Parminder Singh v. State Of Punjab And Another




   
 


 

 



  !"#"

 $ #%& 

"' "

 

 !"#$%&'(# $#& !

) $

"(

)*** "+, -$  ' * )*.#"

.#"

/+***+ #%&* )*/0

+, -$ "'  *1* $#& !

) $$
*+
"  '   "  &  $/  #  -   341  * '5 $ 6#"

 $  *774187*4*1789#- "379+ 3:4 
 " /- ; +"- /// "#&"6#  ' - "  " $       &""  $ - ' "<"/*

6#" 0"  "&5- '/ "'   *1      ,"    - -   *   0,+  0 ,  $"'-&/"+$//5 '","/

5" /, ""'#+0 "''$  - ' "*  &"" $ "+ ' ", =  ' 0 $

" #&5'5 - #  $ "' - "0 #/& $#/>-"&#" $' -"" $  # #"+  6#" // "#&"6#' - "" $ 5& 6#"

 " $%#"-*

 " #, "81*1*1717- '" ''  &$     /   #<
//6  ) "  $   -   ""+  "  -   &$      #      /   #<
//6 ) "0"/" - ""' *
'#"#-  "+/)
+ /" '  84*?*1717  " #*; ' "

"/" >  /  ""  $  - '/  %  .#+  --#"<' 




#

-  81*?*1717*  &"" $ ""+/)
+ / "- -/# ' 

''"  '" , - ' ", /#/5       "      --#"      '"  -"     ' <--#" " &-/  -/ $$ "-"*
 , /- #"/$  '"+'#" -   ' "&5/)
+ /* &'#"/ $"# 5' ,"  $ 341* **0 #/ "

0  

 #5="#-  "+"5&-""5

,$$- 5 # "   ',&#" $ ' -""

$5 #  0" "-# " $%#"-*- ?17* "6#//5/,$ - " +0 '"-&" ' -#$  - ' #  $  $$-"# 
 / * .' ,0 # $ $$-"// /5-   $- & '" ,-&/5"/ "'#+ - #  $-/' "-# 0 #/&$#/>-"*  @&/ #' ##& $-""-/# 
 



  



 B.S.Joshi and

others ,"State of Haryana ,-*


.&/0*1/*

$ // 0&5 " # #//- -" $2/+3,*&4-, -*5&6/78,-*9


  ,/ 0 ' ' " , /, '"-""/ /0*  $+ @&/#' #Gian Singh :State of Punjab and another
  &/0*1/*

$# / 0 ""# //0"/&5 #' #$ 6#"

$ State of Haryana :Bhajan Lal9

&/00
&

*

98 $ %# ""#(







 

  







 




 

 
 

  
  

 !

  


"





#

 







   


 


  
 
 
   



$


%&'




 

 








  (









 "



 




 


 


  )*
+ ,


 
#

-

+

,


 



 


(

 


 
 
  
  

   
 !
(

"

 



 








 
    





 

 

 



  (


  
 -
 
"





-

 








 
 

(


 
 



  
 

 

(



.
-
 -


(-
 


 

 (
 



 



 

/


(










 
$




  

 




   

 ( $ 

 (-
(
   


 

 






.

 





 

 

.
0






1 


 


(








 .




 

(-
 *


  
 
( 

 
 
  
   

 


 
2 
  

 
   (
 3  

 (
 

  




 



 





 -


 (




  
   -
   -


-
 

-
  



.
 







 
   (  



 (-
 




(





 





(
  



 
 




 








 


  (

 -
 


(
 
  
   


 -  


   


 



 

-




(

  







 .
 






  
 
  
 
 

 



# 

"


#


  
  

 
(


 

  
 






  



   






 





  -

 







 

  
  

 (




#









  
  








  

  
  
  
 

 


 





   


 

 



  

 


 
#

-

    

  
 






 

 


+ ,



 

-

 

 








#

 


 

  

  4 ''/5 /0"/&5 @&/#' #'/  $%# " "

 #+"'' 0  '" ,  - ' "+ - #  $ ' - "0 #/& /5&#" $' -"" $  #&5// 0 --'

'5 $ ' "&56#"

0 #/&"-# " $ %#"-+0 "'/5  &%- $ / "/#- # - 341* ""#/+ " #$"  -" "6#/5$//"

0  &'""/&5%#-/'-" -+

 *774187*4*1789#- "379+3:4 
 "

/- ; +"- /// "#&"6#' - "

" $     6#"

  6#    '       &""  $  - ' "*

/"" "5  '""

//& #&5 "-  " $ - ' " ""-  &$  - #&/ 0*

 ""// 0* 
 $#& !

) $    $%;#



  /#-=5 ;

"'= <" ( "< ;

 ' &/( "<