High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22593/2014dismissed

Gurpreet Singh v. Presiding Officer It Patiala And ORS

2015-01-13Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan5 pages

"#$$%&'&()

*+,+$$#-&(./ $#&#&($+ 1$+'*'

+$'&2&(. &%$+#/$+'

$',(2$(#'

+$'$(#)0 + -1&+3425%"#$+#/$,$#&#&($+ /$&('#"(#7+&#,$#&#&(&'2&+$%#$2"."&('##/$"7"+22"#$2 8

4,"''$29:#/$(2*'#+&";+&9*(";4 "#&";"47/$+$9:#/$+$$+$(%$ /"'9$$("('7$+$2"."&('##/$,$#&#&($+7+3<"("(2/$/"'(#9$$(/$;2 $(#&#;$2#"(:+$;&$ =$"+($2%*('$;",,$"+&(.+#/$,$#&#&($+7*;2'*9<&##/"# #/$,$#&#&($+7"'$<,;:$2"'$;,$+"##/$ *(>"9-#"#$"+$/*'&(.

+,+"#&(27(4 ";$+3#;"4&'#+&%#-"(.+*+&(,+&;4

"(27"'

2+"7&(.'";"+: '?

@0,$+<(#/&',+$'$(%$7"'9$&(.<"+3$2&( #/$"##$(2"(%$+$.&'#$+<"&(#"&($2"##/$-#"#$"+$/*'&(.+,+"#&("# ";$+3#;"&#'$;7$5$+4+<

#/$,$#&#&($+7"'(#";;##$2 "(:7+3"(27"'(#<"+3$2,+$'$(#*('$;7*;2'*9<&##/"#$5$( 7&#/*# ,"''&(. "(: ',$%&&% +2$+4 '$+5&%$' #/$ ,$#&#&($+ 7$+$ #$+<&("#$29:#/$+$',(2$(#0+,+"#&(&(5&;"#&(#/$<"(2"#+: ,+5&'&('#/$(2*'#+&";&',*#$'%#/$+$&("#$+#9$+$$++$2"'#/$ %#!+.*<$(#+"&'$29:#/$%*('$;&'#/"##/$(2*'#+&";+&9*(";7/&;$ ,"''&(.#/$&<,*.($2"7"+2/"'$++($*';:2&'%"+2$2#/$$5&2$(%$#/"# /"29$$("22*%$29:#/$7+3<"(&(#/$'/",$2%*<$(#'"#A0#

00 A0

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

!" #$ "%%% &"# '()*+'

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

00 &(2&(.7$+$/$;2#9$7&#/&(#/$$A%;*'&5$2<"&("(2>*+&'2&%#&(#/$ +&9*("; 25$+#&(.9"%3##/$"%#'#/$,+$'$(#%"'$4#/$$5&2$(%$ "22*%$2(+$%+2(9$/";#/$7+3<"(&(#/$'/",$7+3';&,'A 0"(20 "'";'%,&$'"##$(2"(%$+$.&'#$+A0#A0

/"5$ 9$$( 2$";# 7&#/ "(2 2&'%"+2$2 9: #/$ +&9*("; ( #/$ ;;7&(. +$"'()0

#""

& '

(

( )* + ',

- , .

. . .

0 * + '

0 * + ',

. *

* 0,

3( /

.2 0 2 4.

. ' . - &

.2 0 2 4. .

5' &

. 0 2 4.

0 2

(4 0 ##6

7%859 :

2 3. 2

$ 4,

2 ' .

. 4,

;

- "

! - , (#/$#/$+/"(247/&;$+$%+2&(."&(2&(."'+$."+2'#/$+$ 9$&(.(+$;"#&('/&,<"'#$+"(2'$+5"(#9$#7$$(#/$,$#&#&($+7+3<"( "(2 #/$+$',(2$(#0+,+"#&(4#/$2$,'&#&( 0 -/";>&(2$+ -&(./4 "(".$+#/$+,+"#&(4/&'"&2"5&#A 0 @&('*,,+# /&'2$,'&#&("'";'#/$'#"#$<$(# 0-7"+"(>&#-&(./4(%/"+.$ #/$ +,+"#&( 27( "# ";$+3#;" "(2 7/ &( #*+( #$(2$+$2 /&' "&2"5&#A 0"'";',+2*%$22%*<$(#'A 0 #A 0

7$+$+$$++$2#"(2&(7/&%/#/$("<$'";;#/$$<,;:$$'47/7+3$2 &(#/$-#"#$"+$/*'&(.+,+"#&(4 ";$+3#;"/;2&(.#/$,'&#&(' +3<$(4$;,$+'"(2"'*";+3$+'7$+$<$(#&($29*##/$,+$'$(%$ #/$,+$'$(#,$#&#&($+*+,+$$#-&(.//"2($5$+9$$(<"+3$2+<#/$:$"+

/$ 2%*<$(#' "22*%$2 ( 9$/"; #/$ "(".$<$(#@<,;:$+0+,+"#&(A 0 # 0

";'&(%;*2$2#/$ "##$'#$2%,:#/$,":<$(#5*%/$+4'";"+:9&;;'"(2'#",'&#&(+$,+# <(#/7&'$"(2&('*%/2%*<$(#'";'#/$("<$#/$,+$'$(#,$#&#&($+"' "($<,;:$$#/$+,+"#&(42&2(#&(2"<$(#&(

00 /"#","+#4#/$+&9*(";7/&;$,"''&(.#/$&<,*.($2"7"+2/"' (#&%$2#/"#+#/$+$;$5"(#,$+&2&$<(#/ %#9$+4

"',$+A #/$,":<$(#'+$;$"'$2&("5*+#/$+$<,;:$$'47/7$+$";' $(.".$2"'$;,$+'("<$;:+*(&(2*4 ">&(2$+-&(./4";>&(2$+-&(./4 "+9/".-&(./4"(.-&(./4$'/ "> "(2$:4-*3/2$5E*<"+4*+<$$# -&(./4-"(# "<$#%7$+$'/7(#9$9$#7$$( ' D4 @0# '?@04 7/$+$"'#/$2%*<$(#A0 +$;&$2*,(9:#/$7+3<"(+$;$%#$2/&'

'";"+: '?

@0,$+<(#/(;:-*%/2&'%+$,"(%:&(#/$B*"(#*< 7".$'/"'.($*($A,;"&($29:%*('$;$5$(2*+&(.#/$%*+'$/$"+&(. &(#/$,+$'$(#,$#&#&(#2": /$&(2&(."%#+$%+2$29:#/$+&9*(";"'+$."+2'#/$+$ 9$&(. ( +$;"#&('/&, $<,;:$+0$<,;:$$ 9$#7$$( #/$ ,$#&#&($+ 7+3<"("(2#/$+$',(2$(#+,+"#&(4&'*,(2*$",,+$%&"#&(#/$ $(#&+$$5&2$(%$"22*%$2(+$%+249#/(9$/";#/$7+3<"("'";' #/$+,+"#&(&$#/$$<,;:$+-*%/&(2&(.7*;2(#%";;+"(: &(#$+5$(#&(9:",,;:&(.#/$2&%#*<;"&227(9:#/$(C9;$-*,+$<$ *+#&(

%"'$'*,+"! ('$B*$(#;:4#/$&<,*.($2"7"+2&'"&+<$2"(2#/$7+&# ,$#&#&(&'2&'<&''$2

$#&#&(2&'<&''$2 - .

%/#(0'12(3 ;*%3:

/$#/$+#9$+$$++$2# $,+#$+F$'