Naresh Kumar And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ANR

    

       

!"#$%#&'('$)* +,

,

 
 























 
 


 





























*  -. , / 

/.
 





 
 
 
 !"
#


$


 
%#
 !"






 
 !"



 


$!
%
&'
 
((((


/.0,

.  ) *
 
 
  



"%
++,-++.


/  

0



1 "







"




 2
0 "
/

" % 
#

2 
 + *
 
 
  


 %
"% 




"

0
 %
2


" %

2 
 
*

% 

 %
)3)4

 $2
%"
 %
)536
7
%"2%



 8
7

9:8

3 ;%
  "



/ 
! 
 
 +<))+=)3
"
! "


 


 
*
 

+<))+=)3
 



 

 





 
 












    

!

"

  " 

#
 "


!

















 #

 






 





  $
" 
$ !


 

%

 
&!
"

 



! 






 

'
 









(   )
*





&!

"
 




  
 )
&!!

 

!

"

+ "

"
 
 !









!


*






&!
, "


&

# 
-.(

 




(   /
 

"
 $




/  (
 








!

(






0"


 '
1 
,!'
!

!
 "

"
!
( 

- 2
- ! 
,! '
*()

! !



3  

!!
 ! 
 


0
!!












!







'
!
 


  



 





$ 
 





 '
# 







""

"





!



# 


'





 !
$





!




"

!




 "

 !'
1 
,!
 "

 

  



 


 0

 

# 







  '

 !







# 






! 




 
!
 



3
! !  






!

 "!
4"


5!
3 "




   6
* )
7(8
9,
/'


 


 


 
 '
 
!
 
(



 


!

,
-
$ "
! 
 
"

$






$



--,'
*()
!



$





3


!






 











0
 !
 

$ 
!

 7(8




 




,"

 

 

 







1 
,!


 

 

0


  "







    '
$
 '

 

$

!
 
 

'
!

"

!



!




0
"


  
 
 
  
 
 '



!



 


,!
   


 

$



"

!


%:%
 
$




 

5- 





&

# -.(
  

$

!



"

!


%:%





 


&






&!
, "
 
+ "

, "
 


"

!


%:%


'

 








( 

'
'





 
  '
1 
,!
 "

 


 $



0"



5-

 

!


 
 




5


 
- ! 

;

 






 !
; '
 
5&+'
3  


 

!




 $ $ 



+
 0
 !
 

 

0
 

&$ 
+ !'
3  


1 
; 


"








; 
 


 

 !
!

(   (<

 6 >
" %
  

 
 2 



 %
)3)4






2
" %
%

%
"

!

2 


?






2
" 

"


#
"

"


 

"2


 %
0

2 "



"


 "
#


2
 %
2


2
"

2 



?


"

!

%#
 1
*
 



 1

0

 

 
>!%
@



 1

0 "
0
"



"  
2" 
 
%

0 "

 


%!%
@#
 
"


0


2 

" %
#
#
 
"
2 




 
!" "

@

1




 1

0 "
0

 
 
" 
@

 



:
!"

"   
0

%
%#


"


  
 "

"  





  

%! 





" 
*


"
%
2"1



  
 %%
  %
"


2
  %





 


" 
&

  

%! 

%%
  


 
< -


%

" %
 2 

 
#


'  
 
0


 
 


0
#
!%2%
 
 
#
 

" 
0
*
" %

2 

#"
#
!
?

2" 

"%
" %
2 
 
*
#
%

!


 %
 1
#!
" % 
2
"
2" 

 
%"1

 
!" "



 
!" "



#
" 


 %
)3)6
7+8



:
!
!"

A 

 
*
2 

" % 
2
"  
# 
!
!"
, 0
!

%
" %





 

"
#

2%
 "
. @

 %

"


 

2
 



 

" 



"

 






 
#
 %

2
"




!%2%

 
!" "
#
 

"% 


#
 %

2
"




" %

2 
 4  %
)3)4


%
#
2
#"

 " 
2%#
 





 

 &!!
- ! 
 




0
!!







=


$ 




"



'


 !


 '
  


    "
$ 
 
  











!







'

  




 




$ 
 

'




 '
# 








""

"





!



# 





'





 !
$





!



"

!






> !



 



$ 






# 
  
  !


 "




$

!!







0




!
/)
 !
!!


!


! 
.






 !

 "

'




"

$



!
(
 
( )
5 @

 %

2!
A 
 %


! 

  %

%"2%

%%
%"
"
#

 

 1
0



%"2%

%
"  "
0
! 


# % 2
#
:
2 

#"

2
?

2
 

 
*
2 



 
%"
"
"


2





" %

 %

?

2 


/  
 


"

2 

!
 
!




 "

 1
)= 

B "

 :2%
  
/ 

  



   !"#$$%&'%(%

%

A 

"  

2
 $ "

"" "
#
%  


  
%


%"2%
 %

*
/ 
 



% 

"


 


2


" 

*
/ 

%
 ? 

@







$ 
2

 '
 

 


! ""


!$ $ 
! '



2. 








 '
    

$




 
 
 
!








 
!



 $ 
!


! 


 



  

 

# 



!









  
  "
 
# 





 








# 


'










 




"

 


 



 

# 





1 

!




 
 !
 


$

!


 !



#

 '

# 






#

!

$ 



 





!

#



 




 





$





#



# 





 



 # 



 










! 
!



 '
 "


!
# 


'




@

  



 

!




"










"

 











 
 '
$


# 



# 
  





















@ 
 '







$



 !
 

 



# <
)) 
/   "





) *

+ ,
%-(.%#%$
 
 %
,


 $2
C " %
!"
7! "%
/ 8
/%
000
 %
)5,)

*
 %
 %




2
%%
2
 




%


2 %%

?"


*
/ 
 
%


"% 


!"
#
" 
2






%! 
 %

#%%

  
%

 %

  "

 
 

" 
*
/ 

% 
?*
 !


!



# 





 
'
*/'



"



 !
 


 

$  






0




"












 






 

"
 
 $ 

!



# 





'


2 









  !
 
*/('
 
!!




 


!


! ! "

 
 
!!


  '
*/ 

!
 

@ 







! !
 

 









 

!!

"




 

"
 


$  .!

 "





!



 
'
*/'
 

3 "
 "!
 
  

 



  "




$  .!



 
    '

3 "
 "!
!



 


 $







 "



"



 






!






"'

!

 

$






!!

"








 
'
*/?

)+

*   * /  0 

 1

 1

0 ,  !,!    , +"#$%-&%'%2'
  
/ 
 !

 %
)=<

&%
"%
C "
 %
)5.3

*

 %
%
#
2


"


%

 %
)=<

)5.3
 %
 
 D)=<
-

7 8
A$ 
!


!!'

 !


 '











 


# 




"








 





$!

5 



$  

!




 
  

 


"







0
 





!

'


"

 


'

'





"


'
 

=

-

$ 




$


 .

!

! "






$!


5 

" 


#







+


 !!


!


 
 !









!=

8




0
 





!




"






 



 

'

!!



# 




# 






'
  





 






# 

 


?
 :2%
  
/ 
!
 

&%

/ 


%



 %
)=<
7+8

)5.3
 %

 %


#1 
2

2





2
"

%


%
 

"

 

*
/ 

%  )


 "






 
!





 

 

!$ !



 
!  !



 

 
 




$ '






$ 
 !
 

$  















!


 








"



   $







,!
7 8

 !  





"







 

 


 







 " 
$ 


!

!




















$ 



# 



" $


#

! ""

,!
7 8


$ '




$ 






 !!


  !









$ 

3 "
 



! "








 


$  












 # 






<
)3


 
"

 
#
 


" 
0
! 
 

=3=++==)
#"
 

2=.

-

 0






- ! 
1 =.


 !!

"
&

 






A<
 
 


$


   "






- ! 
"


# "


$  

0
B "

$ 



 !
! 

--,
( 


 !!
0








"


 



"

 
!

"



 
 




 


"


  =.
 
, 0'
;
C
;


5-
 :



&
& 0
B '
;

 )D,,

 

44,
!!



&

- 0 '
;

/ D,,

 

B;9
3 4 (
&
E
,'
;



D,,

 

-
5 )
&
; 
B '
;

 D&

 

--
5 


 !!

2





3

F!
3 "

>-
;

( (

 !

&

- 0 
 

GD


3  


!

! !





 






  




<
)6
 


 
1

"%




 



 
#
"

2 
 
*

 


"2 
 
"


#
"

2 
 
 %
)3)4



"2 ?


:
2 
 
*


!

? 






" "% 

 %

?

2 


/  
 

 


"

2 

!
 
*


"



 




 

"

" 

"
2
/  
 


"

"

"%
" %
2 
 
0

2 "


"

 
"

 

"!
2
$



 :2%
  
/ 

   ! " & 

*

 " &
*



#
 

"  




" %

2 
 
*





 
 
 
 %
#"
! 

"
# %
2
 2$"

!%2%

 

* 



 %
"2 

"
# %
2
 2$"

!%2%

 







"

 2$"

!%2%

 



%
2"1



" %

2 
 
/

0


 
>!%
 


%%
2%

"
2#
#
 %%
  "
 "

2 
 
0


 
2
" "
%


 %%
 
0
#1 

 
 
)<
*



 

" 

 
#
 


/ 

 %
)3)6


#"
! 

 

%"
 
 %
)3)6
 

 

  

01



  1 .

7 8
-



$

!

"



.



!!





 
- ! 


&

 


 '
+ $

 
, !
- ! '

$   


 !






 


 
 



 !
! 
 !
( 

8
;

.



!!




! " !




!

"


 !




! 
 "


%


$
$ 

 

 '

 

! 
 $
!!
$
 0
.



'

 !





"!
   
 
  

 !
 "


 ! 






!



 
;

.












'

"
 '



  


$
$ 


 '
!!

! " !






!

"


A#


 !




!
 










.+ !
 "

 " 
$ 
 
#! 




7(8
.








)
!

"


!!







 



$ 
  


!
  !


 "



"


# 








 !

 
#!   



    =

-

$ 


  



'



 

 '
# 







""

"
 





 
 


"'


# 

# 



 !
$





"


#

"

!


<
),
@

 %

 %
)3)67+8







%"2%




%"
 
*

'!


! 
 

+5=6)54.

 
#


%"
 

 %

' 

/


&
*
"

'!


 


+5=6)54.





 % 

0

 

%"


%
2% 

' 
/

"%
%"
 
 %
)3)67+8


A 

:
!
!"



 2 


#"

%
!

 %
2


 1

0
*


 "


 

2
%"2%

%"
 
#!
  / 
 3   

 +"#$#%&%(-%

"%

"




:
!
!"

%"2%






0

0 "

'!


 


+5=6)54.

!#



$




  
/ 
0
"
"%





:
!
!"



 2 
#"

 "% 
!



 1

0
*
 
# %
2
 %



" % "




















 "

 
"2


 %
)3)6

#%%

 %
)3)<


*
/ 


 

"



#
"

 % 

%2%

 




0 "
0 
2

/ 

#
"



"


 

0
#"



#
 2!
).


#1

2!
" 






/ 



"  
 



 %
)3)4



 
%%
2


2
"




" %

2 
 
*



%%



 
#
"

"


" A  %
2 


 
#




 
)4
*  


2!
 
)5



%" 78

 
%%
%







/.
 

+,

,

 Prince Chawla ;
1 - E-
;
2%
E-