← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15762/2018dismissed

Indian Institute Of Science Education And Research Iiser And ANR v. Chairperson Board Of Governors Iiser Mohali And ORS

2018-07-17Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh13 pages

       





    



!"

#$

"%&'&#( )

*+, -

 

              

 

      

)

.

/ 0 1

12

   

  !  "

 # "$

! % &"

 



' "$$  "



# ' ( "

 

 ) *+

   "

 

 ,  



 #   

  ( 

(  $  

-  

      

  

 .!3"

('!&!*!"/ + $  

-1 ) , (

#      

    3++4*5" 7, 

    

    )   ,    8

  

!

     *349+4*5" 7+5

 * ) +2

      $       #        8 :

$$        +*49+4*5  "  7,+   +,49+4*5 " 7,,+;49+4*5" 7,37,; -8 

:   , ( !

 #   #     8-   " 

 $   $ -    )      



(-"+44<$ "

+4*+

 .!3"

%!/ 8 ( " $6  

 



          -       8       8 

  " ) + #   

 # # 



(2

  %'

 ((    =

      ***,

>   

  

           4945+4*3" 7,?  

 .!3"

1! !*!"'/            8

  -        ) +   "     

 " 7,# 8  

(  8  

 $$(



$  $$   8-    ) ,        ( 

    " 7,>>( $$

#     8

 8$  $$

 #   "  (     



 8 -

#

  

#  

-  -8 -#$ 

  (

 8-  ( - (

 *39+4*50   # 

 # 

 

    -$

  $ (- -   $ 8 -

    "       '  

     

,8-

( #( *39+4*5 3  >  >(   $$

  8$        4,4++4*5" 7+ 

  $$ 

  8- , (  

7 $$ ( $   

#(@A .  ((B"

 8 2#

0 "

# C<4447A$D2"

 (



6

-#

  $ ( ,+3,97A  > &0$@

 >6

- 

2 !#

22  -&8  :

     A3#"



?4447A

 " $ 

#

2 ! &8 

 (  8 

(    /

 ; E   $ 

( E



  # 8 0

     88 (

  #( 8$

( $ (  " 7+5 "  8 ($

 

   $



  

      



!

  $ 

  #>    *5



 $- $



         

*53



 #

 9 $  

-#8

   (  FA<+5+A+4*5  (   #



*3++4*5 #   8

$

(  +54,+4*5 "  #   +54,+4*5 

:

  ,8     $

(

( #   8 (  

  (     ) ,   B

    

8

 -#  (  ( ,#

  $   , (# 8 !

(



(

  0

 ( $  # #  *9+4*5 #   # 8A

  *349+4*5 *9+9 

 -

 #    +        ( (  

         $ (      *39+4*5 *9,3 

!(

, (       #  

-   8  A <    -  * 8$  

  8

$   ) * (2 7"( 2  8-  ) + 0 8 -    

 3

"#   @A .3* 

$    $,

>     8 8 -    (       $$   8-$  8   + -    ( 

    

 2 

$ (

/ 5 " 8

  8 -       = 8-

7





   =

(

#  

#   #  

     =

   +<49+4*5(

8-

2 8 !2

   -# ( (

# 8  8 

 

  = 8 

#

# 8 -      # 8

$  ? " $  

(

   +54,+4*5 ( ) *5,*,4  * #  =    $$

  $$

  8-  $

#($ @A  G8 %  



$ 

% 

"8B( 

$ 0

$ (  - "  -

0"  

' -"

 > $ 

 -

 

  '8   

$     

 

$  $$  '8  



!  (   0  $

  - *4 $

 #  $  0   $$

  

(##  -

A( 

  8

 $$

 (#6

 ( A (  ( " (       #    2    0   $$

      

 (    +<+4*5     8$            $    ) *  ( $

(

*,4<+4*5  !

    ** " 

 $$

-  

  

 -

#   #    #       B

        

 $$

8

       8

  8-  (  (

(

#         $  #                

 ( ) *+ *+ ,+$

(



*?;+4*5 (    ( ,

 A  

 

 (#  

 #

 , #$ 8-    (#  

'

( +,,+4*5 ) *+-  # 8 $ 8 ( $8 *,   #   8- ,2  (

!$ $ 

!

8- ) *+  #  -   # 8

8 



# - 

    0 ##

  -  

#    8-



$

( *?;+4*5 # # 

$ 0      -   

 ( #$

!(   

#  

  " 

0





 

    *4+

  *39+4*5 " 7+5

!(

,#

# 8  

0  # 

  $ (

  8  - - 8'

       





8- 

 

#   



8 (  



 $($

(

 *,4<+4*5

 $

(  -

#8

  " 7,A+ ,-  # # -$   $8 

 $  *3 &       (  

8 ( $  8

 " $     

 (                $    $

 

   (   ( 

    #     



 $

  *5+B       ***,

 # 

 #  *; B (   8$ $ 8-   

 ( ( (  8 

   

 #    8 8  ,2## !(  (

0 #   "

$ 8 -    

 

 3

  "0   (8 -    -   8  $ 

  

B

  

   = (

#  $

#  8 

#  



 #

 

 3

"    8

*9 " $ 8



 "(  $) *5,**,$

( +54,+4*5 (( 

,

  @A .

 "(    $     *5,**,   ((  

2 ( 

#   2# # 

(

 -E   

# :

 8- E    ( 

   

 (    $  "   :

   8-  

   

! (# 

#  ((

(   - (   

8-2  '8B(  ((   "

 (  ( 

(   $(

 >>( $$

G #  - 8$ 

#  -  8A'   E  



     8  $$

!

 

$ !

( ( $    #    

 )   %     ((  

2E  

  #   

B G8  '8B(  

-

$



( #  

 

-

8-

  2



- 8$  

# 8 #     $

/ *< "  -      #      =   8-     



#  *5 ) # $( 

 

  3++4*5" 7, 8-(  (

 ,      "   *5

 #   



        0

 6

  *5

  @A *5 1*'4"('&#(- "( +!&"'-

&'%&4+&( 5, 45#%""6&(7'

* $- $



       @A  #    -  

(  (  $   $  (1  #  ($ 

-$

  

( : - @ 

    #   $  

 

          -# $( # +  8  ,

 3

$- 

       $  

        #  

 





!

  / *? "  8  ?

  *5

$



((

8-- $ ( - ($8 

 

(  8     $  

 +4       ( 8

     8-

 -

 (  $     8-  #- 

    8

   

     #

 8



 $  

 ($

( +5,+4*5        

    =       *  !

:    E*349+4*5 

     ( " 7+5

 (  #    #  $   -

     #      8- 0  $$

 -      : -           (   (       8$ 8

##

    8-      

      $

(    8     *,4<+4*5 0  $$

G  # ( (  ,8    



 6$

( 

  (     ( 



 - # -  =



!

   +* 0!(  $ (    *4+

 # 6 

 

$!

$  # 

  *349+4*5" 7+5

!(

,  :  $ 

 6$

(



 >  -

    *4+

 8 (     @A 8 3"

3 &54"5'#(-

# 56 #$ #9"5(#5'

66 +  (   $- 



$

 !

8-$



 6$

(/ ++ 8

 $!

$   (   $- 



$

 !

8-$7



 6$

( 

 -  (

#  #

$  -8

     $

  #  8

     8  

  $      #  8-  

   8   $  (     (     -  

 # (-     (  0  # 6 (  !(

$       $ ( 

 " 7+5  

$(

  !

 8-  (    

  

    6

(##  *,4<+4*5"   8 -  (- $ ( " 7+5 8- *  8

 -  =   "  +,   # 

 8

        #        $8   #  -$        $   $ 

:12

 ;

  *+,

-

 F  !(7  I @ J  F  8 I @ J