← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21920/2015disposed of

Arshdeep Singh v. Union Of India And ORS.

2015-12-21Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari12 pages



      

 ! 

  

   

    

    "# 

  

   



    

     $  !"# 

   

    

  $   % &

 & 

   

    

 

 '  # 

("



   

    

  )  # 



 

   

    

  *  "#"  + "



   

    

  %!  &'%  ((('  , - ( ./ 0/ 

.1 234/23 /23 2 $ 4$42'

- 

!5/ 0 -  5&

/ 0 

.1 3)'42'

-

./ 0 

.1 23$2 42'    '

.1 234/23   23 242'

-  ("/ 0 

.1 3342'

 - +

6 #/   

. "/ - 6&(/ 0 7 #

6 + "/ 0  8 -  6 +5 / 0  9

 -  "

7

/ 0  

- 

! / 0   $ (() *)+), ) -. /),0 !      &   ""         #   

 .1    234/  23$2 /  3)'/  33/  23 / 23 2 $ 4$42'

!0

5 &.1  23442'

!     0""

  ."  '

)     &  +0942'        :

  & 

.&&      9

 /  #   '    #          "   0   

    $4 

      9.

  .""     0 0     +0"0 0'7 .0&  42'942)  ! "'#  &

  ;

!   

0

0"0 0 "

 0    #   0 

$4  

  0  

  "

0 #"0      &   .

  

  " 

!   "  #$  %&'

(     !'

  ')'  

*

 

<  922/      "

  0& 0  

42$942'

0/ & " "  " "  8  00/##  

 

+'$(,-.! - !  +/  0

"  

   #  /  # 0  

0& " " 00 # "

 0

 0 

$4  90""  !  0             &

"    

00 '  & 

   "" &       #  "

    ;

 !    

0

0"0 0 "

/  " &  

  

 &  &"   0 !& "   . "0& 0   0

  

"  /&     !'

" %  0  !'

')'



!0   

0 #

 $4

 # 0# 0 

# 0 #"  "'0"   ""

0 & .

&( ".   &

 ""   0 0"   ""



 $4  %# /

  

  " /&   !'

"#$%&'

( !'

=')'  

/    7

 + 0   0      #   0&&

0 2 4* 42'#

  0"        ;

 !     

 0

0"

0 0 "

#    0 



  &     00

"/    &

   42 4* 42'

.1 *'42'# "" #""#0



0 8  &""

& ' # 

 ""

0  00 &

   !  &    #  

  0 



! )'12 3  "     ,9 >

 

 

  







  



   

          



 !        "

# $% &

'%& 

 (



#

)  *+  



   

    ( ,-

 

   



  

 

 .   /    

  

     +  

   

  



  !  '

/  ,*  .

   

          ( ,-

 

 





     

       

         

  

 &   

 1



 

 )   %& 

  

  





!'

/, *

  3

& &

4 51   

 

  

 1         

 

  &      

 6  0" & "0 0 &-

%& 07 "& /# 0 #

" 90"" /#

  0"  &

  0"

;

5  !" 4* 42'

<9;  ,9 7( 8$   

%   

     ( ,-

 

   

  

  

   

 

        

    ! 

(    



 

        

 !9 1 !,

2 2 !

   :  

     

    

 & 



 

+  





    

,



  & "0 02* 42$

< 9;$&0&

".

.""   0 0/  .

      

/  . "   0 0  #"  "      #      0""   "  

$4 0 

 '     "   ,9 7( : $       

 %    



( ,-



 









   

    ! 

   

(  )   &  

   &    

  4 5 ,!(,1 0 !  -

 ( '+



*"

# $ % &

4.%   : 

  

 



 

  &

  

  1    



     "

# $ % &

 '%& 

   (

  ;  #

 )  *  +  

   

    

   ( ,- < 



    





.  

+



<



0 !    "#$%  &  

  

       

,

    

  .         &

  / =0  (   1     

  

 

  > (&  '

   "#$%*

 

 

  

 

  0  0 0& 0/    #"    0"    

     #"     "    &   

    0 # 0    0 &  & ;

!   

0

0"0

 !/ "

"  ""/

0

0# 0 & " "

"  "

?    #  ! # / &"/% &

 &  + "

 & "  ""

" &  00 # 0 

   00 #    & "  "

      0   !  

"

&  #  

  00  &  #   4'

42'/     && " 0     .    2'

42'     " 0  !0 ".""  & 

0 099#2'

4@ 42'//&    "

"    %# /  &   "

"

00   00   0

 " #  !#&0   

 &   0 /## '$4   00  0

 " !  & < . 

!  "     4  ! -  %&'

(    ,'+ !

)')' !'



13* 0 "

    /#   ".0

 <0  ##"&  & & 

"#   0#" 

  "##"  !  "# 00



   00 099/ &  0

 

& !"    & ,9 >9 #.  ?  

. .  

      

  5 (&        

   &

   .

   

.

  

    

      .  

&  .



 &



.

 &:

       

  $     

& & :



  1

"

 1 

 " (



@ A'*0 (11!2B" 4

 -





@ A'5*5(115==B %& C. ( 3 : 

@ A'=*9(11 !90B"

1 

 4

D

@   A'!*    (11  ==B  "

  %  

 -





@ A'!*(11 =!B  "

 1     

   "   (

  

@ A'*0(11!2B

5      5 (&            

  



  



       .     &   & 

   .       

      



 

  

              &

&                 

& .

. 

& 



 

& 

 



? .   . 5 #

  &&

  

   &    

   

 

   /&

& . 



.          

       







      

   

       

 

&  

  &



&&

.

& 



 



 

 

&  





 .       



"( &&



 25    .     

  .  

 2 09  0! 0   

 05      

 

)(" 

  "(                &&

         &&

  



5                    /&       .            

/&     5 (&   



1      

 

       

    

   & 

 

 

/&

 .

   

    & 

 



&&

    

&

&

&



 

E

 

  

 ?



?  



  

 

 .    &    :  

         /&         

A$ (&

@  ( C ;F

@ A'92*(11 BG1 " 

%  + # ( A'99 *(11

  50BG



FF   ( -3

@ A'*2(115!!B

HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH  I ' *5 (&   

     .  



 &

  &  .

                   

  

 

 !

(&    

  A

     1

3 +& '&*B   

 

/&  ? 



  



    &

     

 &    &.&   /     J 

.

 

 

. 

: .          &    .  .  

    . /   /  

  :

   

 

        

5 (&    

    .    

  

    1

 3 +& '&*

 :





 /&   

       &

:

!  & "5

0   "

  & <.

5 +4! "% 0 

  1 3       

 (  62   "   '   !!

. ! !'



1378  /   . 

&    # 0

  0           

0     #""

 "

?   ##  





   

    & 

&

  && "0 .# 

 #5 "80   "0

  # & " "/

# 0&&

0  &  &  &"

/."'

) /    05#

! #   ""#  !

 &0 & 

"

&      " ?      "

<&

 2& 00

"/" &# """ 0"     / #    .(('0 % -    4