/($7%$($(*3#)&()6())%&#)(* /0'$00)

*: #)$4%/#6#*'4#<#$4#&/%2A%&$4%%#/5(%//%)50$(* #77/2(*8%>'4#*8% 5#*&* ?1$4%/#6#*'4#<#$ #8#(* 7#))%&/%)50$(*#77/2(*8%>'4#*8% 5#*&-%#/*%&'0*)%5/% %//%&$ $4%/%)50$(*7#))%&*: ? $4%#*'4#<#$) *%(84@0/(*8 2(55#8%)%*&/)(*8$4%%#/5(%//%)50$(*$4#$#4)7($#5#*&8(/5)'55%8% )405&@%'*)$/0'$%&(*$4%#/%##*&$4%/#6#*'4#<#$)405&%>'4#*8% $4% 5#*& 3($4 $4% /7/#$(* B(&% /&%/ &#$%& C ?1 $4% 2%/*6%*$'#*'%55%&($)%#/5(%//&%/&#$%&: 4%# /%)#(& /&%/3#)'4#55%*8%&@<$4%7%$($(*%/@< (5(*8C :

34('4 3#) &%'(&%& *

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

$4%0*;#@B(55#8%66*-#*&)%805#$(*"05%)1 ?C#)#775('#@5% $$4%.$#$% #/<#*#"1($3#))0@6($$%&$4#$$4%66($$%%4#& #(5%&$ '*)(&%/$4%)0@)%D0%*$/%)50$(*)7#))%&@<$4%/#6#*'4#<#$134('4 %*&/)%& $4% (*($(#5 /%)50$(* /%8#/&(*8 %>'4#*8% 5#*& #) ($ 3#) @%*% ('(#5 /$4%(*4#@($#*$) $4%2(55#8%4%(6708*%&/&%/&%)*$

: &%#53($4$4%)($0#$(*#)%*2()#8%&(*05%= $4%05%)4(/&7#/$< /(84$)3%/%'/%#$%&&0/(*8$4%7%*&%*'< $4%5($(8#$(*134('4'#**$4#2% #*<%

%'$* #'$1$4%/%2%*0%%*$/(%)4#&#5)@%%*'4#*8%&)$4%/#6 #*4'4#<#$4#& 7#))%& $4% /%)50$(*$ '*)$/0'$ #4)7($#5#*& 8(/5) '55%8%*$4%%>'4#*8%&5#*&134('43#) /$4%@%*% ($ (*4#@($#*$)

$4%2(55#8%1$4%(6708*%&/&%/@%)%$#)(&%#*&%>'4#*8%@%#77/2%& *$4%$4%/4#*&15%#/*%&'0*)%5 /$4%'#2%#$/9/%)7*&%*$ :)0@6($$%&$4#$# $%/$4%6#$$%/3#)/%6($$%&@#'A@<$4()0/$1$4% 66($$%% '67/()(*8 /(*'(7#5 .%'/%$#/(%) $4% %7#/$6%*$) '*'%/*%&1!#*#8(*8 (/%'$/ $4%/7/#$(*#*& (/%'$/1 %7#/$6%*$ *&0)$/(%) #*& 66%/'%1 3#) '*)$($0$%& .#/7#*'4 B(55#8% #*'4#<#$1!#*%)#/3#)#5)/%D0%)$%&$#$$%*&$4%6%%$(*84%6#$$%/ 3#) '*)(&%/%& $4/%#&@#/% *$('(*8 #55 $4% #'$) $%/ '#*'%55#$(*

%>'4#*8%1$4%/7/#$(*4#&'#/2%&0$8/0740)(*8)($%)*$4%#/%#1 %2%* $4% #55$6%*$) 4#2% #5) @%%* 6#&% #*& * $3 75$)1 %2%* '*)$/0'$(*()'675%$%4%/%()*7/7)#5 /'*)$/0'$(* 4)7($#5 /'55%8%(*$4%#/%#1#))088%)$%&@<$4%.%'/%$#/(%) %7#/$6%*$) '*'%/*%& * #'$1 $4% 7/'%)) / %>'4#*8% )$#/$%& 3($4 # 75($('#5 @#'A8/0*&# $%/ 0*&#$(*)$*%3#)5#(&@<$4%$4%*4(% !(*()$%/* $4%5#*&@%5*8(*8$$4%/7/#$(*4%/%()*6%/($(*$4%7/%)%*$ 7%$($(*14%*'%1$4%)#6%@%&()6())%& *0/7(*(*160'44()$/< $4%'#)%()*$/%D0(/%&$@% 8(2%*#)$4%/%4#&@%%*&(

%/%*$/%)50$(*)@<$4%/#6#*'4#<#$%($4%/ /%)52(*8$%>'4#*8%$4%5#*&3($4$4%/7/#$(*/'#*'%55(*8$4#$*%

#'$134('44#&'6%*/%'/&1()$4#$$4%%*$(/%7/'%))

5#*&)$#/$%&34%*$4%$4%*4(% !(*()$%/4#&5#(& 0*&#$(*)$*% /#

C 4)7($#5 * = $%/ $4% (*($(#5 %>'4#*8% 5#*&1 $4% 6#$$%/ /%6#(*%&(*5($(8#$(*(*#55<1$4()'0/$2(&%/&%/&#$%&

C)%$ #)(&%$4%/&%/&#$%& C ?'#*'%55(*8$4%%#/5(%//&%/7#))%&@<$4% 2%/*6%*$7%/6($$(*8%>'4#*8% 5#*&@<$4%/#6#*'4#<#$3($4$4% /7/#$(*#*&/%6($$%&$4%6#$$%/@#'A //%'*)(&%/#$(*$3#)(*$4% 3/($7%$($(* (5%&@<$4%7%$($(*%/4%6#$$%/3#)/%6($$%&@#'A$$4% 2%/*6%*$ 4% 7%/#$(2% 7#/$ $4% /&%/ 7#))%& @< $4() '0/$ () %>$/#'$%&@%53+ E.0

('%($$@)%/2%$4#$$4%D0%)$(*#)$34%$4%/$4% )0@;%'$%>'4#*8%()&%$/(6%*$#5$$4%(*$%/%)$ $4%2(55#8%/)/ 34%$4%/$4%)0@;%'$%>'4#*8%4#)5)$($)0$(5($< /$4%70/7)%

/34('4($3#)&%'(&%&$@%%>'4#*8%&1#/%$4%$3 #'$0#5 ())0%) 34('4 '#* @% %

%'$(2%5< /%)52%& @< $4% .$#$% 2%/*6%*$(*'*)05$#$(*3($4$4% %7#/$6%*$)'*'%/*%& %6#<4#)$%*$#&&$4#$$4%D0%)$(* )%$$(*807#'55%8%

#55)3($4(*$4%#6@($ &0'#$(* %7#/$6%*$134(5%$4%)($%

/ )%$$(*8 07 # 4)7($#5 4#) $ @% &%'(&%& @< $4% %#5$4

%7#/$6%*$ 4% *&0)$/(%) %7#/$6%*$1 * $4% $4%/ 4#*&1 305&@%$4%&#5 %7#/$6%*$$/%7/%)%*$$4%2(%37(*$

(*&0)$/(#53/A%/)$346$4%)($%) /'*)$/0'$(* $4% &3%55(*80*($)*%%&$@%7/2(&%&@<#3%5 #/%.$#$% *)%D0%*$5<#*& /$4%/%#)*)# /%)$#$%&3%)%$#)(&% $4%2%/*6%*$/&%/&#$%& C$4 %'%6@%/1 ?**%>0/%9

" /$4%5(6($%&70/7)%$%*#@5%$4%.$#$%2%/*6%*$$ $#A% #* #77/7/(#$% &%'()(* # /%)4 * $4% @#)()

/%'66%*&#$(*) $ @% 6#&% @< $4% 66($$%% '67/()(*8

= /(*'(7#5.%'/%$#/(%) %7#/$6%*$) &0'#$(*1%#5$4 #*&*&0)$/(%)$3(55@%#77/%'(#$%&( $4%66($$%%4%#/$4% /#6#*'4#<#$ #*&$4%. /#*<$4%/)$#A%45&%/ @% /%6#A(*8($)/%'66%*&#$(*)$$4%.$#$%2%/*6%*$ 4%%*$(/%%>%/'()%)4#55@%0*&%/$#A%*#*&$4% (*#5&%'()(* )4#55@%$#A%*3($4(*#7%/(& :6*$4) /6$4%&#$%

/%'%(7$ '%/$( (%&'7< $4()/&%/(55$4%*1@$4$4%7#/$(%) )4#556#(*$#(*)$#$0)D0F 4% 66($$%% '*)()$(*8 /(*'(7#5 .%'/%$#/(%) $4%

%7#/$6%*$) &0'#$(*1%#5$4#*&*&0)$/(%)G!#*#8(*8 (/%'$/ $4% /7/#$(*#*& (/%'$/1 %7#/$6%*$ *&0)$/(%)#*&66%/'%13#) '*)$($0$%&/$4%6%%$(*81*$('%3#)())0%&$$4%.#/7#*'4 $4% 7%$($(*%/9/#6#*'4#<#$*$4%(6708*%&/&%/&#$%& =17#))%& @<$4%2%/*6%*$1($3#)*$('%&$4#$$4%/7/#$(*4#&#5/%#&</%9 75#**%&$4%#/%##*&'/%#$%&$4(/&7#/$</(84$)@<#55$$(*8)($%) /8/07 40)(*8)'4%6%)2%*'*)$/0'$(**)6% $4%75$)4#&@%%*'#//(%& 0$)/%8#/&)$4%(*$%/%)$ (*4#@($#*$) $4%2(55#8%1($3#)*$('%&$4#$ $4%/%4#&@%%*'* 5('$(*8/%)50$(*)7#))%&#$&(

%/%*$$(6%)1#77#/%*$5< *#''0*$ 2(55#8%75($(')4%/7/#$(*4#&3($4&/#3*($)'*)%*$

5#*&4%%>'4#*8% 5#*&3#)#553%& /$4%70/7)%

'*)$/0'$(* 9@%&4)7($#5134('44#)*%($4%/@%%*'*)$/0'$%&*/ $4%/%()#*<7/7)#5 $4%2%/*6%*$$'*)$/0'$$4%)#6%#$$4%)($% *)(&%/(*8 $4%)% #'$)1 $4% %#/5(%/ /&%/ &#$%& : #77/2(*8 %>'4#*8% 5#*&3($4$4%/7/#$(*()'#*'%55%& *)(&%/(*8$4%# /%)#(& #'$0#56#$/(> #'$)1#)*$('%& (*$4%(6708*%&/&%/13%&*$ (*&$4#$$4%)#6%)0

%/) /6#*<

(55%8#5($< /$4%/%#)*)6%*$(*%&#@2%1$4%3/($7%$($(*()&()6())%& #;%)4 (*&#5"

0&8% #/(*&%/.(*84.(&40"

0&8%

6A 4%$4%/)7%#A(*8H/%#)*%&+

%)H 4%$4%//%7/$#@5%+

%)H