M/S Victor Cycles Private Ltd. v. Sarvesh Kumar Jindal



   


  




  






 



     

!""

  # $% $%&# ' 

"  


   
!

  "


  (   & '  )$ !*%  !+% '  )!   +,-# )!   !  -  )! %""

   # '  )$ !*%   !..* )!%"    "
 # 

/% % #   . %#0 **%  .%#" 0 *  " "  %.  

)%

 .0 %    %
.# $ !""

 /%.  

* 1#   

3  *%  "    ""  0 .   4 666777  28  # .  8  :

              
 ))

(  /%1# %.   

  "#0* %") %#.%%     %  %  #    *  1#      

  #    % "    /%.  

0     (,# ""
 ( ;%".. 0 *

%""

 <  ( " = 7%   %

3  "%.  

) # * " %5  .% " #%> .$% 

  -#" $%   -#")% " .

% .     

   #  %  "

   <$% $% &#  '  =

!  "  %  .      

  

3)

(*"     )#*%%


( *  "    %        %:#    

8  *%  %    . # 
 )

*" % !"#  % .  

)%"

 " %# 


( 8

3%  ( "      *  % ".%.  

)*%%*. .   0  0%  %     ? 



3)   %  #   8)

(*".      )*%%*. . 0 0%%  7%   % % 0  %%""

 ( " )"
 

(       %#"" #

  /%

 )*%   .%*   )% %" . % #  "

%%*    

!"% .      

)  %       *    0  1#      0 



/%""

 %%%   


)

  

! %# 
 )

* %   *%  

8)%""

 
 9)

)



2

8)


) 

8


  

)

*"  

7 %      % %""

 ( "  

  " # 0 $% 

  -#")%* 

5%%#%# %%.  

" 

 

%"

 <"  % = # %. "    ,#   

3)*%%* *%*  



! ""

 # ?67
# 2%  #) <% @ A="   %    "#"

% "

 %"## 0 %"  .  "    ,#  )   

3% 0   /%# ""  %.  

*  

 "  %.%1#   . % 

B% "  .%"  .%  *%%0  "#%""0+)  .*%% :#  7  0 %% "  . ) % "  .%"%  %* #0   /%0 " 0 %""

 #  

".

  #  "  .%""

    %%%""

  %* %#""  %) %#""  %.  

#  0

$

  C%  0 .)%#0 %. 

%""

*

" %"   

' %-  7 #   .  "  ? 

 )%" %"

 ' %*  %"" *  %% * "    

 &"#  %   '     $#   &#   '   ?



  *" %"   0 .  

     .&"#% ' )$#  &# ' )$.-#"  $% 

  -#" ? 2

)    *  #" %1 9 /%" %" 2

  *        #      



 #<=% # "%

% 

0 "%0  %% %0 

  .     %              %     . "    :#%) ). )     

.%   %"")#  ." .)(  ) +  #     B  %%* %"% ""   %""

 ( "

 

7#%  %%.  

#  #%.  

%0 . 00 C( $%
, %  -#"   7    #0   %  $%
, %  -#"  *  % %!#  )*%% 0 *+ .%""

   . .   %  "# %.  

)%   %" )*%% "%.  

% 0  

/%""

   %  +0   % # 

%0 # %"

  !

. % 

%

0  %%" . 0* %  %.  

  %

3* *%%%  7#%   %%# 0 %"

 <"  % =0 # ? 
#  %"

 "#

 # . "    ,#  /%  .*%. %  *

 . %"

 % 0 :# 

7% 0   %% #%"

 %*%%   %# 
 8)



? %%% )%   #  "  .

%"  #0 %%  <""

 % =%  "#%* %"%""

  " 0%# 0 *  B)*%  .%" -" $ .%) 7 # )#% < C=)#0 %%""

 *  %#""  %* 1   % "0 % "  .%""

  B#% #0 %C($% 

  -#")*% "" .* ) % %% " %* %""

 C%     .%  . #:## ?7
#  9 % 0 "

 $%
, %-#"* %% !#  %  ( "

 B#%  %% "

 * *   *

 . %  . %#0 * %0, *%.%   0  %# % 10# ?77
#

 *. #"0 % "  .%  

&

0%#    B )%  0"  "%0,

!% . 

>%.#  %

"  .  %  ")  %  #  *  "    1    %     ?  .%*   ) %%

   %# %.# %%""

 (  "  * %#""

7 %*   ) *%"

%%""

 ( " *  "      %  .      

   %  ""  *    *   0  %  "

 )   ). 

%"" * 

' %-  7 #  .   "  -#

) "   *" %" *1#*% % . .%  %   

    ?  2

)           <%  ""

  % =* #" %1 9 D% *%  "              

)  %   #      % " %" *1#) *%%

 ""%  *  :#%.  #%""

 ( "

)*%  C(-" $ .%)   7 #  )""  )%%%"" * 0 %

 ( "

 #  "  .%    1  % *  %"   # 

"  .%""

   % *$ 2*% $ <0=%$"
 !)3<%  @3!A=)%:# * %":#0%

'

  0""  %.   

" 7 #""%#0  )% #" ,#.   "  0  %  $#"   #   Pemmada Prabhakar & Ors vs Youngmen's Vysya Association ()* +,-./0

 % %  %%  /% #%#

$ 2%3!)*%%"% # "

  .%  #     )*%+ * .%   %   %"" )% 

 %"" % #%   0"

   $ 2%3!%  ""

 0#%#%0  0 %    . %    7 %*)$ 2%3! *# 0""

0 *% %   % #. %    " %"% )*%% % "  % . $ <0=%3! % 1  ""  . %""    .

#0:#   7 % 1%%*@ A%0 #  

/%#% %,#.  " Pemmada Prabhakar10 2(0.

034/(  7 %     +*
** %""

B  #0 % *)%  %#.%)%*)     

<  A =   .  

/%$#" #  # %%"" *"#%0 %"% "

 %"#"% # 

/%##%# %        %0 #  .%% 

%# ""

 7 % 1)*%  * ."   )% #  0  B*)* % %% * %"%"" :#0" %0 #  0#""   &" . *% # )% #0  %.#   

/% 1.#  % "  .%

 0 %"

# 7  0 %%0 0%%#)%""

 % "

%%.  

 # #  
% %*   )%""

   "

%%.  

*1#

 #      7 % *%#)0"  " +#"%"

# *  ?7
# 9  )% . #*:#0"  ) %#%0" +     7 %)%

   %       "  %  #  !     )  % .  

#  ".  %".)* %. %0 /% % . *%  .%   "  


 
 8)

7 % %%""

 ( " %%.  

   .   0  %    %  . #    .   7  % #  )% #0  %   *%. #



/% 1.#  % "  .%

 %%.  

 00 .#  * %  %/ "  + * !# "# 



%.  

;1

 %% # 

%* % -# #+%< # ,0=  .#.)*%% 

 .#. 5%%%"#%. # ; . % % ".%.  

 ; .

%  ; % """ 1# %.  

%0 "#% 

/% )%*     "


< 8

= 
 8)

< 



3= /%%

 ( " * 

  $%   -#") % % " % "" %* 01  $%

 
   -#")  *%  ""     )    %  % :#  

 7 %#  )  ( #%  %/ " .  

9

/% 1.#  % "  .%

 0 ? 
#   7  0 %% 0% #)"#    0  %# *0%   0  #0:# #"#  ?77
#  *#

#0#% "  .

%""

  %%#   0   B*) % F!""

# . %.#  * %F !""

#) (""  )# %%"  # 0# ?77
#   !

%*)%#)%  . )1  %0, 7 )%""

 %    ""

    "#%"

 %  #)*%%*   

3*%"%.  

% *01# 0



/%#



%+  %"

 %"##)*%%#.%0 "#              #   "  .  %

 )*%  ."8 2%"

 %"# #)%#0 %%#   .%#" "  %.  

%   

3)*% % "##*  B #" %,#.  " 63/787 399(/(+ 0:+ (,;()(/(;()( <0!

6.8(/7 6;()=(,(
(*-(/()7 >:+

-()=+,.0->(//(+ ()* ()+,-./   

 %!

8

!   )%#.  ,#  *  #%0%) *%%% )"%.   

)*01# 7 "8%"

 %"##) %  0  "

 0  % "

  %  %      % 0  %  %  . .*% %"   %""

  7 "2*"

0 %"

 %#  #%"

   *% %"

   0# % . %  *% %"  

*% %   

#%. # :#% "

  /% "  .%""

 * %# %%"

 %%+ * .%%  % 

#% #%.  

/%":#0 1   # .

 ?77
# <= "0% "    %    " #  )%  #

 #% G0#% )1"*% % %#)#

#% )%%

 * #    B )% :#  ""

0  



0   #0:# #)# ?77
# <=  ""

0 *% "    %    " % # /%# 0#  )*%%

%"   # 7 6!"(9;()(0>(8;

*.(* ?;

0 ()* ()+,-./ <0!

!(=,-(<(,0(9(8

*.(* ?;

0 ()* +,-./0

   

+)97). %5$#%$#" #1  )  )%0, *%.   0  %#0:# ## ?77
# 

   H  

)*% %%   # 0      %""

0  0# ?77
#

  /%1" #    %#  *%%0%%#00# ?77
#  

7 ) 5 %%# 8,! -(@>() "(3/ <0!

-!

(/7)*./ (9 7)@-



 
&$% %"##  .  ,#  0%.1# %  *#  0# ?77
#   /%#%  %# "##.  ,#    % %#   .%#""   !

F'#.5 %%$#" # 3/?(=0- 7)@- <0!

-3/( (9

&$ 

 5 % %# "##       #0:#   #    " )         %)0# ?77
#   ""

0  ) %  <""

 = 

0 %%%#0:#  #0# ?77
#  0#% 0

 

2

/%" 01     % .

  !

"   0   #""  0%



   *%%  %         " .     0 1#    .)%%" % 

#% #%.   

B*)   

/%  "#%  + *

%.1# %  %%"% * *

"  %%" *# % #%.   

7 #%#  )%  # *%. %#0:# # %  /%#% #

 %,#.  "0 %$#" # 63/787 399(/(+10 2(0.

034/( 7 %)%"## ,#  *  #% %1#  . %   7 %  1)%$#" #% %%#0:# #0#  ?77
#    C% %" )%"  %* B )%,#.   ""

0  &" . *%# )%  #0  %.#   % "  .%""

 *%.0, # ?77
#    2

B )   

 %  ""

         *# 0 %0 

*% %0 +     0 %#



/% 1.#  % "  .%

 *%.  *

 .  7"% %"

 %%$#0(
. 



7  %  



2)%"

   . 

 .#" %   <""

 =  %%$#0(
. 



2 

2



2*% 

/%"

 



  "  %%$#0(
. 



2*

   

2     .  %      0#  %     <""

 = # #" %%$#0(
. ) %  #  *      

 *%    "         

 7*"

"

0 %"

 %%*  *   *

 ." %"%  5%% #% # %%"

 * *   *

 . " %"%   

/% .#  % "  .%

 *%.% # 
 8)

5%F !""

  #)  %      "   %  %  ""

   %#   0 # %5 +.# 
 8)

$#%"  %F!""

#*#    %"

 %  %""  %.  

"  .%""

    %# 7 *%# )  .  )% ""  

!

%"  . 

 #""

 ) )  "





 "
  +%

  C%%"+ .  I4 C%%"0

I4