High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/871/2007disposed of

Gurmej Singh v. State Of Punjab

2022-08-04Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

! "

&& '(( )"* (+ )(

) %#, +- &&

& +%, !, )"*

.....

/%#( & +# + $#( "+$ ++

, ((+ ((#( 1+$, #(, -#+

-# +

! "

) ( + ((+ -0 +0, (

+$ #$( #(

0( 0 # ( 3

56 +& 0 #, +$ % 4 0

#&0 (+ (

(, ( ( # (0

! "

#+ &"# 7+ * 8 0( # #+

& *&((+ 2 (( &0 ) #+ #$%, 2% $+ * 3 0( 0( ( #-&0 # #+6 * %

0( #

, +-&+ #&&# &#( '# ( - #$%6 && #&0

*( &+#$ (#( 1(*# 7 &# & *+ * %6 %0 #+ (+ '# + % &#(%# * 6 +0 #+ #

8, '#

(+6

+#$ ( '# 20

( *(#$

(+6 && %( ( +#( &(+

(&6 * ), &$ ( $ %(

&# + #+ %6

&# &+ '# ( && *& ( (%&+ ( &#( &+

&# '# %+

(% +#+

0 , % #% 2&+

(# #+ 2&+ 9#&& %6

2%#&,

&# (-+

&( &&

(&&#$ (+, (2 (+, ( %(*+6 * :

), $#$ %+ *#$ &&2+ %(*+

2% (++&0 9 ( && 9#

9 (+ $#-#$ *&2( %2#% (+6 #(+ #$% %+ (- %(&, (( (% #-+ #"#( & ( + *&2 $#-

%# #$% 2#(6 %,

3 *&2( & (#+

%(6 && +26

& ( 9#6 $#$

-0 , #"+ 9 #-#& ;(#& / /6

*% "# &( #-+

2%#&, 2% (% (

*+ #"#(6 2%#&

&# $#$ &# (# &+$ $+#$ #+, (%

(( &# 0 %++ 4 &*# *#+$ %#6

&# $ ( <= )< ++ 45; &*# #$%, # = +0 #

#(6 4 &*# ++ +( <= )<5 *&2 (

&# ( > &# (#, *(#( %, & ?4 <= )<5

++ $#(

(

4)6 % &# 0

&# 2 #-#& ;(#& / /, 2% ++ *+0 &0#$6 ;

#+ #>( +#$( $+ & +% #$ <= )?

( 6 ++ *+0 ( (

-#$ &# # <= );6 (#+ (

+#$&0 $

+ +6 (

##, *&$#$( + * 4

-+ # (&+ & %-#$ (& 4 *#$ ((# @ @6 & 9 # &# ((((# -#+ -0

6 % &# 0

&# 2 &

+#$&0 #( +6 4 + $% (# &6

8, &# 0 2%#& *#$ ( %

%29 #-+ ( # # $+ & #

(+6 &# 0 2 +#( &(+ & (+

(

<= )76 (,

+ * $#( &# *#+6

9 & 9 #$+ 4, +#$

( (+ +#( &( ( 9

&+ 9# *&2 # *=

9#$

&%( &0#$ (#+#& %(, * &0 92

&+ $ ( -+6 +#( &( ( (+ 4 9%+- (*& ! #$%6 %,

(+, 2%#& &#

(+0 $ 9# -+

+#( &(+ & 6 4 + $% (9 % %

-+ #

&, (&+

(& %-#$ ((# @ @6 $% (# & & -0 +6 &# (#, & 9# +(#+ ;6 &

&%( %@( 2#$ # #+ $#- 4 (

##, *(#+( *&+ (#+ 9# $ -+

( ?A, )"*, %+#$%

%$% (*& 1(*# 2% +&#-+ %( & (&( # 6 ## + 0 # A*0 -#+ <= )) && # &( (#+ % *&+6 ( &+

& #+ $ +

#(%# , (

&# #-(#$# % &##(,

%&& $#(

+ #&+ 1, / /, 2% #+#$

#*& ((#(

((# 1+$, #(

(&0#$

#( + ( (

) , #+#$ # #

$#(

(+, &++ $#&0

&# #& #$

( ( # -#+ , ( # #+ &&2#$ 2#((( )C 1(& #$%, )C

(*& 1(2 #$%, )C #(%# , $%( , )C ; 1(& #$%, )C8 ; &"#+ #$%, )CB ; !

#$%, )C (*& 1(*# #$%, )C 1(*# 7,

&#, )C:

) #+ #$%, )C

4( ! #$%, )C 4 &*# #$%, ?A <= )) ++, %, ( # -#+

&(+

++ 33 ) , && # ##$

# ( ( #$ ( # -#+ $#(

(+,

* +#+ ( ,

+#$ # %( &(&0 #-&-+ %#(

(6 2# &"# 7 %-#$ #&&# &#( '#9 "# '# #(# *( (, (% +#+ ( &#9(

'#9 "# '#

8, &$ %# ( ) #+ $#$, 2%

'#9 "# '#

%6 2# (+ $#$ '#9 "# '# (0#$ (% &#-

(+6

>& 9 & *2 % +#$ = %$ % 2+( ( (& $- - # (%

(+ #"#(6 % ##

+ # 6 % (+ &0

#&&# &#( '# (#+

9 &

#$ + -#+ ,

#+ %

( C % E+2#+ ( C

A+ #& &+ &&2#$ #( + ## # C%% &"# 7, 2#

#&&# &#(

'#9 "# '# 90F ## C%% &# * & ( ( 1(*# 7

)C ) #+

)C:F ### C%%

$- *&2( 9# ##

( +%F #- C%% (& (++ $- - #

$- *&2( 9# (+F - C%%

&&(

)44 4)F %#$ $ (, #& #++ # G %&+#$ &"# 7 #&&# &#( '#9 "# '#

*" #$ ( * (%

#$ +-#( )#( G

#++ %&+#$

#+ (+5 2# (

#$ 9#$

&# 2% '#9 "# '# + ( #+

2# *+ -9 %(*+ + ( &#9 ( ?

-#+ + +, (+ -+ - # ( $#- (++ 4 (& (++ $- - #

+#-+ (& &

(+ +% /%(,

&*& % #+ #$

+ /%

%&+ $#&0

-# +

+#$&0 ( +#&+ *-

/% && & $$#-+ "+$

-# + ( %( #&+ ( & 4

%#$

2% & + #+ -0 # (0+ &# # %-#$ #&+ 3:

) , ##$ ( && ((++ +#$ + & *#& $+

-#+ + ++

G2 & %(

#& %#$

%- %+ &+

(& &&5

(+, &+

(& *(#+( $#$ %$% + :

-0 (,

0 * (+ #+ %#(

+#+

+#$

(( ## )C

&# 1(*# 7, ($$(#

$#- 2+ $ '# -+

+#$ ( (&, 9#&&+ # #&&0 ($$(# $+ %( % 0 2#(( )C:

) #+ /% #+ %#(

&(( + #+ &+

(& && %( (#(&0 +#(+ #+ ; %( &#+

((( #

(, +#( &(+ $#(

)44

)4 %(

-# +

+#$ &+

(& &&, (++ $- - # && 9+ 2#

+#$ , ##

(#$ +%

(#$ ( *+#&0 #"#( ( &#9&0

( +% % *(,

&+ * (#+ + 92&+$ &#9&0

( +% * 2#% 0 ##

( +%

( ( *+#&0 #"0 ( &#9&0

( +%

(& $+ "+$ $( (%2

2%#& *#$ #+ 33 ) , (+

(+ +% 2# ( (& (++ $- - # /% #& -#2 (

# ( (

-#+ -#&*& +

&++ G (

"#$!%&

"#'% (!!%&)

$ #&

(++ $- - #

+#-+ (&

& 9+ 2# 9#

(#$

&#& #"#( (% (

*+ 4 &

( %(*+ *(-#$ 2#

0 0#$

0 &-#$ %(*+

%#&+ *%#+, *&+ %(*+ 2&+

#&0 *#& 2&+ *%- (

&& &#9&#%+ ;2-, #+ ##

( +% 2# +( * %

(#+#$ #( #"0 #&# +

#$% %+ ( + #$% 2#( % *&2

%( $#- 4 ##

( +% 2#, 2&+ %- (#$%20 #&# + #"#( -#& ( 4

(#++ -#2

( 92&+$

* #*+

&#9&0

( +% 2# 9#$ 9# 4

#&0

9+ 2# 2#% 0 %0 (, %, $- - #

(#+ (&#$ #

$#$ ##+ # $ (++&0 9#$

(#++ -#2,

)44

#( #(% =+#$

0( (

(+0

## #&+ *%& ,

%( &+0 +$ & #(

0(,

+0 &+( #((#( ; (%2 * #-&-+ 0 %

# #&

; (+ * &0 #$

* #&0, &9#$

%#&+ H+

# ( (, (*(#- ( #( 2++

0( #$( #( , 2%(, # (+ ( 3

5 9 ( # 4 +& 0 #, +$ #$( #( #+ 0 /% && 2% *#& %-#$ $+

((# (((# ( &(+ *#&, -#+ + ++

, ( + (+( &&+6 *#&5(0 *+(

&&+ /% && +# + (+ * %# 1+# #& $#(, #( 2#%# 29

+0, #&#$ 1, #( 2&+ #(( 2( ( $#( , ( ( $

(+ (+

& 1#&, #( +$ ##$ (

3 C#% (

+## #, & (+( +#((+

0 %#( "+$ * ( 1, #( ((0