Ishwar Singh v. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal Cum Labour Court Panipat And Others
# $%&%!'
()(
&*+ -%'.* (((((( % %!' , / ,&0& * , &%#%'.
""%$ ,1 '#0& ,% $04 3!0, !0, 1 '%6
! * ,&
(((((( &6!'# ' &
, & '
7,( -0''8 4# 91 #9!$
:5 .
%# !0'& 2;
"!, 6 % %!' ,(
( ( ( % %!' , :&*+ -%'.*;
"%2 # %'& +,% 6 % %!'
0'# , , %$2 & <= !'& % 0 %!'
'#%
& >%'.
?0 &*%'.
,# ( ( :'' @0, <;1 && # '#0& ,% $04 3!0, !0, 1 '%6
:, &6!'# '
* , %';
+* , 38 , " , '$
'&+ , # ' .
%9
%4 4 '
"%2 # 6 % %!' , +!,>4 #%&4%&& #(
( ,% "281 %& #
%'#0& ,% #%&60 & ,9%'.
# 4 '! %$ 0'# , - $ %!'
'#0& ,%
%&60 & $ 1 ) :* , %'
" , , " ,, #
A) $ A;
* , " , "%2 #
%4 4 '
3 "!, '#0& ,% 2$045 3!0, !0, 1 '%6
:* , %'
" , , " ,, #
A * 2A;(
( & 6 , 6 % %!' ,1
66!%' #
!'
'%6
' , !!6 , %9 '> 5%4% #1 /%22 .
&,
%& ,%$ '%6
:* , %'
" , , " ,, #
A, &6!'# ' '>A;
3,0 ,81
%4 # +!,> # * , 06 !
( ( < 0'# , $!' ,!2 , &6!'# ' '>(
* %4&
*%& & ,9%$ & + , +,!'.28 ,4%'
!'
(( +% *!0
&!'
$ 0& 1 6,%!, '! %$ 1 '! %$ $(
& 6 , '1 *%& & ,9%$ , $!,# &6! 2 &&
%&"
$ !,8
#, +%'.
&( 1= 6 , 4!' * ,8
$!462 # 8&
$ 2 '#
*0&1 *%& ,4%'
%!'
0'2 +"021
,3% , ,81
.
%'& 6,%'$%62 0, B0& %$
9%!2 %!'
- $ %!'
) $ ( *
"0, * , %4 #
&%'$ *%& B0'%!,& 3 '
66!%' # $ '1 * , "!, 1 , &6!'# ' '> 9%!2 6,!9%&%!'& - $ %!'
) $
+ 22(
$$!,#%'.281 &!0.* , %'& 4 '
+% * "022 $> . &
2!'.+% * $!' %'0% 8 & ,9%$
! * , 3 ' "% &(
( *
"!, & %# %4 $!' & # , &6!'# ' '> "%2%'.
% & +,% '
4 '
+* , %'
% $ .!,%$
'!
66!%' #
!'1 * '$ 1 * , %& '!
?0 & %!'
,4%'
%!'
*%& & ,9%$ &(
%& # # $ , &6!'# ' '>
* , '!
, 2 %!'&*%6 & ,9
& , 3 + '
, &6!'# ' '>(
& 6 , , &6!'# ' '>1 %
22! # +!,> # 62!8%'.
!0 &!0,$ # ""
!8 . '$81 -!'#* 60,1 && '#* !
#1 '%6
:, &6!'# '
* , %';
'.
. # %# , &6!'# ' . '$8(
( %4 4 ' 1 !'
!8 . '$8
2&!
%462 # #
, 8 , &6!'# ' 1 +*%$* "%2 # % & & 6
, 628 +* , %'
%
, &6!'# ' '>
22! # +!,> # 62!8%'.
!0 &!0,$ # ""
%
'.
. # % :, &6!'# '
- $0,% 8 . '$8;
!'
# 4 , &6!'# ' '>(
%& $ , &6!'# '
- $0,% 8 . '$8
% ' 9 , #%& '.
. # & ,9%$ & * ,1 6 % %!' , +!,>4 ?0% *%& B!3 !'
*%& !+'(
%& "0, * , , &6!'# '
. '$8
, &6!'# '
'> ,4%'
$!' , $
"!, & %# , &6!'# '
- $0,% 8 . '$8 !'
(<( 1 9%# 2 , & = )<
* , " ,1
22! # +!,> &!4 ! * ,
. '$8(
$$!,#%'.281 % 6, 8 #
'!
' % 2 #
, 2% "(
<( '
&%& #%'.& , % &1 %&&0 & + , ", 4 #
, % & 2 # * %, , &6 $ %9 9%# '$ 3 "!, 2(
( " , $!'&%# ,%'.
#%'.&
+ 22
,% 2= 9%# '$ !'
, $!,#1 9%# % & + ,# ( ( :'' @0, <;1 #%&4%&& # %4 6 % %!'
"%2 # '(
(
"!, 4 ' %!' # $%,$04& '$ &1 "%2 # %'& +,% 6 % %!'( )( ,' # $!0'& 2 "!, &034% &
,, # #%&4%&&%'.
%4 6 % %!'
+% *!0 $!'&%# ,%'.
#%'.&
+ 22
,% 2= 9%# '$
$ # !'
, $!,#(
%& &034% #
,4%'
%!'
& ,9%$ & 6 % %!' , +!,>4 $!462 28
,3% , ,81 0', &!'
0'B0& %"% #
$ !'
, &6!'# ' '>(
%& &034% #
9 '
!# , &6!'# ' '> '.
. # & ,9%$ & !0 &!0,$%'.
. '$8 "!, 60,6!& 462!8%'.
6 !'(
*0&1 %460.' # + ,# %& +,!'.
%& 2%
&%# (
( ,# ,' # $!0'& 2 "!, 6 % %!' ,
+% * *%&
&&%& '$ 1 6 ,0& # 6 ,3!!>( ( 6 ,0& %4 4 '
+!02# &*!+
6 % %!' , +!,>4 $ .!,%$ # #
66!%' #
!'
, &6!'# ' '> +% * "" $ ",!4 3,0 ,81
+!,> # * , 06 !
( ( < !'
4!' *28 ,8 &( 1=1 *!+ 9 ,1 *%& & ,9%$ & + , ,4%'
, &6!'# ' '> !'
(( +% *!0
&&%.'%'.
&!'1 # &6% "
$
$!462 # 4!, 8& $!' %'0!0& & ,9%$
$$!,#%'.281
22 . # 9%!2 %!'
- $ %!'& 1
) $ (
( !,# , &03& ' %
% & $ & 1
, # *%4& 2"
+% ' &&
"0, * , @ 4%' # -*,% 'B% -%'.*1 , '$* . ,
!'
- *# 9 -%'.*1 2 ,>
",!4 #%'.
#!$04 '
,8 9%# '$ (
( '
! * , '#1 , &6!'# ' '> @ 4%' # % & , '$* . , -*,% '
D04
, &6!'# '
%( ( !8 . '$8 @ 4%' # % & 6,!6,% !, -*,% 70> &* D04
"0, * , 2 # #!$04 '
,8 9%# '$ (
( * ,' # , 0,' #
"%'#%'.
% %'$043 '
06!'
6,!9
66!%' #
!'
, &6!'# ' '>1 *!+ 9 ,1 9 ,3 4 '
:;
'!
3 '
$!,,!3!,
#!$04 '
,8 9%# '$ 2%>
66!%' 4 '
2 ,1
'$ , $!,#1 84 '
,8 $( ",!4 , &6!'# ' '>(
*%& , .
,#1 ,' # , 0,' # "!22!+%'.
"%'#%'.&
"
#$$%&
" "
"
'
%
()*)*)
#$$%&
*))+
,- "
.
/
/
"
.
"
0
1 $% .
2 ,
3-
""
"
"
"
4
5$%
2 ,
<
))*)
**)4 0
0 6 "
2 ' 2 2 "
.
0
7
"
" "
"
"
"
"
"
"
""
" "
8
( $!'&%# , #
"!, & %# "%'#%'.& , 0,' # ,' #
&6 $%"%$ ?0 ,8 3 '
%& # ,' # $!0'& 2 "!,
+* * , * , %&
#!$04 ' = 9%# '$ +*%$* &*!+&
66!%' # , &6!'# ' '>1 *!+ 9 ,1 ,' # $!0'& 2 "!, 3 '
0'
, " , !, &*!+
#!$04 '
, .
,#(
0, * ,1 %
,&
$,!&& @ 4%'
%!'1 ,28
#4% #
66!%' # *,!0.* 7=& !8 . '$8
"0, * ,
#4% #
,4%'
%# , &6!'# ' - $0,% 8 . '$8(
*0&1 4 '
*%& $,!&& @ 4%'
%!'
# 4!2%&* & *%& ' %, $ & (
<( $ # +% * *%& &% 0 %!'1 ,' # $!0'& 2 "!, 6 % %!' , +!,>4 &034% #
,' # &*!02#
., ' # , 2% "
.
%'& , &6!'# '
%( ( 7=& !8 . '$8(
* '
,' # $!0'& 2 "!,
&> # &*!+
# 4 '! %$ %& #
.
%'& , &6!'# '
%( ( !8 - ,9%$ 1 ,' # $!0'& 2 "!, 0'
&*!+
&0$* # 4 '! %$ (
'"
$ 1 # 4 '! %$ :'' @0, ;
%& !'28
.
%'& '%6
' , !!6 , %9 '> 5%4% #( ( $!'&%# , # 9% +1 !'$ '!
# 4 3 '
%& #
.
%'& , &6!'# '
%( ( !8 . '$81 $ ''!
%4
, 2% "
.
%'& % (
*%& , .
,#1 , " , '$ $ B0#.4 '
, '# , #
!'A32 -06, 4 !0, '#%
0 9 :
; . " ; 1 :;
- ) +* , %'
"!22!+%'.
!3& ,9 %!'
*+
"
"
< "
<
"
=
< "
< " -' "
1 "
>
"
$
< "
<
.
*# &
3
"
"
"
"
"
<
<
"
?
>
"
*@ .
*# &
'; < "
<
B< "
<
"
"
"
"
%"
"
"
CB
) .
* "
"
"
"
"
"
1 < "
<
"
"
"
" "
>
"
1
<
<
"
"
"
%"
"
"
"
)
*
<<
"
"
<;<A B
<
""
?
%
&
%
C C C ?"C
2" "
7 5
4*4 <<
"
C
"
"
C
"
"
""
1 >
"
>
"
> ""
B
4 1
#
& >
# "
&
/ < "
<
"
"
> "
/
"
"
"
1
"
""
D
"
"
?
"
)
@+7
"
D 6 ""
D 3
"
"
"
' "
" "
"
'
?
"
/ "
"
<<
E8
( *0&1
3& '$
# 4
.
%'& , &6!'# '
%( ( !8 . '$81 +!02# '!
' % 2 #
, 2% "
.
%'& , &6!'# '
( )( 9% +
3!9 #%&$0&&%!'1 #!
'!
"%'#
4 ,% %'& +,% 6 % %!'
'#& #%&4%&& #(
( 22 6 '#%'.
662%$ %!':&;1 %"
'81 &* $2!& #(
()(
&B>& * * , &6 >%'.=, &!' #
=
!
* * , , 6!,
=
!