Devender Singh Malik v. Haryana Power Generation Corporation Ltd.& ORS.


 
   

  !


   

"#"$%"&'( )    

  

  

    !" #    $ !%$&'

%()*#+,-./!+,&/ $++.

&0-$  '   1&  "  $*1&  23 1&    "

30"31&   ( 



 *   .

  "  4 3 &

567  !

3    /  

3     

3   !  1 83 

"

   95 :&

;3 
5<1   "  95 :&

;3 
7< 

  =57 :&

;3
=< 3 "2  4     
3  4

  4     "   

  

3   21 23  

1  ""3

   

     /  4  1     32

    "     " 14

  2/ & >  . 

?1 ""  "  &

 +



+ 

6 

+



    !" #  3  . " @

 
"2  AA911 


    "  2

   75 3 

 

""3

 

 3



& 

    
"2 1" "" 

!34    

!B(7?7A 5  =1

 !3  

  2

     "   .  
"2     = 4   C4 3"2 !34 

!

  &"" (9? ?43 2   

  799$ 3  1"  @



  ?9 @

3 A9



 !+6$ .1

 !#1

. 
"2  ?9    

 

 "4  "  2  4 2"  1  951 "    

"  3



 + 3"2   4  " 

3

=57  2"

 "    

 2 

  &  

           
"2 1" "" 

!34   

  "   # 3

""

 " 3    
"2    "2   3

   2  .      4  3" "    55    2    D 2    " 

3

     2       ??=1  

83 2" 

83 4   

9

 2  

 2

  2"

." 

"  95  1 
34

3  2

9

 2/

3 "

 




4   1 3 4"3 

  .  
"2  4  " 

3 2

=57 "" "3

2 1



  4  4  

 4

1 4   

  "

"   

3@3

  3" @32  4 C43"2 !3


 

    

      

 !

"

   3

  "

3

  ;  4   2 1

 

 "  22 32  

 

  

83 

62" 



1 23 4"

 ;

 

"

  /

 3   "      4   

 55  "  2  2 

"

95  1 "

 " 3 4  1

 4   A  1  3

 ""

     3 3     2   @

 3  "3 3   @32  "

 4  

!3  C43"2!3 / 1"  3

     4   +; 3  

     4



  

"

6

"



 2



"

   3       2

 "

  2 75  9/   

    "    4

  

  

  



2 3"

3 3

  "  2 75     9

1 

         " 1 2 >/$ >/$(A=A3  7?/! 

  

   2"1 



 $E >/$ (A7 

A
 593 

?917=17?/!



  

"1





" >/$(7=93 

7?1 ?91*/!



 >(1 3 1 

 

  "     2

 "

  2 =9  =9  . 1  "   4    32   

    >/$ 

 24

  2

"

  2=9=9



4 3 1

 

3   "    551 

   3   !+6&2 1  !#  2   "   3       32 &

2" 24 !  +

1@ 1  !#1  3  "  75511 

 3 

" 32 !  3 "" 755 



 "   3    55% 551

 3

 2         #   $%    #
&    '    (  ' 

/

 3    "  83   "  

1 

 

   2  55

24      . 

1  !#1  3  3

" 

1 2" 2   " 43 4  3   2.  "

  

2

3  2

 " 

1 

      "    22  75  % 551 

     

    " 3 "

2

1

 3 4  4 

2 20 ."   

"       

 "

;  51 51 95 

9
 5   "

 4

  

 ""3

   "     

1 ""  

 

"   32

 

    .   

3 

 

 "  95 

  

  "

 "    1

 

3   " ""

2@"   

 2 

/

3

 "  
"2



 "       "    1   3     

 9 /  33 4   "

4 3 2

  2  "3

  6  32   !%!(5? 7 3    3

4   "

4 C43"2!3 1

!3  ?A?4  

 4

 > 

3 1" 3 2    ;"

3

   32

83 11 ; 

1" 

 ""

2" " 1  "

  4

 "

  

  3 2 2 

 
" 3 . 1

 "

 44

4

  2  5 / 3

 "  "3  ""4.  "

 

 4 

!3

    D 2

  1 3       "

."  "33  "

95 


 

36    2   55    43  D 2   

       "

  .

  @  23  

5
 4

   !3  



3 

 



      FE    1    "@3

  

83  2" 1            4  ""   4  ;"

 4

"

 3 ."3"  



 4 2   

83  2" 

   

"

  "

 4

3 ;" 3   ' +,+" 
% ,&-,./#-,'011  )

 2)03"2!31 

  "

4 ! &2

 . 83 

"

  3   1   

 ""

  )    '

*+   +

(  '     ' '+ ''+*+ ++ ++ (     +  +    '+  '

  ,          '+ '

   *     * -            .

      

   /      ++  +%   *+ (            + 

        

'+ '

 

+ * ++ (     +' + +(   +* +    -'+    +.

 +0'+     

'+ '

       +   -'  +        +  +   +  (    +'

+  (

+  '   +  '

       (      +  %   '+ '

  

               # '+-     + 

      + -'+  '       +0 '+ ( +     + + *

(     '+  

      '         '+      * ' '+

7


  %     ( ' +   *  '    

+#+ 

 (   +  %  '   '+ '  * 1 ++# '+ '

 

+ *++ (  /        '  +% + *   +  $+  '            +  * 

(       *+     +  (      '

'  -'+  

+     

'+ '

 ++# 

  *+  ( %     2 7 /  12" 2   "  55 75543"  3 

"   32   !   3 ""   

  "  3 4 3   55% 55 1 "  3





" 32 + 3

" 

551 2" 2   243 "  3   2. 1

  

 

3 2   



4 /

 ""

      34        4 2      

83 1 43  

83    "   1   

 4         

 3

 

  " 

2"  .

"

 3 2  

3 " 43 "    "  2 "



   "2 "

4



 2     "

   51 51 95   51 "   2

"  

   2  "

       2  4 4     

  .

=
 "

  

 2

  "

  1 "  2/

4 3 1

3 "

  

 "1    4

   

1

   4

3   "  = /

"

  
 

"

  "

3  

   4 83  4 3 .

C4 3"2 !3

"3$"+,$40 /'/#+$4   "

"'3" ,'& +-"$# 5# $,6-,#-
-,'&$,/$&-,  

272  3 '

)

3  +( ''+ 

 +  4   

(4      

 %        

         % 

  (          '  +     *  * '   %     5 ' 

 
 ( +(     '   #  4  

      '  +( +

 '

 '   ( % + ' ' # % %   .

#    4   

(4   '+  '

  

+   

 + * 0   *         6%7   $   8 "9!   

!" :  "9!  ;
.

;

":
< "9! "=;>#7  ?

7 %<    8 ""@   

 ;

!> #+''%

 8



@;":
<

 ;@ ; >#'+$  %A

 +B

8

= ;

== :

=

  9 @:
<

= 

=@!>   

  %  8

@ 



9:

!  

CD ;

=> 

  3 %     A 8

; 

;

:



CD ;9 >

'';

@#' 

 

  +   ++  4  0  '       0        

?
                                 '+  

  +     %'   8 ""=  ; 

;!: ""=

CD !@9: ""=  !
.

> 

.

# +(  *        4   ++**4   ++ 

  % +      +0+ *+     * *

   '      '+  '

  1    

'+  '

        4  * 0     +    ( +  *  '     + (    6    +*+ *0      '

  * *+   +   *  +      *+ ' 

 +   +   '       +0 '+  B %  ++      +%     * /        ( +0  '

  ? ." 

 2

4    4

  D 2

" "@3

 2



2

 $1"    "   323

+ 3   3"  23

 . 32  

 4 3

   "        ""3

     1"



1   @

"2 "

515195 543  @

  /          

  "

       1  ;"

4    
"2

          "    1 

 !3  



2

" 34 " !

83  1

 "  

."

 4 " 




1  

 1

"    2   "   

"

   

 1 3"  

   
"2

"

"""  "





  

 *    "6$8,$40   @G B "

6  H 6( B"4 H 6(