High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2373/2006dismissed

Karnail Singh v. State Of Punjab

2022-09-21Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

! "#$

$$ '(( )*+ (, )(

&$ '(- ,. $$

/ &#$$- /- )*+

00000 $$ "#$ ( %# &

12 3

4- ,

3 #

%( )(5 &#

+( ( - !64

(& 7& 7- %#(, )$# # #59 9 #, :,%- #$ - #( $$%#(

#% .#$$% $- ((((# 4!

;% 5 &(;

8#& $# ( # #$ ,,

, - .#, *,% ,,

( , ((, .5 ,5- ( ,% #%( #( #,

5( 5 # ( $;&< ,$ 5 #- & ,% 2 5

#$5 (, (

(- ( # (5

4- $# 5

)$# # #59 9 $, 2=> 3% ?&# , 2.(#%#% # =2@ ,#%

.#$$% &$ '#$$% +*#

;#%< 8& $# 5 &, #% .#$$% $-

(# (#,- #,#% ( +#% 3 ) A!!

5#% 8 %5 +%( &.#%

( ( < (#% $# 5- .( #, + ;

+$5< &,, +(#( ((# # & # $( B#, +- ,#( $(,< 2 $,

((

5#% ( #

(+( ( %5 +%( $ ( 8, ( &

#%& % (

, ( ( /C, # %#(<

, % (

#, ( /C, # <

%, , DE )1

9&- 2 ( 8#$((

((%< (( &- & :#, )- + #.#(# 9 9 &, (<

8&#$- 8 8#((( $5 /,#$ ( & = .#$$% %& 3& ( # = '#$$% &&$ "$ $(

( &5 *#, $# 5< &#% (- ) %. #,

$$#%

#%& % (

( & /C, # - &8.-

#, )<

(

( , DE )< & ,# #( )- 2

, ( 8 %5 +%( $ (

(,< &( +%(

# 5 &(;< 2 ;

$ 4

%5 +%(-

.#% &( # $(< +#% 8#%&,- ##% 5 &(;

%5 + %

;% 4

( , +% 6 ;% 4

% < %5 +%

##% (#, 5 &(;

., # $(< & 8 $ $( 8 +$;

$( ($, ($ 2 &.#% ((# 737< & :#, ) $( #E, ($ &.#% ((# 7:7 $$ &( $(< $ ($ ((#( ; < &-

8 $ $(- 8 +$;

$( ( ($ ((#( ; # $# ((((#- .#,

DE )D< ( $% $( ; #

(,5- .#,

DE )D=< ( 2 &,, . ($ & 3& #,, 8#(( 8&( ($ ( #, ) ($< > '#, " , .#,

.# %, 8&$ ,#%( .5<

,#%$5 (, &#(

(< 8&#$ (#% - ($ (

, ( = ., ; # $# ((((#- .#,

DE )D= #(&, %,( (- .#,

DE )D= ( #.$5< B#(# , ( , %,< 2 ( B DE )/

$# (# +(#( $ 12 DE )/=

%#(,< 2 , %& (# $ $ DE )>

$# (#-

$,%, $ ;- 8&(-

5 ; ,+$ $ ; E ,52 ,

5 :- 9 9-

.#% $# # DE )2 :- 9 9 ((, B#(# , DE )=< &-

5 &,, . 2- 8& ; ,+$ $ ;

42 &,, . 8 $ $( ( ($ ((# ,$5 ($, $% , ; (+$ :(+# ( ,(##% &( & $ DE #- )*+- &,#%&- 8& ,(#, ( # $( ,# &,, . # 2< DE ):

#.,

& $ DE #- )*+- &,#%&- $( &( 5 &,<

$# #.(#%# & $##(-

&$$ %#(

, #$,

&$$- #$ #$ :,%- #( ($#,

#( , ( $#,

&$$

(( .#,, , ) - & #,#% # #

&% , %#(

(,- $,, %#$5

$# #$

( ( # .#, - ( # E #, $$8#% 8#((( )F (+$ :(+#

# $ $( & $ DE #- )*+- &,#%&- #(&, #,.# DE ) ,#% #,- $ #, ((((#- #% &8#& ; $

)F > '#, " - )&%&- 2 9 9 ,(,

(, ( ,5- # 8#$((

((%

> 3% &, ( , .#,

.# $$ ,#%( %,

((((#

"#$ #%&< #% ' ,#%(- , + >=2 8& , $ '- ($#% # ($ &.#% ((# 737 ;

# $# ((((#- .#,

DE ) - (,

2 $8#, )F )

" - $;- # - 3;, +%& , %#(# .&# $(- (#% ( ,- ( 3 ) A!!

(,( & " 8# G&# '#$$% 9# > ., ( DE ) )FA & :#, )- + #.#(#- 9 9 , 8&( ,# #( %5 +%( +#%

( ( &,

# 5 &(;

(##, %, ,#$

)F4 2 3% 8#(( 2.(#%#% # ,(, %,#% $- .#% (.$ , (

( # $#, .#( , ( 9&- #( .#,

$(,

,, , ) - $$ # ##%

# ( ( #% ( # .#, %#(

+ ,#, $$%#(

,#% # + $($5 #.$., &#(

3 +

$( + $,

#% , .#, -

E #, > /+ &

) #59 9 F- 8& +%& (

, , # %#( 3 !

) #5 9 9- (#% %#( 3 !-

4- 1G

,(#, $%

5 > ., & 5 5 DE F= > & (, %#( 3 - 8&

5 (

$ E ##- 1G

( $% $ > ., & 5 5 DE F= F#& &- , .#,

$(,

&#% % (- #$

.# (

#, (

1$#% %%#., *,%

, ( - $$ , $ + &#( , #, %$ &#%

- $# # &.#% + #$, , 6!

) - ##% ( $$ ((,, ,#% , $

38 $ &(

#$ % (

&. &,

($ $$=

(,-

($ +(#,( %#% &%& ,

2 &#(

(- 8#((( $5 )FA & :#, ) )F4 2 3% $$5 (, ( # (5 %,

&.#% +

( #( ((((# 4!

;% 5 &(;

.#$$% $ 8#& # $# ( & &( )F( (+* $%&5

((E ## +&$

+ &5 ( ;

&# %(

$, (&,

#$ # &

,(, $

.# #%

%#.

#(#

#, 3 .#( #5 +8 &( )F(

&( + $$%, ., , &5

#%& &. #.$.,

&#(

8%$5 ,(, %#(

(

.# # #, + % .#, %&,

> '#, " - &%& ' %, &( + ., .#, 9& %( $% 85 $,#%

, ( # .(# $$%#(

( , ) - &.#% + #.$., &#(

8%$5 $( &.#% + $,

$$ $

( )F (+$ :(+#

# $ $( & $ DE #- )*+- &,#%& ( )F4 2 3% #

(

5 , (% $ $( &, & $ DE #- )*+- &,#%& #

,## &

DE ):

%( (&8 $ $( #., & ($( # ($( $$#, ( ($( ((#( (

#, #($- $( #, (

(,5 ((#(

& $ DE #- )*+- &,#%& &# # #$$ # &( $5C, $5(#(- ## %#. $( 5 &,( ( # (

(($$5 ., #(

&% %#(

+5, (&,8 (+$ ,+

($ $$ &( ;, %, *,% .#( %,(- ,#( ((, & , #( %, $5 $ + ,8

+% #(, 8 $( B#, >8.-

$, # 8& *,# &( +

(, $$ (( ( ,#( ((, $,5- $ $ &, & $ DE #- )*+- &,#%& #

,## 2 #(

$$ 8, & $ (

$ E ## + (# ( ( , $ .#$+$-

$, , ( (( % *,#

9&- &#( +* #( 8#&

( , %, #(,

($ $$

48&(- $( + (

& $ DE #- )*+- &,#%&

# ,$5

,5(-

( ,+

#, 8&& $( &,

& $ DE #- )*+- &,#%& 8#& #%

9&#(

# #( $( 8#& ( $,5 ,#( ((,- $ $( &,

& $ DE #- )*+- &,#%& #

,##

,5( ,$5 (,#% $ $( ,(

!"#$%$&&#'( %)*+,,-./0 . 2034 8&#$ ,$#%

$#% ;%( #

8& $( (

$ E #(

,5( .5- &8.- & .#, $( , *,#

(,- ,$5 &$, $

E +* #(,

($ $$ )F (+$ :(+# , $$ ( E ### &# #(&, #,.# DE ) (#% , E ## # &# #, &#( +* 8#& &, #$ (+$ :(+# +#% $ 8#((

$, &. .$#,$5 ,, .#, #,.# ,#, > (+*

((E ## +&$

9&%&-

((E ##- (, & (

#%( #,.# &. + (, + (#% #,.#- #,

#%( %,

#$ :2- #( (, #,.#

( + (8 +

#( ;

( #( ((((#

+, ( #( 4 4A - (# &( #$, (&8 &8#(

$+$

$ (

#((# $(

($5 (

( %,( E +* 8 #,, 8#((( $5 /,#$ 3& &. + E #, ( # ( #(

(#,, .#8- &#( +* $( ,(

5 8#%&% ( &( + ,#( ((, ,#$ +.- 8 #$ 8#((( ,#, &.

#. ,( $($5 %#(

%#.

&( + 8&5 $# 3E ## #,, 8#((( ,(

1& - #,,

+# #( *( $

# B# $8 2 #( 8& .#,, +( #,,

+#-

%#. #$ 8#((( #( ,#( ,,

#%$ :,% &#( *,% 5 $!5%1 "$ &&# '( %)* +,67.+0 .20 4,4- +(., (# #( #$ 8#(((

5 .#,#5 .$ & 8#(( &# ( (

,#( ,, (# $5

&# #$ ,(#%#

( %,( & +* 8,

($ $$ 1

3 !

, ( 2 #( ;

#, +( #

$, ,$ #((# G,

($ $$

$, # &8

$(( (#, (

2 *,%

+5 $

- # +(., $8 # #( .5

$ . # & #( ( ,$ #$$%$#5

, #% ( (#C- .#,

$$ &+5 8#$$ #, #((#+$ 8$,

(#, $$

# ( ( #, 8&& (#( *,# +

2 ( (#C

$ ,# $8 , & ((#+#$#5 .#,

$$ $#;$5 &. + , #$, ,#%

( ( ( (#C- &- #

$, (#, .#, #( $#+$ , #((#+$ .#,

%, *,%

.# ((, #$ #( B# ,#$,- 8$$ (,- ,( (

#$$%$#5 ## #5 2 #( +(, #($ .#,

## $8 9& #( #$$%$#5 ## #5 &8#&-

#%& &.

$$, # &#( 8&#$ E #(#% $$ *#(,#

( 8,, $$ #(

( #+, 3#& #

, $8 $$ ,(.( %, (

((#- ;#% .#8 (+(#$ B#5

+, .,

( ( %, *,%

.# , ( &$,

$ #( 8#&

# #( ,#( #((,

,#%$5 !

$$=

#( ,# (, + &# :,# #$ %#(- #( 8#&# 8;

,5- #$#% :- 8$, #(( 8( ( ( ( (,

*#$ ,% ##% ( 3 ((5 ## # (

, # #

# $ %&"

# $