High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15654/2018allowed

Amandeep v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Amit Rawal6 pages

!" "#$%$&'()

!" "#$%$&'() * &+"", "!$!$&"- .% /! !" -0 & &+!1"-% "%,&+"&!% 2'3 42/5/52 2'3 42/5/52 2'3 42/5/52 2'3 42/5/52 -"%"&!' 2-* -+"",/$&612 &&7+8# !"7

-!1","!$!$&"- 2-/ 9- :1219&! 7 7 -0 & 5/527;4< 5/527;4< 5/527;4< 5/527;4< 1","!$!$&"-1 %,- 0"+ -!1"$%%9 &#" =-$!$&!1"& !9-" * &+ *9%%"">$&6+$-"#!$&!!1"-"%,&+"&!%!#&%$+"-1$%-"?9"%! -"@" %$&6 1$* & "*"-6"&#0 , -@" +*$%%$& 1$% #1$@+-"&$&!1"%#1@ & :-$"

7 !1" ,"!$!$&"- $% ,-"%"&!@0 @+6"+ $& $%!-$#! $@7 1 AA -71 8$&6:""&#&8$#!"+$& # %"-"6$%!"-"+8$+"+ !"+ ( 9&+"-/"#!$&% )B7(( &+ !1"&+$ &"& @+"7 -%1-!D!1"3E &+/"#!$& !1" -#!$# -96% &+%0#1!-,$# /9:%! &#"%#!7B C -%1-!D!1" /#!3E1","!$!$&"-1 %:""& %"&!"&#"+* F$*9* -0" -% -!1"

"&#"#**$!!"+9&+"-!1" / #!!$% @@"6"+!1 !!1","!$!$&"-1 %!=#1$@+-"&7& *"@07@ &$@@ &+

98- A$@@7=1 -"%!9+0$&6$&/!2$#1 "@3%&8"&!/#1@$& $%!-$#! !$ @ $&#@ %%&9-%"-0 &+57-"%,"#!$8"@01","!$!$&"-= %$& -*"+ :0 !1" %#1@ !1 ! %$&#" !1" "" 1$% = -+% 1 % &! :""& +",%$!"+7 !1"-"

-"7 !1"0 =9@+ &! :" @@="+ ! #&!$&9" $& !1" %#1@ 1"

,"!$!$&"-7!1"-"

-"7* +" & ,,@$# !$&!!1"/9,"-$&!"&+"&! $@71 AA -

- -"@" %$&6 1$* & "*"-6"&#0 , -@" -- &6$&6 +*$%%$&G%#1@ "" 1$%= -+% % ##-+$&6!1$*!1"-"$%&!1"-* @" *"*:"-$&1$% *$@0 !"-&!$#"7!1"-"%,&+"&!%1 8" $@"+!1"$--",@0=$!1=1$#1 !1"01 8" ,,"&+"+ &-+"-, %%"+:0!1"/9,"-$&!"&+"&! -$%&7 $%!-$#! -$%&7 1 AA - + !"+ :0 =1$#1 !1" ,,@$# !$& $@"+ :0 !1" ,"!$!$&"- -6- &! "*"-6"&#0 , -@"1 % :""&+"#@$&"+& !1"6-9&+ !1 ! %$&#" !1" ,"!$!$&"- 1 % &! #*,@"!"+ &" 0" - $*,-$%&*"&! #&8$#!$&&-" -&"+1$% $-%! &&9 @6+#&+9#!-"*$%%$&7!1"-"

-"71" $%&!"&!$!@"+ -, -@" 4" -&"+ #9&%"@ - !1" ,"!$!$&"- 1 % %9:*$!!"+ !1 ! !1" ,"!$!$&"-1 % ,,@$"+ -, -@"$&!"-*% !1" -0 & + &+9#! -$%&"-% ;"*,- -0 "@" %"< #!7 B C - %1-! D!1" #!3E %,"-=1$#1!1"/! !"8"-&*"&!7$&#&%9@! !$&=$!1!1" $%!-$#! 2 6$%!- !"- &0!1"-

$#"- ,,$&!"+$&!1$%:"1 @ 7:0&!$ $# !$&$&!1"

$#$ @ H"!!" &+%9:A"#!!%9#1#&+$!$&% &+$&%9#1* &&"- %* 0 :",-"%#-$:"+7-"@" %"!"*,- -$@0 &0,-$%&"-7$ !1"/! !"8"-&*"&!$% % !$% $"+!1 !$!$%+"%$- :@"!+% - &0!1"-%9

$#$"&!# 9%"!$% @% %9:*$!!"+!1 ! %,"-/"#!$&(;

<;:< !1"#!7!1",-$%&"-$%!:"-"@" %"+ & !1" 6-9&+ %,"#$ $"+ $& @ 9%" (;<;+< !1" #! - ,"-$+ &! "F#""+$&6 9-="">%"1 % 9-!1"-%9:*$!!"+!1 !!1"#!#& "-%,="- 9&+"-/"#!$&&!1"/! !"8"-&*"&!!* >"9@"%$&=1$#1/"#!$& ;

<;+< !1"#!+" @%=$!1!1"D,="-!* >"-9@"%3@ 0$&6+=&!1" #&+$!$&% & =1$#1 &+ !1" * &&"- $& =1$#1 ,-$%&"-% * 0 :" -"@" %"+ !"*,- -$@09&+"-!1"#!"1 %-"

"--"+!9@" !1" -0 & + &+9#!-$%&"-%;"*,- -0"@" %"<9@"%7 )C -%1-!D!1"9@"%3E

( !#&!"&+!1 ! %,"-9@";$< !1"9@"%7 +*$%%$&$&%#1@$% @% %9

$#$"&!# 9%"&!1": %$% =1$#1!1","!$!$&"-# &$&8>"!1",-8$%$& !1"#!!$% 9-!1"-%9:*$!!"+!1 !!1","!$!$&"-1 % :""&+"#@$&"+!"*,- -0, -@"&!1"6-9&+!1 !1"1 %&!#*,@"!"+&" 0" - $*,-$%&*"&! !"- #&8$#!$& &+ 1 % &! " -&"+ 1$% $-%! &&9 @ 6+#&+9#!-"*$%%$&=1$#1$%%,-8$+"+$&9@" ;< !1"9@"%& !1$%-"6 -+71"1 %-"

"--"+!!=+"#$%$&% !1" $8$%$& "&#1 !1$% 9-! -"&+"-"+ $& !1" # %"% I9-,-""! /$&61 I9-,-""! /$&61 I9-,-""! /$&61 I9-,-""! /$&61 .% /! !" 9&A : &+ /! !" 9&A : &+ /! !" 9&A : &+ /! !" 9&A : &+ &!1"-J &!1"-J &!1"-J &!1"-J ;(< ;-$*$& @< &+ I "", > I "", > I "", > I "", > .% /! !" -0 & /! !" -0 & /! !" -0 & /! !" -0 & &+ &!1"-J &+ &!1"-J &+ &!1"-J &+ &!1"-J ;

<;-$*$& @< (&!1"# %" 9-,-""!/$&61 9-,-""!/$&61 9-,-""!/$&61 9-,-""!/$&61 ;/9,- < ;/9,- < ;/9,- < ;/9,- <7 !1" $8$%$& "&#1 !1$% 9-! 1 % 1"@+ !1 ! !1" #?9$%$!$& -"*$%%$& & ##9&! 6+ #&+9#! - ! @" %! 9- *&!1% #&8$#!$&$% ,-#"+9- @,-8$%$& &+$%!19%+$-"#!-0 &+&!* &+ !-0 &+$&!1"# %" "", >;/9,- <

"", >;/9,- <

"", >;/9,- <!1" $8$%$& "&#1 !1$%9-!1 %1"@+ !1 ! -"%!-$#!$& &" 0" - $*,-$%&*"&! !"- #&8$#!$& ! :"#*" "@$6$:@" -!"*,- -0-"@" %"1 %:""&$*,%"+:0= 0 9@"%=1"-" % !1"-"$%&%9#1-"%!-$#!$&$&!1"#!7!1"-" -"7!1"9@"%# &&!%9,"-%"+" !1"#! &!1"!1"-1 &+7@" -&"+#9&%"@7 ,," -$&6&:"1 @ !1" /! !"71 %%9:*$!!"+!1 !9@" !1"9@"%1 %:""&"& #!"+&!1": %$% !1" ,="- #& "--"+ 9&+"- /"#!$& ;

<;+< !1" #! $& =1$#1 $! $% ,-8$+"+!1 !!1"/! !"8"-&*"&!=9@+@ 0+=&!1"#&+$!$&%&=1$#1 &+ !1" * &&"- $& =1$#1 !1" ,-$%&"-% * 0 :" -"@" %"+ !"*,- -$@0 & +$%%"#!$& !1" % $+ ,-8$%$&7 $! $% % $+ !1 ! !1" =-+% 9%"+ $& /"#!$& ;

<;+< !1"#! -" 9&+ %;$<#&+$!$&%7;$$<* &&"- &+;$$$<-"@" %" " 1 % %9:*$!!"+ !1 ! !1" +*$%%$& $& %#1@G#@@"6"G,- "%%$& @ $&%!$!9!$&% !1" +","&+"&!% !1" #&8$#! ,-8$+"+ $& 9@" ;<

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

$#$"&!# 9%"!$% +*$!!"+ !1 ! !!1"!$*"=1"&!1"#!= %"& #!"+$&B7!1$%,-8$%$&= %@" ! 9,& -!1"#*,"!"&! 9!1-$!0!+"#$+" %!=1 !%1 @@:"!1"%9

$#$"&! # 9%" -!1",9-,%" "&!"-! $&$&6!1" ,,@$# !$& !1",-$%&"-%$&!"-*% !1"#!:9!=1$@"@ 0$&6+=&!1"9@"%$& )79@" !1" 9@"% = %,-8$+"+ !+"

$&" D%9

$#$"&! # 9%"3 % ="@@ $& =1$#1 +*$%%$& $& %#1@7 +"@$8"-0 =$ "7 19%" -", $-%G&"= #&%!-9#!$& &+ * --$ 6" ,-$%&"-3%:-!1"-3%%&-+ 961!"-$&# %"1$%:-!1"-$%&! @$8" -"!1"-"&#"7$!1 %:""&@ $++=&$&!1"9@"%!1 ! +*$%%$&$&!1" %#1@$% %9

$#$"&!# 9%" -!1",9-,%" %"">$&6!"*,- -0-"@" %"7$! =9@+ @@=$!1$&!1"+"

$&$!$& !1"#! &+ -!1 ! * !!"-!1" 9!1-$!$"%=1$@" ,,@0$&69@"( !1"9@"%=1$#1@ $++=& !1" ,-#"+9-" - !"*,- -0 -"@" %" =9@+ @> $&! !1" "@$6$:$@$!0 %

,-8$+"+$&9@" !1"9@"%$&=1$#1$!$%,-8$+"+!1 ! -!1",9-,%" :"#*$&6 "&!$!@"+ - , -@" &" #*,@"!" 0" - $*,-$%&*"&! #&8$#!$& %19@+ :" !1"-" @!6"!1"- =$!1 $-%! &&9 @ 6+ #&+9#! -"*$%%$& ="8"-7 !1$% 9-! $& !1" # %" 9-,-""! /$&61 ;/9,- < 9-,-""! /$&61 ;/9,- < 9-,-""! /$&61 ;/9,- < 9-,-""! /$&61 ;/9,- < 7 =1$@"+" @$&6=$!1!1"9&A :+&+9#!-$%&"-%;"*,- -0"@" %"< 9@"%7B ( &+9&A :+&+9#!-$%&"-%;"*,- -0"@" %"<#!7 B

1 %1"@+!1 !* $&! $&$&6 6+#&+9#! - !@" %! 9-*&!1%$& A $@ !"-!1"#&8$#!$&$%+$-"#!-0 &+&!* &+ !-07!1"-" -"7!1"% $+ A9+6*"&!%?9 -"@0 ,,@$"%!!1"# %" !1","!$!$&"-!1@+!1 !$&# %" "*"-6"&#0, -@"=1"-"!1","-%&$%%"">$&61$%-"@" %" -!1",9-,%" +*$%%$& 1$%#1$@+-"&"%,"#$ @@0=1"&!1"-"$%&* @"*"*:"-$&1$%

*$@0 ! @> !"- !1"*7 !1" #&+$!$& #*,@"!$& &" 0" - $*,-$%&*"&! !"- #&8$#!$& &+ " -&$&6 $-%! &&9 @ 6+ #&+9#! -"*$%%$& 9&+"- !1" #! $% +$-"#!-0 &+ &! * &+ !-0 & % - %7 !1" #*,@"!$& &" 0" - 1$% $*,-$%&*"&! $% #&#"-&"+7 $& !1" # %"

"", >;/9,- < ;/9,- < ;/9,- < ;/9,- <7!1$%9-!1 % 6 $&1"@+!1 !!1$%#&+$!$&$%&@0$&!1" 9@"% &+ &! $& !1" #!7 !1"-"

-"7 $! =9@+ &! ,,@0 $ !1"-" $% & "*"-6"&#0&!1": %$% =1$#1!1"#&8$#!$% %>$&6 -, -@"@!1961 @" -&"+#9&%"@ -!1"-"%,&+"&!%1 %%9:*$!!"+!1 !$&!1"# %" "", >

"", >

"", > ;/9,- < ;/9,- < ;/9,- < ;/9,- <7=$ " !1",-$%&"-= %%"-$9%@0$@@:9!1 % @%%9:*$!!"+!1 !!1" $%%9" %!=1"!1"-!1"-"$% &"*"-6"&#0-&!$% @% +$%#-"!$&:"# 9%" $!1 %!:"! >"&$&!#&%$+"- !$&&!1"6$8"& #!% &+#$-#9*%! &#"%

"!1 ! %$!* 07$&!1",-"%"&!# %"7!1$%9-!1 % 9&+!1 ! !1","!$!$&"-1 %:""&#&8$#!"+$&&"# %"1"-"$%& @@"6 !$& 6 $&%! 1$* &0A $@

"&#" &+!1"-"$% %!-&6 ,,-"1"&%$&$&1$%*$&+!1 ! 1$%#1$@+"&=9@+:"+",-$8"+ "+9# !$& -= &! ""=1$#1# &:" -- &6"+:01$*&@0$ 1"$%-"@" %"+&, -@" - %1-!,"-$+

19% ! >$&6 $&! #&%$+"- !$& !1" #!% &+ #$-#9*%! &#"%7 * !1"#&%$+"-"+,$&$&!1 !$&!1$%, -!$#9@ -# %"7!1","!$!$&"-1 % & "*"-6"&#0 -6"!!$&6-"@" %"+&, -@"! -- &6"!1" "" - +*$%%$& 1$% #1$@+-"&7 =1 -" $& &9-%"-0 &+ 5 #@ %% 9-$&6 !1" #9-%" 1" -$&67 @" -&"+ #9&%"@ - !1" ,"!$!$&"- 1 % $& -*"+ !1" 9-! !1 ! @!1961$&&!$#";&&"F9-"<7!1"%#1@1 ++$-"#!"+!1","!$!$&"-! +",%$!!1" ""!$@@( :9!&!1"-"?9"%! 1$%=$ "7!1"% $+,"-$+ 1 %:""&"F!"&+"+7!1"-"

-"7!1",-"%"&!,"!$!$&$%1"-":0 @@="+ &+ +$-"#!$&$%$%%9"+!!1"-"%,&+"&!%!-"@" %"!1","!$!$&"- -!1=$!1 != ="">% & 1$% 9-&$%1$&6 ,"-%& @ : $@ :&+% &+ %9-"!0 ! !1" % !$% #!$& $%!-$#! 2 6$%!- !"7 1 AA - ! $% * +" #@" - !1 ! !1" ,"!$!$&"-%1 @@%9--"&+"-!!1" $@ 9!1-$!$"%&!1"+ !"=1"&!1","-$+ 1$%, -@"=9@+#*"! &"&+ ;5/52< ;5/52< ;5/52< ;5/52< () () () () 1"!1"-%," >$&6G-" %&"+ '

"%G 1"!1"-",-! :@" '

"%G