Vipan Kumar Ralh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab And Another
""
! !
!
## $ ! % &'
""
!# (! # !"#$%&'" #"%
#
!#! )"
*#+ !! ( ,-(. / !% * + -(. / !% !! !
#+ * + !! $0 -(( +++- &'+ * +0.&,$0 -(. / !% !# (! +1+ #"%
##)* # ! # '!! % !( (!
$!/ 341 ,0% 5# 0 % +678( !(9+66+1:67(!
$!/ #374"- 3:;-<:; !0# !
!(
/!$ - , -# /
0=
!#'#!5! /!!(0# #0 !% !'## % / #!( !(6;+3+1:16>!? "1@+
5!# =#0 !0# !
!(',/ "
!# (! +1 ( ! .!# 0 / !/!( ! + =!.!
- = !
.! % !#!/ '
!#-%
!#
.!( #!
!! (
!, !# .!( !
#!(# !-= # ! % !/ #!+ !'## % !#!- !! !
# !. A0 ! ! =!
%
', ,0 / % !#! /!!(0#= ('! % !!?!
/#!('#! % /!## % ( #- 5!# (
!#'#!5! /!!(0# #0 !% ,'!
5# !( ! !
!# %&# /!+
.(! (!
#( !(11+4+1:11( !/ !( !# ! '!% !
5*0# !B ,*0# !% !/ (0
# !! #-#/ !(!('!% ( !
5*0# !B , *0# !=# # ( !/ !( #!( # ! #/! !#!- ! !(*- #! #
! ( !(16+7+1:11 +C ! # # !?!(
0 # !! # %/ # !! -& # !! % //#!(B! !
#
($ & $0
!/ (!( 86+4+1:11 0 = # !! % $ (!
$0 !/ (!( 69+7+1:11+ !'## % !# !! #- ! !(*- # / / (!( ! ! # !# .!! !
!( / #!.
,( !# //#!( !#! /#! ( ! !
#B//#!( .! '!! (!/ !(
/ !( %%!(!
#/#!+ .! ! ( ! !(/ #!
% !#-!
#!( !/ ( ! #! ', ! !(*- ' !!
# %# , .# % !341 ++= = !0 ,A!#/ (!
#-#,'!!/!## 0.!!%%!/ , (!
(!
# (! !.! '#! % /!## %, =#! #!/ !!(# %&# /!+$!/ 81: #!5
!. % / #(!
-= !#/ '!# /!( !%
/ (0 % ! %%!/!#(!
!( ! (!+ !!0.!= ! ! % %%!/!#
!0!( ,/ !( ( !%/ '
!# .!/'
,#!
!( (# !- / %/ #!/ = ('!% !!?!
/#!+ ! D'
$ !! '!
%/#!#/ (0
B.S.Joshi and others .#State of Haryana +,)
-%./)0.) 1 %
=!(',
!/ /#! %2.*3+)%4,+ ,)5%6.78+,)9
1
.!(!
= # .
.!( !#! /#!(#!
!( =+ !% !
- D'
!$ !! Gian Singh :State of Punjab and another %./)0.) %
(!
= !##!( !!
!
=#!
!(', !$ !! % 5# 0 % State of Haryana :Bhajan Lal9;;%.//%
;6 % !&(0! !(##(!
)"
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
-
(
/
(
$
( $
(-(
.0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4
,0 =#!
!(', D'
!$ !!
%&(0! #( #0 - # ! = ! !# .!
! !
!( / #!- !/ % /!!(0#= ('!
!
,'#! % /!## % (',
=0(//! 0 ,!
% !! !
#',5# 0 = ('!#!/ 0 !!(# % &# /!-= # ! '&!/ % !0# !!/ 0(!
$!/ 341 # !# - %(# !/#! (#5 ,%
= !' ( ! !
##!
!(',&(/ !/!(! #( !/!-
+678( !(9+66+1:67(!
$!/ #374"-3:;-<:; !0# !
!(
/!$ - , -# / (
!#'#!5! /!!(0# #0 !% !5# !(5 !! !
# !'## % !/ #!+ !!( !## #, !##
!' (',
! !
#(/ ( # % !/ #!( # !! # !/ (!( '!% !/ '!
=+
! # (#
=!(+ #"%
# #$ <"
/A, #!A0B !# !() !#B ! '
!) !#B