High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15608/2018dismissed

National Institute Of Pharmaceutical Education And Research (Niper) And ANR v. Chairman Board Of Governors Niper Mohali And ORS

2018-09-12Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh11 pages

!$%&%"'

(

)!* +,

(

- . + )

)/

!"

#$

% ! &!

'!

%"!

! (!

)* ( !% ! &% # %!

+

!

**,-**.

& / "

01 )23,*3)4! -.& #$

)

1 )+3,*3)4 ! -*

#$

*

"

+

$ #

/ )23,*3)4 ! -,

#$

)* " "

.+

6 #$

+&

# " $ " #$ $

(

* 5

7

89 ) *

"" )2,*3)4 ! -. " *

+ " "

# "

&

"

)

( & &

#

!

" " &

#

$

*#$ +

!

$

( $ " "

!% < "

$ " "

+= 01 &

&

$

"

#

"

* $ "& " * #

"

"

= (

+ #$ " )23,*3)4&

$ 2

)+3,*3)4& '

*3)>

+"

" < " #

+

1 "

" #

*>3,*3)4#$

)*

1

)+3,*3)4*))? $ $#

#$

+ > ;)23,*3)4*)+* " "#$ $

"

#$

+ *+2>

*

)23,*3)4 ! -.

"

+ , $ #$

) * #( & '

#

# #

)

*

& $ $!

)2=# %

*33+

8) 0 !

19$

"

#$" = &

)2 % *33+ !

& "

&

= @#$

= "$

=

#

#

$ @

& #$ $

=

#

# $

#$ & '

& &

""

#$

" " $

'

#

& !

0

"#$

!)??4!

&

&'"

= & .*

" )*)**3). "'

$

& "

* #$ "

)

(

!)??4!

"

*+) %!

)?,> 23

04!&5 !

)2/ %

*33+

& $ $

'

$" $

# $ &

" $ &

$

& ' " $'

$"

# !

% *> !

" $ = !

!

$

! -.

& *. )?,>

& "

* '&"$#$1

'

' . =

'

)23,*3)4! -. #

"

"

&

&

(

!

/ # "

#$ !

!

$=

"

$# $

"

/

(

=

0

$# '

" & 0"

$

1 .+

" *>3,*3)4 "

& # #$)>-),A *3)4

"

* $&

+

$

5 @ :

>.*3)4! -)1*

!

$- & = &

& * '

)+3,*3)4&

"

*>3,*3)4

"

#

#

=

$ #

4 < "

#

#$

"

"" "

&

$ $

& #$ # B ? = &

)

" * :

)3

)2)=# % *33+$

@

"

#$" = &

)2

% *33+& 0 # &C1 8!6%& 77+ =

$ # #$

: =

"

#$ " " & $

$ "

9 )) = #

'

$

"

#$ "

1 # #$

$#$

&

#

% && '

#$<D#

E'<" 8%9:'67 /7%&;'<!=7:

'%=!7&% :

7!*+

:

8%$!

;'$!44"7,

!447:

'< '" ;!7 8&+ / !*6 8%9:

/0>7, ?!6%& 77,

!447:

'<

7&+

1

) + +

"

#$&

"

: * :

< $ #

% & $ # #$ # #$ * : # $ " )23,*3)4! -.&

"

&

0

" *&

"$ $ "

&

;

( " <D# % ) !

;7&; 7 8&+ 0@4%$

"'$!7'

#"7 "=!7''$!

70& '<

;!7&,

A ) AB

)> + /%7'

!<% 8&+ ">>% !!

'C0%7:

'7+

3 3 ) D3DB

) !

%;7 8&+ .4 /7%&;'

<='%

;!7&,

1

) 1B

7+

4%* /0>7

!E '7+ 8&+ ) !

&&> '7+

33 )

1D '<

> 7E&;

;0 4 8&+ /'F7

;',

D ) DA+ 1+ " ).3,*3)4

* #$ @"

&

" )2,*3)4! -. & #

* & " "

& $ %!

'! % ), %

&

'

! @ *&

$

# ).,*3)4

)2)=# %

*33+$

@

"

#$"

: !

#$ )

* # ).,*3)4 # )2 "

#$

#$

+

" '

& &

#$

1 " *&

" & " 0

G H :

1

* ! "!

$ B )> % *> ! ! "!

$

1

#

)2/ % *33+ &

$

'

$ " # $ & ! "!

$ !

% *> ! ! "!

$

#

: $!

$ '

#$

#(

),

+)* % *33+

&

= 0 # &C1 80'$ %"'

'< "F!7& ;!

"7<+ % 4 !

&" & C1 #

!

!

/ "

$#

$

"

" $

& %

;

"

( ( "

$"

$

9 ). *. )?,>

" "

# !

!

$ *.) 0 # &C1 8*. "'&%<!7 %"'

**!4 )

"

!

!

$ & "

)3 " "

(

'

"$9 )4 = # "!

!

$

! -.& & & ( )? " " "

"

# !

!

$& "& & "

$

1 #

01$

!

!

$&

$1#

$ "$

+

$

.+

"

"

& #

1# = !-%

/ #

1 &

#$

"

*3 "

#$

" *

#

" : &

*& "!

&'

#$<D# !

( " #$

) !

;7&; 7,

)> + /%7'

!<%,

.4 /7%&;'

<='%+

7+

4%* /0>7

!E,

'<

> 7E&;

;0 4-& $&!&

&0*7,

# <&

! -. '

"

(

'" $

$#

! -.

# '

" * *) & #

"

#$# #

)/

)!* !>@!7

,

+ H

'"- B C I

H # I